6 ms·
The housing market looks like a bubble, 2008 regulator says
- 93po 3y agothis feels meaningless, you can find impressively credentialed people saying it is and isn't if this dude was confidently correct he should go make billions on the market
- huytersd 3y agoNot until the crash. How do you make money in crashing real estate prices anyway? Only accessible thing that comes to mind is shorting REITs.
- 93po 3y agotons of companies to short that are heavily reliant on inflated housing prices
- pxeboot 3y ago> How do you make money in crashing real estate prices anyway? Buy low and sell during the next bubble? This time, it feels like so many people are waiting for the crash to happen, it may not be as bad as last time.
- huytersd 3y agoI don’t mean over a decade. I mean making money off the crash event itself.
- nuclearnice3 3y agoShelia Blair is a woman, not a dude. Her name is the first two words of the first sentence of the article. Is part of the reason it feels meaningless because you only read 10 words of content and it was difficult for CNN to pack a satisfying explanation of the economy into that limited bandwidth?
- randomdata 3y ago> Shelia Blair is a woman, not a dude. Why can't a woman can be a dude? I thought we moved past the age of gender exclusivity?
- kelseyfrog 3y agoEver kiss a dude before?
- 93po 3y agoThis feels needlessly combative and adds nothing to the conversation
- nuclearnice3 3y agoGotcha 93po. I intended only to playfully point out that YOUR comment hadn't engaged deeply with the substance. I overshot the mark and I apologize. Thank you for pointing out my mistake.
- 93po 3y agoThanks for the mindful reception. I can see your point too.
- n9 3y agoi hear you and I don't disagree. That said: I feel pretty OK about selling my house that has appreciated >100% in 8 years (east LA) and renting a nicer house for a little less money. Could be that I'm wrong, but at the very least I profited more than $450k for simply buying a house, living in it, and selling it. If nothing else I effectively lived rent-free for the past 8 years and am left with enough cash to pay rent on a similar place for the next 11 years all for the opportunity cost of a down payment.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> if this dude was confidently correct he should go make billions on the market Remember: Michael Burry of The Big Short fame nearly went bankrupt waiting for the market to collapse. You can be right and not get the timing right; the very relevant Keynes quote is "Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Burry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Burry > During his payments toward the credit default swaps, Burry suffered an investor revolt, where some investors in his fund worried his predictions were inaccurate and demanded to withdraw their capital. Eventually, Burry's analysis proved correct: He made a personal profit of $100 million and a profit for his remaining investors of more than $700 million. Scion Capital ultimately recorded returns of 489.34% (net of fees and expenses) between its November 1, 2000, inception and June 2008. The S&P 500, widely regarded as the benchmark for the US market, returned just under 3%, including dividends over the same period.
- bluGill 3y agoNote too that when his investors got nervous it would be too late to get in. There were long months when you couldn't buy anything, you had to already be in and then ride things out.
- bongobingo1 3y agoIts funny reading this, because the housing market has never not looked like a bubble in my life. I guess it wasn't a bubble in the 70s-80s? Its hard to conceptulise what a housing market that isn't looks like.
- lispisok 3y agoAgree. I dont see the government letting another 2008 happen either. They will do whatever it takes to keep housing prices from declining significantly on a large scale
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThere could be some weird world in which it's popular for house prices to go down. If that becomes the case, then populist politicians will eventually get elected and let them fall. I don't see this happening soon, but stranger things have happened.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoWeird? That’s literally what millennials and gen z and any other generation who can’t afford the bubble houses want
- yakubin 3y agoBut there’s too few of us. The elderly are always going to outvote us.
- randomdata 3y agoThe millennials are the largest generational demographic. Add in the adult segment of Generation Z and the elderly are greatly outnumbered. But Generation X holds the balance of power. They are the wildcard.
- 3y ago
- debacle 3y agoWe are certainly in a bubble. In some ways, we're better off than 2008 since we wont see nearly as many foreclosures, but on the other hand if interest rates stay sane for the next decade, there will be many people who are in homes they wont be able to leave. I'm not sure what this will really mean, except that obviously it will be harder to buy a home for some time, and you'll likely see a rise in renters (which we have already been seeing, and which from my perspective is not a good thing).
- arbuge 3y ago> The median home price of an existing home stood at just $278,200 in August 2019, according to the National Association of Realtors. That figure has since spiked to $407,100 as of August 2023. “Talk about a bubble. That’s a classic supply-demand imbalance,” Bair told CNN in a phone interview. Is it really a bubble though? How much is $278k adjusted for inflation since August 2019? And if there's really a "supply-demand imbalance", wouldn't that be a further justification for the current prices? I assume she means too little supply for existing demand.
- svnt 3y agoDoesn’t matter if too few can afford to purchase it because of interest rates.
- Salgat 3y agoExactly. Lower prices will appeal to corps and folks who can pay in cash long before anyone else can afford the same price.
- d3w4s9 3y agoEh, can't bother to run the numbers youself? $278k in August 2019 has the same buying power as $333,512.66 as in September of this year.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 3y agoIt's more complicated than that since the cost of housing is included in "official" and unofficial inflation numbers (33% of US Consumer Price Index is housing). So multiplying by the inflation rate and comparing to the current market is circular. A better indicator might be the inflation in the money supply over that same period, but idk I am not a finance guy.
- giantg2 3y agoThe CPI also shows what categories within it have moved. It would take more effort to calculate since none of the calculators online have that option, but it could be done.
- illwrks 3y agoSays it all really... it's a puff piece to promote a book launch. “If supply remains constrained, this could go on for some time,” said Bair, who last week released a new children’s book about bubbles called “Daisy Bubble: A Price Crash on Galapagos.”
- yieldcrv 3y agoits only a bubble when people want to sell or refinance though also unlike 2008, people dont have many adjustable rate mortgages, and if they do, it wont adjust yet over 50% of current mortgages were started in 2020-2022, locked into to 2-3% rates until 2050! they don't have enough equity yet to sell and live in a different home. the speculators didn't get a continued rally, they're all stuck. supply isnt going to occur just because aspiring buyers cant buy at these prices or pay a mortgage at 8.5% at any price any counterpoints that would bring housing prices far lower?
- YokoZar 3y ago>any counterpoints that would bring housing prices far lower Policy changes allowing substantially more construction finally bearing fruit? We have a long way to go but there has been some significant movement in that direction, particularly in the most expensive housing markets.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> particularly in the most expensive housing markets. any indications that is outpacing demand? if supply is less than demand, prices of additional units stay the same or go higher if supply equals demand, prices of additional units stay the same if supply is more than demand, prices should go lower or something else is broken like poor transparency and collusion
- starcraft2wol 3y ago> its only a bubble when people want to sell or refinance though The "everyone will just hold forever" theory doesn't describe markets well. People usually move because they have to: unemployment, run out of space, divorce, death, marriage, etc. This will not change, even if the rate of turnover is slower.
- bluGill 3y agoSure, but a lot of people will not have those events and so will be able to hold. A few who have a choice won't upgrade who would have before.
- ChumpGPT 3y agoThere is no bubble like the bubble in Canada. From the start of the Pandemic there were Houses that went from 800k to 1.5 million in 6-12 months. Even today they are still going up. Here is how messed it is. A listing 4 hours North of Toronto. 800k plus for a shit hole with nothing around. https://www.realtor.ca/real-estate/26200220/255-town-line-road-w-huntsville https://www.realtor.ca/real-estate/26200220/255-town-line-ro...
- giantg2 3y agoAt least the property tax is reasonable.
- applied_heat 3y agoIt’s 1.4 acres 3 minutes from all the amenities of huntsville which I see has a hospital, multiple community swimming pools etc. the house has two kitchens so easily you can rent out a suite. The house is not in the middle Of the lot so you can Sell half the land. Honestly looks like a good buy from where I’m sitting in BC.
- randomdata 3y ago> Here is how messed it is. A listing 4 hours North of Toronto. 800k plus for a shit hole with nothing around. Advertisements are not transactions. Said house first listed for $999,999 back in May[1], but didn't sell. It has been listed for $825,000 for over a month now and still hasn't sold. You can slap a billion dollar price tag on a house if you want. That doesn't mean there is a buyer and says nothing about the state of the market. > Even today they are still going up. No. The overall market peaked in early 2022[2] and has been on the downward trend since. In [2] you will even see the infamous dead cat bounce, which is strongly indicative of the crash having already happened, with the market now just trying to figure out where the bottom is. [1] https://housesigma.com/on/huntsville-real-estate/255-town-line-road-w/home/weQp5yODWR17d0ZE?id_listing=XRla7gb0oLgyjEvL https://housesigma.com/on/huntsville-real-estate/255-town-li... [2] https://images.ctfassets.net/gm6df3h7p862/642MhWekUf7LM5PNniVBst/5795d5ce3ae1d34f71b8f90ca1decc1b/natl_chartA04_xhi-res_en.png?w=800&q=50 https://images.ctfassets.net/gm6df3h7p862/642MhWekUf7LM5PNni... [3] [3] https://creastats.crea.ca/en-CA/ https://creastats.crea.ca/en-CA/
- jameslk 3y ago> In many ways, today’s housing market is the polar opposite of the one that preceded the Great Recession. > Back then, reckless mortgage lending helped create a situation where demand became artificially strong. Eventually, it collapsed and the market was left with way too many homes. Yes, and now we have a situation where supply has become artificially weak[0] due to high mortgage rates preventing anyone from selling. That could be corrected if the Fed has to suddenly lower interest rates to prop up some other too big to fail sector, such as commercial real estate or anything else that seems to be teetering as of late. 0. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ACTLISCOUUS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ACTLISCOUUS
- 8note 3y agoThis is a big strength of the Canadian system. You only lock in a certain rate for 5 years
- patrickthebold 3y ago> artificially weak due to high mortgage rates preventing anyone from selling I wonder how much that matters. I agree less people are moving, but typically homeowners who sell will also be buyers, so no net change in availability. I guess some people can afford a second home and they keep the old one and rent it out so they can keep the old mortgage, but that must be small compared to people staying put.
- firesteelrain 3y agoIn our system, housing has to cycle occasionally or you end up with no mobility.
- harambae 3y agoThis is how I think of it as well, the person who isn’t selling is probably one less buyer. What if we change the life necessity to another one — cars. During the pandemic I was thinking about upgrading my car, but I didn’t after prices went up. I’ve just chilled with the same car since 2010 now. So.. did I contribute to the auto shortage that’s on going? Feels kind of weird to look at it that way
- lucidguppy 3y agoHow can we have a housing shortage and a bubble at the same time? The power elite has found out they don't have to build houses and cars in order to make money - just constrain the supply and raise prices. Easy peasy. Remember - the corporations can sit on foreclosed houses for years and not feel any pain. Tell me how the free market solves this?
- applied_heat 3y agoGo Build a house and take advantage of the high prices!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- patrickrafferty 3y agoJust a dumb headline. First, household formation has accelerated dramatically over the last 5 years (see article below). This trend will likely continue, and/or accelerate for many more years. Many of the major homebuilders have seen this coming (e.g. DR Horton). Second, the lost value of office buildings did not merely dissipate - it just follows where people are spending time. Data from Kastle Systems suggests foot traffic back to office is roughly half of what it was pre-covid (40% to 50%). Those hours people are not in an office, they are in homes. If you have a bunch of adults spending ~20 additional hours per week in the home, they will value their homes more. When I was doing appraisal in the aftermath of 08, the buyers driving the speculation looked nothing like the buyers waiting in line today. https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/surge-household-growth-and-what-it-suggests-about-future-housing-demand#:~:text=The%20number%20of%20households%20headed,260%2C000%20additional%20households%20per%20year https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/surge-household-growth-and....
- lepus 3y agoSomething more similar to the 1980s is looking way more likely than the very different scenario we were in during 2008. It's a whole different beast this time and a lot of us are too young to get past our myopic hangup on 08.
- rustyboy 3y agoSo... I should buy a house now despite how "terrible" the market is? 8% interest rates seem like a terrible time to buy. But it sounds like they're going to keep increasing.