7 ms·
Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G turns off
- diyftw 3y agoJust dealt with this in the US. And what did they replace it with? A "4G" meter. So, what, about 8 years worth of functionality before that tech is turned off and yet another few million pieces of e-waste are generated?
- HPsquared 3y agoWho pays to replace them?
- fsflover 3y agoAnd who pays to recycle all the e-waste?
- bayindirh 3y agoYou. The catch is it's burned, not recycled.
- sokoloff 3y agoYou do. It’s hidden in that the power company picks up the initial tab, but don’t let that confuse you into thinking that money doesn’t eventually come out of your pocket.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe same is true from the human employees who'd wander around your neighborhood knocking on doors to do a manual read, though.
- mnw21cam 3y agoHa! Good joke. These days they just send out letters asking the customer to read the meter instead. First time I got one of those, I was thinking "What? No, that's your job. Don't I pay you for that?"
- abofh 3y agoMost of the world reports their meters regularly to get accurate measures - the company still sends someone out every 6-12 months to true up. You're free to lie or ignore it, but the bill will come due just the same.
- bombcar 3y agoMany of them don’t even need to be directly read - they have a little sensor that can be read from nearby, sometimes even just by a utility truck driving by.
- ceejayoz 3y agoSomeone other than you has to read it once in a while; every 3-12 months most likely. I report mine (via SMS) so I don't get a surprise bill (or find I've been giving them a six month interest-free loan) when the estimated use and the actual use differ.
- iggldiggl 3y ago> Someone other than you has to read it once in a while; every 3-12 months most likely. Not here. I assume that as long as your consumption figures aren't wildly implausible, they just leave you alone. You can voluntarily upload a picture of your meter while submitting the reading, but I've never bothered and they've never requested it. Probably there are random spot checks, but personally I've never been subjected to one of those. They might also catch you when the meter finally gets replaced at some point, but power meters seem to be relatively long-lived, so they probably won't rely on that alone.
- jojobas 3y agoOne could mandate a modular design so that the communication pcb could be replaced, i.e. less e-waste. I wonder if smart meter manufacturers stay in business long enough for it to matter.
- bayindirh 3y agoThe one I saw used BT4.2 to talk with the meter, and cellular network to push data to cloud (IIRC). The video is at https://youtu.be/G32NYQpvy8Q?si=YjQfnY9Ag7YUGJAd https://youtu.be/G32NYQpvy8Q?si=YjQfnY9Ag7YUGJAd
- Haemm0r 3y agoOur local suppliers smart meters communicate over the grid (provided the next substation with a beacon is near enough).
- raverbashing 3y agoI'm not sure how modular they are, if they're just replacing a transmitter or something, I've seen some places transmitting only locally (zigbee or other) then a module on the street syncing upstream But let's say even $500 (it's probably cheaper) for something that lasts 8 years is still much cheaper than sending people to get the readings
- phaer 3y ago> But let's say even $500 (it's probably cheaper) for something that lasts 8 years is still much cheaper than sending people to get the readings Probably true, but only as long as one can continue to externalize the cost of handling the resulting e-waste to future generations or at least current-day taxpayers.
- xxs 3y ago"e-waste" is, unfortunately, mostly a term used to deflect from the real issues with all the garbage produced. Shipping and installing the meters likely generates more waste than producing the meters, themselves.
- matt_kantor 3y agoI don't get it. Wasn't the cost of sending people to get readings externalized also?
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoIt was paid for out of your monthly bill.
- matt_kantor 3y agoRight, but that's also the case for the cost of handling the resulting e-waste. Maybe they meant "externalize" in the "externalities" sense—environmental damage, etc? If so that makes some sense, but for a full accounting you'd have to compare that to the externalities caused by all the people driving around to take readings (tailpipe emissions, adding to traffic, etc).
- coldtea 3y agoNobody cares about e-waste. If they did companies would stop producing new products at breakneck speed and consumers would stop buying them. Instead they care about the optics, so you get the ocassional Apple video about how they replaced foo material with bar, while creating not servicable BS - oh, and things like paper straws. Recycling is also mostly BS (things in the "recycle" bins just end in landfills abroad). So this is just another drop in the huge ever increasing pile.
- yterdy 3y agoNobody with money cares about e-waste. Those of us on a tight budget value our devices and lament the difficulty of repair. My phone is 6 years old, and I'm hoping to be able to pay someone to replace the screen and battery at some point (knock on wood). I specifically bought a gaming laptop to replace my hoity-toity Surface-with-the-dead-battery-base, thinking it would be easier to repair. Come charge port issues, I happily tear it down only to find that it's soldered in (my 2008 HP laptop did not have this problem). Even when consumers are forced by circumstances to reduce, and make efforts to reuse, companies essentilly force recycle (which, as you said, is essentially "trash").
- coldtea 3y ago>Nobody with money cares about e-waste. Those of us on a tight budget value our devices and lament the difficulty of repair. People on a tight budget are more concerned about the budget impact of repairability far more than the waste too (which makes sense). And the hundreds of millions with not so tight budget, still buy all kinds of crap, like "fast fashion" and the latest gadgetry.
- yterdy 3y agoI disagree. The difficulty of replacing tech changes one's relationship to one's devices. Things that I see people throw away as "e-waste" are really, "Things someone couldn't be assed to repair or repurpose." For example, broken TVs could be repurposed as large light panels (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JrqH2oOTK4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JrqH2oOTK4), or their main boards could be hacked for fun and profit (https://hackaday.com/2022/11/14/a-single-board-computer-from-a-tv/ https://hackaday.com/2022/11/14/a-single-board-computer-from...). When I see a broken TV, even one I don't own, that's where the pain comes from. Same with phones, laptops, etc. We throw away so mny perfectly good general-purpose computers, it's insane. When we run out of a necessary resource for their manufacture, will we just be scavenging them?
- Garvi 3y ago> and yet another few million pieces of e-waste are generated That's money generated while the e-waste is not factored in. I know I'm stating the obvious. But it's a problem with being realistic, as you start seeing idiosyncrasies everywhere: I run my household on 4g as I can reach realistic speeds of 100Mb/s. Theoretically that goes up to 150Mb/s. A 4k stream (compressed without visual loss) requires 15Mb/s. So 10 people in a household could simultaneously watch 4k content. Did I fail at math? Why does anyone need 5g? What for?
- hotpotamus 3y agoI felt the same way during the 5G hype phase. There were all kinds of sales pitches about how it would enable new applications, but I never really got what more bandwidth was supposed to accomplish.
- bombcar 3y ago5G boils down to “cell phones will continue to work in dense cities” and not really anything consumers care about beyond that.
- rcxdude 3y agoWell, ironically, 5g is much better designed for such small devices to connect to the cell network: it can support lower-power devices and they take a lot less network resources. 5G is an infrastructure upgrade more than a consumer upgrade (consumer benefit is incidental: the network is less congested, especially in denser areas)
- bonton89 3y agoBasically it is so your smart TV can upload all your watch information without getting you to cough up your wifi password. Soon when you buy a toilet seat it will have a 5G modem in it and upload your bowel movement information to the cloud automatically. The possibilities are endless.
- andmarios 3y ago
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoI'm dealing with this in a slightly different context right now - installing cellular remote access/VPN appliances in industrial manufacturing equipment. The equipment is required to have a lifespan of at least 10 years. Our adjacent equipment regularly lasts double that. Some of the equipment is built around castings and transformers that are 4-10x that age. But they also want me to be able to dial into the equipment later, and won't give me WAN access. But no cellular vendor in their right mind will certify that the adjoining towers will have any particular frequency available for more than ~5 years, typically limiting it to a warranty of 3 years. This isn't the only pain point - what about the licensing server that the proprietary IDE for the PLC calls out to? The operating system on which said IDE is installed? Security protocols on the SCADA uplink? Replacement parts and critical spares? Good luck! Unfortunately, a huge amount of industry is effectively subsidized by breakneck investment in consumer smartphones, automotive, and PC equipment. People don't care or don't understand that their choices on the showroom floor for the glossier, flashier, 'smarter' gear result in painful, expensive obsolescence just a couple years in the future. Manufacturers are only incentivized to sell new products and ignore old products, we need a massive shift in consumer preference if we want to avoid this.
- SteveNuts 3y agoThe IT side of manufacturing is a total nightmare. My employer just bought brand new CNC machines which shipped with windows XP controllers. I have no idea why the industry hasn't converged into some sort of Linux platform by now.
- jacquesm 3y agoBecause customers demanded Windows.
- mindslight 3y agoAdd a wifi radio operating in AP mode with a well-known username and password. </s>
- N19PEDL2 3y agoI guess that at some point they will make a deal with Amazon to use their Sidewalk system to provide connectivity to meters.
- theonlybutlet 3y agoI think in reality it is a more efficient use of bandwidth using GSM. The alternative means your utility would have to maintain infrastructure and use up alternative bandwidth. In reality I think there should be regulation to keep some really basic form operating like 2G with GPRS or something on all networks.
- vel0city 3y agoMeters are already hardwired to each other. There's little reason to need it to be wireless to begin with. But either way, it's common for them to also chirp at 915MHz. They don't need their own band to operate, they can participate in these same bands used by other devices. They're not sending that much data.
- tomohawk 3y agoIs there a reason they're using cell networks to communicate instead of just communicating over the power lines? These devices are meant to be in place for decades, so even a custom solution seems like it would be worth it.
- disiplus 3y agoI worked on this, like 15 years ago, but ultimately after you go out of lab, there is so much garbage in the network that a lot of time this is not feasible.
- proto_lambda 3y agoThat definitely exists, but AFAIK it requires special equipment to get the signal across transformers. Not much of a problem in urban environments, but e.g. in low-density areas in the US, where every house has its own transformer, it might be a problem.
- nottheengineer 3y agoA custom solution would only be worth it if companies looked that far ahead instead of maximizing short-term profits.
- newsclues 3y agoHomes tend to have internet connections!
- c0wb0yc0d3r 3y agoWhat if the home is unoccupied? What if the user has a data cap? What if the user has a misconfigured firewall? Personally, with the exception of friends and family phones and tablets, I say "not my device, not my network, not my problem."
- bombcar 3y agoYou just set it so that if there’s a communication issue, it defaults to some “high cost” mode. People will plug it into the Internet to get their little discount.
- RandomLensman 3y agoDoes anyone even care if they are bricked?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- the46a 3y agoSeems like there should be a user replaceable communication module
- quickthrower2 3y agoIt is a shame there isn’t a nationwide grid of wires it could use to send those few KB of data through.
- secondcoming 3y agowhy should a homeowner subsidise a power company by providing free internet connectivity?
- _joel 3y agoI think the OP meant the power cables, what they are monitoring.
- tomalpha 3y agoA sibling comment makes the more relevant point about powerline, but it’s worth considering that whatever the power company has to pay, you the consumer will be paying for in the end. You could make the case (a good one I think) that a homeowner providing connectivity should get a discount to their bill, or that the power company could directly charge for a separate communication channel. That’s kinda saying the same thing in different ways and depending on your point of view they might not feel fair perhaps. But the consumer is paying either way. Edit: “separate communication channel” could include a human meter reader too!
- quickthrower2 3y agoI was talking about the power cables. But wifi would do the trick too, but as you say why should the homeowner subsidize. It is not so much the cost (maybe 1c of connection) but the onus to keep it up at all times and the security concern of letting IoT you can't patch yourself on your network.
- _joel 3y ago
- cabirum 3y agoAre femtocells still a thing? Could probably serve as 2g-5g adapters
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoSo replace a $2 gsm module with much more expensive femtocell?
- kotaKat 3y agoADT in the US already did this, funny enough. They acquired a company called CellBounce (https://cellbounce.com/ https://cellbounce.com/) that manufactures a very small 3G-LTE gateway. They bind it to a single device (eg, locking it to an alarm panel's IMSI) and pass the authentication through to AT&T to allow the panel onto the LTE network. Most of the device itself is just a giant lead acid battery, and the actual CellBounce motherboard is... actually very low component count and tiny. The actual Qualcomm femtocell board (linked below) that they built as a reference design for the chipset is... amazingly tiny. https://fccid.io/2AUQ4-CB34U/ https://fccid.io/2AUQ4-CB34U/ https://old.hotchips.org/wp-content/uploads/hc_archives/hc24/HC24-7-SOC/HC24.29.725-FSM-Femtocell-Blessent-Qualcomm.pdf https://old.hotchips.org/wp-content/uploads/hc_archives/hc24...
- _joel 3y agoOpenBTS is a thing
- windowsrookie 3y agoYou’ll find this happening with many things. Chrysler/dodge/Jeep vehicles built before 2016-2017 were using Sprint’s CDMA network for their telematics. When they shutdown the network it shutdown all cellular features in these vehicles. On the plus side, if you’re looking for a modern vehicle with no way to “phone home” take a look at those. ;)
- api 3y agoThere needs to be a guide to physically removing telematics from vehicles.
- minton 3y agoIf sure that would void the warranty or some other consumer punishment. I wish there was a law that products which data mine had to be free and it was illegal for paid products to do it.
- kibwen 3y ago"Oops, I accidentally ran over a faraday cage and it seems to have unintrusively wrapped itself around the wireless transmitter..."
- bluGill 3y agoEven if free there need to be limits to what they can do, and strong liability for anytime else, including if they are victims of a zero day attack.
- MerelyMortal 3y agoThat's not how warranties work in the U.S.. If you do something to Part A, it doesn't void the warranty to Part B unless the manufacturer can prove it did. If you unplug the cellular antenna, that should not affect the physical characteristics of the engine for example. Companies can claim anything they want such as 'warranty void if you remove this sticker' (or not responsible for damage), but that does not automatically make it true. A Supreme Court opinion even said "warranty void if removed" stickers might even be illegal, but they would need a case to come to them before they can determine that.
- walthamstow 3y agoYet another reason I'm glad I've been refusing my energy suppliers' repeated offers to install a smart meter over the past 10 years.
- hk1337 3y agoDepending on where you are they’ll likely just come and replace it or they’ll start charging you for having to send someone out to read your meter.
- francisofascii 3y agoOr they will estimate the monthly bill, and send meter readers less often than once a month.
- Waterluvian 3y agoIt’s nice of them to ask. Typically it’s theirs for running their side of the contract with you, and oftentimes they’ve got a right to come service it.
- sschueller 3y agoWhy would you refuse if you can get detailed information out of a smart meter about your usage? You can save a lot of power by knowing what is going on and if you have solar you definitely want a smart meter. You also don't need people coming by every so often to check how much electricity, water and gas you have used. Here in Switzerland 80% of homes are supposed to have smart meters by 2027 but it looks like it will take longer, we are at 20%[1]. Once you have one the energy company has to give you access to (by law[2]) it (rs232, Ethernet what every the device offers) so you can read the data from it. [1] https://www.srf.ch/sendungen/kassensturz-espresso/kassensturz/schleppende-digitalisierung-smartmeter-nutzung-noch-nicht-intelligent-genug https://www.srf.ch/sendungen/kassensturz-espresso/kassenstur... [2] https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2008/226/de#art_8_a https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2008/226/de#art_8_a
- executesorder66 3y agoWhat is this "it" that they will brick?
- xnorswap 3y agoI think it's the register making a hash at a pun: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/brick_it https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/brick_it The pun doesn't really work, but when has that ever stopped headline writers?
- d--b 3y agoIn France the electricity meter talks to the provider through the power line. And my newly installed water meter reports water consumption through a custom radio module. It sounds completely stupid to rely on 3G networks which are spotty or out of reach in many places. They’re probably more expensive too and take up some connections to the antenna.
- matthewmcg 3y agoMy municipal water meter transmits readings in the clear on the 915 MHz band. There's a neat program to catch the readings: https://github.com/bemasher/rtlamr https://github.com/bemasher/rtlamr
- jacquesm 3y agoGood then burglars can check for occupancy remotely, helps them to target your house when you're not there.
- TheGeminon 3y agoThey could also check the physical meter for that, or if they are wardriving for the signal they could likely pick up the presence/lack of WiFi/5G/LTE signals which would probably be even more accurate than power usage.
- jacquesm 3y agoDepends on whether or not the physical meter is exposed and that would require them to go by in person.
- JCharante 3y ago1. You can sit in a car and read the meters for multiple houses at once, you actually need to trespass to read the physical meter 2. At home devices will still generate traffic, stuff like ring cameras, any laptops that are set to wakeup on network requests, ipads left behind, tons of smart devices. Water meter sounds like less of a hassle. 3. I don’t think most people use 5G or LTE at home, most would use wifi. 4. You could probably convince gullible people into buying a traffic spoofer device that acts as a residential vpn exit node by saying that criminals can detect when you’re on vacation by reading your wifi usage. Like those devices that will turn your TV on while you’re on vacation.
- Ajay-p 3y agoDo home appliances and devices communicate with the power company via the smart meters? When I first heard about the smart meter there were fears that it would allow the power company to see which appliances you were using, and charge you a different rate. For instance, an electric vehicle.
- sauwan 3y agoI consult in the industry, and certainly don't know everything, but everything that I've seen says that no, they don't. There are companies out there like Bidgely who claim they can do that to some extent, but they likely can only do that for really big loads unless your meters only powers a very few things.
- Ajay-p 3y agoThat is a relief, thank you. It must have been a myth.
- bluGill 3y agoYou want that if done with respect to privacy. Your electric car should not charge when rates are high. Your water heater should only turn on when the wind is blowing and there is a surplus of cheap power. (This requires extra hot water storage to make it through a day)
- mnw21cam 3y agoBut the flow of information (for individual appliances) should be unidirectional from the supplier to the device, not the other way around.
- bluGill 3y agoIt needs to be two way as the power company is better able to coordinate the limited surplus with everyone else. I don't care if my water is heated at 10pm, midnight or 2am, I just want warm water for my shower when i get up.
- archi42 3y agoI'm surprised they're not keeping 2G GSM/GPRS for legacy applications. E.g. considering the life time of cars, for an eCall-like[1] solution having a network that'll be available for a few decades would make sense; or user-replacable modules. For smart meters I had to prepare a network cable into our new main fuse box; but IIUC we won't be getting one of these, for now it's just a requirement. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECall
- inigo 3y agoThere are several comments from people who don't see the point of smart meters, or think that it's just about removing the need for meter readers. There are two important things that can only be done via smart meters: - Time-of-use tariffs, which are aligned to the cost of energy production. For example, Octopus Tracker (https://octopus.energy/smart/tracker/ https://octopus.energy/smart/tracker/) has an energy price set daily based on the wholesale rate. This is (on average) cheaper for customers, and cheaper for the supplier (because they don't need to spend as much on hedging). - Demand shifting, so customers can be paid or get discounts for reducing electricity usage when the load on the grid is high. The UK did this over last winter, and led to a peak energy reduction of 188MW (about 10% of the UK's coal power generation capacity). There's a report at https://octoenergy-production-media.s3.amazonaws.com/documents/Consumer_flexibility_-_ready_to_replace_coal.pdf https://octoenergy-production-media.s3.amazonaws.com/documen... Both are ways of aligning the cost and environmental impact of energy with its price, and both become increasingly important as a higher percentage of energy is generated from variable renewable sources.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe big benefit is taxation: it allows for net-metering with the surplus sold at a low rate to be bought back at a much higher one. Obviously this was the plan all along...
- konschubert 3y agoYou don’t need a smart meter to do that that. Also, two things: * Electricity has a different price depending on the time of the day * grid fees are unfortunately scaled with consumption (instead of being scaled with max power draw)
- jacquesm 3y agoYou do because an old fashioned non-smart meter (even the multi-tariff ones) would only report the aggregate use or production.
- t0mas88 3y ago
- jacquesm 3y agoThose meters aren't exactly cheap, if they need replacement it may well be a net-negative both for the environment and for the company that owns them. Meter readers would visit once every year and for something like a couple of minutes per address, and in many places the meters are outside of the buildings and can be read from the common spaces.
- mmasu 3y agoyesterday a Tell HN reported this problem too: - “Tell HN: 3G sunsetting is remotely killing every Subaru Outback battery” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37971038 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37971038
- specialist 3y agoSmart home and smart city and smart classroom gear are all just future e-waste. Once read an article critical of Google's smart city plans (Toronto?). Author pointed out that all this digital crap is useless after 10 years. Time for another upgrade! Woot! I'm pondering residential PV and battery. Rated life span of 30 years? Really? (I'll be dead by then, of course.)
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoAlso bricks 2015+ish Subaru Outback batteries [when fails to connect]. My Kindle stopped its "FOREVER" 3G updates, too; which sucks e-ink display dick.
- RecycledEle 3y agoIt is (supposedly) very easy to emulate a cell tower. Now imagine there is a war in Europe and hackers on both sides want to shut off a whole town's electricity, one smart meter at a time...
- more_corn 3y agoOh man all the smart meter conspiracy theorists were right! Er, half right. Maybe a quarter right. But some amount of right!
- taylodl 3y agoIn the UK the meters connect directly to 2G/3G wireless networks? That would be stupid expensive to do here in the US (I know, we looked at it). In the US the meters connect to a proprietary spread spectrum network the utility sets up and maintains. The meters are capable of communicating with one another and dynamically update their routing table in order to get the message to a take-out point. Once at the take-out point a fiber connection takes it to the head-end system where the utility can communicate with it.