10 ms·
Thunderbird 115.4.0
- f233f2 3y agoThunderbird is improving so much and so fast since they left Mozilla. I wonder if the same could work for Firefox.
- extr0pian 3y agoThey didn't really leave Mozilla, they formed MZLA Technologies Corporations which is a subsidiary of the Mozilla Foundation. Nonetheless, I agree that things have been drastically improving since the change.
- szundi 3y agoProbably some direct decision maker understands the audience better this way
- NackerHughes 3y agoDoes it bring back the old, perfectly functional UI that everyone’s used for years? No? Hard pass. People don’t have the time to waste searching around for some button or menu item that the designers have moved somewhere else, buried in about:config or removed entirely. They force this ugly, garish mess of whitespace on us and tell us it’s the “most beautiful Thunderbird yet”. Maybe if enough of us cover our ears and clamp our eyes shut and shout that loud enough, it’ll become true. Me personally? I’m sticking with my trusty v102.12.0, thanks.
- jmclnx 3y agoI am fine with its UI, but I really wish it uses gnupg instead of the built encryption. Or maybe have an option to force the use of gnupg.
- neogodless 3y agoFor what it's worth, I upgraded to 115. I can't remember how long it's been. I forgot I upgraded because it doesn't seem that different to me. I still have pretty small fonts and very little spacing around things. Above my reading pane are buttons with words on them like "Reply All" and "Forward." Some menus are still hidden behind an oddly placed hamburger near the top right, just like they were before. Search is still pretty mediocre!
- figmert 3y agoObviously this subjective. I personally never like the old UI, and though it still has ways to go, it's miles ahead of the old UI.
- inanutshellus 3y agoI don't see what the fuss is about. They made rather minor changes overall and gave the app a bit of a facelift. I personally like the changes (for example putting the keyboard shortcuts in the search bars... I don't recall them being there so prominently, but I like the reminder when I forget, and it doesn't get in the way when I don't.) Regardless, we cannot let stagnation be the answer.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoI think the only prominent UI change that happened is that the bar that holds the search box, Write button etc is above the tab bar now instead of below. Personally, I find it a bit jarring, because contextually, that bar only contains stuff related to mail, but that bar and some stuff on it continues to appear even when I switch to Calendar. Thankfully, some CSS takes care of this. Otherwise, it is a quite nice change. Dark mode now also applies to mail contents as well, which is a great change, though I would like a shortcut to swap to light mode.
- pizza234 3y agoTwo things: 1. the designers never considered keyboard navigation, which is now even more awkward than it was already 2. the interface is now very visibly slower - startup and general usage (on two of my systems) This ignores the very long standing issues like: 1. searching is very confusing; there are several different types of searches 2. writing an email still requires opening another window. compose emails like it's the 90s!
- pmontra 3y agoIt never occurred to me that I should not open a new window to compose an email. How would that work? Displace the folder I'm in, or the message I'm looking at? And why?
- pizza234 3y agoIt should do it in a new tab. There have been discussions about it, but all the attempts have been abandoned due to spaghetti code.
- jraph 3y agoAnd many people complained about the UI feeling dated before the change. The new UI has a compact mode, I think you can get an even more compact UI than before. I've used thunderbird forever and I'm not lost at all. I think they did a really good job not breaking us. I guess they can't please everyone but I don't know how they could have done better in this respect honestly.
- folmar 3y agoYes, the compact mode needs a bit of getting used to but is great in the end. A really nice makeover of the old view, even more compact.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoYes, could have been worse. There were several minor amateur moves however. The menu bar in the wrong place for example—not sure what they were thinking. Also hardcoded the highlight color to blue (on purpose), disrespecting the system UI theme. Same thing happened ~twenty years ago with firebug and I was happy to drop it for FF dev tools. Every few years a new batch of "senior" engineers needs to earn xp points.
- hassancf 3y agoAgree. The new UI is crap.
- Derbasti 3y agoI could not disagree more vehemently. The old UI was ugly and clunky and anachronistic. I find the new UI much more readable, with a sensibly usable three-column layout, and much improved message list. To each their own, I guess.
- plibither8 3y agoWhatever happened to their Android plans?
- collsni 3y agoK-9 Mail is their plan
- techwizrd 3y agoK-9 Mail joined Thunderbird to become Thunderbird Mobile [0]. They regularly publish progress updates [1] and their GitHub repository is regularly publishing releases and merging fixes and features [2]. 0: https://blog.thunderbird.net/2022/06/revealed-thunderbird-on-android-plans-k9/ https://blog.thunderbird.net/2022/06/revealed-thunderbird-on... 1: https://blog.thunderbird.net/category/thunderbird-mobile/ https://blog.thunderbird.net/category/thunderbird-mobile/ 2: https://github.com/thundernest/k-9/pulse https://github.com/thundernest/k-9/pulse
- qiine 3y agoI can't wait for them to rollout syncing between desktop and mobile Thunderbird.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoWhat exactly do you want synced? Shouldn't the two mail clients just sync with your mail server individually? If you send an email from desktop, it will land in the sent folder, which the mobile client will then sync and show.
- turrini 3y agoOne feature I'm missing is the ability to display 3 lines (from, subject, and the first line of the body) in the message list. When dealing with monitoring and certain notifications, I have to open each email to see its contents.
- AnonC 3y agoIt’ll come in a future release. What you need to keep an eye out for is improvements in the “Cards View”. Currently it shows only the sender name, time and subject of the email. Quoting from the Thunderbird Supernova FAQ [1]: > Cards View is still in active development. More features such as a message preview line and sender avatars will be added in the future. [1]: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/thunderbird-115-supernova-faq#w_step-2-turn-on-cards-view https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/thunderbird-115-superno...
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoCan anyone recommend a professional, good quality (preferably non MS) email client that isn't thunderbird, please. I'd happily pay.
- contact9879 3y agoCanary Mail is great on macOS and iOS. I haven't used it in Windows but it is available.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoThanks, never heard of it but from wikipedia: "Canary Mail is an email client that offers artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities backed by technology from OpenAI & Cohere, as well as open-source language models from Hugging Face [...] Canary Mail flagship feature, Copilot, leverages artificial intelligence to help users write, summarize, and prioritize emails. The app's free version offers basic features, while the Pro Version, starting at $20 per year, offers additional features, including Copilot" OMG I'd genuinely pay more not to have any of that, ever. I'm afraid CM is not an option, but thank you anyway.
- contact9879 3y agoOh. I admit I haven't used Canary since right before the AI-mania. It's unfortunate that they went that route for what is an otherwise great product
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoNP, all suggestions welcome, thank you anyway!
- blacklion 3y ago"The Bat!"? It was very good in POP3 times, then lack proper IMAP4 support for several years, but now authors claim that IMAP4 support is first-class. It is very old (first release in 1997) client with very-very old-skool features, like different templates with multitude of variables (and not only one option "where to place your signature") and rules to apply them (you could have different templates for different correspondents, you have different templates for new message, reply, reply to all and forward, etc, etc, etc). Built-in filters are rather good too, with a lot of automation. But it looks dated, and HTML support is not the best. And there is no manage sieve client. Edit: Windows only.
- oblib 3y agoI'm pretty happy with Thunderbird. Apple's latest "Mail" app is good too but I still use Thunderbird. I just checked and mine says "115.3.3 (64-bit) Thunderbird is up to date" so I guess I'll be waiting a bit for the update but I haven't run into any of the issues they cite so I'm in no hurry.
- jrm4 3y agoDifferent background color for different accounts is the literal deal-killer for me here. Am I missing something? If not a basic built-in feature, this seems like this ought to be trivially easy as a plug-in, but they appear to have broken it?
- dotancohen 3y ago[flagged]
- hovering_nox 3y agono
- AnonC 3y agoI sometimes dream that Mozilla would somehow convince Microsoft to make it easier to use Thunderbird with Outlook365. Many companies that use Outlook365 disable IMAP and SMTP entirely even though Thunderbird supports IMAP and SMTP with OAuth2. Microsoft has spread enough FUD to convince its customers that Outlook is the only client to be allowed and actively encouraged disabling “legacy protocols” for “security reasons”. Thunderbird doesn’t support the Microsoft specific Graph API. While there are some extensions that could enable working with Outlook365 using some kludgy approaches, it would be better to have that natively supported.
- zitterbewegung 3y agoMozilla and Thunderbird are two separate entities . https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/thunderbird-faq#:~:text=Thunderbird%20is%20completely%20independent%20of,Corporation%2C%20the%20makers%20of%20Firefox https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/thunderbird-faq#:~:text....
- AnonC 3y agoThat KB article is outdated. About Thunderbird: “Available cross-platform, it is operated by the Mozilla Foundation's subsidiary MZLA Technologies Corporation.” [1] Also see [2] for how this came about. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Thunderbird https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Thunderbird [2]: https://blog.thunderbird.net/2017/05/thunderbirds-future-home/ https://blog.thunderbird.net/2017/05/thunderbirds-future-hom...
- appleskeptic 3y agoNothing prevents Thunderbird from implementing the Exchange protocols. Many have done it, including Evolution, an open source competitor to Thunderbird.
- wwfn 3y agohttp://davmail.sourceforge.net/ http://davmail.sourceforge.net/ works well as a O365->IMAP bridge. davmail can be configure so it's clientId matches outlook's
- 3y ago
- Night_Thastus 3y agoThe last couple major updates to Thunderbird have been really nice. I had to follow some tutorials they put out to get the UI better (stuff like Unified folders, tags, the different view settings, etc), but once I did it's been a really nice experience.
- moqmar 3y agoAbsolutely agree, the new design makes it so much more modern & easy to use for the average user. I have the feeling that many complaints here are about specific workflows or specific advanced features, but instead of trying to please everyone by doing everything MZLA has built a really nice email client that just works for the majority of its users and now is in a shape where it might even attract new ones.
- blacklion 3y agoMenu UNDER toolbar is ridiculous. Duplicate toolbar buttons (on main toolbar & account toolbar) are ridiculous. But all of that could be tolerable. What is NOT tolerable is broken "Manually sort folders" plugin. Thunderbird sorts folders in tree alphabetically and only alphabetically, and it is pure nonsense! But before this update there was very handy plugin to rearrange folders in away you need, not alphabet needs. Now it is broken and author says that internal API is completely changed. This is essential feature, IMHO. "The Bat!" mail client has this feature in, I don't know, 2000? With handy keyboard shortcuts (Ctrl+Arrows) too!
- pmontra 3y ago> Menu UNDER toolbar is ridiculous. There is way to undo that, at least on Linux. Edit or create the file chrome/userChrome.css in your profile directory and add #toolbar-menubar { order: -1 !important; } Restart Thunderbird. Maybe it works on all OSes. Credits to https://superuser.com/questions/1787317/thunderbird-114-115-reshuffled-the-interface-again-how-to-fix-it https://superuser.com/questions/1787317/thunderbird-114-115-... > What is NOT tolerable is broken "Manually sort folders" plugin. I sadly agree with you. I'm waiting for some good news from the GitHub page of the plugin. My workaround is to mark as favorites the parent folders of the trees for my customers and place the favorites at the top of the tree list. I never used favorites before, there was no need for them.
- nerdponx 3y agoAh yes, manually setting opaque CSS to revert an idiosyncratic UI design choice back to something that people would normally expect to see. Great, thanks. Seriously, when I saw the "115 vs 102" slider thing on the website, I was surprised and disappointed to realize that that I instinctively interpreted as the new and improved UI was actually the old UI that I was already used to, and the weird iPad-esque thing was actually the new and supposedly improved UI that I was about to get. This is what I donate every month for? It's enough to make me reconsider my contribution.
- thesuitonym 3y ago>Thunderbird sorts folders in tree alphabetically and only alphabetically Except when it doesn't. Personally, alphabetically is the way that I want it sorted, but sometimes Thunderbird starts up and the folders are randomly sorted, and I can't sort the back. I just have to close Thunderbird and start it again to get my folders back in the right order.
- throw0101c 3y agoUnder "Fixes" it lists a bunch of items, but there are no links to bug numbers or commits/pull requests.
- nologic01 3y agoLocal copies of all the different webmail accounts and ability to search through that massive information overload in a unified way. What else can one possibly ask? Maybe some local AI to help sort out things just bit more :-) Its a blessing that the project keeps going strongly.
- titannet 3y agoI barely find anything when using thunderbird search. Is that just me?
- mr_machine 3y agoDefinitely not just you. Often, though I know exactly the info required to find a message, Thunderbird comes up with no results. I've found that "repairing" the containing mailbox renders the message findable. Not sure when things got this bad, but I can well recall in the past Thunderbird's search being fast, thorough, and reliable.
- nologic01 3y agoits takes a few seconds parsing all the accounts/folders (as I have an indecent amount of email) but it never had any trouble finding things
- janci 3y agoSearch never works for me. I use quick filter. It's slow, but works.
- Aachen 3y agoYeah, the "normal" search is for the desperate. Quick search is where it's at. Keeps the view sane and you select which fields to search (subject, recipients, body), the downside is that you have to know which folder to look in, which can also be an upside to narrow it down (I know that's also possible in the search UI but this is easier)
- folmar 3y agoSome years ago it used to work great, but then it changed to searching for words only. Or so it appears.
- mpawelski 3y agoAfter couple of years of not using Thunderbird (I switched completely to web portals) I tried it when they released Supernova and all I can say is that it's... slow. Really, I often have UI freezes, data doesn't appear immediately, downloading mails take a lot of time, calendar also is not that snappy. I somehow expected to have everything super fast as it's a local app (after all the data is downloaded), but it clearly doesn't handle large amount of mails efficiently.
- the__alchemist 3y agoIt runs well enough on my desktop, but on my tablet (SP9 with an i7...), each action has 1-2s latency. Ie selecting a new email, opening a compose window etc. We need a from-scratch desktop email client that is fast and streamlined. I give on Tbird. At least in this version I can figure out how to disable the HTML email formatting and MS-word-style auto-spacing below paragraphs when composing. Also, search still doesn't work for me.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- righthand 3y agoSame. I opened Thunderbird recently after probably over a year and this switch to a browser rendering engine. The entire application locked up while it was updating my list of emails. I’m glad the project is seeing some FOSS love but it also seems to have gone down the entirely wrong path in pursuit of modernization without benefit. Sadly for Linux there aren’t really any great modern UI-style (not browser rendering modern but just the look) email clients so I’ll just keep using my browser since there is now no benefit to using Thunderbird. Oh and this is a brand new machine I built in 2022. So it’s not the hardware.
- jhoechtl 3y agoMy answer us certainly subjective but I find Gnome Evolution quite fast, user driendly and well designed.
- kayson 3y agoToo bad it still completely freezes while downloading emails. The Supernova UI is definitely an improvement but it still has a long way to go... A bit surprised that there aren't really any other strong competitors in the space.
- agent327 3y agoI don't like where they put the new message button (it's weirdly floating over the list of folders now, but what's the relation with that list?). There's also a mostly empty bar _above_ the menu bar (I'm old-school, I like menu bars). It wastes space, looks silly, and cannot be turned off as far as I can tell... I used to have an extension installed ("Mailbox Alert") that provides different notification sounds depending on the account receiving an email, but unfortunately that is now broken. That's a significant step back.
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoCan it finally export and import filters? This glaring and baffling omission was a deal-breaker 25 years ago.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoI think copying msgFilerRules.dat has worked for all of Thunderbird's existence. Here is the full way [1]. [1] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1269514 https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1269514
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoThanks, but that still amounts to "no." If there's no menu item for this basic feature, it's not a function offered by the application. Expecting the user to search the Web for how to do this and then dig around in data files that are buried in platform-dependent application directories is a hokey and not-production-quality "solution." If it's just a data file, there's no excuse for neglecting its import and export (AKA simple copying) for 25 or more years. I mean, how did filter functionality even go out the door without this? They expect people to run around and manually re-enter all of their filters on every computer they own? And to do this perpetually?
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoWith all due respect, Thunderbird is a FOSS project, which is largely run on unpaid volunteer efforts. I think it's quite right to denigrate their efforts because they didn't manage to build a particular feature.
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoI respect all the people who give an incredible amount of time to these projects. I help when I can, and give money to the ones I rely on when I can't contribute any other way. But I heartily disagree that criticizing the product or the development priorities is "denigrating" their efforts. It is simply criticism, hopefully constructive. People were asking to copy filters between machines 20+ years ago. Filters are essential for any E-mail client; I can't imagine what the intended M.O. is for them in Thunderbird at this point. If I weren't exclusively on Macs every day I would absolutely implement this myself; as it stands, I can't justify the time. But I can armchair-quarterback the shit out of it!
- elorant 3y agoThe main issue I have with Supernova is when I move into the Sent folder its focus is on the middle of the stack instead of the last e-mail I've sent. I just don't understand how something that essential slipped in the final version. The whole UI seems like it's half baked.
- xet7 3y agoI changed to Betterbird, because Betterbird added back features that Thunderbird removed.
- yubiox 3y agoThe calendar has been broken for a while now. It is impossible to close reminder popups, neither button does anything. It doesn't sync properly anymore either. I wish there was undo when you accidentally click the subject header and it sorts by subject. It is really hard to get back to sort by date then unread.
- mdaniel 3y agoI don't use the calendar integration, but the behavior you're describing is almost certainly some JS explosion that wasn't handled. "Tools > Developer Tools > Error Console" (Ctrl-Shift-J in my copy) may cough up something that would enable you to file a bug report, if you were inclined, or may even help understand what expectation it had that your setup deviates from
- blackhaz 3y agoI wonder if there is a fork available of normal Thunderbird. I don't understand this. Why destroy a perfectly working application?
- righthand 3y agoIMO, because it’s easier to convince yourself that a rewrite will accomplish all goals faster instead of utilizing the old code.
- tristan957 3y agoBut there wasn't a rewrite of Thunderbird?
- righthand 3y agoThe UI and rendering layer? Yes there was. It may not have been a full rewrite but they ditched the XUL ecosystem also. Do you think the complaints posted in this thread aren’t because code was rewritten?
- jeltz 3y agoYeah, the reason there are perforamnce regressions is due to a partial rewrite.
- WolfeReader 3y agoLots of people griping about Thunderbird! Can someone recommend an e-mail client which does the following: 1. Supports GPG signing and decryption 2. Allows plain text views and composition to be set as default I use ThunderBird for those two specific reasons, and I'd be fine trying something new too.
- hiepph 3y agoSome more features that I like: + Bottom posting can be set as default. + Selected text are automatically quoted when hitting reply. + Many add-ons and utilities are available: DKIM verifier, Mail Hop viewer, Mail Agent viewer, etc. I tried to find an alternative but I couldn't either.
- bronikowski 3y agoThis is not everyone-friendly answer, but Mutt does it. To the second point it's not even optional for composing. Unless you write/use some markdown to text/html.
- narag 3y agoThunderbird has a very useful feature: simplified incoming html view. It strips remote images and js, while keeping the minimum to make messages readable. Responses can use plain text. I really liked Mutt. I used it for one or two years, a long time ago.
- bronikowski 3y agoYou can pipe text/html to w3m/elinks to get the same results. Well, almost the same, some e-mails are not that well designed. I still love mutt, it's so rapid and it works almost the same when I first used it, over 20 years ago.
- rinze 3y agomutt does both things. I've been using it for years. The learning curve is certainly steep, and being in the terminal all the time might throw people off, but it does what you're asking for.
- AndyKelley 3y agoall I want is better spam filtering UI
- happyjack 3y agoI'm really glad TB exists and is still developed. I try it once a year every year because I use Firefox, and TB is cross platform. Honestly, I can't say it fits my needs more than Mac mail.app or the web client when on a windows computer (mailbox.org). I guess what I'm saying is that I have never used Outlook so I've never needed an open source replacement for it.
- Naac 3y agoThey still haven't fixed the 15 year old bug allowing you to open a compose window in a new tab. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=449299 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=449299
- simonebrunozzi 3y agoThunderbird stopped being amazing about 10 years ago. No signs of recovery in sight. I don't know much anymore, but I used to follow the development, and sadly started noticing decisions and mistakes that brought us to this today. Can there be an amazing product behind a non-profit group? Firefox, at least, seems quite better than Thunderbird.
- mmh0000 3y agoI want to use Thunderbird, but man, it's lacking some basic features. Features that used to be available via add-ons, but which stopped working somewhere around v60. My biggest annoyances: * Inability to easily edit the from address -Why: I use Fastmail with 10 different custom domains and custom senders. In TB I would have to manually add in each sending domain. And TB still doesn't "remember" which -from- addresses are used by which -to- address. This used to be solved by the https://www.absorb.it/virtual-id/ https://www.absorb.it/virtual-id/ . Shockingly, the Fastmail webui does have this feature. * Inability to minimize to tray on Linux (Windows does have this feature, but that doesn't help me). * Inconsistent notifications, sometimes you'll get one, sometimes not, who knows why. * No easy way to tell if Thunderbird is using IMAP Push But at least I'm glad they put an IRC client in. If there's one thing I always wanted my email client to be, it's an IRC client. (sarcasm)
- ssl232 3y ago> Inability to easily edit the from address This has been possible for years. Click the From address then "Customize From Address..." and enter whatever you like. But > And TB still doesn't "remember" which -from- addresses are used by which -to- address. is indeed correct, and annoys me too.
- mmh0000 3y agoYou can only "Customize From Address" if the domain you're wanting to send from is added to your sending profiles. So. Yes. it's possible. But it's user-hostile.
- ssl232 3y agoHmm. Do I have it right that you mean you can't send from e.g. "test@example.com" (using "Customize From Address..." then entering that address in the From field) unless another address for the domain "example.com" is set up as an account in Thunderbird (e.g. "hello@example.com")? If that's what you mean, then I don't think that's correct, as I just tried it and Thunderbird let me send the message despite me not having any account for example.com in my profile. I did of course get a response from example.com telling me there was no MX server, but that tells me Thunderbird went as far as sending it.
- v3ss0n 3y agonova is slow, bloated UI, Dark theme looks horrendous. Mailspring seems to be best alternative so far.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoIs there any good alternative to Thunderbird which also supports maildir, can handle external changes in maildir well, as also has secure support for HTML-Mails? Thunderbird seems to have drop proper support for local content a long time ago.
- matjus 3y agoOrganizing folders is pretty annoying - especially if you have the bad luck to drop a folder somewhere it shouldn't be. Everything freezes while you wait for a couple thousand messages to move where they shouldn't, just so you can move them back where you want them. Certain aspects of layout state don't persist when you close and reopen. I was annoyed that I spent a few minutes getting the ideal folder/spacing layout for RSS in one tab and Mail in the other only to see both revert to the same on reopening. I was pleasantly surprised, briefly, by the Matrix chat integration. I use Beeper, and while that program is a marvel, the desktop app is yet another Electron app with few customizations available -- like a lot of Beeper users, I want no pictures, high density, tiny text -- basically, I want xchat! The Thunderbird chat implementation is tantalizingly close to this. But there are essentially NO options for cleaning up or organizing "Conversations", or open chats. Beeper manages to replace display names (I think by syncing contacts with your phone), it would be awesome if Thunderbird could do the same. Similarly, it archives older chats in a weird tab system ("today", "yesterday") -- why not just put it in the chat window like anybody would expect? There seems to be confusion about who the Thunderbird user is -- like, I use it because I want RSS and chat and multiple email addresses in one window, I want no-frills, I want a wall of text in a native application, I want to be able to hide profile pictures and backgrounds and icons and any other visual noise.