5 ms·
'The early adopters have adopted': US carmakers slow their EV growth plans
- belter 3y agohttps://archive.ph/T1pQQ https://archive.ph/T1pQQ
- tpmx 3y agoSo, are we in the Trough of Disillusionment or in the Slope of Enlightenment? Probably the former, still...
- CamperBob2 3y agoWe are in the "Valley of (Perceived) High Interest Rates."
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoIn the UK there's a very noticeable avalanche of anti-EV stories in certain newspapers. Presumably that has some impact on uptake and adoption. This campaign to curb the lies is being very generous by assuming no active malice, just clickbait tendencies: https://www.greencarguide.co.uk/2023/09/stopburningstuff-launched-to-combat-misinformation-about-electric-vehicles/ https://www.greencarguide.co.uk/2023/09/stopburningstuff-lau... > Whether the headline is ‘your electric car will catch fire’ or ‘multi-storey car parks will collapse because of EVs’, the stories are becoming more prevalent, more inaccurate and more ridiculous – and are primarily driven by the desire of publications for more clicks. Gaining more clicks is evidently being prioritised over checking the facts, and over the urgent overriding need to reduce air pollution and combat climate change.
- Reason077 3y ago> ‘multi-storey car parks will collapse because of EVs’ Well, this actually did happen at Luton Airport recently. Massive fire destroyed hundreds of cars, partially collapsed the parking building, and caused huge disruption at the airport. Of course, it wasn't caused by an EV, as many initially suspected, but a diesel car catching fire.
- Symbiote 3y agoThat car park was built in 2018, so hopefully it was built taking into account the weight of modern vehicles. But they built it very cheaply: > Hopkinson said there were no sprinklers in the car park and firefighters were advising the airport to ensure they were fitted. “Sprinklers may have made a positive impact on this incident,” he said. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/oct/10/huge-fire-breaks-out-at-luton-airport-car-park https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/oct/10/huge-fire-br...
- magicalhippo 3y agoThe last major parking garage fire here in Norway was also started by a diesel car catching fire[1]. Although several EVs were parked and started burning, the batteries did not[2]: Observations during the fire indicate that electric vehicles did not contribute to the fire development beyond what is expected from conventional vehicles. [1]: https://elbil.no/ett-ar-etter-p-hus-brannen-pa-sola-lufthavn-elbiler-brannsikkerhet-og-myteknusing-velkommen-til-webinar/ https://elbil.no/ett-ar-etter-p-hus-brannen-pa-sola-lufthavn... [2]: https://www.dsb.no/rapporter-og-evalueringer/evaluering-av-brann-i-parkeringshus-pa-stavanger-lufthavn-sola-7.-januar-2020/ https://www.dsb.no/rapporter-og-evalueringer/evaluering-av-b...
- bluescrn 3y agoBattery fires do seem a legitimate concern for the electric-everything future. And a multi-storey car park inferno started by a battery pack is no longer a hypothetical situation. Would you charge a cheap chinese e-scooter in your home unattended? Would you even want a Tesla Powerwall in your home, given that even the Tesla Megapack grid-scale storage has had fire incidents? But the real problems with EVs in the UK are more related to charging infrastructure (large percentage of the population who can't charge at home due to living in a flat or relying on on-street parking), and the cost of electricity going up massively. And the cost of the EV to begin with, with an ever-rising cost of living and stagnant salaries.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe recent increase in interest rates surely had something to do with it. An EV trades higher initial cost for lower operating costs.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> The recent increase in interest rates surely had something to do with it. Elon Musk said so... He said, repeatedly, he was worried about high interest rates (and they're not even that high: I've known 13%+ in my lifetime) and the effect on buying people cars with loans (which is: most of them).
- j45 3y agoEarly conservatives/early majority will likely learn about hybrid, then phevs, and then ev’s. Conveniently there assists to be new battery technologies in the next few years. Toyota is also about to go heavy into EV, and with it a trusted customer base.
- twisteriffic 3y ago> Toyota is also about to go heavy into EV, and with it a trusted customer base. And given recent behaviour, no interest in making stock available to the north american market. Despite still being heavily advertised, there are no dealers in my province that will even take a pre-order at this point.
- j45 3y agoTrue. There might be some Lexus options in hybrid or PHEV. Lexus have been long in the tooth for a while on several models. I wonder if Toyotas new battery tech might just pop into the prime to be more efficient and longer mileage in the future.
- jraines 3y agoThis is me. Just bought a CRV Hybrid, as a long time Honda driver, and I love it. I would’ve bought electric except that most of them have taken Tesla’s example and decided that electric has to also mean “screens and weird design decisions everywhere”. I could deal with that, all things being equal, but the price premium just pushes the decision over the line. I might’ve also made the leap to Tesla since it’s competitive on price now but I’m not in an area where service would be convenient (even if good/fast)
- j45 3y agoHonda has been very late to the hybrid game in SUVs but the CRV is awesome and bigger, I know someone looking at it jn my life. The only thing comparable is the few years there was an Acura MDX Hybrid and it was more of a performance hybrid like Infiniti liked to do. Teslas are def interesting, Model 3’a seems to have an advantage over model Y for efficiency. I have a few friends focused on the 2016-17 Model S/X with unlimited supercharging and the new driving computer. The S/X seem to run forever once any issues are ironed out. Topping up charge every night and not spending time at a gas station is a little appealing especially for any places with inclement weather. More awake time to live.
- Tade0 3y agoThere are also people like me - who were considering an EV but in the meantime... stopped driving altogether. Ok, I haven't completely stopped, but I do less than 6k km annually - at this rate my current car will last me more than 20 years.
- the_snooze 3y agoI'm in the same boat. I bought a small ICE car a few years ago, figuring that the fact I drive so little (under 5000 miles a year) gets me most of the fuel and environmental benefits of an EV without the cost or inconvenience.
- ghaff 3y agoI had to get a car summer 2022 and I was lucky to get what I wanted without too long a wait. Electric and hybrid options just weren't there for what I wanted so I figured I'll buy something and see what's out there in maybe ten years.
- saltcured 3y agoAs someone who has had several cars like that (built in the late 70s and late 90s), I'll note that operating costs get much harder to quantify with an older car... I suppose it depends on your maintenance philosophy and risk tolerance, but the cost per distance goes up dramatically for infrequent use and as the car ages. Many fluids and components don't just wear out by distance driven, but also by time since manufacture or time exposed to the environment. I keep wondering how EVs might behave in this regard. Can they be effectively parked to defer their useful lifetime, or will batteries and power electronics also degrade whether you drive or not? Imagine power electronics succumbing to "bad capacitor" fiascos like other consumer electronics, or batteries being cooked by poor charge controllers when a car is constantly on standby. But I also wonder this about the ever growing informatics systems, regardless of whether it is EV or ICE. Will modern cars be able to be used 10-20 years later, or will some crucial systems fail with no cost-effective service option because manufacturers have moved on to completely different tech? I'm very disheartened to see the smartphone obsolescence mentality seeming to infect car designs. I followed the "buy and hold" strategy for the past 30 years, but I start to wonder if I'll be forced into leasing due to these concerns about the practical longevity of all the newer tech. It seems the only way to make the manufacturer somewhat responsible for the residual utility of the car after its prime years.
- hackermatic 3y agoI've seen very few chargers with prominent signage, visible from a major road (the ones in supermarket parking lots usually can't be seen until you're there), or next to existing gas stations. I also haven't seen any entertainment media showing someone plugging in or unplugging their EV, whether through product placement or organic scriptwriting. How else, in America, will the non-enthusiasts realize that owning an EV could be a practical option, even an ordinary one?
- josephcsible 3y ago> I've seen very few chargers with prominent signage, visible from a major road Is there a point to such signage when the cars' built-in navigation knows where the chargers are and automatically routes you to the most optimal one on trips where you need one?
- inigoalonso 3y agoThe point is to convince the people driving ICE cars that the chargers exist.
- ghaff 3y agoIf I were considering an electric car, which I'm not, I would probably look at maps that presumably exist on the Internet before I'd trust random spottings on my part.
- jacooper 3y agoUntil it breaks or becomes out of date.
- tippytippytango 3y agothe charging infrastructure just isn't good enough for non-enthusiasts and apartment dwellers
- rainsford 3y agoI think the apartment/city dweller problem is a major limiting factor that does not have an obvious or quick solution. Owning an electric car if you can charge it at home is a pretty big experience upgrade over a gasoline powered vehicle since it is considerably cheaper to fuel and it happens with very little effort while you sleep. For those people, the less convenient experience of on-the-go electric charging might be worse than stopping at a gas station, but it happens rarely enough that it's not necessarily a major consideration. If you can't easily charge at home though, electric cars kind of suck and offer a noticeably worse experience. Sure, you could probably make it work by exclusively charging at public fast chargers similar to how you fill up a gasoline car now, but those are much harder to find and inconveniently slow enough to be annoying to use on a regular basis. I know people who do this because they like the idea of a electric car enough to put up with it, but that's not going to ever be most prospective car buyers. Trying to make non-home electric charging competitive with gas stations is going to take a long time and faces a catch-22 if EV purchase rates slow down. And upgrading every condo/apartment building and city with street parking to have sufficient overnight charging capacity is not a quick answer either. Anecdotally, I would absolutely buy an electric car if I didn't live in a condo with no charging facilities, but no way I'd do it without being able to charge at home. However, also worth noting that while I wouldn't move just so I could charge my car, I probably also wouldn't move to a new home without EV charging options unless I was forced to for some reason. So I'm guessing market pressure will make it happen eventually, not it's not right around the corner.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoDo you have 120V at your parking spot? I know several people who bought electric cars, planning on putting in a charger in their garage. And then never bothered, because 120V was good enough. You can come home with an empty battery Sunday, plug in every weeknight, putting on 100 miles of charge overnight and taking off 50 miles every weekday for commuting and have a full battery by Thursday or Friday.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoCost is the biggest problem - we need affordable EV's - something affordable in the $20,000 range. Also hybrids are more realistic than pure EV's.
- rainsford 3y agoNon-plugin hybrids solve a different problem. They're more efficient, but they're not really a solution if you want a car powered by electricity. Plug-ins are interesting because a lot of people could use pure electric power for commuting and the gas engine for longer trips. But they're really only useful if you can charge at home and at this point I wonder how many potential plug-in customers just bought a pure EV, which has an attractive simplicity to it rather than having all the problems of both types of power trains.
- Moto7451 3y agoGood plugin hybrids are a very viable option. At some point I’ll need a three row vehicle and most of our needs would be handled by something like the Mazda CX9. The next best option with three rows and electrification is the Rivian. The Rivian is a different type of vehicle than what I really need, even though it’s cool. What I want is an electrified station wagon, but the latter doesn’t really exist anymore. The CX9’s 26 miles of battery power is enough to handle the majority of our standard in town trips without burning fuel.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoCitroën ë-C3 was just released in Europe for just over $20K.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoWhen is the ID.2 coming out ???.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIn the states at least, there are barely any $20k cars left, those people are just in the used car market now. China, where no one want to buy used cars, has plenty of even $10k EVs. If the USA and China ever drop car tariffs…and USA safety standards are revised a bit, those cars could be sold here.
- gigel82 3y agoThere is a recent anti-EV campaign, not sure who funded it or why (probably oil companies). I'm seeing a lot of negative press in the past couple of months.
- ivraatiems 3y agoThere are so many massive, complex, institutional problems with the auto industry that I am not sure "not as many more people are wanting new EVs as we thought" is the problem the article, and the executives it quotes, think it is. It feels like the industry is blaming consumers for not wanting what they're willing to make and support. It should be other way around. We don't have a usable national charging network. EVs still don't have the range of gas-powered cars. Many EVs are much more expensive than similar gas-powered cars. Few mechanics and dealers fully understand how to work on EVs. Conspiracy theories are rampant - somebody told me they thought the tires on EVs would give them cancer; another person told me he thought all EVs were just explosions waiting to happen (as though an IC engine is better!). Chevy recently attempted to discontinue its small, affordable Chevy Bolt in favor of larger, bulkier, more expensive vehicles built on a new platform. It did this during a year where the Bolt sold record numbers and was widely hailed as one of the best and most economical EVs around. The Bolt converted people - myself included - who could not or would not have otherwise bought an EV, and Chevy tried to discontinue it (and later relented and said they'd offer a new version of it in the face of popular demand). But sure, it's the consumer's fault. How dare people not buy new cars.
- mullingitover 3y ago> We don't have a usable national charging network. I feel like there's a big lever the federal government has its hands on that would solve this in record time: Add a substantial gas station tax which is only applied to gas stations with fewer than two level 3 chargers, and watch how fast the national charging network happens. It doesn't even need to cost the gas station anything. A vendor can foot the bill for installing the chargers and split the profits with the gas station. It would be a boon for gas stations, since EV charging customers are far more likely to generate foot traffic in their stores (where they make the majority of their money) than gas customers who just gas and go.
- darknavi 3y agoWell until recently with the wide-spread adoption of NACS I am not surprised gas stations didn't make the leap. Now there isn't much of a "technological ambiguity" excuse and they should be able to execute clearly.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThere are still large market gaps in terms of the types of EV you can buy. I am waiting for an AWD EV with high ground clearance and decent range, which doesn't seem to exist currently. You can get all of this in an inexpensive gas car and there are substantial parts of the US where these checkboxes are legitimately non-negotiable. And this is before the issues surrounding charging. Maybe in five years the situation will have improved.
- mint2 3y agoSame. The problem is the current EVs only market certain demographic- status seekers, truck people, and commuters. No decent suvs for real people yet, which is a large untapped demand.
- josephcsible 3y ago> I am waiting for an AWD EV with high ground clearance and decent range, which doesn't seem to exist currently. Don't Rivian's vehicles meet all of those requirements?
- anonuser123456 3y agoRivian's cost $$$ and their maintenance is even worse. There was a post on here where the cost to repair Rivian's bumper was like 42K.
- jinushaun 3y ago$90k is not something the average person should be paying for a car.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoRivian is getting closer but the effective real-world range is too short.
- josephcsible 3y agoEven with the Max Pack's 410-mile rated range?
- heteric 3y agoSynthetic fuel is the way to go.
- lordfrito 3y agoThere's so much fanboyism around EVs, I think that EV proponents seriously overestimate their appeal and impact. To must of us a car is just a car, not some statement to the world about my alignment with the right causes and the cool kids. It seems like a highly emotional topic for those that are proponents, not a good sign. The automakers, not wanting to be left out, jumped in once it became clear that EVs were kinda workable. You can't blame them, they have to follow the market. I'm sure they had internal doubters, but you have to see plans through just in case. I'd argue investment in EVs is just a hedge for at least half of the automakers. Outside of a few diehards proponents, no one I know is particularly interested in owning an EV. EV proponents can't stop talking about how world changing and life affirming they are. I'm sure that's where part of the lack of interest stems from.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoTruly "car is just a car" people will switch when EV's are cheaper than gasoline cars.
- lordfrito 3y agoThere's so much fanboyism around EVs, I think that EV proponents seriously overestimate their appeal and impact. To most of us a car is just a car, not some statement to the world about my alignment with the right causes and the cool kids. It seems like a highly emotional topic for those that are proponents, not a good sign. The automakers, not wanting to be left out of the Next Big Thing, jumped in once it became clear that EVs were kinda workable. You can't blame them, they have to follow the market. I'm sure they had internal doubters, but you have to see plans through just in case. I'd argue investment in EVs is just a hedge for at least half of the automakers. Outside of a few diehards proponents, no one I know is particularly interested in owning an EV. EV proponents can't stop talking about how world changing and life affirming they are. I'm sure that's where part of the lack of interest from the rest of us stems from. We just don't care.
- simonblack 3y agoWhy do we hear time after time about the electric vehicles themselves? That's putting the cart before the horse. It doesn't matter if every family goes out and buys an electric vehicle at all. WHAT DOES MATTER IS WHETHER OR NOT THOSE VEHICLES CAN BE USEFULLY CHARGED. Step one is NOT getting everybody to buy an electric vehicle. Step One is putting in the work on building a capable electricity grid. When the electricity grid in Texas goes down in winter from overload, WE KNOW THE ELECTRICITY GRID IS INSUFFICIENT! We need to spend trillions on electricity grid infrastructure before we try to get the general public to buy an electric vehicle. NO ELECTRICITY GRID CAPABILITY, NO CHARGING OF MILLIONS OF ELECTRIC VEHICLES AT THE SAME TIME = NO SALES OF ELECTRIC VEHICLES TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
- anonuser123456 3y agoI don't understood why plugin hybrids aren't more popular. The Toyota Prius prime is like a 'just take my money' car for me. My commute would be all electric... but I can still use gas if need be. Best of all worlds.
- ivraatiems 3y agoI agree, the Prius Prime is a very attractive car (both in terms of looking surprisingly cool for a Prius, and for the reasons you mention). I went for a full EV because I wanted to just not have to worry about gas or IC engine maintenance anymore.
- kkfx 3y agoLadies and gentleman, try to read it under the wood: the real point is that a right BEV price is LESS than an ICE counterpart. That's not a thing automakers want. Secondly most automakers have ceased decades ago doing REAL free research to focus on short-term results, as a results Chinese automakers start to do almost BETTER things that western counterparts. That's are IMVHO the main points: people rightly do not want to pay overpriced BEVs and do not want to pay more than nearly identical Chinese counterparts. So western automakers try to catch the reactionary push of many against all new things to keep selling hybrid absurdities few years more.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoQuote from article to support this: > GM chief executive Mary Barra said this week that “moderating the pace of our EV acceleration” would allow the company to maintain strong pricing. And several other complaints that there's too much competition.