4 ms·
I'm a bit confused about them calling it a cloud computer. The primary benefit of cloud is you spend opex instead of capex. Isn't this moving back to capex agai
by robertlagrant 3y ago
I'm a bit confused about them calling it a cloud computer. The primary benefit of cloud is you spend opex instead of capex. Isn't this moving back to capex again?
- subarctic 3y agoYa, in the past the messaging was more like "get the ergonomics of the cloud with the economics of owning your own hardware", I think it's confusing to just call it a "cloud computer"
- robertlagrant 3y agoYes - that makes loads more sense to me. It's cool that you can spin stuff up and it's all integrated with the hardware - having seen fairly large VMWare installations and all the faff it takes to make them work, this seems really useful. I just don't think it's the same as the cloud, and the article seems to discount the main reason for the cloud: opex, letting you get started (and stopped) quickly and cheaply.
- subarctic 3y agoI might have the wrong idea of what these terms mean, but isn't avoiding capex the main reason for the cloud?
- hotpotamus 3y agoIf they lease it to companies, would it be considered opex?
- robertlagrant 3y agoIt would be interesting to buy a load of them and set up as a cloud vendor :)
- throw0101a 3y agoPrivate cloud is a thing too: lots of folks run VMware, Hyper-V, or OpenStack in-house.
- steve1977 3y agoAnd it's as much of a misnomer there.
- throw0101a 3y ago> And it's as much of a misnomer there. Dude, why are you even in this thread? Trying to be a Debbie Downer is just going to ruin the rest of the day. * https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/ Trying to get the last word in on the Internet is a quick and easy way to have a bad time. Let it go and move onto something else.
- wmf 3y agoThis has definitely been true, but what if Oxide is the first actual private cloud?
- jbiggley 3y agoThat was the line we were sold by cloud vendors. There is a reason that significant portions of both native cloud and migrated workloads are shifting back to self-hosted; the cost savings never materialized. My google-fu failed to find any articles for or against my statement that weren’t paid advertising or lightweight tech summaries. StackOverflow will have to do. https://stackoverflow.blog/2023/02/20/are-companies-shifting-away-from-public-clouds/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2023/02/20/are-companies-shifting...
- robertlagrant 3y agoOf course - every pay as you go service that goes above a certain amount of utilization will be better replaced with up front investment. But that doesn't mean that the opex model is bad in general; you've just only picked cases where it's bad.
- wpm 3y agoSo, what you're saying is, that whether opex or capex models are better or not...depends? That there is no silver bullet, golden gun, one-size-fits-all platitude anyone can post in an HN comment? If the opex model doesn't work for an organization, that they perhaps just went above that utilization threshold where it doesn't make sense anymore, and would be a potential 0xide customer?
- solatic 3y agoThere's two independent issues: capex vs. opex, and flexibility. When opex is a primary benefit of the cloud, that's specifically for start-ups and other businesses that have little working capital. The actual primary benefit of the cloud for most cloud customers is flexibility - prior to AWS adoption, getting a server provisioned could be a multi-week if not multi-month affair negotiating between devs or operators and on-prem infrastructure workers to get the servers through capacity planning and provisioning. AWS made provisioning so simple, that you could start to set up auto-scaling, because you had extraordinarily high confidence that the capacity would be immediately available when your autoscaler tried to scale up. But opex is not a benefit of the cloud for heavy/established businesses. Cloud opex is a financial expenditure every month that you can't get rid of and counts directly against your profits. Indeed, the desire for capex in the cloud is so high that businesses routinely purchase Reserved Instances and other forms of committed usage, which allows accountants to treat the cost of the RI as capex and then discount the expenditure through depreciation (to zero, since there will be nothing to sell when the RI expires) over the lifetime of the RI. It is normal and frequent for businesses to make capital expenditures to reduce their operational expenditures over time, thus increasing their monthly/quarterly profits. Oxide's unique value proposition is to give customers, particularly those with high monthly cloud bills that they have difficulty reducing, the operational flexibility of cloud computing with the profit-improving benefits of capital expenditures.
- quickthrower2 3y agoThe way you put it, this capex thing though is sounding like just sacrificing cashflow for some accounting sophistry. Surely the main benefit of reserved instances is lower TCO and if you can show you can afford AWS for 3 years a bank would surely loan you the money to pay upfront if you can save say 50% it is simply cheaper even with interest.
- solatic 3y agoAgain this goes back to flexibility. RIs necessarily take away from your flexibility. AWS and others try to grant you the flexibility anyway, by allowing you to shift RI credits between physical instances, but lower TCO is definitely not guaranteed. If you buy an RI for a server type you're not actually using, you're spending money on servers that's getting wasted compared to not actually buying the RI.
- e12e 3y agoPrivate Cloud allows infrastructure team to run big server parks efficiently, while product teams can "buy" resources easily. It's essentially why Amazon made aws, why Google made Borg. For a regional hospital for example, there might be a desire for in-house network and hardware - but perhaps the system for digital patient journals run on Kubernetes and managed databases.
- axelthegerman 3y agoSure but some businesses care about how much they spend and then about capex vs opex. I'd rather have $1 in capex than $10 in opex
- fuzzylightbulb 3y agoReally depends on cash flow.