6 ms·
Good. But this will keep festering until it is killed for sure. And even then they will just rehash it in a different form and push it again. The problem is a
by wkat4242 3y ago
Good. But this will keep festering until it is killed for sure.
And even then they will just rehash it in a different form and push it again.
The problem is also, this won't work. The pervs will simply use something else, prompting even stronger regulation to avoid having unapproved apps etc. Meanwhile we will all live in a panopticon society for no tangible benefits. In the end it could even kill FOSS and open computing because anyone who can edit the code can edit out the spyware.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoThe EU is already planning to make that happen through the Cyber Resilience Act[1], which imposes unreasonable constraints and litigation risks for FOSS users unless certified. [1] https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/cyber-resilience-act https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/cyber-resi...
- raxxorraxor 3y agoThe EU tries really hard to kill any innovation in Europe at the source. But this is even worse than that. It would allow for dubious security resellers to define adequate protections. That would basically be their own products. Everyone in IT knows that there are borderline dubious products that heavily border scam. Not every security solution of course, but there is a lot of bad sheep that present as much a danger to security as direct attacks. If you want to protect user data, don't collect it. Best security you can achieve. Perhaps I am overanalyzing and this just tries to introduce formal processes to deal with security concerns. But it doesn't look like it. It seems you need a third party to certify your products for once and I believe this is lobbying for questionable security products and lawyers in one go.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> The EU tries really hard to kill any innovation This trope is getting tedious. The EU tries to regulate the Wild West that the internet opened up. That's not at all the same as "killing innovation". It's reasonable and realistic to try to regulate. I'm fearful of attempts to regulate the internet, because there are strong forces that want to load the regulations with provisions that would be a dictator's wet dream. But to my mind, unregulated everything is a nightmare.
- wkat4242 3y agoUnregulated everything does lead to 'enshittification' yes. Because when there is no legal framework the only guideline is profit, nothing else. Some stuff the EU does is really good, like the GDPR, the right to be forgotten, the right to repair (smartphones with replaceable batteries and standard USB connectors). I don't even think it kills innovation. It just makes sure it is aligned with society. But at the same time they do things like this....
- nickpp 3y agoGDPR: clicking cookie banners till the end of time while any ad-supported startup this side of the pond died or jumped ship to the US. Right to be forgotten: a blessing for corrupt EU politicians who can finally scrub their record clean after buying out newspapers. Since they couldn’t buy the tech gigants… USB-C: the largest cable throwaway to avoid… throwing cables away. Replaceable batteries: something I never needed or wanted but hey, the wise Brussels regulators must know better what is good for me.
- janosdebugs 3y agoI made use of the right to be forgotten extensively, thank you. Before that most accounts were undeletable.
- nickpp 3y agoI am happy for you. Now, what do you think, was the ability for you to delete accounts worth the fact that the mayor of my town keeps winning elections in spite countless corruption charges and scandals - all conveniently wiped off the internet? Regulations are usually well intended but second order effects are rarely thought out at all.
- janosd 3y agoCorrupt politicians win elections in non-GDPR countries a whole lot too, unfortunately. I'm no political scientist, but I think it has a lot to do with people being unwilling to learn about and engage with the political system, among others. I live in Austria and when it comes to more complicated topics soch as politics, or IT for example, people are outright proud to claim ignorance. Most people actually don't know that they can and should write their EU MEPs. I have, and I have gotten into very fruitful conversations with them. However, instead of asking our kids to know institution names by heart, maybe asking them to engage with the system would be a good start. Also, if I were into social studies, I'd look at social media and how they drive outrage, and a good way to show kids how such an influence operation works so they don't fall for it. My wife and I have been a little active in this area, but way too little to make any meaningful difference, unfortunately.
- rdm_blackhole 3y agoThe EU does not understand that the world runs on FOSS.
- janosdebugs 3y agoDo politicians elsewhere?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- janosdebugs 3y agoI have to say, I recently got a push into the direction of agreeing with "the EU" a whole lot. The CNCF was organizing a "security slam" where they surveyed CNCF project users what they would want for security compliance in the projects. See one such post here [1]. As you can see, we got some high profile users: Epic Games, the Space Force, and I personally know of two household name telcos who use it. I asked the organizers about potential funding for the work that needed to be done since the project wasn't a commercial endeavour for us. They didn't even consider this before making demands for work that would consume several days if not weeks. The funding they had amounted to some gift cards and t-shirts. (They are very nice people, but there is not much they can do either.) I am personally very frustrated with FOSS as it stands today. It's disingenuous: either the project is almost unusable on its own and you need to buy services from the people creating it (Kubernetes), it's missing parts you need, you get a pseudo-OSS license (BSL), sometimes funded by a foundation that has to do a whole lot of extra work to get donations and more often than not pays entry-level salaries or you run a project because you love doing it where you are expected to do the compliance work ... Why exactly? And about 95% of the changes requested are basically paperwork to check off the boxes, ship material of bills, etc. Not the fun kind of problems. (Note: the CNCF doesn't pay its contributors anything, at least I didn't get a dime so far. The only thing I got was a truckload of paperwork, requests for more free work besides the project reviewing conference submissions for KubeCon, and more.) I think, if you are a commercial FOSS user you should absolutely be on the hook for getting your wallet out and paying for people doing the ridiculous about of slog required for compliance. Pay a foundation for the compliance work, or hire the people working on the project to get it done. Does the EU get it right? No clue, but something has to be done. Supply chain security is important and the work needs doing, which somebody has to pay for. [1] https://github.com/orgs/ContainerSSH/discussions/574#discussion-5709118 https://github.com/orgs/ContainerSSH/discussions/574#discuss...
- akavel 3y agoUm, the very website you linked to seems to contain the following fragment: "(...) except for specified exclusions such as open-source software (...)" - wouldn't this mean that FOSS is specifically not at risk??? edit: Even going further through the links, then searching for "open" in the actual text of the document (https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:52022PC0454 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...) gave me the following: "In order not to hamper innovation or research, free and open-source software developed or supplied outside the course of a commercial activity should not be covered by this Regulation. This is in particular the case for software, including its source code and modified versions, that is openly shared and freely accessible, usable, modifiable and redistributable. In the context of software, a commercial activity might be characterized not only by charging a price for a product, but also by charging a price for technical support services, by providing a software platform through which the manufacturer monetises other services, or by the use of personal data for reasons other than exclusively for improving the security, compatibility or interoperability of the software."
- Aerroon 3y agoThe explanation at the end says that none of the large open source software projects would fall under the umbrella of open source software because somebody is making money off of it some way.
- proprietario 3y agoBut this is exactly the point (which I think is good). This whole thing is applicable if you produce software commercially, regardless if OSS or not I read it as this: In effect, if you make money of the software you destribute you are responsible to address security issues I hope that this is a change for the better. Now everyone who piggy-backed on some OSS project so far has to either maintain a fork (-> more contributions) or provide incentive for the dev to fix it (money?)