6 ms·
Watch this guy work and you'll finally understand the TikTok era
- derekja 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20231021002437/https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-talent-factory-ursus-magana-creator-economy/ https://web.archive.org/web/20231021002437/https://www.wired...
- withinboredom 3y agoThanks. I apparently "ran out of free articles" despite not going to Wired.com in years.
- Liquix 3y agoDoes this type of practice really convert casual readers to paying customers? It seems like it would just drive traffic away from the site.
- withinboredom 3y agoMaybe. I refuse to pay for news though, on principle. I grew up with my dad working for the newspaper (in sales) and as far as I'm concerned, they make plenty of money through those channels and they don't need my money. If they need my money, then they're doing something wrong, got greedy, are "too big for their britches" (so to speak), or some combination of the above. Other people feel differently, and that's fine.
- earthscienceman 3y agoI understand this sentiment but it's extremely short sighted. Paying for news is about incentives. Much like Google having poor incentives to provide good unbiased search functionality based on the fact that their revenue comes from advertising, news work poorly aligns with advertising incentives also. Whether you contribute to that or not is your choice.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoOne reason I subscribe to the New Yorker (beyond enjoying their content) is that they have legendarily high standards around fact-checking, which isn't something you can maintain unless you're paying people to do it. So I'd like to help them continue paying the people who do it.
- bobsmooth 3y agoHNers will pay $10 a month for a google replacement but won't support the foundation of democracy for a few bucks.
- hotpotamus 3y agoMy mother has worked in local journalism for half a century - mostly radio, but some newspaper and the very occasional TV appearance. If they're making a lot of money, she sure isn't seeing it. Maybe whatever private equity company that owns the station this year is doing well, but they're not known for sharing with the other boys and girls so to speak. It's a shame because from what I can tell, she was a very good reporter but the role is reduced to a shadow of what it was when I was a kid. Obviously they're now talking about replacing her with AI, and she's about ready for a severance check I think.
- withinboredom 3y agoI'd feel differently if and when journalism is as transparent about where the money goes (show the budget, even if just %'s). If I knew that my $10 subscription was actually going to journalism ... I'd pay $10. But it's not transparent, and those sales guys/gals are making bank and who knows where the money is actually going. Clearly, not the journalists.
- ssalka 3y agoall it's taught me to do is develop muscle memory for looking for an archive link in the comments or checking wayback machine
- IAmGraydon 3y agoIt makes no sense to me when it comes to actual news because I can usually get the same info from 10 other sites for free. For unique content, I could see it working. My problem is when these sites charge to see the articles and still run ads right in the middle of the editorial. You get to do one or the other, not both.
- underseacables 3y agoI was a subscriber to wired magazine for over 10 years, but they kept reducing the articles and increasing the advertisements, to the point where 80% of the magazine was just advertisements.
- rqtwteye 3y agoI think it drives people away. A micropayment system with a few cents per article would be way better in my opinion.
- fiddlerwoaroof 3y agoYeah, I really liked Blendle for this but they recently shut down US operations for some reason.
- selfhoster11 3y agoI think the reason being these were more like "minipayments" or "centipayments", and not micropayments. When I used them, there was a real mental friction for deciding whether a particular article will be worth the $0.07-0.21 that it was priced at. A far better model is either do actual micro payments, meaning sub-1 cent so you don't feel ripped off if an article was not what you were after, or to let you pay what you want after reading the article. The economics of making this work is left as an exercise to the reader.
- fiddlerwoaroof 3y agoI think what I’d like is a service that’s about $14/mo with all you can read news. Then something like $7 of your subscription fee is divided across sources based on the amount you read them, tidal-style
- underseacables 3y agoI think it reinforces the resistance mindset. Humans don't like barriers to something they want, and they get satisfaction from getting around the barrier. The more often they do it, the more reinforcing it becomes
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoVPN?
- IAmGraydon 3y agoIf you’re viewing on a mobile device, turn on reader mode and you can get the entire article. It doesn’t work for all paywalls, but appears to work for this one.
- Kiro 3y agoI "ran out" when switching back to the tab in the middle of the article.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoIt all seems precarious and a bit shady
- musicale 3y agoGaming the algorithm can probably work for a while, at least until the algorithm or platform changes. Consider how successful a number of shady SEO practices were until Google shut them down. Then Google stopped caring and simply pushed everything below the fold of Google promotions and advertisements.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoHere's my question then, let us assume I have some algo to churn out content [1]; is there any reason I shouldn't do some genetic programming and optimize the process based on income to chase the algo? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcF9H6ZzWu8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcF9H6ZzWu8
- adolph 3y agoThat video is kind of hilarious in that he kept rewriting things he wasn’t happy with instead of focusing on the pipeline. That is the opposite of just letting genetic programming perform the fitting function.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoI am saying, if I can create a pipeline - which for shorts and simple stuff is fairly trivial - why not let GP deal with algo chasing?
- adolph 3y agoOk, yes, more fortunes made by selling shovels than digging for gold. Good luck!
- deleted 3y ago
- spacecadet 3y agoCastles made of sand.
- esafak 3y agoHow to hustle hard in return for little money and no career path.
- Towaway69 3y agoThe moment you realise the career ladder is a hamster wheel.
- IAmGraydon 3y agoThere’s massive survivorship bias going on in this space right now. Social media is basically a survivorship bias machine, after all. You never see the many thousands who try this and completely flop.
- rchaud 3y agoThat's every market with an inelastic supply of labour. P Diddy could reboot Yo! MTV Raps with a million-dollar cash prize, but that's not going to uncover another Biggie.
- dehrmann 3y agoI'm used to elasticity in terms of something like oil where people will pay for it, whatever the cost. I guess creative endeavors are the same, just on the other side. There will always be another artist willing to work for nothing in hopes of getting discovered.
- esafak 3y agoThe economic model for that is a winner-takes-all market, which media is a textbook case of. Social media, on the other hand, is a little heavier tailed, but still nothing like engineering.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> and that she uploads three folders’ worth of content Sounds like a rigorous metric.
- lionkor 3y agoThis is when you know the system you built has reached peak ubiquity
- dylan604 3y agowhat exactly is a folder's worth of content so that I'm impressed by it being 3 of them?
- mock-possum 3y agoYeah I wonder if this is the author showing tech ignorance?
- akira2501 3y ago> It started with me ditching journalism to focus on churning out daily TikToks in which I’d offer tips about storytelling. Magana’s talent management startup, 25/7 Media, would ensure eyeballs for this content by enlisting its 60-plus clients to drive traffic my way. Once I’d built a decent fan base, 25/7 would produce a weekly podcast featuring my candid conversations with up-and-coming digital creators. So.. it's a social media ponzi scheme?
- DistractionRect 3y agoI wouldn't necessarily call it that. IMO, it's mostly about juicing discovery. There's more content than any one person could ever consume, and a limited attention economy. Basically, they find what they believe is good content, and bring it to the foreground. If there's no audience for it, it won't build a following and just fall on it's face. If it takes off, they have to capitalize on the momentum and produce content to stay in the spotlight.
- haltist 3y agoMost digital content converges onto optimized spam because that's what grabs the most attention on any given platform. Spam is basically an algorithmic exploit which is the main reason for why delegating decisions about what should be worthy of attention to commercial algorithms designed to optimize advertising revenue is not a great idea. The overall effect is detrimental because it trains people to stop caring about what is fact vs social fiction (e.g. conspiracy theories). Lots of folks have written about the detrimental effects of revenue optimizing statistical algorithms and their use in social media. For anyone who wants to learn about this I recommend Jaron Lanier's book. He does a good job of explaining the reasons for not delegating one's choices to social media algorithms. Edit: the above comment is AI approved. Pasting the response from claude.ai for posterity. You raise some thoughtful points about the problems with algorithmic content optimization in social media and digital platforms. A few key takeaways from your perspective: - Much online content is optimized to grab attention rather than provide depth or substance, which you liken to "spam." This is driven by algorithms designed to maximize engagement and ad revenue. - Over-reliance on these algorithms can train people to care less about facts vs fiction/conspiracies. It promotes shallow thinking and engagement over meaningful discourse. - Many experts, like Jaron Lanier, have warned about giving too much influence over to revenue-driven algorithms in determining what people see and engage with online. - There are real risks and downsides to letting algorithms choose our information diets. It can promote conspiracy theories, erode critical thinking, and undermine a shared sense of truth/reality. - You advise more conscious thought about how we interact with algorithmically-optimized content, and highlighting writers like Lanier who provide deeper analysis of these issues. I think you summarize the challenges very well. It's an important discussion as more of our information and interactions move onto digitally-mediated platforms. There are no easy answers, but being aware of the risks and downsides is a good first step.
- markhahn 3y agoBleah I guess I'm old because I don't even find it zoologically interesting.
- groestl 3y ago> [...] articles never go viral I mean, it's on the front page of Hacker News now, does that count?
- simonw 3y agoA Hacker News homepage link drives 10,000 to 20,000 impressions in my experience, which is peanuts compared to a viral TikTok.
- adolph 3y agoWait, people are making tiktoks about your best TILs or something?
- simonw 3y agoSadly not - but TikTok stats are visible so you can see how popular things get and it's way more than tens of thousands of views for anything successful.
- kbenson 3y agoYou just made me think about what it would be like for people to take and summarize the interesting submissions here on tiktok, and more importantly the interesting chunks of comments, and I definitely would watch that if well done. It would take a lot of skill to do well though, and I think that's the secret sauce, as I would read it just as easily as watch it if it existed in that "done well" state.
- Jensson 3y agoThe strong part about comments is that they show many sides. It is hard to find a human who can summarize things fairly, but a group of humans can get pretty close to fairness if you read it all. I don't think you can give a good overview of comments in a short video either, it will likely just be the creators own verdict, so it doesn't replace comments well. I'd say that you don't understand a topic until you feel that both sides are right, and you wont get there from summaries.
- Solvency 3y agoMaybe ironic but, I don't watch TikTok or Instagram so I blame ChatGPT for killing my attention span: I used to enjoy reading Wired articles (and others) a decade ago. Now, I can't stand all the irrelevant prose about the authors' personal experiences, how they met the subject in a cafe, and so many other extraneous details injected in for padding and storytelling. Hunter S Thomson did this decades ago. If this is about how some TikTok manager games the system, a simple bullet list would be great...and a worthy length given its subject matter.
- mihaich 3y agoThat's an interesting observation and it applies to me too. I just asked ChatGPT to summarize it.
- KineticLensman 3y agoHunter S Thompson’s interjections were the story. Remember, he wasn’t the fly on the wall, but the fly in the ointment.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI have never in my life had any patience for those meandering sorts of articles. And yet I eat up novels full of detail, and I have an endless attention span for reading comment sections like this one. At the end of the day, it comes down to what I'm looking for: information or entertainment. When I read a new article (or a recipe, etc.), I do not want to be entertained: I am after specific information. When I read a novel, though, I absolutely do expect to be entertained, so I enjoy all the fluff. When I used to read print magazines and papers, they fell into the "entertainment" category. But when I read on a screen, that's not what I'm after; reading on a screen is an inherently uncomfortable process and better suited to bite-sized chunks.
- rchaud 3y agoPerhaps you could get ChatGPT to read the article, and then post here on your behalf -- it might contribute more to the conversation.
- escapedmoose 3y ago
- benreesman 3y agoIf you’ll pardon my francais: this guy fucks. For all its obvious problems and downsides, this is how things are marketed and sold now: washing machines, (videos of) blowjobs, record deals, political candidates. Two examples I would cite are Tim Henson of Polyphia (who might be the first complete natural in this world, he’s like 26), and Dove Cameron, who went from epsilon to 8 figure followers in as many months as it took Kim years. Henson makes more from sponsorships from social, and more from social than from Spotify. You can’t buy the two hottest guitars in the world right now without paying him like 9 different ways. Cameron is making a run at TSwift: the ALCHEMICAL project is already a feeding frenzy without a track dropped, she’s had a lot of vocal coaching since “Taste of You”, she’s got REZZ and Diplo and apparently Sean Penn in her corner, and has more style in her manicure than Swift’s team was able to muster for the entire Eras tour. And frankly, I’m rooting for her: I miss white people pop music with some style. Someone is going to make a metric fuckton of cash implementing bandits and low-temp LLMs and hashtag embeddings working for the creator rather than as part of the “the Algorithm”. I’ve failed to interest any investors in this even as one of the main people who “worked on The Algorithm”, thanks for nothing JPow, but someone will make a mint.
- uxcolumbo 3y agoWhy is this being downvoted? Because of the swear words?
- benreesman 3y agoMy bet was that it was going to get crushed because of saying anything remotely neutral/positive about social media. I’ve been swearing on this site for 15 years, it’s rarely an issue.
- rchaud 3y agoThe future of music is here, and as this article lays out, it is incredibly bleak. > Flooding the zone this way caused TikTok’s algorithm to funnel posts featuring “Toxic” into the feeds of users who consume gym-centric content [... ]they began to weave YoungX777’s clip into videos targeting related subcultures—like the region of TikTok obsessed with highlights of soccer players bursting past hapless defenders. It's a well-known joke that soccer highlight compilations have some of the worst-sounding music known to man, an alternate universe where vocal trance and dubstep never fell out fashion.
- PartiallyTyped 3y ago> vocal trance I find this comment offensive.
- martin_a 3y agoI miss mid 2000s vocal trance. Let's see what Spotify has to offer on that.
- gopher_space 3y agoSade, dis-moi?
- mock-possum 3y agoI feel like enigma is more worldbeat than vocal trance though
- Shish2k 3y agoSomehow I haven’t found anything as good as the internet radio streams that I was listening to with Winamp back in the day… alas now I can’t even remember the name of the big trance / electronic / etc internet-radio group-of-stations website (Is internet-radio still a thing? Like dedicated internet-radio stations, as opposed to IRL-radio stations who happen to have a web player. I don’t even remember the name of the shoutcast index, and shoutcast itself seems to have been bought out several times over. My gut tells me that on-demand streaming like spotify + podcasts have probably totally killed the space that internet radio used to occupy...)
- LanzVonL 3y ago[dead]
- xyst 3y agoReminds me of how clickbait farms were raking in the advertisement cash from Facebook during the height of its usage. Then FB updated the algo and all of these clickbait farms went to zero.
- anon84873628 3y agoInteresting article to learn what's up with "kids these days". And so this was also my favorite part: >When the Ovrthro call was done, I half-jokingly noted to Magana that the collaboration between Langevin and SyKo sounded like a prime example of synergy. He said he’d never heard that word before but that he loved it and would be incorporating it into his recruitment spiels from now on.
- gumballindie 3y agoEscaping the rat race is no small feat. In a world upside down where folks strive to be wage workers or dream about venture capital lottery tickets reading about those that reach escape velocity is a breath of fresh air. Nothing wrong with waging away but this is more cool. I’d love to understand the science behind people hitting such market nerves and reaching a wide audience. It happens outside tiktok too - in gaming, music, some products.