3 ms·
He's not quite making the leap I thought he would, so I'll make it. Our browsers are dumb, and encourage 'search'. Google's made inroads by making a faster br
by mgkimsal 15y ago
He's not quite making the leap I thought he would, so I'll make it.
Our browsers are dumb, and encourage 'search'. Google's made inroads by making a faster browser that makes it easier to 'search' (through them, of course), but keeping track of that information in the browser sucks. Browser bookmark tools are a joke, and web-based ones, while better, generally aren't much better.
I envision a 'browser' that can track my behaviour, watch what I do, show me more detailed history info, make 'history' part of my 'search' results, adapt my search to my behaviour and more. Perhaps Google will be the ones to do this, but they'll only do it if they can show us more ads (or "more relevant" ads).
Ideas: "history" on chrome, for example, shows me a little information on pages in my history, but not too much. Did I copy/paste information from that page? How long was I on it? Show me thumbnails from that page. Show me other meta data from that page (author, friends that shared it on facebook/g+, etc). Information on what I did with info on that page is often what I'm looking for, not just every page in my history with a particular word on it. Screenshots would help jog my memory, but so would something that said "you copied 'foobarbaz' from this page and emailed it to sam" next to a history result.
Merging in local bookmarked and historical pages in with regular search results. Or, more to the point, merging in external search engine results when I'm searching through browser history. Have an option to make searching my local history the default, with extras merged in from google/bing/yahoo/etc.
None of this will happen overnight, but... there's a huge amount of metadata associated with the activity with page data that isn't being used, because having us go to a browser bar and search (again!) for the same data we found 2 hours ago is more profitable. Our browsers are dumb right now, and there's quite a lot more that could be being done to take advantage of the local intelligence that lives on our desktops or in our devices.
- sreyaNotfilc 15y agoI actually have an idea for an alternative that I'm building for my website (artjutsu.com). I've been using it for about 3 months now and I still have a ways to go to make it more useful. I believe it may be something that you're interested in. I don't want to spill the beans though, so if you want to know more (or help me test/build it) please email me. Yes, search is basically a grab bag, and browser history is decent but get's convoluted the more you use it. There are ways to make this easier, but why reinvent the wheel when you already own the wheel, right? Changing search will change major search engines business model, and share holders hate radical changes. Especially when you're raking in major dough.
- web_chops 15y agoI found stumble-upon to be pretty good in this regard (mainly due to the user curated bookmarks) though the quality has gone down a bit recently (thanks to the spammers)
- gcp 15y agoI've found the cases you describe to be one of these areas where Firefox seems to behave way superior than Chrome. It's not entirely as advanced as you describe of course, but usually just typing parts of a few key words returns a list of relevant sites you've ever been to, and the ranking is very good. The algorithm seems to even take into account whether you originally typed in the link etc. In general, if you've visited a site once, it's way easier to find it back with Firefox, and it doesn't require a Google search. If you think about it, it is very logical that Google doesn't want to move into this direction.
- lubutu 15y agoThis is the one reason I stick with Firefox. In Chrome if you search for the name of a YouTube video, with a string you know was in the title of the page, you're very unlikely to get that page as a result. If you're lucky you'll get another page with a link to the page you want in the suggestions list. In Firefox it'll almost always be an instant result, right at the top of the list. It seems strange, but Firefox's search really blows Chrome's out of the water.
- willy1234x1 15y agoThe Awesomebar is one of my main reasons why I never left Firefox. It really is just too great. The ability to use wildcards to narrow my searches is too great. Plus adding keywords for searches is too great, if I want to search Youtube, I type yt <search term>, Wikipedia? wk <search term>, these small features are such great boosts to my browsing experience.
- cromwellian 15y agoI just tried this experiment and I get the same results. Firefox uses Google search on the backend, so I don't see how it could be otherwise.
- ErikD 15y agoHe means using the auto-complete in your address bar, not actually searching with it.
- nitid_name 15y ago>I envision a 'browser' that can track my behaviour, watch what I do, show me more detailed history info, make 'history' part of my 'search' results, adapt my search to my behaviour and more. Perhaps Google will be the ones to do this, but they'll only do it if they can show us more ads (or "more relevant" ads). Doesn't google do this "in the cloud" (ugh) already? They use your past history to tailor results to you (as DuckDuckGo calls it, "in your bubble"). It's done on their servers because they want the information, and quite frankly, have better resources to compute it on (not to mention they benefit from comparing you to others like you and so on and so forth).
- mgkimsal 15y agoThey're not recording any of your activity on those pages (typing, mouse movements, copying, etc) and storing that as well. Mixing in all that usage meta-data is what I'm talking about.
- BHSPitMonkey 15y ago> Google's made inroads by making a faster browser that makes it easier to 'search' (through them, of course) Just thought I'd point out that Chrome supports different search engines and even politely asks you which one you'd like to use at first launch.
- iamgopal 15y agoApart from privacy policy bullshit, if google can save my searches and behavior securely and show me when I need it, it will definitely save me couple of hours a week.
- dclowd9901 15y agoIt's sad to me only one person here seems to "get" his point. When I search for something, I still tend to have to open four or five pages to get the answer I'm looking for. "javascript remove part of an array" Why when I "search" for that, do I have to parse, in my brain, titles, descriptions (and so on) just to get my answer? I've searched for this a few times before,I know, because I'm terrible at remembering particular functions across languages. Why can't my browser know when I've found the answer before? Hell, why can't my browser even offer me an option to remember that answer. I'll be happy to highlight it for it, but it's clunky and clumsy with a dumb bookmark. No nuance. Nothing was solved. And god forbid I bookmark every answer I look for; try searching through that.
- MichaelJW 15y agoIt looks like Google are working on it. Here's what I see when I search for [regular expression], as I often do to double-check syntax: http://screencast.com/t/A9DoZXes6 http://screencast.com/t/A9DoZXes6 Edit: It used to be the case that if you bookmarked the result (and had your bookmarks synced with Google), it'd star the result as well. Seems this feature has gone, though.
- jlarocco 15y agoI see your point, but I don't think it's a real problem. Bookmark a Javascript reference and then you can go there directly, no searching necessary. If it's specifically previously answered queries you're interested in, maybe something like OneNote would be a better solution? Then you could search your notes and probably find the old answer with a lot less noise.