7 ms·
Our minds have evolved to thinking of "theft" and "ownership" in terms of physical terms, for the most part. Digital presents dynamics that don't neatly fit tha
by andsoitis 3y ago
Our minds have evolved to thinking of "theft" and "ownership" in terms of physical terms, for the most part. Digital presents dynamics that don't neatly fit that legacy mental model.
With digital goods, it isn't about stealing a product. It is more about stealing an income stream or someone's time and labor. When I deprive someone of an income stream that they are able to generate without coercian (by forcing others to buy), I am stealing their income stream which is really stealing their labor and time. The object (in this case digital) is simply a proxy.
Another angle to come at this from is to take it to the other extreme. If I spend all my days creating a digital product that people want, and everyone copies it, they are stealing my labor, my time, and I had no say in it.
- zerr 3y agoUnlike physical objects, copying digital goods has a zero cost, including for the author. So when the pricing does not reflect this (e.g. when ebook's and printed book's price is in the same order), it encourages unauthorised copying. It makes me think that sub-dollar and single digit pricing for digital goods are fair and expected.
- sbuttgereit 3y agoThis premise is terribly flawed and thus the conclusion is terribly flawed. First, the premise completely ignores the costs related to producing the original work being copied. That cost of development can at the very least be assigned to each copy made. And the assertion that "copying digital goods has a zero cost" is also false: if you've managed free access to electricity, storage, bandwidth, computer equipment, etc. let me know where so I can look to moving there. To be fair, many of those costs on a per unit basis are typically very small, but they are crucially not zero. Second. Prices are not a reflection of cost, but of value to the purchaser. Sure, when you produce a product, digital or otherwise, you are thinking about the cost to produce and trying to manage that aspect, but whatever the cost is it doesn't determine what the market will pay nor should it. If the product is highly valuable to a buyer, they'll pay more. To the degree you manage your costs relative to what the market will bear for the price, you will either profit to some variable degree or... if the market doesn't value you product for as much as it cost you... you'll lose your shirt. And yes, if I take a year to produce a piece of software and value my time producing it at say a modest $100k for my time, I could copy that software a billion times over only sell 10 copies: I'd only even break if each copy were sold at $10k each. It's true this isn't exactly a "Costs of Goods Sold" scenario in the regular sense, but it ultimately ends up meaning the same thing. So looking at just the cost of copying a digital asset without considering both the full cost of producing the asset relative to sales tells you nothing about what is fair in pricing. To be clear: a fair price is one where the money you spend on the product is less than the value you receive from that product in return. The actual dollar amount is irrelevant to it being a digital good, tangible good, or service.
- splitstud 3y ago[dead]
- coretx 3y agoLet's impose a tax on IPR rent seekers because they STEAL from everyone by means of creating deadweight loss. Incarcerate them when they don't comply.( As we do with all thieves )
- natch 3y agoYou definitely do have a say in whether to make things and what to make. I’ve made some copyable things for reasons other than money. Bullets on a resume, scratch own itch, fun, learning, etc. One has to accept that copyable things will be copied, and freely choose (you do have a say) whether to spend your time making them or not.
- hermannj314 3y agoI have written software that has eliminated a lot of jobs. I am not going to jail anytime soon. It is not a crime to deprive someone of their income stream, so I don't follow why that argument by itself concludes anything about ethics of digital copying. If it does, lock me up as well because I'm going to keep eliminating income streams for the rest of my life.
- raspyberr 3y ago>It is not a crime to deprive someone of their income stream You can't just fire people without a reason though right? Some job rights are protected to some extent in some countries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoYou haven't eliminated jobs: the bosses of people who are getting laid off are, after they buy your software. Crucial difference. > It is not a crime to deprive someone of their income stream No, but it is a crime to steal. If someone has created digital goods, put them up for sale, and you acquire them without paying, that is stealing. The fact they didn't "lose" some physical product in the process is irrelevant. You have cheated them out of their commensurate half of an even exchange they have offered. If you don't like the exchange, find it too expensive, the product not worth it, what have you, that's fine, you are free to not complete the transaction. You are not free to bypass it and gain the thing you weren't willing to pay for without paying.
- tm-guimaraes 3y ago> It is more about stealing an income stream or someone's time and labor. When I deprive someone of an income stream that they are able to generate without coercian (by forcing others to buy) Very murky argument, because pirating something doesn't mean that if the piracy option was not available, a purchase would happen. So, was the income stream really stollen, or did it not exist to begin with? Also, the "without coercion" is also shaky. Copying (for most digital goods) is practically free/unlimited. Everyone is being coerced by force of law/jail to abide by artificially scarcity rules. I wonder about the % of University students that would be facing legal consequences if laws were always enforced when some pages of study books are copied (and these aren't even as simple to copy as something digital) > they are stealing my labor, my time The labor already happened, it was not stolen, the revenue speculation was just wrong. It happens to any kind of business, regardless of piracy or not, I would argue that relying solely on income that comes from a good that is replicated almost freely is not a good business practice. Same shit with Free Software movement, FOSS is not a business model, you can make money with it, but FOSS itself is not a business model, it's up to you to figure a way to make money with it. (And nobody is being stolen of labor when someone clones a repo/downloads some package). Plenty of people made their careers with just Free Software business, and there have been DRM-free games in #1 spot on Steam. The same applies to any other digital artifact, it's up to you to figure a way to make money, the easiness of copy-ability is part of the physical reality, "artificial scarcity" is "artificial" for a reason.
- tticvs 3y agoThis logic doesn't hold in the case where you would not pay anything for the product. For example bypassing a NYT paywall with archive.is doesn't deprive the NYT of any income since I would never subscribe to their paper or pay them any money.
- iopq 3y agoWhat if I would never pay for it in the first place? Then I'm not depriving you of anything
- robertlagrant 3y agoThen why do you have it?
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoBecause it can be obtained for free.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIf that's all it takes, why not just use public domain things? They're actually free.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoBecause I want the other thing I can get for free. Think of it like this. If you are flicking through channels on your TV, you might find something halfway interesting that you want to watch, and so you do. But you never would have paid for it. Same thing with piracy. You might check something out of curiosity or boredom, but never would have paid $20 for it, and me personally, I'm not going to 'rent' something that requires DRM to play, and don't want to own it on physical media, so piracy is the clear choice. This is pretty normal human behavior, and I see no ethical issue with it. There is only the fallacy of the lost sale as a flimsy counter-argument, the rest is greed and lies.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIt's greedy to want things for free that aren't available for free. You're right that greed is normal human behaviour, but that doesn't make it okay, let alone good.