3 ms·
This is indicative of a lack of competition.
by SoftTalker 3y ago
This is indicative of a lack of competition.
- BartjeD 3y agoAnd also of regulatory capture.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYes I was just about to edit my above post and add that.
- perryizgr8 3y agoAlso of over regulation.
- Podgajski 3y ago[flagged]
- stevebmark 3y agoCompetition doesn’t drive down prices in American healthcare, it usually increases prices.
- crobertsbmw 3y agoInteresting. Do you have any support for this claim?
- atoav 3y agoWhat you think about doesn't apply to healthcare. You cannot pick your emergency room like you might select ddifferent groceries, because if you do, you die. It is not as if there are other nations with formidable health care systems that are way more efficient that one could look into.
- silverpepsi 3y agoThis isn't real Every business, every business has people who go in with the "no matter the cost" situation. But the market sets the schedule of pricing, so if either their status is not "revealed" or the business is simply not allowed to alter the price scedule from person to person, then it is literally no different than -A rich family deciding they'll eat at the amusement park without asking prices, and no matter what, even when a small coke has reached $10 -A guy who walks into a new restaurant after his first 48 hour fast and after payday atd decides to completely ignore the prices and just order unconditionally -A taxi driver get a flat outside of a tire shop by pure chance and it is the start of a ten hour planned shift etc. ad Infinitum
- atoav 3y agoOur goals with a health system are: - give as many people as possible health care - do it in a cheap and efficient way - without stifling innovation If markets are a good way to do that, sure. But let me ask you one question: Who do you think will negotiate better prices for any given procedure or medication: 1. A nation-wide health insurance that makes up 90% of a companies volume 2. The solitary regular Joe who is in pain and uncertainty about their health No need to answer me, because the numbers and real world examples already exist and this is a known market dynamic (bigger buyers can negotiate better prices). This is why patients in nations that have such systems pay sometimes multiple magnitudes less than people in the US. Now let me ask you another question: How would you structure a health care market if your goal was to extract as much money as possible and how would it differ from what you guys already have? If you ask me, the market for healthcare in the US work as intended. Just not for the customers.
- joe_the_user 3y agoNo, just no Health care is a situation where competition cannot be a spur to reasonable costs because individual consumers are simply not in the position to make the kind of "free market" choices that economists (or more often free market ideologues) expect they'll make. Moreover, the malignant and abusive US health care system is in fact a product of layer upon layer of failed "efforts to create competition" intended to reduce cost "through competition" to the point that by now all the abusers really know the dance and will be profiting next year from any further or replacement layer you add this year. (and "no regulation then!" as the US 1900 results in doctors being just heroin dealers - like my great grand father interestingly enough). Most other industrialized nations have a state run medical system that's far superior and cheaper than the US system. They didn't solve their problem with "competition".
- userinanother 3y agoThere is no competition because there is no market transparency at all. There is also no pricing transparency, the prices aren’t even posted and you can’t know what anything costs before you get the bill. How can there ever be competition in that environment
- fires10 3y agoMost medical decisions are not shopped. It has nothing to do with competition. Quality of care is first and foremost for me. I want to live costs be damned. Only rarely will cost come into it as a decision for me. Only on things I don't need. This is for both emergency and non-emergency care. I don't know of anyone who seriously and consistently looks at costs when making medical decisions. I usually have higher priorities.
- Tostino 3y agoYou don't know people who live near the margins then. Cost was pretty much the primary decider for me prior to making a decent living, so much so that I put off rotator cuff surgery for 10 years because I couldn't afford to have it done, no matter how much I "shopped around".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 3y agoHealthcare services are not a free market. The idea that competition can drive down costs would be funny if it wasn't driven by such cynicism. Like a lawyer buying time with objections they know they will lose, the "let the market fix things" people push for price transparency, which they don't get, and then they'll push for time to let that work out. It won't because people who buy healthcare - you and me - don't shop. And we won't shop. Insurance companies don't shop either. Providers hire admins who's whole job is to game the system, which enriches the provider slightly, employs the admin, and extracts wealth from insurance companies and ultimately patients. The hard truth is that, ultimately, providers, are to blame. Skilled professionals should NEVER say "I don't know how much it costs" to their clients and get away with it. It's your JOB to know how much it costs and to understand the experience of your patient. I get it that you don't WANT to know, that it's complicated and depressing. I get that because all patients get that. That is not an excuse for not paying attention to the details. It is providers who regularly make their patients wait for hours after the appointment time. It's providers who order expensive and unnecessary tests for every condition, or who refer to multiple specialists. Each of these decisions increases the cost of care, the provider profit margin, and the stress on the patient. Because the provider is ultimately the one with the skill that the patient needs, I blame them for this systemic failure. If you're a doctor and you give in to the status quo, hire a large staff of billing agents and write scripts for all the tests and drugs you can, YOU are the problem. If you took your oath seriously, you'd never accept the way things are. Instead you advocate to maximize your profit margins instead of patient outcomes, and as a result you make the entire system sick. With any luck, it will get so sick it will die.
- isykt 3y agoWhen’s the last time you were in the back of an ambulance telling the driver which hospital to take you to?
- QuarterReptile 3y agoThe principle in that case is elasticity of demand, not competition. As in, my mother always made sure to beat ambulances to us when school or sports reported us injured, because she was worried we wouldn't be confident enough to shoo them away on our own.
- FireBeyond 3y agoAs someone who is a paramedic, we will absolutely listen to you if you say you want to go to hospital X, not Y. If you're unable, we'll take you to the one that best is equipped to deal with your issue. HOWEVER... the insurer. If you're talking about two hospitals in the same town or part of town, no big deal. If you want to go to the hospital 15 minutes beyond that? Your insurer will deny the ambulance bill. Their argument was that "if you were sick enough to require an ambulance, you should have been transported to the closest facility, stabilized, and then transferred to your preferred facility" versus taking a longer ambulance ride.
- s1artibartfast 3y agohow much of healthcare spending is related to emergency procedures? How much is scheduled weeks in advance? how much is scheduled months in advance.