3 ms·

You realize I didn't mean we manufacture nothing, but that we manufacture much, much less than we used to, right? If we can't agree that manufacturing started

by e40 15y ago

You realize I didn't mean we manufacture nothing, but that we manufacture much, much less than we used to, right? If we can't agree that manufacturing started to move out of the US decades ago, was accelerated by NAFTA, and that we are a consumer of goods made elsewhere (more than others are a consumer of goods made here), then this conversation isn't going to go well.

Locke1689 15y ago
You're right, it won't go well, because you don't seem to know what the facts are. Check the parents data. Not only do we manufacture things, we manufacture much, much more than we used to.
liber8 15y ago
Not sure what metric you're using to claim that we manufacture "much, much less than we used to". US manufacturing output continues to hit all-time records. Measured in real dollars, output is ~40% higher than in 1990, and ~$220% higher than 1970. See http://unstats.un.org/unsd/snaama/dnllist.asp http://unstats.un.org/unsd/snaama/dnllist.asp for data.
jerf 15y ago
The only way to stem the tide of downvotes here is going to be to stop repeating yourself in other comments and directly address acslater00's graph. There's nuances here to be explored in what exactly is being manufactured, and there's some other interesting ways to extract bad tidbits of news out of that data, but it is certainly the case that the data does not justify running around shouting "DOOM! DOOM!" about manufacturing qua manufacturing in the US. Personally I'm upbeat about the future. As robots and automation continue marching forward, the US goes from having a major labor cost disadvantage relative to poor countries to having a significant educational advantage. (Not a unique advantage, Europe and Japan also have good stories here, but China is not as well off on this time frame per capita.) I don't expect the broad direction of that curve to change anytime soon.
travem 15y ago
Here's a good article to read on the subject http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-welcome-rise-in-manufacturing-jobs-in-the-us/2012/01/12/gIQAxLPcuP_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-welcome-rise-in-man... In summary US manufacturing output is increasing and US manufacturing output exceeds that of China by about $100B, but only employs about a tenth as many workers as China.
- CamperBob 15y ago
  In summary US manufacturing output is increasing and US manufacturing output exceeds that of China by about $100B, but only employs about a tenth as many workers as China. Didn't read the article, but do they count companies like Apple and Boeing as "US-based manufacturers?" Of course they are, in the sense that they are US-based corporations who manufacture and sell $X worth of goods per year... but crediting the US with their "manufacturing output" would be nothing more than brazen statistical dishonesty. Also, if "manufacturing" is defined as the "act of final assembly," as it is under certain Commerce Department regulations and those of other government agencies, would Apple be able to meet that criterion by setting up a factory in California that did nothing but bolt together imported PC boards, cases, bezels, and LCD panels? It is far from clear that the US really manufactures much of anything anymore, the way the term would have been defined in the post-WWII era. I've heard people only half-jokingly refer to McDonalds as a "manufacturer" of burgers.
matwood 15y ago
The US is manufacturing more than they ever have and it's continuing to grow. If you want to complain about the loss of manufacturing jobs complain about automation and not the incorrectly stated lack of manufacturing output.

by e40 15y ago

Locke1689 15y ago

You're right, it won't go well, because you don't seem to know what the facts are. Check the parents data. Not only do we manufacture things, we manufacture much, much more than we used to.

liber8 15y ago

Not sure what metric you're using to claim that we manufacture "much, much less than we used to". US manufacturing output continues to hit all-time records. Measured in real dollars, output is ~40% higher than in 1990, and ~$220% higher than 1970. See http://unstats.un.org/unsd/snaama/dnllist.asp http://unstats.un.org/unsd/snaama/dnllist.asp for data.

jerf 15y ago

The only way to stem the tide of downvotes here is going to be to stop repeating yourself in other comments and directly address acslater00's graph. There's nuances here to be explored in what exactly is being manufactured, and there's some other interesting ways to extract bad tidbits of news out of that data, but it is certainly the case that the data does not justify running around shouting "DOOM! DOOM!" about manufacturing qua manufacturing in the US. Personally I'm upbeat about the future. As robots and automation continue marching forward, the US goes from having a major labor cost disadvantage relative to poor countries to having a significant educational advantage. (Not a unique advantage, Europe and Japan also have good stories here, but China is not as well off on this time frame per capita.) I don't expect the broad direction of that curve to change anytime soon.

travem 15y ago

Here's a good article to read on the subject http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-welcome-rise-in-manufacturing-jobs-in-the-us/2012/01/12/gIQAxLPcuP_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-welcome-rise-in-man... In summary US manufacturing output is increasing and US manufacturing output exceeds that of China by about $100B, but only employs about a tenth as many workers as China.

CamperBob 15y ago
In summary US manufacturing output is increasing and US manufacturing output exceeds that of China by about $100B, but only employs about a tenth as many workers as China. Didn't read the article, but do they count companies like Apple and Boeing as "US-based manufacturers?" Of course they are, in the sense that they are US-based corporations who manufacture and sell $X worth of goods per year... but crediting the US with their "manufacturing output" would be nothing more than brazen statistical dishonesty. Also, if "manufacturing" is defined as the "act of final assembly," as it is under certain Commerce Department regulations and those of other government agencies, would Apple be able to meet that criterion by setting up a factory in California that did nothing but bolt together imported PC boards, cases, bezels, and LCD panels? It is far from clear that the US really manufactures much of anything anymore, the way the term would have been defined in the post-WWII era. I've heard people only half-jokingly refer to McDonalds as a "manufacturer" of burgers.

matwood 15y ago

The US is manufacturing more than they ever have and it's continuing to grow. If you want to complain about the loss of manufacturing jobs complain about automation and not the incorrectly stated lack of manufacturing output.