4 ms·
How to Leave the House of Lords
- spandextwins 3y agoWhat a messed up bureaucracy. Imagine what would happen if a group of people left and started their own government by the people and for the people?
- NeoTar 3y agoYou'd maybe end up with a system where one member of the upper house was preventing any senior military appointments - https://www.defenseone.com/policy/2023/08/army-now-2nd-service-without-senate-confirmed-leader/389158/ https://www.defenseone.com/policy/2023/08/army-now-2nd-servi...
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Appointments to the House of Lords have long been a sore on the British body politic. In 1922 David Lloyd George was exposed for egregiously selling peerages in exchange for donations to the Liberal Party. The Honours (Prevention of Abuses) Act followed in 1925, but the banning of such overtly corrupt practices didn’t restore complete confidence in appointments. A century later, Boris Johnson’s resignation honours list and the peers it created (or, in several cases, did not create) sparked another bout of introspection about who is worthy of a place on the red benches. This skips the cash for honours scandal in the early 2000s[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cash-for-Honours_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cash-for-Honours_scandal
- toyg 3y agoIt's definitely an article with a massive Tory slant. It doesn't really say why "it was no longer deemed possible for a member of the House of Lords to be prime minister" - because the political winds had been turned by Labour after Churchill, forcing modernity upon Westminster. And it treats Tony Benn as a footnote, when he was arguably the strongest proponent of such arguments even before his father died. Hogg and Douglas-Home simply rode the coat-tails of a great man for base self-interest, and effectively reneged their commitments a few years later.
- gadders 3y agoWhich great man is that?
- toyg 3y agoTony Benn, one of the best PMs Britain never got.
- gadders 3y agoNo. The only thing he was ever right on was Britain leaving the EU. He was a far Left agitator whose only policy position was "do the opposite of the USA".
- toyg 3y agoYou clearly have a limited knowledge of his experience, largely from his latter years. He was actually a pretty centrist element in Labour, until his experience as Postmaster General, Minister of Technology (delivering the Concorde), and other cabinet positions, made it clear to him how fundamentally undemocratic the British system was (and is). He then moved leftwards, and on many causes history proved him right - Iraq and Afghanistan to name a few, but also the need for abolition of the Lords, which continues to be plain to anyone who wants to see.
- robertlagrant 3y agoTory slant how? Cash for honours was a Labour scandal.
- toyg 3y agoThe Tories engaged in similar practices, before and after that scandal. Literally every Tory treasurer ascends to the Lords, together with lots of party donors, and Boris Johnson even got in his chum Lebedev despite opposition from the security apparatus. That's why that scandal is never mentioned nowadays: because things got even worse after 2010.
- oakesm9 3y agoElected British MPs are also unable to resign. To allow them to do so there is a "legal fiction" where they're appointed to an "office of profit". This disqualifies them from being an MP and triggers a by-election. These are unpaid positions with titles like "Crown Steward and Bailiff of the three Chiltern Hundreds of Stoke, Desborough and Burnham". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resignation_from_the_House_of_Commons_of_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resignation_from_the_House_of_...
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoI'd say 'MPs have a rather ridiculous manner of tendering their resignations'. Potatoe, potatoe. Unless someone can share an instance when an MP could not leave the House?
- NeoTar 3y agoApparently not since the 1840’s: > The Chancellor may in theory deny an application, although the last time this happened was to Viscount Chelsea in 1842. In the debate over expelling the fugitive James Sadleir in 1856, the Government committed to refusing any potential application he would make. From the Wikipedia article referenced above.
- Robin_Message 3y agoSince only two (or maybe three, I'm not 100% sure) of these positions exist, a mass resignation would be delayed by having to cycle people through the appointment and release of these figurative roles. It also created a curious effect where a Sinn Fein MP (Gerry Adams), who like all Sinn Fein MPs never took his seat because he would not swear allegiance ot the crown, had to accept a crown job to resign, which David Cameron criticised him for (in rather poor form). And there is nothing aside form precedent preventing a capricious government from stopping MPs from resigning by refusing to make such an appointment. It's all fun and games having an unwritten messy constitution until a government exceeds its powers to e.g. prorogue parliament against its will and we have to wait months for a court to rule on it when a proper consitution would never have allowed such an act in the first place. An insurrection like January 6th would suceed in the UK because there is so much arcane bullshit where our constitution should be, we are solely dependent on the good will and character of the current government to run things as they are meant to be run.
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoIt's also custom that members of the House of Commons cannot resign their seats. To get around this any member wishing to resign is made the Bailiff of the Chiltern Hundreds, by doing this they are an employee of the Crown and hence disqualified from being an MP. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn06395/ https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn06...
- toyg 3y ago"Prior to the 18th century, serving in Parliament was often regarded as an obligation to be accepted reluctantly, rather than an honour to be eagerly sought. Voluntarily relinquishing a seat was not, therefore, something to be encouraged." How times have changed. I'm sure a lot of that attitude was just posturing, but still: ambition for power had to be somewhat dressed up in clothes of virtue. Now we've fundamentally dispatched with virtue, and simply put up with the (supposedly) less scummy of the lot.
- michaelt 3y agoPrior to 1911, MPs didn't get paid. Which of course meant only the very rich could afford to seek election. Back in the 1850s paying MPs was a working class demand, hoping for working class communities to be represented by working class people.
- caf 3y agoIn those times it wasn't really a position of power, though - the crown in practice had considerable control over the parliament, and attending parliament would have often meant a considerable cost in time and money. Imagine jury duty, but it's on the other side of the world and you have to pay for your own flights and hotels.
- jrumbut 3y agoAnd also imagine that in a time where a new set of clothes cost a considerable share of your income.
- 3y ago
- gadders 3y agoAs a Brit, I think I would rather have a hereditary peerage I could leave to my family than be Prime Minister. Not sure if that is typical though.
- tialaramex 3y agoAlthough it remains technically possible to issue hereditary peerages (and indeed because Parliament is sovereign even if it was no longer possible they can just change the rules) there haven't been any issued to non-Royals in my lifetime and it's unlikely that under any foreseeable circumstances more would be created. Forth years ago maybe if you married into royalty somebody (well, Liz) would green light a hereditary peerage for that, but today that's frowned upon. I'd guess the other plausible route might be to do something so incredibly famous and heroic that a George Cross is seen as inadequate. Maybe a mad terrorist with a dirty bomb threatens to detonate it inside a central London orphanage, live on TV and you single handedly defeat them despite being unarmed? I dunno though, I think a week later people would be like, "The medal is fine, and he can go on a celebrity cooking show or something, we don't need a new peerage".
- gadders 3y agoYeah. It's very unlikely to get something these days. The last person I can think of that got a hereditary title (not necessary the last person to get one, just one that I remember) is Dennis Thatcher getting a baronetcy. And wikipedia tells me: "It is the only baronetcy to have been granted since 1964, and is one of only three extant hereditary titles awarded outside the British royal family since 1965." Anyway, I'll keep up my gym going etc just in case I am inside an orphanage when it comes under attack. I'm not sure though whether the fact that new hereditary titles not being created is more or less egalitarian? It now means unless your family did something 800 years ago you're out of luck.
- balderdash 3y agoSomething of a nit, but I thing Baronets are a bit of hybrid in that they are not peers, but it’s a hereditary title