16 ms·
Europe's CSAM-scanning plan is tipping point for democratic rights, experts warn
- orangepurple 3y agoWill a CSAM scanner implementation eventually be repurposed to block politically sensitive material? Telegram is already modified by the Google Play store to block specific channels.
- nvy 3y ago>Will a CSAM scanner implementation eventually be repurposed to block politically sensitive material? Of course it will. This is a certainty.
- dmitrygr 3y agoWhy the question mark? Replace it with a period. It is cleaner.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoBecause it is a rhetorical question and it would be grammatically incorrect to use a period.
- MerelyMortal 3y agoPerhaps we need a way to show that a question is rhetorical? /r
- michaelt 3y ago> Will a CSAM scanner implementation eventually be repurposed to block politically sensitive material? The likes of Google already have content scanners automatically censoring some messages - namely, blocking e-mails about cheap viagra. It would be very easy to add some extra keywords for politically sensitive topics - but we've been blocking spam for 25 years and I can't recall any reports of it happening.
- autoexec 3y agoIt'd take a whistleblower for us to know about it. Companies have been repeatedly caught filtering politically sensitive topics inappropriately (yahoo comes to mind https://archive.thinkprogress.org/yahoo-appears-to-be-censoring-email-messages-about-wall-street-protests-updated-d9ec9c4fa4eb/ https://archive.thinkprogress.org/yahoo-appears-to-be-censor...) but it's usually explained as an "error" and I suspect that in many cases it genuinely is, it's just impossible for us to tell the difference between "caught them red handed censoring" and "caught them red handed being bad at their job"
- johngladtj 3y agoIf you can't find any instances of politically motivated censorship in Google results you have been willfully blind.
- michaelt 3y agoI didn't ask about search results - I asked about e-mail spam detection performing politically motivated censorship.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoOf course it will. They couldn't care less about children, they're just using them as a polical weapon to make people accept it. I have absolutely no doubt that the system will be immediately expanded to search for and punish wrongthink of all sorts.
- anthk 3y agoIf you use Android use FDroid, much better.
- jjgreen 3y agoOf course. The UK RIPA (regulation of investigatory powers) Act was widely advertised as a measure to combat terrorism, it very quickly became regularised and is used by local councils to investigate cases of people illegally feeding pigeons. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/dec/25/british-councils-used-investigatory-powers-ripa-to-secretly-spy-on-public https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/dec/25/british-counci...
- RajT88 3y agoYep. Argument one is, this system will quickly be used mostly for other things. Argument two: Even if you can stop 100% the transmission of CSAM materials, you are not stopping the abuse of children. Just the secondary abuse of distributing the materials.
- XorNot 3y agoIt happened almost immediately in Australia with COVID tracking data[1]. Were I in a position of any type of authority, careers would be ending and jail time would be getting handed out like candy over this. I'm not in charge unfortunately and not enough citizens know how to react to these expansions of power until it impacts them personally. But as soon as the capability exists, it really is a slippery slope: it's far easier to gradually expand the scope and reach by administrative changes, then it is to start the program up initially - and there's no track record of any government reasonably resisting this sort of insider threat. [1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-16/police-refused-to-stop-accessing-safewa-app-data-premier-says/100218764 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-16/police-refused-to-sto...
- RajT88 3y agoExactly right - and initially the expanded use of these systems is not visible. PRISM, for example, was found to be used frequently by NSA employees to look into the activities of romantic interests or exes. Nobody knew about it for years until an audit took place. We're told that the abuse of this system was unusual and handled appropriately, and no longer a problem. (Is it, really?) The next phase is of course the court cases, where authorities seek legal access to the data which is collected. Usually the police win these cases to establish legal precedent. Still - your average citizen is not reading civil rights-related or tech-related news, and they have no idea this happens. By the time your average person finds out what the newly collected data is being used for, it's far too late to do anything about it. Then there's the political aspect, which we are not likely to ever hear about. The boss's boss's boss's boss needs a favor done, don't ask why or for whom. That data, go get it. Listen, be discreet, no email and no cell phone. This is the one which is the most scary; an authoritarian in power who wants to target the opposition. Depending on the country, that could be a list of people who disappears and is never seen again - or in the US, gets raided over dubious charges by the local police as a form of harassment.
- rich_sasha 3y agoI have a different proposal to solving the privacy vs enforceability issue: require a license for strong encryption. Any Tom Dick or Harry can have encryption of a certain strength, chosen so that the cost of breaking it is around some dollar cost over the next N years. Low enough that the NSA will do it for terrorist suspects, but high enough that any mass surveillance is infeasible. Also, require court warrants for accessing this data, or attempting to crack the cypher. There will be applications where this is insufficient, say e2e communication with banks. These can be licensed and supervised. I think this provides a decent tradeoff to a bunch of problems: - people can still enjoy fairly strong encryption - states can't spy on people willy-nilly - but will be able to do it, with a lot of effort, where they are really motivated - sure, "bad guys" can still download GPG and encrypt something with a very hard cipher - but that in itself will be an offense...
- dmitrygr 3y agoPoe's law vibes...
- simonw 3y agoThis is a terrible idea. Today's "fairly strong encryption" is tomorrow's broken encryption.
- rich_sasha 3y agoWell, assume some Moore's law increases.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoThe European Commission is on a power trip.
- rtkwe 3y agoState security apparatus is forever in a conflict with personal privacy rights. Everything that protects Paul Public also protects Chris Criminal/Tommy Terrorist(/Randy Revolutionary), it's an old issue that pushes continuously for weakening any form of privacy protections from legal (investigators love that so much of our lives now lives in 3rd party hands so they can access it easier) to technological (the continuous assault on encryption since it became feasible for the average person to use in communications). As a side note this is also something that anyone who works in privacy preserving software will have to recon with at some point if they think seriously about their goals. If your tools are strong enough to protect journalists (or insert whatever oppressed group you prefer) in hostile regimes it's good enough to protect criminals doing things you personally abhor.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoCriminals doing bad things it's the cost of having privacy. We never had and we will never have a perfect society. Just look at the EC members: they hide their communications, use WhatsApp to negotiate contracts worth billions of dollars (see the Pfizer direct "negotiation" between von der Leyen and Pfizer) but we should give up encryption because criminals use it as well... The hypocrisy is astounding.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>The European Commission is on a power trip. Never waste a good crisis. It's been well documented that crisis events are the best opportunities of governments to expressly push out anti-democratic and anti-citizen laws that lead to erosion of freedom and wealth transfers from poor to rich, as those types of events provide the perfect excuse to bypass the usual and very long and through democratic processes where everyone takes their sweet time to dissect, analyze and debate them. And we recently had plenty of crisis: Covid, inflation, waves of refugees, war in Ukraine, war in Israel. "Don't think about it too much you poor taxpayer, you don't understand this issue anyway, it's too complex for you and plus, you're too busy being distracted and worrying about this virus/rampant inflation/CoL/war to have time to think about such petty issues like your privacy, so just sit back, relax, worry about paying your rent, and let us worry about protecting your online privacy, m'kay?"
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoThis is an attempt to solve the right problem (CSA) but of course the wrong way. It's like 30 years ago saying "people record such abuse onto VHS tape - if we talk to Sony and Scotch we can prevent this in some way". Well actually it is a little more realistic but still ... preventing Child Sexual Abuse should be a huge and high priority for all governments, all citizens. If there was some sure fire guaranteed method we would do it tomorrow, no later the cost We just don't really know how - it is some combination of mental health reform, massive educational reform, child social services reform so that the really at risk kids are treated but also extending that meaningfully to all children. I would be interested in any clever ideas
- thfuran 3y ago>If there was some sure fire guaranteed method we would do it tomorrow, no later the cost No goal is worth pursuing no matter the cost.
- rowanG077 3y ago> If there was some sure fire guaranteed method we would do it tomorrow, no later the cost. That's obviously not true. Here is a simple solution: sterilize as much of humanity as possible. Preferable via an airborne mutagen or something like that. Boom no children to be abused anymore in the span of a few generations.
- anthk 3y agoUse Tox. Toxic for GNULinux/BSD terminal nerds, ATox for Android users, QTox/UTox for PC users with Windows/Linux/Mac/BSD and who knows.
- wand3r 3y agoTraffic fatalities would fall nearly to 0 if we made all speed limits 25mph. Obviously, as it has been for decades, child safety is the cloak that tyranny is dressed in. Not to mention CP is a common thing to pin on inconvenient people in society. The EU has been doing a lot of rent seeking off Google & big tech. They hit them with fines all the time. If I actually believed they gave a fuck about people or privacy it wouldn't be as offensive to me, but they don't. They want big tech doing what they want, they want "protection money" or at least a slice of the pie, and they want more government control of citizenry. I always admired Europe as an American, but its clearly in the same (or worse) state of decay as the US.
- kiba 3y agoLowering speed limit to 25 mph isn't a magic wand. People will speed what they feel safe to speed. If we want to reduce pedestrian fatalities, there are a raft of social policies and urban planning decisions we can make that reduces fatalities to a potentially very low level if we decided that's a priority. We don't need to rigorously enforce the speed limit to make that happen.
- omginternets 3y ago[flagged]
- kodt 3y agoMake it illegal to own a car that does not have a governor which limits it to 25 mph. There are ways around that. Then the only people speeding are those with illegally modified cars. Then you just have to suggest the only reason someone would want to drive faster than 25 is to specifically run over children.
- all2 3y agoThis sounds vaguely familiar. I've seen almost this exact chain of reasoning somewhere and I can't quite put my finger on it.
- rad_gruchalski 3y ago
- camdenlock 3y agoJeez man. Seems like a news story about the EU being on a power trip hits the front page every week now. Thanking my lucky stars I don’t have to live under such a controlling regime.
- robswc 3y agoIt makes stuff like GDPR ironic too.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoI hadn't even considered this, but you're absolutely correct. That's hilarious, in the most depressing way possible!
- cbg0 3y agoThis is far from what a "controlling regime" looks like.
- landemva 3y agoThe eu now has pretend democracy so those who pass eu laws are not accountable to the people. I know people disagree with facts about eu voting, so let us know when typical eu person gets to vote on chief Von der Leyen retaining office.
- autoexec 3y agoI'm not sure if the US is much better, or if we're just a lot quieter about the three letter agencies spying on our communications. In some ways the transparency is kind of refreshing. At least the EU has something to fight back against while we can only guess at the extent of the abuses that are happening right now.
- irusensei 3y agoCurrent day EU is trying to be like one of those comfy Norwegian prisons but with more guards and surveillance.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago
- emilecantin 3y ago> “The very fact that people are viewing these images — which is exactly the intent of the Commission to try and overcome — is a form of abuse itself. So if we now take innocent pictures, which have been shared among consenting individuals, and expose them to potentially hundreds of other individuals down the investigation chain then we are indeed actually creating more victims as a result of this.” This is the crux of the issue. Not only will this plan have a bunch of negative side-effects, it will actually hurt the very people it's meant to protect.
- ASalazarMX 3y agoOkay, you got a point... but also, think about the Terrorists! They could be exchanging Terrorist Secret Messages right under our noses! Seriously, whenever anyone justifies their actions with "Think of the children" or "Think about the terrorists" single-minded emotional appeals, I can't see it as anything but cheap manipulation. It should be required for proponents to back up their safety claims with hard numbers. They ask to give up a lot without without accountability, and I don't think the damage outweighs the benefit. For example, the Patriot act didn't result in a wave of terrorism crackdown, au contraire, it facilitated massive human rights abuse, but the rights it took have not been given back. Same with the massive increase in airport security, I don't know how many terrorists they have caught carrying nail clippers, but it seems like less intrusive methods would deter most terrorist attempts.
- throw310822 3y agoMuch worse even, and given the recent and ongoing events, several EU governments have shown zero respect for freedom of speech and a tendency to accuse large parts of their population of "supporting terrorism". In the UK, police regularly harasses citizens for expressing their voice on social media and elsewhere on sensitive politic matters. And I am supposed to welcome these governments reading into my private messages in search for possible crimes? No way.
- kelnos 3y agoA former co-worker of mine used to work at a company where his job (he was a fresh college grad, so got the shit work) was to go through tons of text messages, social media posts, etc., and mark them as spam or not-spam. He... didn't last very long. It was just soul-sucking work. A level worse is the people who have to trawl through social media posts looking for the gruesome types of ToS violations: images of extreme violence and gore, cruelty, etc. A lot of people in those kinds of jobs need copious amounts of therapy to deal with it (but unfortunately many seem to not have access to therapy). Having to look at suspected CSAM all day to give a ok/not-ok determination on it? God, I can't imagine what that'd do to a person.
- Humorist2290 3y agoI think, but mostly hope, that this client side scanning initiative will fall apart. Not just because it's an obvious destruction of civil liberties for us in the EU, but also because it's doomed to fail even if implemented. The underlying concept is ineffective at dealing with CSAM, or any kind of adversarial user scenario. Unfortunately my hopes have a bad legislative record. Clients aren't trustworthy. Ignoring the myriad services that exist, and will come to exist, which just never implement this -- there will be (somewhat) easily accessible versions of apps that remove such telemetry. E.g. VScode is to VScodium as WhatsApp is to WhatsAppium. Imagine the spoofing opportunities. Message someone, get their client ID, report that client detected all the worst CSAM imaginable. Think of the false positives. Think of the expense. Think of the children. Think of the children whose non-abusive parents send banal but confounding photos to each other, get hounded by CSAM allegations, and some fraction of whom get separated from their child. Passing this will be a huge expense of time all of these legislators could use better. Implementing these directives will be a huge expense of money and knowhow to build a flawed and exploitable system. Enforcing the consequences will have untold amounts of suffering unrelated to CSAM. And likely after the first few creeps are caught, the adversarial actors will just start using other channels. But by that point the conversation will have shifted to clientside scanning of thoughts...
- ChrisKnott 3y ago> "Think of the children whose non-abusive parents send banal but confounding photos to each other, get hounded by CSAM allegations, and some fraction of whom get separated from their child." How do you see a false positive progressing into child separation? People who are actually convicted of possessing CSAM don't necessarily lose access to their children at the moment.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoEver since I started writing on this issue, I’ve had a number of folks contact me and say they were unwittingly flagged by Google Photos’ ML-based CSAM detection algorithm. The most recent of these told me the photo was sent as a (pretty awful) prank in a WhatsApp group, and their phone auto-saved it to the camera roll. All of these folks lost all access to Google services with minimal options for appeal, and have had their lives disrupted in various ways I can’t imagine. I have no way of verifying what these people are telling me, and I can’t help them even if I did. And even more than this: my first reaction is to wonder if they’re all actually pedophiles who are just lying to me, and/or if they’re going to text CSAM at me. (Because that’s the power of this accusation — nobody will trust you once they hear it.) Some of these folks have had their lives ruined and some have told me they were hospitalized and considered suicide, even though they weren’t actually prosecuted. I can certainly imagine being in their situation due to the mistake of having an asshole friend-of-a-friend in a group chat and some bad settings in my phone. (I have neither, thankfully.) If none of this stuff convinces you, here is a much more carefully-documented version of a similar story in which a dad took a photo of their toddler’s rash and was subsequently investigated for CSAM. This one has the “happy” ending that the accused is entirely cleared by the police, but never gets his Google account back and has to live with whatever other trauma and shame comes from the investigation: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/21/technology/google-surveillance-toddler-photo.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/21/technology/google-surveil...
- kypro 3y agoAlmost all European nations currently believe that it's perfectly okay for 14-16 year old children to have sex with adults. I'd argue if we are so concerned about children's safety we should first change the law so pedos are not legally allowed to groom and have sex with children in the EU. The most hilarious thing about all of this is CSAM and online safety stuff is that Europe is totally backwards when it comes to child sexual safety. You might recall that recently in the UK Hollywood celebrity and sex-addict Russel Brand would frequently call taxis to pick up his 16 year old fan girls from school so he could have sex with them. This was perfectly legal because pedophilia is legal in most of Europe..
- vik0 3y agoPedophilia is being attracted to persons under the age of 13, which isn't legal anywhere in Europe It is in the Middle East, but their (Islamic) culture doesn't consider it as pedophilia, and (some) men in their 20s and 30s get married to young girls of around that age
- RajT88 3y agoPedophilia indeed is referring to sexual attraction to prepubescent children. Hebephilia refers to sexual attraction to early pubescent children. Ephebophilia refers to sexual attraction to mid to late puberty children. In the US, legally none of these are explicitly outlawed. There are "ages of consent" laws, which are aimed at the age of emotional maturity of the individual. Also in the US - people like to label violators of age of consent laws as 'pedophiles', because that label connotates the worst of the worst sexual impulses. But in fact, they're conflating the two things often enough - a 19 year old having sex with a 14 year old is most definitely not a pedophile, but he could be breaking the law still which makes him a criminal. But hey - let's throw in one more twist here. 100 years ago or so, said 19 year old would have been committing pedophilia, because the age of puberty has dropped drastically since then. All that said - I'm not going to die on the hill of suggesting an Ephebophile is less bad than a Pedophile. Just that most people are using the latter term incorrectly, and conflating it with an age of consent violation. ...And for the folks downvoting me: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedophilia#Misuse_of_medical_terminology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedophilia#Misuse_of_medical_t...
- chaostheory 3y agoThis is just further evidence that the GPRD is really just protectionist legislation for EU tech and media companies. The EU doesn’t really care about the privacy of its citizens
- hinata08 3y ago> supports mass surveillance and is willing to give up on democracy "against child abuse" > supports whoever does war everywhere around the world, by selling weapons to one side, gas to the other side, or saying some side is just defending themselves and should continue to do whatever We have two conclusions two this : EU supports children* *unless they come from Yemen, Gaza, Ukraine, or are somehow on the Mediterranean Sea (then they're on their own. If they die, that would do fewer migrants) And EU is scanning that you have compliant views on the world events. I can totally see that if you're not a journalist who documents war abuses, and if children were involved in these, you'll have evidence of "child abuse" and you're going to get reported. Sorry to get political for once. But we have never ever done a single thing for children (EU was just a business club, nothing more): They let known paedophiles continue to work in schools, they just change their jobs. Some "mandatory" sexual education was defined at the European level. It was aimed to teach children about themselves, and how to recognize, refuse, and report abuse within their families. But it's often just skipped in schools because "budgets" and "planning". And unless your local government (usually the city) pays for activities and clubs for children, they're just left to grow on their own : if they're in a city with drugs, they're usually raised by the cartels. EU won't set up activities. But if it's about scanning everyone's phone, then they say they need to act for the children.
- snickerbockers 3y agoHow the hell do euros spend 5 years proudly bragging about their GDPR to the rest of the world and then go ahead and even consider something like this? I assume this doesn't directly violate the GDPR but even so it seems like an obvious contradiction to the spirit and intent of GDPR.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoI don’t understand what confuses you so much. This is for “the safety”. “Trusted governments” will make sure “exemptions” are in place and everything will be “okay”. Why worry, do you have something to hide?
- anfogoat 3y agoThis weakens your privacy with regards to sharp governmental powers, something the GDPR never strengthened or addressed to begin with due to its categorical exemption of law enforcement. Well, competent law enforcement (if you needed a laugh). And to all the EU cheerleaders about to educate me how, thanks to the GDPR, my local municipality has to treat my email with care when I go ask for a building permit: go gaslight your grandma instead.
- alexanderchr 3y ago"Competent" in this usage means "empowered" not "proficient".
- anfogoat 3y agoCan't believe I missed that, especially for how off it seemed in the latter form. Thank you.
- alexanderchr 3y agoNo it’s not at all a common use of the word, stumped me too the first time I saw it used like that.
- 3y ago
- moonfern 3y agoThe EU minus Denmark and Ireland who have opted out from the area of freedom, security and justice domain. I don't see how real democratic control over CSAM-scanning is possible in the EU. But national parliaments can vote for/against laws with their version of CSAM-scanning.A new parliament can changes those laws.
- caesil 3y ago"known and unknown CSAM" Given where image AI is, this is certain to detect a colossal amount of false positives. In fact it'll be impossible to sift out false positives soon, if it isn't already. This plan seems like fighting the last war when there's a much bigger and different problem looming.
- RIMR 3y ago"Unknown CSAM" just means scanning all your files with AI to judge content. They can't be searching for infringing material that they haven't seen before, they'd have to train a model to interpret images. Which means lots of people are going to end up flagged for pictures of their own kids, because just about every parent has nude photos of their children somewhere.
- ls612 3y agoWhich means the state has a ready made reason to detain anyone they don't like on the grounds of "child abuse". That sounds like the point of this to me.
- DeepSeaTortoise 3y agoAlso you can't just have hundreds of thousands of judges, lawyers and jurors looking at CSAM all day, can you? Better to have a panel of 10 or 20 carefully selected experts (of course with secret identities to avoid them being threatened by major csam cartels) who will inform all involved parties (including yourself) at how much csam you looked and how bad it was.
- dtx1 3y agoIf everyone is guilty of breaking the law, the true power lies in selective enforcement of these laws.
- euzi 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RIMR 3y agoThe entire argument can be summed up like this: It is impossible with current technology to completely eliminate any photos or videos from existence. So long as the Internet exists, and people have access banned media, that banned media will continue to proliferate. To combat this, the state needs to be granted extraordinary powers to peer into people's devices and accounts and look at their files so that we can prosecute people in possession of banned media, and the state super-duper promises that the only media we'll ever ban is child pornography, and nothing else ever, though you can't actually stop us when we push to expand this power later, which we will absolutely be doing.
- squarefoot 3y agoIn a few years all CSAM will be AI generated; if they don't hurry up, they'll be left only with fighting terrorism as an excuse for draconian laws.
- didntcheck 3y agoThis is a blessing for them. Now they have an excuse to "regulate" AI. I doubt they'd try to ban local models entirely (even for them, that's ridiculous), but the accusation will offer a convenient way to harass sites offering them
- Havoc 3y agoUndermining of privacy like that sure seems dangerous in a me & my rights sense, but the ability to sway public opinion on a grand scale via twitter misinformation & cambridge analytica stunts etc seems much much more dangerous to the concept of anything "democratic" to me. Who the f cares about encryption protocol details if you've lost control of the state & the primary democractic mechanism as a whole?
- yukkuri 3y agoCSAM is just a smokescreen. The monitoring is the goal, and if/when they force this thru it will rapidly expand to cover anything and everything
- anonzzzies 3y agoBut similar initiatives will appear everywhere in the end once they land somewhere (outside openly totalitarian regimes where they are already in place, like China). They have to be stopped, but I am afraid they will happen in the end, everywhere; once they happen in some western countries, others will have the blueprint to copy to theirs. And citizens everywhere are being lied to; most non tech (but also tech) people think this is a good thing. Friends in the US, UK and AU are applauding this type of stuff coming to their countries. Because of the children. Unfortunately no one takes it serious enough to take massive ad and tv campaigns to member states and educate the public that this is simply bad for everyone and doesn’t help the children.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoAlso the members of the council pushed for website censorship, which will be included in this bill. They also directly lie about the contents. The EU allegedly has fact checkers, but they are a joke as otherwise they would flag publications of the commission left and right. To be honest, I don't see the EU as a public good anymore. For a while already. It has degenerated to into a bureaucratic technocracy. Before anyone tries to mention that I can vote for parliament and one of the council members and everything is super dandy,... I know and that doesn't make anything any better. Democracy is so indirect that we can do away with it completely in the current implementation. We will get bombed with such bills until something sticks. This isn't anything I will support.
- Zuiii 3y agoClient-side scanning can't and won't work because: 1. Users can scramble the files to pass scans. 2. Users can use the same client-side scanners as black boxes to verify. There is no scenario in which client-side scanning works unless the user is not allowed to modify anything on the system. Not the images, not the software. Mark my words, the only thing this will be good at is identifying honest law-abiding citizens with political causes that are not aligned with their current government. If this passes, real democracy, the sort that ends unpopular government-endorsed laws like race discrimination and prohibition, will die in the EU.
- kelnos 3y agoI think all of the arguments here talking about why these sort of measures don't work to reduce CSAM (or have too many false negatives or too many false positives) are missing the point: While legislators do care about reducing child abuse, they're mainly using it as justification for this stuff so they can increase surveillance and control over their citizens. This is just a play to mandate client-side software that acts against the interests of the hardware owner. Once it's on there, it's a much smaller step to increase the scope of what it's required to do (either legally or through shady backchannel means) to things that the average person wouldn't be in favor of.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoDon't know why you are downvoted, but that is very true. They also try to implement a unique internet ID per citizen to implement age verification. The motives are pretty transparent here. Some say they don't want that, but they are very likely lying.
- anonzzzies 3y agoNote that as it stands the current proposal won’t pass as there are multiple member states (NL, Spain, Poland) against it and it’s probably unlawful. It has to be thoroughly revised to pass; those changes probably will make it more useless than it already is, but hopefully saves us from privacy/encryption backdoors, this time.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoThey also have ambitions to block websites, basically common web censorship. The current president of the commission already tried that on a national level in Germany. It cannot pass under any circumstance, it needs to be rejected as a whole. There is no compromise to be had.
- anonzzzies 3y agoMany petition to vote in favour of this proposal; cannot find one against. I did email our dutch minister with concern. Any other plans? It is scary how many (including tech people) want this to happen ‘for the children’.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoThere are immense lobbying attempt by large tech companies. Otherwise nobody in tech circle really supports this at all. On the contrary, the rest of the industry is more or less unanimously against this with a lot of experts deriding the ideas. Also some civil rights activist that believe this proposal to be quite illegal.
- anonzzzies 3y agoWell most people who work in tech and who are technical that I know personally, are, to my surprise, in favour of it. I just asked them after reading comments here. But they, like many, did not inform themselves; they just ‘want more protection for children’.
- Alifatisk 3y agoCSAM and Chat Control is some of the scariest ideas EU is pushing. What shocks me the most is how little people react over this.
- jug 3y agoThank god Wojciech Wiewiórowski is a voice of reason in the middle of all this. But it’s extremely concerning that it’s reaching all the way to our final thin lines in the EU. This shouldn’t even get further than the lobbying.
- Woodi 3y agoLooks like CSAM idiocy is just smoking gun for changing EU treacies. And as usual it looks like Germans want to be more important then others...