3 ms·
What is the heuristic they are checking for here? That problematic actors overwhelmingly will be unable to show an active wifi adapter?
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
What is the heuristic they are checking for here? That problematic actors overwhelmingly will be unable to show an active wifi adapter?
- dehrmann 3y agoI'm guessing that's bots in data centers.
- sanswork 3y agoAlmost everyone uses wifi for everything now. If you're using Ethernet there is a very high probability you are actually a proxy/vpn exit on a rack in some random residential location.
- olyjohn 3y agoWell that's a shitty filter because now criminals will use wifi or fake using wifi. And then they will get right through. It's not that hard to fake. Security Theater.
- sanswork 3y agoYou're filtering for people using vpns to access your site from a country other than the one they are claiming. They likely aren't criminal operations just users operating outside the bounds of your service. They aren't going to have the ability to do anything but sign up for a vpn service so it works quite well for stopping them.
- viraptor 3y agoIf you get a list of wifi networks, you can look them up in various databases too check possible locations of the device.
- rsync 3y ago... which reminds me of an experiment I keep meaning to run: Can I do a quick wifi survey (somewhere) and then replicate the SSIDs and channels in a completely different location and fool one of these SSID mapping functions ? What are these functions scanning for to perform the geolocation other than SSID and frequency and MAC addresses ? Relative or triangulated signal strength ?
- viraptor 3y agoMost routers these days default to auto channel assignment. And the triangulation near any thicker wall will break down anyway. I'd be surprised if they looked up more than SSID for a match and then adjusted the location slightly based on signal strength.
- toast0 3y agoAlmost certainly. I'd guess most of these services are usinf BSSID (more or less mac address of the access point) instead of SSID and not using channel number or signal strength. If you report GPS position and BSSIDs anytime you see them, you can probably approximate a location when you only have a BSSID. IIRC, precision is fairly low for wifi approximated position, but maybe it's gotten better since I last looked. If you want to do a test, I'm happy to send you BSSIDs or whatever you need by email (address in profile) and you can geospoof to my house. I run too many APs, so it should work with just mine, but I can sometimes see neighbor APs as well. Google's api documentation [1] has only the macAddress as a required field, and that you need at least two addresses; but it does accept a signal strength measurement, as well as channel and snr. Other apis may vary. [1] https://developers.google.com/maps/documentation/geolocation/requests-geolocation#wifi_access_point_object https://developers.google.com/maps/documentation/geolocation...
- viraptor 3y agoYou can find bssid and other details from around the world at https://wigle.net/map https://wigle.net/map
- jcul 3y agoYes I think that would work. I remember moving house before withing the same city and moving our wifi router with us. For a while my phone kept placing me at my old house, when it didn't have a GPS signal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]