7 ms·
It's Time to Tax Billionaires
- janandonly 3y agoI laugh at this idea. Sure it would be nice if possible. But people become billionaires through the art of inheritance and not paying taxes. They tend to excel at both.
- dontreact 3y agoYes it's difficult. I think we should have a pretty high bar for evidence required to decide that this idea is impossible. Because once you decide that it's impossible, then there will be no more evidence collected. I would like to see a wealth tax passed and then evaded and then a follow up to stop the gaps etc. A few cycles of this before deciding it can never be done. I think this is a multi decade effort that is important for the future of all societies.
- sokoloff 3y agoIt will be interesting to see the ruling on Moore v United States* in regards to the adjudicated Constitutionality of a federal tax on unrealized income, the ruling of which has implications for the Constitutionality of a federal tax on wealth. * - https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/moore-v-united-states-3/ https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/moore-v-united-s...
- SoftTalker 3y agoWe already have an inheritance tax why is there an objection to a person being successful during his or her life. Are we saying we'd be better off without Amazon, Google, Meta/Facebook, Microsoft, Apple? All of these companies were built on the vision of one or a small number of founders. They collectively employ hundreds of thousands if not millions of people. You who make six figure salaries slinging javascript would probably not have jobs like that without companies that billionaies built. Would they have bothered or even been able to do it if we taxed away not only their income but also their wealth?
- text0404 3y agoyes, we would probably be better off as a society without those companies (we can say that with certainty for meta _alone_). destabilizing democracy, suicide nets, AI for the "defense" industry, surveillance, misinformation, mass manipulation, adtech, etc. > You who make six figure salaries slinging javascript would probably not have jobs like that without companies that billionaies built. doing something else more productive? your disdain is apparent in this comment, so i'm sure you wouldn't mind it if people who "sling javascript" for six figures find something better to work on. > Would they have bothered or even been able to do it if we taxed away not only their income but also their wealth? do you start every side project with the question, "well how much will i have to pay in taxes when this makes me a billionaire?" most innovation in human history has existed absent a profit motive.
- xyzelement 3y agoBillionaires top of mind for me: Bloomberg, the Google guys, Steve Jobs, Bezos, Dalio, Musk, Gates, Zuckerberg. Many grew up poor (probably Gates & Zuck had the most growing up but not billions) and none of them are famous for building products and companies with impact, not tax evasion.
- avgcorrection 3y agoWhy would an inherited-billionaire be at the top of anyone’s mind?
- xyzelement 3y agoThe post I am responding to made a blanket statement about the group. I don't have a survey[1] of what percentage of billionaires are or aren't self made - so I thought about it, and of the ones available for recall, all were self-made. I assume what the poster talked about exists, but it seems to not be the most obvious case. [1] While replying to you, I did a quick Google and found this link: https://www.chicagobooth.edu/review/billionaires-self-made https://www.chicagobooth.edu/review/billionaires-self-made According to this, what the poster was talking about was more true in the past. ~40 years ago, 60% of billionaires had come from rich families, while 10 years ago (when this article is from) that number was down to 32%. One can presume that this trend continues over the last decade as well. So at least 70% of billionaires are self made, and 20% (according to the same source) come from very poor families. So at the very least, we can say that the post I am replying to is true for at most 30% and is false for 70%.
- avgcorrection 3y ago> The post I am responding to made a blanket statement about the group. I think they can fend for themselves. > I don't have a survey[1] of what percentage of billionaires are or aren't self made - so I thought about it, and of the ones available for recall, all were self-made. I assume what the poster talked about exists, but it seems to not be the most obvious case. Inherited billionaires don’t make for exciting stories. That’s why they aren’t at the top of anyone’s mind. Was the point. But “self-made” can also be loaded: > [1] While replying to you, I did a quick Google and found this link: You’ll see that that he defines certain people like Zuckerberg as not really being “wealthy” but “upper-middle class”. But I guess economists might have a certain bias towards the upper end of the spectrum when they only research wealth and those entities and people who have it.
- sokoloff 3y ago> With effective tax rates equivalent to 0% to 0.5% of their wealth, billionaires are proportionally taxed far less than ordinary citizens. In countries with income taxes but not wealth taxes, that's not surprising and not an indication (to me) of "evasion". But it's a convenient soundbite, despite being misleading in the context of inclusion in a "GLOBAL TAX EVASION REPORT 2024".
- dontreact 3y agoIt is in fact for many people a solid argument for a wealth tax.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> that's not surprising and not an indication (to me) of "evasion" Not directly, but it is indirectly. Overwhelmingly, wealthy people write more (tax) laws than poor people. It's in the wealthy's best interest to help themselves as well as their peers.
- DanHulton 3y agoIncorrect. There should not even _be_ billionaires. It's _long past_ time to tax billionaires. At this point, it may not even be possible.
- bentruyman 3y agoThere really aren't that many billionaires. Most of what we refer to as billionaires are people who have a large equity stake in companies they run. So are we saying once your equity becomes to large you have to start selling shares? People who say this stuff usually have zero clue how money works.
- marnett 3y agoI’m interested why you think most of global billionaires are people with large equity stakes in companies? People who often focus in on just the capitalist entrepreneur sect of the billionaire class often have zero clue how global Class Systems work, and just how many billionaires there are that have never worked an honest day in their lives.
- lkbm 3y agoDo you know of a place with a breakdown? Skimming through the Forbes list, the top ones are pretty much ones I recognize as having been founders, CEOs, and/or early employees of large corporations. As I scroll down the list, there are a lot more that I don't know or believe are merely decedents of those such people, but I still see plenty I recognize as founders or as still running companies. Is it 10%? 50%? 80%? Don't just assert we're clueless without providing some source to show us that we're wrong. Far too often such assertions aren't actually based on anything but vibes, so "just trust me" isn't much good.
- nix0n 3y ago> once your equity becomes to large you have to start selling shares? Yes. If you own over $1B of corporations, you have too much power.
- somethoughts 3y agoMy hot take is that if the Forbes 500 ranking was determined based on verified taxable income and personal taxes paid to the country of primary residence - instead of arbitrary self reported income and self-appraised of property valuations - a lot of stuff would work itself out naturally.
- godelski 3y agoI like this. Because it is both funny and points to the fact that for these people it is more about having a leaderboard score than utility. I mean there's really nothing Musk (or even Gates) could do that say... Gianluigi Aponte (#50) couldn't do. Which really is no different from what Pierre Chen (#500) can do.
- organsnyder 3y agoThat's not quite true. Musk bought one of the largest media platforms in the world and remade it to his whims. There's "fuck you" money, and then there's "fuck everyone" money.
- godelski 3y agoYeah, there's a non-obvious qualifier there. There's definitely things that Musk can do that those people can't. But the number of things that richer person A can do that poorer person B can't do exponentially decreases based on B's net worth, not on A's. So yeah, Pierre Chen is gonna have a hard time buying Twitter but he's still not going to have a hard time buying a mega yacht, multiple million dollar homes, and could start a space company if he wanted to. We're quibbling over some pretty fine nuances here but from technical correctness I agree that you're correct. Just not in the "practical" (for lack of better words) sense. They're approximately equal. Much more equal than, say, between you/me and John Bogle (created Vanguard: net worth ~80m). I'd say there's even a bigger gap between Bogle and Chen than Chen and Musk. However you define value (things, capital, good life, whatever) is not linearly or exponentially tied to monetary wealth, but that's a sublinear function that looks exponential near the origin.
- 3y ago
- chollida1 3y agoThis gets brought up alot, and a few things always tend to spoil it. 1) the world is global, if the US did this then alot of billionaires would suddenly move to Canada. Until the tax code is unified people will chose where to live partially based on taxes. Look at how many people move from Silicon valley to Texas or Washington just before their companies IPO. People will just move to avoid the tax. THere are plenty of countries worth living in that don't have a wealth tax. France found out the hard way. https://www.investorschronicle.co.uk/education/2021/02/11/lessons-from-history-france-s-wealth-tax-did-more-harm-than-good/ https://www.investorschronicle.co.uk/education/2021/02/11/le... 2) Wealth is not as easily measured as people want it to be. And most wealthy put assets inside corporations so not much wealth is held in their name. Can you tax a person for wealth held in a corporation outside of the US? Tax treaties tend to distinguish between hard asset held in a country, factories and real estate and less tangible assets, like stocks, dividends, etc. 3) Right now alot of people complain about being taxed on stock options for illiquid options to begin with. We've all heard horror stories about tech employees having to exercise their options and pay tax on that when they can't actually cash out the shares to help pay the tax burden. How do we tax an employee who holds millions of dollars in illiquid options that are well in the money? And how is that different than taxing someone on the price of a Picasso painting that a billionaire owns but has very little liquidity? If you claim that the billionaire can just sell the painting for what people will pay for it even if its pennies on the dollar, then you can argue so can the tech employee. Someone will always buy your shares for pennies on the dollar if you don't want ot pay the wealth tax.
- gavanwilhite 3y agoThe US is pretty keen to enforce its tax law internationally. If we did a wealth tax, there would be a number of options to limit using movement or citizenship renouncement as an easy out.
- godelski 3y ago> the world is global, if the US did this then alot of billionaires would suddenly move to Canada. Yeah, just like how there are no companies in states with high taxes because raising the corporate tax rate will just cause companies to move and only leave small companies like Google who can't afford to move stuck with the bill. We have a long historical trend of observing people moving to avoid taxes. Just ask Europe with its 0 billionaires.
- irusensei 3y agoIs it me or this is a very low effort “we should have world peace” article that doesn’t bring much to the discussion? > The billions raised could help governments avert oncoming crises like future pandemics and extreme weather events driven by the climate crisis I’m not sure what to say here. I’d approach ideas from people who use incoming doom scenarios as excuses for empowering government very carefully. Almost feels like having Bezos keeping his dollars a better idea.
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoVice News recently declared bankruptcy, which means that their libertarian philosophy has been sold to the highest bidder
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoClose. It was sold to the Saudis
- ianburrell 3y agoThe wealth tax feels to me like "we've tried nothing and we're out of ideas". If we want to tax billionaires, we should start taxing their income. Undoing the tax changes since Reagan would go a long way. If it isn't possible to do that, then it won't be possible to tax wealth. If it doesn't work, then we can consider wealth tax.
- Accujack 3y agoUndoing a lot of what Reagan did is needed. Taxing Billionaires is tricky... they can manipulate data (like anyone else) to show their actual income as 0 dollars. I'm more worried about what would happen to the money thus produced... the US government has been digging itself a large fiscal hole the last 3 years and shows no sign of stopping.
- wenebego 3y agoProblem with taxing income is that they take out debts, paying taxes on the minimum payments, and then pass the assets with stepped up basis to their heirs.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoWhat income? Buy, Borrow, Die. Most of their income is not traditional income. They live in debt because debt isn't taxable.
- dlubarov 3y agoBuy, borrow die relies on the step-up in basis upon death though; it's a bit of a loophole (albeit with some justifications) which could be closed. I tend to agree that the focus should be on closing loopholes before trying an entirely different tax.
- tombert 3y agoDo billionaires make income? Don't most of them just have absurd quantities of stock in a valuable company that grows to an absurd value, and instead of selling it they just borrow against it? Stock (at least in the US) has traditionally not been taxed until sold. EDIT: Ah, I just saw that HumblyTossed made the same point I did; I should have read the other comments.
- dmitrygr 3y ago> With effective tax rates equivalent to 0% to 0.5% of their wealth, We do not tax wealth, we tax income, so this is complete nonsense.
- gwenzek 3y agoWhy do we tax income though? Especially for billionaire in a globalized world, it's easy to hide incomes. Wealth is harder to hide.
- dmitrygr 3y agoI am not arguing that taxing income or wealth is right or wrong. Only that given how current taxes CURRENTLY work, TFA's controlled outrage is idiotic.
- alxmng 3y agoI cannot understand taxation for the sake of taxation. The purpose of taxation is to divert those funds to pay for something. "We want to fund a new healthcare program, so we are going to pay for it by an increase in taxes" makes sense. "We want to tax billionaires because they should pay more tax" does not make any sense.
- tombert 3y agoI don't think that's actually true since the 70s with the introduction of modern monetary theory. If I understand that correctly, taxes serve effectively as a means of decreasing wealth disparity, subtracting money out of the economy, and ensuring that a minimal level of work gets done. They are not a means of paying for things, at least at the federal level. At the state level, where they don't control the money supply, I think it might matter more. I know that MMT is a bit controversial in economic circles, and I am very much not an economist, but that's my understanding.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- worik 3y agoMMT is mostly magical thinking There is an element of truth
- tombert 3y agoI'll admit that I'm getting my lay-person's understanding of it from "The Deficit Myth" by Stephanie Kelton, who is a real economist but I have no idea how respected she is in the fields of economics.
- munificent 3y ago> The purpose of taxation is to divert those funds to pay for something. That is a purpose of it. But another use of taxation is to act as a counter-balance against the natural property that power is self-reinforcing: When you're rich, that gives the power to increase your wealth. And as that system iterates over time, inequality increases. I think it would be a better world if we taxed the rich more even if we just straight up burned the money. But, also, you can do useful stuff with the money. If nothing else, you can use it to lower taxes on everyone else.
- nickdothutton 3y agoDuring the Roman Empire, taxes collected by the regime were as high as 1%, soaring to a dizzying 3% in times of war. Tax collectors were so detested for gathering these kinds of sums that they were often murdered.
- foota 3y agoThe roman empire also relied heavily on slave labor from captured territories and gifts from the wealthy.
- Zetobal 3y ago...and spoils of war. If you were a pleb you paid your taxes in blood.
- foota 3y ago... Was that a pun? I read this as the modern usage of plebian and only now realized it might not be what you meant lol. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plebeians https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plebeians
- knodi 3y agoI like what Bernie Sanders says: income over $1 billion should be taxed at 100%.
- m3kw9 3y agothey are taxed already is just the rules are too lax and they are too good at avoiding so you need unescapable rules. Example, taxing based on NW increases. which reminds me how difficult it is to create a good rule because taxing based on networth increases could be a purposeful way a country is trying to stifle their own economy and allowing other countries that doesn’t have these rules let their companies grow bigger and faster.
- dadjoker 3y agoGovernments could also stop taxing the crap out of the middle and lower classes, but that would require them to stop spending like drunken sailors, but when you operate under the idea that government is the provider of rights and everything else citizens need, this is what you get.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- strangesmells02 3y agoThe United States makes an astounding amount of money in taxes already. Why isn't the emphasis on using the current tax dollars more efficiently? Every government institution that I have been a part of has massive amounts of waste and not on a small scale either..but on a large scale. universities, scientific research labs, government grants, defense industry, bailing out banks who gamble with client money, etc. They lost billions in Iraq. No one knows where it went. We're giving billions to Ukraine with zero strategic interest to the United States. Bills pass constantly in Congress with funding riders that have absolutely nothing to do with the bill itself. We don't need more taxes in America. We need some accountability for where our current money taken in taxes is being allocated.
- jvanderbot 3y agoTwo competing partial solutions to fiscal health? Why not both.
- strangesmells02 3y agoI don't know whats a more intractable problem making the government more efficient or taxing "wealth". I'm open to both but my gut instinct tells me that there would be less unintended side effects by just making the government more efficient. However, I can imagine massive problems trying to do either.
- tomohelix 3y agoLess side effects. But also much harder to implement. Especially when the people with the power to change things are incentivized not to change it. So let just settle for the next best thing while we ride this clown show for as long as it can last. Because let be honest, the US gov is still doing an OK job compared to some truly dysfunctional ones out there. Not many Americans are dying to emigrate yet.
- strangesmells02 3y agoI think people come here despite the government. If they wanted a good government they would move to some country in Europe which pays slightly more taxes but they get way more value for it. I don't think the US government is doing a good job at all for the amount of taxes we pay.
- anononaut 3y agoI'd rather see elimination of income tax and any other direct, tangible theft of earnings to the rest of us. The lines between billionaires, megacorps, banks, and politicians are blurry. I don't trust them to tax themselves fairly. Just start removing the needless taxes for those that are obviously impacted by it. While we're at it, end the Fed.
- NoboruWataya 3y ago> There are around 2,500 billionaires in the world right now, with a combined wealth of over £10 trillion. Just a fraction of that money is enough to, say, end global poverty, eradicate malaria and re-freeze the Arctic. Does anyone know if any of these claims (about what we could do with a fraction of £10 trillion) are remotely true? I highly doubt we could come close to ending global poverty by simply throwing £10 trillion at the problem. Re-freezing the Arctic also seems technically infeasible but I don't know much about it. Eradicating malaria sounds somewhat more realistic I guess?
- anononaut 3y agoThey're sensationalist claims. Global poverty, hunger, etc. aren't zero sum games we could win if we just had enough players to give up their equity. There are logistical impossibilities blocking humanity from these types of solutions.
- worik 3y ago> I highly doubt we could come close to ending global poverty by simply throwing £10 trillion at the problem That isobviously true But we could make a huge dent in poverty in countries with functioning civil society. Cash does not completely end poverty but it ameliorates the worst of it. The best examples I know of are in India and Brazil Redistributing money is very effective
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lux 3y agoIt always blows my mind seeing a post like this on HN and the top comments nitpick whether such a tax is needed. These people don't need defending and they don't need that much money (for comparison, this was posted on here the other day and really illustrates the disparity quite well: https://mkorostoff.github.io/1-pixel-wealth/ https://mkorostoff.github.io/1-pixel-wealth/). The reasons for taxing them (including a flat rate on their net worth which would be a terrible way to tax people in lower income brackets but could be a great way to level things off at the top end where avoidance is rampant) are many: funding climate change reversal, poverty, health, housing, medical research, the list goes on. We don't need more pedants splitting hairs about how to more effectively use the existing tax revenues. That is a distraction. We should do that too, but we should absolutely tax the hell out of the billionaire class who have been taking more than their fair share from our resources for decades and living at the expense of all of our futures.
- Julesman 3y agoYeah, it's ahistorical. Some of these comments are soooo confident and condescending while ignoring basic history. Many high school kids know that the tax rate has gone down dramatically for the past 40 years. Turning that around even a little isn't some kind of hyper-leftist agenda. Like, is it really that radical to dial it back to where Reagan left it?
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThat itself is an ahistorical take. Tax as a percent of the economy has gone through the roof, both as a percent of GDP, and as inflation adjusted dollars. If you compare to a benchmark like the 1940s, tax% of GDP has more than doubled, and GDP has increased ~4x. This means someone today taxes are about 10X the taxes (controlling for for inflation!) Consider that 40% of US GDP now is collected in some form of taxation.[1] 40 cents of every dollar earned is taxed and spent as the government chooses. This is more than between FDR and Regan, and much more than the 20s (~15% of GDP). https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/37/Federal%2C_state%2C_and_local_tax_revenue_as_a_percent_of_GDP.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/37/Federal%...
- HissingMachine 3y agoIt's time to stop populist drivel like this, if this was just a political decision that was easy to implement and had only positive impacts, it would have been done decades ago, but just like "let's end crime" and "end hunger" this is just another populist political message to basically lie to people and I'm fed with this stuff. Truth truly took the back seat in the past decade.
- virtuous_sloth 3y ago"It's Time to Tax Billionaires Out of Existence (vice.com)" There, FTFY.
- brocklobsta 3y agoI think the better question is, Which entity can better allocate the capital? The government or the billionaire? Given the historic track record of government spending I would argue the we are much better with the capital staying in the private sector. As a bonus, if capital is grossly misallocated in the private sector, the company may go out of business, and those resources are freed up the the highest bidder. When the government grossly misallocates resources, the burden falls on the tax payer and rarely gets fixed in any reasonable time horizon.
- worik 3y ago> Given the historic track record of government spending Building schools Building hospitals Building infrastructure Police Parks The post office for you Americans in the USA
- nickpp 3y agoNow do private investments: everything else. Every single object and service I use or interact with every day. From the clothes on my back and food on my plate to the house sheltering me, furnace heating me, car carrying me and the computer helping me earn a living. Would you like to compare ROIs?
- anononaut 3y agoI agree with the sentiment, but it's a little too optimistic to presume tax payer foots the bill only for public sector endeavors. The huge financial industry bailouts weren't even that long ago! Private over public, but there should be no "too big to fail" and no cartels.
- spigottoday 3y agoSeems to me that half of government spending winds up in billionaires pockets. Nice work if you can get it.
- simonh 3y agoReading this you would think billionaires are all sitting is swimming pools full of money like Scrooge McDuck. The vast majority of these assets are in the form of the ownership of companies. The only way to unlock that wealth is to force sale of these assets. This raises several question. Who should control these companies. Government? Now politicians and civil servants are running your economy. Plus you don’t actually get any extra public revenue to spend on anything. You just confiscate industries you now have to operate. So ok, let’s sell these shareholdings. To who? If we’re ending large scale private wealth, where are the buyers? I suppose you might dilute ownership to more private capital but is that actually better? You’re just arbitrarily changing ownership. Seizing one persons assets and selling it to someone else. Some of those people will do better at it that others and what do you know, we’ve got billionaires again. Except now they know you’re going to take their assets off them. What effect will that have on stock prices, investor confidence, entrepreneurship? I don’t think this has been thought through very well. Or at all. The way to fix taxation is to, er, fix the tax system.
- southernplaces7 3y agoWhile rich people avoid taxes all the time and many of them outright evade them illegally, the focus of narrative entirely on how this causes public finance problems is a joke. Modern states, especially large modern states, annually obtain absolutely gargantuan amounts of money and spend gargantuan amounts of money on all sorts of projects that very, very often are at best of dubious value and in all cases often managed in ways that make them far more expensive than they could be. Other vast amounts of that state spending are even outright destructive or purely criminal, with hundreds of billions per year going to military campaigns or support for different interests that are entirely motivated by power games. Why should all this never be profoundly questioned? Why should it never be strongly questioned why a major state like the U.S. with an annual budget in the multiple trillions, which regularly spends hundreds of billions on absolute black holes of public finance, might not trim or change some of that spending? At the same time placing all fashionable NGO and media focus on the far smaller amounts evaded by billionaires is nearly absurd in how unbalanced it has become, but then, they're easy whipping boys (and girls). Even if you took all the wealth -not income or revenue but total wealth- in all known forms from all of the world's 2,688 known billionaires right now and applied it to public spending, its totality would barely cover the annual budget of the U.S. alone for more than 2 years. It would cover only a tiny fraction of the total pending outlay of the U.S. National Debt. Again, this is just as the above applies to one country. Yet, it's the billionaires (and i'm no fan of them in many, many ways) that should be the explicit focus because of their tax avoidance schemes? I'd say that far larger issues exist with the sheer size of modern state spending, along with its scope and management problems.
- wdr1 3y ago> There are around 2,500 billionaires in the world right now, with a combined wealth of over £10 trillion. Just a fraction of that money is enough to, say, end global poverty, eradicate malaria and re-freeze the Arctic. The US Federal government alone collected $4.4 trillion in 2023. I'd have more confidence in statements like that if existing revenues were used to solve any one of the issues stated.
- amai 3y agoI‘m in favor of an income tax which gets higher the more wealth you have already accumulated: https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/9421/why-not-have-a-wealth-dependent-income-tax https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/9421/why-not-ha...