6 ms·
Why teachers in South Korea are scared of their pupils, and their parents
- underseacables 3y agoA personal anecdote. I have a friend who teaches English in South Korea. He teaches at a private Academy, and the administration is terrified of the parents. The students openly mock teachers, hurl racial abuse at those of color, without fear. Disciplining them risks drawing the ire of the parents, who blame the school and therefore the parents withdrawing their kids from the academies.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoI wish they gave some concrete examples of why the teachers are so afraid. What do they mean by discipline? Can a teacher send a student to the principals office? Would that risk them being sued by their parents?
- kotojo 3y agoFrom a bit of a ways into the article "Ahn says she would like to see penalties for parents who make unfounded accusations against teachers or practical measures put in place so that mandated changes can be adopted in classrooms, such as removing a disruptive student elsewhere to allow teaching to continue." So, it seems like they don't even have the power to make a student leave their classroom without fear of retaliation at the moment.
- kijin 3y agoIf you send a student somewhere outside of the classroom, the parents can argue that 1) you deprived him/her of educational opportunities; 2) you mentally abused him/her by sending her alone into the dark, scary corridor; and 3) you damaged his/her self-esteem by doing this in front of all the other students. If the parents are in a particularly vindictive mood, they can probably get a psychiatrist to back up their bullshit, too. None of these charges are likely to stick under the revised legal framework, but the mere threat of a lawsuit can be tremendously burdensome to a young teacher just out of college. The teacher who committed suicide in Gangnam last summer was only 23 years old.
- rqtwteye 3y agoI have heard similar stories from US teachers I hike with. Parents will side with their kinds or just not care and school administration will side with the parents or do nothing. This leaves teachers having to deal with discipline issues but not having any tools or support to actually enforce discipline. They all want to leave the job or take retirement as soon as they can.
- brycewray 3y agoRelative of a US teacher and can confirm. The COVID lockdown made it worse but things were deteriorating before that.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoI’m sorry but good. A mass resigning or mass exodus from that industry would be good for everyone involved. Teachers should never have been disciplinarians. Their role is to teach kids. If kids are a behavior problem, the teacher should be allowed to expel/ban them from the classroom. This is the only thing that school administration needs to back teachers on. Education being compulsory for students who don’t want it is an extreme social mistake and one we should remedy as soon as possible. These disruptive students do far more damage to other good students than the benefit they provide if you “try hard” to make them work anyway. Not worth it. The status quo in America gives teachers far too much power to decide the lifetime earning potential and fate of young students. Teachers are extremely tyrannical and that fact is never brought up at all in education discourse. (not even by the “anti teacher” right wingers)
- andrewprock 3y agoThe power of education has nothing to do with the teachers. It has to do with hiring for professional employment with degree requirements (e.g. management, government, lab techs, etc). There are tons of people who can do various jobs but do not have the required (often extraneous) certification. Parents are not chasing learning, they are chasing certification. Those two things correlate, but not enough to satisfy parents. A good example of this is journalism, which used to require little to no certification, but which today can require masters degrees for some positions. In the end, the people that know and learn will have longer more productive careers, but there are enough sinecures in Korean (and US) society that the value of certification is overweighted.
- gryn 3y agonot from korea but I think it's the same dynamics that can be seen elsewhere where there are private schools & cram schools, ie the parent are a direct source of revenue. where you have highly disrespectful and disruptive students that don't want to learn and cause a ruckus but the teachers can't say anything even sending them to the principals office because they risk getting fired, and they tend to be easily replaced in the private sector. sending them to the principal office does nothing, because they tend to be boot-lickers scared of losing a source of revenue. They won't scold the child and what exasperate the problem is the parents have the view that their child can do no wrong. Anecdotally, The only thing I've seen that work in that case is more parents with more social influence complaining about said problematic children (since they risk losing more if the group of parent decide to move their children).
- panzagl 3y agoSounds like they need a union.
- robertlagrant 3y agoUnionising against the parents?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe customer is not always right. Parents can be savages (speaking as a parent who has had to interact with some of these folks) and administration can have no spine or will. Also why there is a teacher shortage in the US. Shit job for shit wages. The desired outcome is student education and actualization, not necessarily parental happiness. Some parents feel otherwise. Lots of Karens of all genders out there. thadt’s comment is spot on (chef kiss): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38050798 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38050798 Lots of other great comments in thread about what teachers face from parents.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI'm not sure if you've replied to the right comment. What's this got to do with whether you can unionise against your (sort of) customers?
- thadt 3y agoThe article poses it as a question, but the answer is evident - it's a culture problem. Not 'South Korean' culture, but specifically the culture of relationships they've allowed to develop between parents and teachers. A good education comes from a collaboration between parents and teachers. Parents are ultimately responsible for their child's education, and teachers serve as helpers pursuing that. A teacher's authority is delegated from the parent. The parents mentioned in this article appear to wish to train their children to treat them, their teachers, and others with harassment and disrespect. If a teacher or school system isn't willing to help them in that endeavor, then they are pursing different goals - it's not a relationship that can work. One of the parties in that relationship can and should leave to go do something else.
- m3kw9 3y agoIs a law/school rule problem, the law allows easy suing and parent harassment of teachers. The new laws now restricts a lot of it
- lvl102 3y agoWhile the Korean public school system is very flawed at least the teachers get paid well enough there. I would not want to be a teacher in wealthy neighborhoods such as Gangnam.
- Michelangelo11 3y agoTiny detail, but very interesting to me: > In the past, Ahn said, “If I could not give my personal phone number to them, sometimes some parents would come to the parking lot and watch and see and take a note of my phone number from my car, then they would text message me.” It is customary for Koreans to display their phone number in the bottom corner of their windscreen. I'm amazed this can work without everyone being bombarded by spam calls etc.
- kijin 3y agoIt became customary because parking spaces are so hard to find in Seoul. You often need to block someone else's car. When the other car needs to move, they'll call the number on your windscreen. It's usually on the driver's side near the VIN sticker. Most people answer immediately. They know they should expect calls if they parked where they might block somebody's movement. Collecting these numbers is not scalable, though, so it's rarely used for spamming. If you're worried about strangers getting hold of all the personal information and social network profiles tied to your phone number, you can get an anonymized 050 number that forwards to your real number.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIs it scaleable from modern higher resolution google street view images now?
- kijin 3y agoCan't see anything on publicly available street view images. The stickers are generally small, have low contrast, and are often hidden by the dot pattern surrounding the windshield if you look from straight ahead. (They are inside the car, on the dashboard. Example: [1]) You need to stand right next to the driver's seat and look down. Besides, there have been multiple data leaks of pretty much everyone's phone number, and over 80% of all available mobile numbers (010 + 8 digits) are in use. It would be much cheaper for spammers to buy a previously leaked dataset or even just call random numbers. [1] https://images.app.goo.gl/42Yevdz3uoAo3tDZ9 https://images.app.goo.gl/42Yevdz3uoAo3tDZ9
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- g8oz 3y ago"parents are regarded as like a consumer, with consumer sovereignty, and school and teachers are regarded as service providers”. This is absolutely true in North America as well, especially in more affluent neighborhoods.
- cantrevealname 3y ago> Government data shows 100 public school teachers killed themselves from January 2018 to June 2023 I think this kind of data analysis would be impossible in the U.S. and Canada, unless done by a government agency. I've never heard of a publicly available database[1] of cause of death in North American, let alone correlated with things like occupation, age, etc. [1] Note that I'm talking about current data, not 100 year old historical data.
- dchung333 3y agoThe CDC runs numbers on this for teachers the rate is about 7 per 100,000 every year this is one of the lowest rates out there. Similarly this rate translates from the 500,000 teachers to a rate of 4 per 100,000 which is statistically much lower than the USA and lower than the rates of suicides in the country as a whole. The article also likes to claim that this is caused directly by this specific policy which is also not true. The suicide rate in South Korea is primarily focused on the elderly population that was abandoned while the nation grew, it's primarily focused on the financial collapse that occurred in the 90s when the nation's stock exchange was targeted by other financial markets in order to generate wealth a similar event has occurred in other Asian countries which forced several million people into poverty. As for the other issues hyper competition is intense in most Asian countries, these issues are not unique to South Korea. In fact they are significantly worse in China and India. There is no culture problem but a systemic issue of a lack of jobs and opportunities and the overproduction of elites or highly educated individuals.
- m3kw9 3y ago“ It is customary for Koreans to display their phone number in the bottom corner of their windscreen.” That’s a wtf cultural thing I didn’t know about Koreans
- ilickpoolalgae 3y agoIt's because there's a huge shortage of parking spots and too many cars in Korea, particularly in big cities. It's customary to just park illegally and rely on the other party calling you if you're blocking them in.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoAmazing that this is so common people would affix their number on the car at all times instead of maybe putting a note on the wiper the few times they have to screw someone double parking
- dafelst 3y agoIf you drive in a big city in Korea, blocking someone in can be a multiple times a day kind of thing.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoAlso common in China. You can even get printed cards with a space for the number. Probably a healthier attitude to engage first and get angry second then a furiously passive aggressive social media rant or damaging the car, both of which I might expect if I blocked someone in over here.
- izzydata 3y agoAre all the students and parents a problem? Could there be a way to get non-disruptive students and their parents to fight against the disruptive ones? The teachers might not be able to do much because their job is on the line, but if enough parents who are equal customers get upset that their kids aren't getting the education they are paying for it seems like they could force the minority of disruptive students to fall in line.
- The_Colonel 3y agoThat seems like a very complex scheme. The parents get only second hand information from their kids who quite possibly can't evaluate the situation correctly and often don't mind it (they themselves don't care that much about education, the disruptor is a cool kid) etc. It's also not clear how they would fight it, like vote to reprimand the disruptor / their parents?
- DenisM 3y agoPerhaps make video recordings of classrooms? There could be some privacy issues, but an escrow process could help, plus classroom should not afford expectation of privacy.
- wrp 3y agoFirst some context. Since long past, I've heard that public school teachers in the USA generally come from the bottom 20% of their class. In contrast, applicants for teacher training in South Korea are required to come from the top 1/3 of their class. I've experienced a huge difference in the quality of discussion I can have with American versus Korean educational professionals. My point here is that Korean teachers have a higher level of training and professionalism than Americans might expect, so if they are complaining about something, it's really serious. Now, on to what has changed in Korean society the past decade. TFA points to the symptom but not the cause with "the teacher-parent dynamic is unrecognizable from just a decade or two ago" and "parents are regarded as like a consumer, with consumer sovereignty." The big issue that TFA doesn't mention is demographics. With a declining student population, schools are desperate for cust--...err...students. I teach at the university level and academic standards have fallen through the floor. I'm not saying this is the only source of change, but I do think it is the main factor.
- joshl32532 3y ago> I've heard that public school teachers in the USA generally come from the bottom 20% of their class. No way this is true. ~57% of teachers have Master's degree or higher. Bottom 20% of their class means they'd barely have enough GPA to graduate, let alone get into a MEd program. https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/ntps/tables/ntps1718_fltable04_t1s.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/ntps/tables/ntps1718_fltable04_t...
- wudangmonk 3y agoI remember watching Hellbound and the most incredible thing to me was watching the scene where a a gang of 'minors' storm a police station because apparently nobody could stop them that they felt confident in attacking a police station full with armed police. The series itself is pretty good but I just found it funny that this particular scene broke my immersion in a sceries with interdimensional deamons that come to take souls to hell.
- Longlius 3y ago>Ahn says parents have called her mobile phone some days from 6 a.m. until 11 p.m., wanting to talk about their child or complain. This happens in the US too. I think we generally need much stronger rules about when parents can contact teachers and what expectations there are about response times. You shouldn't need to spend every waking minute of your day on-call for a job that pays ~$60k/year. This kind of stuff is the norm now and people wonder why no one wants to go into the teaching profession anymore.
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoWhy do they give their mobile number then?