10 ms·
I had an epiphany about self driving recently late at night on the streets of San Francisco. It was a somewhat deserted part of town, and the roads were empty.
by paxys 3y ago
I had an epiphany about self driving recently late at night on the streets of San Francisco. It was a somewhat deserted part of town, and the roads were empty. There was a lone Cruise car chugging along and constantly stopping at red lights. The signals were so badly optimized that the car would be the only one waiting at a completely empty intersection for minutes at a time, only to be stopped again at the next one, and the one after that. A single mile of empty road must have taken this car 15+ minutes to traverse. All the top engineering, sensors and ML algorithms in the world and the car was still at the mercy of a basic city planning failure.
We have been conditioned to think of autonomous driving as the answer to the traffic nightmares in every city, but tech will never ever be able to solve a social problem (just like how building a wider road will never ease congestion). Had even a fraction of the hundreds of billions of dollars that have been poured into self driving so far been spent towards, say, improving sidewalk quality, making traffic lights smarter, putting sensors along roads, coming up with a standard communication protocol for these sensors, building out public transit, improving urban planning etc. over the last 15 years, we would all be living better lives today. But a VC would rather set that money on fire to have a small chance at a 100x return.
- mepiethree 3y agoI agree with your general point but will note that Google has been working on smarter traffic lights (albeit with much less funding than Waymo) https://sites.research.google/greenlight/ https://sites.research.google/greenlight/
- oceanofsolaris 3y agoBut SF is a damn rich city (due to all the tech companies and their employees). Why didn’t they solve or at least tackle these problems? It’s not like Cruise / Waymo could change city planning against the cities will, even if they wanted.
- paxys 3y agoBecause smart people who work in tech are above silly things like urban planning and getting involved in local politics.
- andrewia 3y agoSF politics are notoriously slow about a lot of things. There are actually new, significant lobbying efforts to tackle some issues: https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/tech-rooted-groups-seek-to-shake-up-san-francisco-politics/ https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/tech-rooted-groups...
- Tiktaalik 3y agoJust because the population of SF is rich doesn't mean SF is rich. Cities have very weak abilities to raise revenue, and are relentlessly politically attacked whenever they try to raise more revenue via higher property taxes and other things. Our cities are actually starved of revenue and especially post pandemic at risk of bankruptcy without bailouts from higher governments.
- scythe 3y ago>but tech will never ever be able to solve a social problem I don't know where this mantra came from but it definitely falls in the risible category of leftist rhetoric. Technology has already solved multiple social problems, most obviously the advent of telecommunications itself solving the problem of coordinating actions at a distance. But more embarrassingly, the solutions you propose in the following paragraph are mostly technological. People just need to drop this line.
- ironmagma 3y agoIsn’t every problem a social problem anyway?
- alooPotato 3y agoTo have the city planning work correctly you kind of need participation from the cars. I.e. if the traffic light infra structure knew the destination of every car it could do things more globally optimal. So in that sense, driverless cars will actually help because of kind of nuanced reason. My guess is that there will only be a small number of driverless car companies (tesla, waymo, cruise, apple, etc) and it'll be much easier to add regulations that those companies need to send their destination data in realtime to the traffic light infra. I think that would basically be a non-starter for peoples personal cars.
- paxys 3y agoWaymo or Cruise cars on the road today aren't talking to any city infrastructure. The companies are not talking to each other. Heck even cars from the same company aren't communicating to try and coordinate some kind of traffic pattern or share data. The entire current approach to self driving has been a dead end from the start.
- alooPotato 3y agoYeah they aren't talking to city infra now. My point was that it will become easier to make that happen once a larger % of the cars on the road are self driving.
- paxys 3y agoWhen will it become easier? After all these companies have gone bankrupt?
- alooPotato 3y agowhy do you think they will go bankrupt?
- paxys 3y agoBecause that's what happens to companies when they run out of cash to burn and still don't have a viable business. What do you think happened with Apple's massive self driving car division? Or Uber's? Lyft's? There are dozens of failed companies in the space already. Ultimately GM and Google are going to run out of patience as well.
- TotoHorner 3y ago> I had an epiphany about self driving recently late at night on the streets of San Francisco So, the entire amount of VC dollars that went into Waymo is ~$5.5 billion dollars. If you look at the entire self-driving market, it's probably less than $12 billion in total. San Francisco's yearly budget, is $15 billion dollars. The Federal Gov spends 50 billion dollars per year on maintaining federal highways. So yeah, you didn't have an epiphany. You just couldn't be bothered to spend 20 seconds thinking about the math.
- rangestransform 3y ago5.5 billion gets you a bit over 2 miles of subway in nyc [1] these days, hardly the public transit revolution needed to make autonomous driving redundant [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-23/in-nyc-subway-a-case-study-in-runaway-transit-construction-costs https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-23/in-nyc-su...
- petemir 3y agoI always envisioned a kind of world peace where all car manufacturers got together and in a not-designed-by-committee way developed a mesh protocol where vehicles and “the city” (i.e. traffic lights, railway crossing and so on) could communicate data to each other in order to ease some of the limitations of current autonomous driving technology.
- starlevel003 3y agoPerhaps we could optimise it further, by having sets of steel paths for the cars to drive on too.
- Avicebron 3y agoOr we could link them together to make it safer so one doesn't veer off the track, maybe get nicely furnished stations where people can switch over to another set of linked cars to get where they need to go. Imagine the possibilities!
- lurker919 3y agoInteresting approach, making the links dynamic could help in last-mile mobility as well.
- anticensor 3y agoAt that point, we have just reinvented trains. Which is not a bad thing.
- ironmagma 3y agoIf you can sell America on trains, I don’t care what roundabout pathway you have to take to get there, I’m for it. If it’s just self driving cars on a dedicated roadway, fine by me.
- oatmeal1 3y ago> But a VC would rather set that money on fire to have a small chance at a 100x return. Blaming VCs for public policy failures is fair when they lobby to create those public policy failures. In this case, it seems like their efforts (lighting money on fire) are likely to improve pedestrian safety, so it doesn't seem fair to blame them.
- hnav 3y agoThis is by design, San Francisco discourages driving that way.
- andrewia 3y agoCitation needed. When googling for traffic signal information, all I found was discussions about expanding right-on-red bans to more intersections, and traffic lights with LIDAR. https://www.sfmta.com/blog/smarter-traffic-signals-prioritize-transit-and-people https://www.sfmta.com/blog/smarter-traffic-signals-prioritiz...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 3y agoMost intersections in the Bay Area have magnetic sensors underground to detect cars and expedite a green when appropriate. Where was this mile-long stretch? 3rd street?
- saagarjha 3y agoYeah San Francisco has some of the best traffic lights in the Bay Area when it comes to predictive signaling and synchronization
- dekhn 3y agoand for a long time you could drive on Great Highway at 35MPH and hit green at every single light. Always enjoyed that except that I would have preferred 50MPH
- esoterica 3y agoIt should be illegal to drive above 25mph on any street that pedestrians regularly cross (i.e. all urban non-highway roads). Your enjoyment of speeding does not supersede other people’s right to not get struck by a car going 50mph.
- dekhn 3y agoThis was not a necessary point to make, as I merely expressed a preference. And the law isn't going to be changed to accomodate your desires.
- wsinks 3y agoI'm not arguing with you, but is there any documentation of SF's predictive signaling and synchronization and how it's the best?
- saagarjha 3y agoI don’t have any, unfortunately. This is just anecdotal from driving around.
- alkonaut 3y agoHaving a big flat 4-way intersection is an antipattern. If you have a major road (2 lanes in any direction, or over 30mph) intersecting another major road, then traffic lights just shouldn't happen. You get pollution from starting and stopping, T-bone collisions etc. This is an infrastructure issue. Culturally I sort of understand how the US ended up with bad walkability and bad public transport. But what I do not understand is how road infra is so horrible.
- Robotbeat 3y agoSomehow it’s the tech bros fault.
- noobermin 3y agoYoure right it's not their fault directly. Instead, taxes should be higher on texh companies so planners can do their jobs.