6 ms·
The site in question: https://anti-israel-employee.co.il https://anti-israel-employee.co.il Two of the posts on the website that flags a "anti-Israeli" / "terr
by diggan 3y ago
The site in question: https://anti-israel-employee.co.il https://anti-israel-employee.co.il
Two of the posts on the website that flags a "anti-Israeli" / "terrorist supporter" person:
> I know this is a professional plattform but we are human .. and you don't have to be a Muslim to support Palestine, you just have to be a human being. #SaveHumanity #SavePalestine
> Praise and thank the Lord. #betterlatethannever #savethechildren #prayforGaza #prayforpeace
Is this what counts as "terrorist" supporter these days?
Overall I agree with you, people should be shamed for any sort of support of terrorists, no question about it.
But this seems to be something else, it seems to be flagging "anti-Israel" sentiment, which seems to include a lot more than just anti-Zionism.
- vkou 3y ago> Is this what counts as "terrorist" supporter these days? Yes, in many mainstream circles. It's absolutely insane. The world goes insane every time this 75-year war gets front-page billing.
- isykt 3y agoThose of us who came of age during the "War on Terror" are feeling a distinct sense of deja vu.
- underseacables 3y agoI would agree with you that it is wrong. Just because someone disagrees with Israel, or calls Israel out for actions that it has committed, is not the same as terrorism or making a threat. It's a really fine line, and I think regrettably that it moves with the political climate.
- alephnerd 3y agoThe issue is foreign commentators can do it in an unneccesarily divisive manner that causes blowback. Plenty of Israeli Arabs (eg. A few who directly report to me) have denounced Hamas on LinkedIn but also voiced public criticism to the heavy-handed response that the IDF is doing. Heck, several of the survivors from the Nova Music festival were saved by Bedouin nearby, and plenty of the ongoing shelling in the North is impacting Israeli Arabs. Heck, a Chechen/Circassian mosque was hit by a Hamas rocket. Western commentators are making it a black-and-white issue where you either support the Palestinian cause or the Israeli cause with no middle. The 2nd/3rd/Nth generation Jewish and Arab diaspora have both been posting some vile comments about the other.
- colpabar 3y ago> Western commentators are making it a black-and-white issue where you either support the Palestinian cause or the Israeli cause with no middle. I think you are being too charitable. From what I have seen, it's "you either support the Israeli cause or you are a terrorist who hates freedom." All we need now is a war criminal republican president for democrats to loudly criticize yet support at every opportunity to invade a country that had nothing to do with the attacks and it'll be just like the early 2000s again.
- alephnerd 3y agoIt goes both ways. I've seen some toxic douchebags say that the only good Palestinian is a dead Palestinian. I've also had some douchebags PERSONALLY tell me "From river to sea, Palestine will be free" under the assumption that as a brown guy I'd sympathize. Everyone is in their own damn echo chamber and yelling across of each other. Assholes on sides need to get fucking slapped.
- SauciestGNU 3y agoThis is the problem though, you're equating the wish for an end to the occupation of Palestine with an explicit call for genocide. The two are not equivalent.
- pauldenton 3y agoI don't know what you mean. The Palestinians want to kill Israelis and the Israelis want to kill the Palestinians. Expelling Jews from the river to the sea means all the territory that is currently Israel becoming no longer a Jewish state. Israel may very well deconstruct Gaza so it's no longer a state as well. Equal things at stake
- CaptainNegative 3y ago> ... and you don't have to be a Muslim to support Palestine, you just have to be a human being One can support innocent Palestinians without supporting Palestine, the same way one can support innocent Israelis without supporting Israel. Not sure why they decided to sneak in some dehumanization into what masquerades as a positive sentiment.
- TrinaryWorksToo 3y agoIt's also not so great a leap to think that supporting a country means supporting its citizens. Your interpretation is valid, I don't understand why it would need heavy moderation. Perhaps hiding the post and asking it to reword it to be clearer?
- unmole 3y ago> Not sure why they decided to sneak in some dehumanization into what masquerades as a positive sentiment. Yeah, no. That's meant as an appeal to humanity beyond tribal solidarity. Reading dehumanization into it is a bit much.
- CaptainNegative 3y agoHow do you read that other than as "if you have humanity, you support Palestine", which is semantically equivalent to "if you don't support Palestine, you have no humanity"?
- hanniabu 3y ago> Is this what counts as "terrorist" supporter these days? Yes, when you're standing in the way of Israel and US ravaging a country by supporting those people, you are a terrorist.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> > Praise and thank the Lord. #betterlatethannever #savethechildren #prayforGaza #prayforpeace > Is this what counts as "terrorist" supporter these days? Does "better late than never" refer to Hamas's attack on Israel, where they killed roughly a thousand people? If not, what does it refer to? Does "Praise and thank the Lord" refer to the same thing? If you're praising God for that, you may not be a terrorist "supporter", but you're certainly a terrorist cheerleader and advocate. And if you are referring to that, and saying "pray for peace" on the same line? Then your hypocrisy is nauseating. All this is based on my interpretation of "better late than never". If I'm interpreting it wrongly, please clue me in as to what it actually means.
- justin66 3y agoIf you have to puzzle out the meaning of a hashtag maybe you're not dealing with the kind of terrorist threat that should be censored.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoI can accept that... provided it applies on all sides. It means you can't say "that's a dogwhistle" when the far right says something that is not overtly racist. (Or at least, you can't expect "that's a dogwhistle" to result in them being censored/deplatformed/whatever.)
- justin66 3y agoI'd reject the notion that a hashtag you don't understand and feel inclined to question alongside a bunch of hashtags with an obviously positive meaning is equivalent to racist dogwhistling. Given the positive context of the hashtag it seems possible "better late than never" refers to the trucks carrying aid finally rolling, the freeing of hostages, or some other positive thing. It's not strongly associated with much of anything that's trending on twitter. A person with doubts about that commenter's intent would seek out greater context in the poster's other comments, I would think.
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago
- crabbone 3y ago> Is this what counts as "terrorist" supporter. Well, yes. Here's how. People who make arguments for "good Palestinians unrelated to Hamas" and for "ceasefire", against "humanitarian disaster" all very obviously blame Israel for harming those "good Palestinians" and not stopping firing etc. Which definitely helps Hamas and doesn't Help any Palestinians, nor Israelis. For the most part it's just stupidity of people uninvolved with the conflict who found it easy to believe a story of oppression by a superior military / economical power. This is also what pushes the idea of "Hamas not representing Palestinians". While, unfortunately, it does. But every Western society rejects this grim reality. Because admitting it would lead to asking very inconvenient questions, revision of previously established policies... basically, admitting to being stupid and being manipulated by some "Nigerian prince". Here's one example. Every political / military organization which wants to kill all Jews and establish Palestine "from the river to the sea" tries to legitimize this claim by appealing to UN's charter that warrants every nation the right to rule over themselves. In the case with Israel, there's what appears to be a conflicting resolution from the UN legitimizing Israeli state. While UN finds time to condemn Israel on a monthly basis, it could never find time to resolve this dispute. They'd have to go back and revisit this claim about every nation being able to rule themselves, amend it with some cases where that doesn't apply... but they are happy to sit on their hands, and the conflict keeps going. UNRWA is the same story: bad decision that keeps fueling the hatred, but UN will never admit they did something stupid, and will never reverse their decisions. So, back to blaming humanitarian disaster on Israel: Israel is as much responsible for the humanitarian disaster as the world's oceans are responsible for the rising sea level. Israel is playing its hand the best they can. But, they aren't the reason civilians are dying in Gaza. No more than gravity or the engineers who designed fighter jets. So, why is it surprising that Israel doesn't want to hear itself blamed for something that had no influence over? They are facing the same media device that's used by Americans who claim that "blue lives matter" -- a superficially innocent claim that, out of context could just mean that someone wants to support the police doing quite dangerous job, while, in reality, it's a reactionary stance that's meant to counteract the other sentiment: "black lives matter", instead of being used to actually help the police. People behind the tag of "SavePalestine" don't really want to save Palestine. They are manipulating public sentiment to be against Israel. Had they really want to save Palestine, they'd be appealing to the UN to cancel UNRWA, to work with Israel in declaring Gaza a "failed state", preventing Gaza from having its own government, military, courts etc. instead having some form of international government, blue helmets etc. take control for the next 3-5 decades at least.
- grumple 3y agoI didn't really want to engage on HN as I think this whole post doesn't belong here (politically charged content is something this site generally avoids), but I will highlight the issue here. If you jump in to advocate support of Palestinians / Gaza, but didn't express any support for Israelis / Israel when Hamas (the elected and still popular government of Gaza) murdered over 1000 civilians, you're not an unbiased supporter that just wants peace. You have ignored the catalyst of the current episode of this conflict, which was an incredibly, obviously evil act against Israeli and foreign civilians, by Hamas, and widely celebrated in Gaza. The worldwide attacks on Jews and synagogues, the chants of "Gas the Jews" and "From the River to the Sea" (which is a call for genocide of Israelis), the open calls from Palestinian terrorist groups calling for attacks on Jews worldwide, make it clear that antizionism is inextricably linked with antisemitism (as does the actual history of the conflict).
- LindeBuzoGray 3y ago> Hamas (the elected and still popular government of Gaza) murdered over 1000 civilians Israel killed over 1000 Palestinians from 2018 until before Operation al-Aqsa Flood. There's nothing really unusual about it from.that context. And Israel us currently massacring civilians in Gaza every day. > the catalyst of the current episode of this conflict Israelis murdered people on an aid flotilla a few years ago, and are evicting West Bank Palestinians from their homes with settlers, as the Israelis parade around the al-Aqsa mosque.
- grumple 3y ago> Israel killed over 1000 Palestinians from 2018 until before Operation al-Aqsa Flood. There's nothing really unusual about it from.that context. And Israel us currently massacring civilians in Gaza every day. Hamas makes no distinction between their soldiers and civilians deaths. And given their blatant lies about the supposed IDF attack on a hospital this week (actually caused by a Palestinian rocket which failed) and impossibly high and fast death count, and the whole being a terrorist organization, they can't be trusted. Israel attempts to avoid civilians casualties via roof knocks and phone messages. The only exceptions here tend to be people storming the border. You are comparing that against designed, intentional murder, rape, and torture of civilians by Hamas. > Israelis murdered people on an aid flotilla a few years ago, and are evicting West Bank Palestinians from their homes with settlers, as the Israelis parade around the al-Aqsa mosque. That flotilla was trying to break a blockade and had been warned against it. When the ships were boarded, there was violent resistance, which resulted in some of the fighters being killed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_flotilla_raid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_flotilla_raid Evicting Palestinians from their homes in the West Bank is obviously vile behavior. It's hard to get a liberal government elected in Israel to stop it given the state of the conflict. About the mosque: It was the holiest site in Judaism for a thousand years before Islam existed.