5 ms·
It took seven years but over-40s fired by HP win $18M settlement
- datadrivenangel 3y agoWill probably work out to ~$15k per person after fees.
- tyingq 3y ago"If approved without changes, each of the 358 plaintiffs in the California case stand to earn $50,279 in gross individual recovery. Net of attorney's fees, costs and expenses, however, that total shrinks to a "minimum of $15,000," court filings indicate."
- zer8k 3y agoLike usual lawyers walk away with Ferraris and the victims get a pittance. It's particular egregious in this case. $15k is almost surely less than even a year's wages. How pathetic. The very least they could do is calculate 7 years worth of interest on the 18M...but then the scumbag lawyers get more.
- jstarfish 3y ago> $15k is almost surely less than even a year's wages. How pathetic. That's not the worst of it. It took seven years of effort to be awarded a $15k payout. Cutting the lawyers out altogether, even the full $50k is still less than a single year's salary for the median household. It doesn't fix anything.
- valianteffort 3y agoI know basically nothing about the law but isn't the most important thing here the groundwork they laid? Since this case can be used as precedence for others who feel they were discriminated against.
- jfim 3y agoIt seems like such a minor fine that it's likely doing the opposite: showing businesses that it's completely okay to do so, and the worst that can happen is a slight fine.
- rio517 3y agoSeems like a slap on the wrist.
- pan69 3y agoIt's a settlement, which makes it even worse I guess.
- strangesmells02 3y agoOne company down...the entire rest of the tech industry to go. As an over 40 the job search is grim
- throwaway5959 3y agoThe job market in general blows right now. Keep at it and good luck!
- strangesmells02 3y agoIts out of this world bad. Like every job after a day has hundreds of applicants according to LinkedIn. Online applying seems to be shooting the rez into the void
- pfannkuchen 3y agoCurious what sort of level you are, if your company does that? I have wondered whether the ageism thing is partially related to younger people being a lottery ticket in terms of talent+commitment level. The company might get lucky and hire someone who is way overpowered but currently under leveled because they have not yet had time to reach their terminal seniority level. This ends up being a great bargain for the company. Whereas with established people it’s a bit more you get what you pay for.
- swatcoder 3y agoI think a bigger “legitimate” factor is craft culture. Because of the industry’s recent rapid growth wave, the approach experienced older developers take to the craft is often very different than what’s trendy among younger developers and teams where they dominate, and there’s easily a clash where both think the others’ approach is totally bonkers and a red flag. Somebody seeking a job may know or believe they can adapt, but the hiring team just sees an outsider and assumes the outsider doesn’t know how to do things “right”. This applies to skilled young developers trying to break into “old school” teams in defense/enterprise/industrial/etc as much as to older developers trying to keep up with youth-dominated FAANG and imitators, but it’s tolerated in the former but can get labelled as ageism in the latter.
- gemstones 3y agoA take on why there’s so much over 40 discrimination, and why I expect it to decline somewhat in the next decade: Imagine the crotchety (young) programmer you know. The guy who’s kind of a mild know-it-all, who gets disinvited from business meetings for being too abrupt, they guy you have to front with a good PM to talk to anyone external. Maybe a little autistic, perhaps undiagnosed; regardless, they seem to have trouble connecting and “getting” people. Early CS - before it was well known that it would be a fast track to the upper middle class - was full of these people. Computers draws that personality type in. Limited interaction with others, working code wins, you can get lost in a math problem. But we needed more programmers! And now, it’s well known that being a programmer is lucrative. So the younger generation is less full of people who really love computers and want to escape human interaction; they learned computers cause they’re smart, and want to make money. But they’re probably good with people too! Most people are. Where does that leave the older generation? Over a certain age, you’re more likely to be the type that’s a bit hard to work with, swimming in a sea of graduates who have people skills now. And as you might expect, companies will pick the people with hard and soft skills given the choice. They don’t want to entertain the prickly guy who wants a math problem and a pizza slid under the door, if they have alternatives. As the pool of devs widens, expect the age discrimination gap to narrow. Not go away, but narrow. People never really liked the no-social-skills aspect of CS nerdiness. They just tolerated it, for a time.
- sneed_chucker 3y agoMaybe. Sounds like a pet theory to me though. I have not found the over 40 engineers I've worked with to be like that. I've always felt that the ageism in tech has more to do with the fact that older workers generally have families, more savings, and more experience at different jobs so they can't be manipulated into being overworked the same way young and single people can.
- filoleg 3y ago> I have not found the over 40 engineers I've worked with to be like that. Keep the survivorship bias in mind. It would make sense within that per theory that the engineers in their 40s who have both hard skills are soft skills are the ones to be the most likely to stay employed. Which is why those ones you end up meeting would be more like that. And that would also align with the fact that many former engineers ended up leaving the field (whether voluntary or not) by that time in their life.
- theGnuMe 3y agoWhat. A. Joke. Won’t stop companies from doing this.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoAnd tech companies will still swear up and down that tech workers simply don't exist at any price.
- dave333 3y agoMany severance packages preclude filing such lawsuits as part of accepting the package. Also at another large tech company I have seen statistics including age published by the company when they make layoffs that would tend to refute any possible age discrimination. Easy for a company to fire a few more juniors to get the age stats clean, then quickly rehire. So the law is in place, but in practice it is limited in effect. On the hiring end, age discrimination is rampant.
- justinclift 3y agoThe fine, and the amount each of the people receives, seems to be missing a few 0's on the end. :( :( :(
- lysergic 3y agoWhy do companies more or less openly discriminate against older people?? It's nice to be able to have a more experienced professional give advice and help you out. I've heard multiple times when interviewing for jobs, that their company has a "young" culture and it always made me uneasy.
- citrin_ru 3y agoThere are many young people in IT - fast growth of the industry being one of the reasons. People prefer to work with people which are like themselves e. g. young prefer to work with young. When I was young I myself had a bias against older IT precessional which was foolish as I can see now. What puzzles me executives are rarely young but they allow ageism to thrive.
- davidgerard 3y agoIf you have the temperament for it, consider switching to sysadmin. There's a lot less age discrimination there, and decades of experience is a distinct plus point. I'm 56 and my employability is fine.
- kokken 3y agoI’ve been thinking about that move. What do you think are the main skills that a SE should refine if they want to transition to a sysadmin role?
- davidgerard 3y agoIt's a high level support role with a view to systemic reliability and enabling others. You're a roadie, and now you help others be Eric Clapton. Once you understand what ops is for, skills can be acquired. I'm not sure how to show a transition on your CV - but emphasising the "ops" side of "devops" to claim experience will probably help.