6 ms·
Taking on SpaceX: Why Germany is building its own spaceport
- p1mrx 3y ago> The launch pad will be built some 350 kilometers from the coast in the remotest corner of Germany's Exclusive Economic Zone. https://maritime-spatial-planning.ec.europa.eu/media/14877 https://maritime-spatial-planning.ec.europa.eu/media/14877 Looks like the latitude will be around 55°N, not exactly ideal for a spaceport.
- pacbard 3y agoFrom what I learned from KSP, a high latitude launch site is helpful for polar orbit. That's why Vandenberg is used for this purpose over Cape Canaveral (or other equatorial launch sites) in the US. It will be interesting to see how this shakes out because there are other nations participating in ESA that have both land and launch sites that are at higher latitudes than Germany's floating launch site (e.g., [1]). [1]: https://www.euronews.com/next/2023/01/13/this-arctic-space-centre-could-become-the-first-to-launch-satellites-from-mainland-europe https://www.euronews.com/next/2023/01/13/this-arctic-space-c...
- Rebelgecko 3y ago55° seems ideal if you want to launch at an inclination high enough that the orbits will go over Germany (the domestic tech stuff mentioned in the article) or areas that are of interest for defense reasons (eg Russia)
- mcpackieh 3y agoFor reference, Russia's Baiknour is at 45.965°N (about a thousands kilometers difference, not counting longitude.) A high latitude should work fine for Earth observing satellites that are suited for polar orbits, but I can't help but think it would make more sense for Germany to make a deal with France to share the Guiana Space Centre.
- fomine3 3y agoI imagine that having a launch site on far away location isn't ideal for R&D. Location is a US' advantage that's hard to catch up. Not having any lands for east is great.
- _fizz_buzz_ 3y agoDepends on the orbit you want to launch into.
- fooker 3y agoGermany doesn't have the resources to take on anything. They have a shrinking economy and a rapidly aging population.
- sMarsIntruder 3y agoEnergiewende unfortunately will give the fatality to the economic system. Problem is: a weak Germany is a problem for the current European economic balance.
- throwbadubadu 3y ago> will give the fatality to the economic system. When?
- f1shy 3y ago10 to 15 years
- kuerbel 3y agoWell, just like how some conspiracy theorists claim people will die from COVID shots 'soon,' but keep adjusting the date, we can expect the Energiewende 'fatality' to happen right around the same time that elusive 'soon' arrives! You know, always on the horizon but never quite here. ;-)
- nickik 3y agoIts of course always nonsense to talk about 'fatality' as the people are still there and the economy will not just stop. But lets not pretend the lackluster growth isn't related to issues with energy.
- ben_jones 3y agoWhen Star Citizen is released
- V__ 3y agoWhy would it?
- TruthWillHurt 3y agoHow's the Eurocloud project doing? Are they done writing regulations and started on services already?
- silenced_trope 3y agoreminds me of Quaero: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaero#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaero#Criticism
- helge9210 3y agoFrom what I see in Germany, this project will be drowned to death in meetings to prepare meetings to define policies even before the first rivet is ordered to be produced.
- vardump 3y agoSigh. I wish you were wrong.
- FL410 3y agoWell don't worry, we have a fully stacked Starship waiting up to half a year for a Fish & Wildlife survey. Take your time.
- FireBeyond 3y agoAs it should be. Musk's "To Mars!" shouldn't just get to say "fuck Earth, we have grander plans".
- avmich 3y agoZander was saying "Forward to Mars!" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Zander https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Zander but he didn't have the technology yet.
- oefnak 3y agoSome local fish and wildlife is not the same as Earth.
- FireBeyond 3y agoHow many “Fuck local fish and wildlife”’s does it take to get to an unacceptable level of destruction for Musk’s profit, I mean, mission? We can survive six months of an environmental impact study.
- aporetics 3y agoThe attitude proceeds from the same presupposition, which doesn’t seem—using planetary ecology as a yardstick—to have much keeping it in check.
- themgt 3y agoTo start, Dutch company T-Minus will launch a rocket from the German-Offshore Spaceport Alliance (GOSA) mobile platform. This company apparently doesn't even produce orbital rockets: https://www.t-minus.nl/post/barracuda-rocket-at-esa-pac-symposium https://www.t-minus.nl/post/barracuda-rocket-at-esa-pac-symp... Their largest in-development rocket is tiny, like a 1/4th the size of New Shepherd? Nowhere is it mentioned what orbital rocket would be launching from this spaceport. Just back of napkin I can't imagine you'll see any orbital payload delivered from this pad by 2030? The obvious thing for Europe to do would be have ESA fund a replica of NASA's COTS/CCDev/HLS programs, which have overall delivered stunning return on investment and arguably the only reason China isn't absolutely dominating space launches now. This type of token "spaceport to nowhere" pet project is going to deliver absolutely zilch. Ariane 6 is a dead end and there appears to be no plan forward.
- nickik 3y agoESA already had the ATV to do what CommercialCargo does. But because of cost they stopped that program and instead helped with the Orion service module. They are committed to Orion service module and have no interest in going back to cargo resupply. Given how close the ISS is to the end. By the time they would have finished a new cargo ship, the station is gone be close to gone. And they simply don't really have the budget for CCDev. It simply doesn't fit in their budget. And even worse, given how absurdly high the cost for the Ariane 6 are, you would expect 6-10 billion for a crew capsule. And you know the European would go for some dumb space plane idea that's gone cost even more.
- electriclove 3y agoThe only reason China isn’t dominating is because of SpaceX. NASA helping fund flights is great and helpful to SpaceX but don’t mistakenly credit NASA for SpaceX’s success.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIt was more than helpful; SpaceX would have failed without the COTS contract. There's a tendency by some to describe money paid out by the government for services rendered as "government funding", framed like some sort of unearned charitable gift given by the government to the company which entitles the government to all of the credit in the end. This is an immature point of view that is often the product of motivated reasoning (particularly, motivated by personal dislike of the people/companies involved. There's also some people who thought that capitalism would be trapped on earth with space being the exclusive domain of governments, and are bitter to realize that won't be the case.) Maybe your comment is reacting in part to this tendency, I find myself frustrated with it as well. Nevertheless, the truth is that SpaceX didn't have the money to develop Falcon 9 until they got that contract. I think themgt is correct to say the creation of contracts like that in Europe could provide European rocket companies the same kind of opportunity to develop technology and prove themselves.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoNo government is going to "take on spacex" because what works for spacex is to act in all the ways, good and bad, a gov entity would never do. Such projects would work much better if they would instead relyon the strength of govs instead of being a fish trying to follow a bird. Of course, attempting to do it anyway and failing miserably while transferring the public money into parasites is a very gov thing to do. So it will happen.
- electriclove 3y agoStrength of the govs to do what??
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoStability, long time horizons, can adapt the law to their need, a communication on patriotism, no incentive to squeeze money out of every step, employees protection... Every weakness can be a strenght depending of the context. Good profiles that would not consider working in high pressure, high risk envs like spacex can be interested in gov projects.
- electriclove 3y agoBeen there, done that.. reality plays out quite differently as evidenced by the stagnation of NASA versus the commercial space industry in the US.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoCounter point, spacex wouldn't do this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37995119 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37995119
- electriclove 3y agoI’m sure they totally could if they had assets out that far.
- nickik 3y agoThis is all a bunch of questionable nonsense. Small launch is already an economic terrible and all companies are losing money and are trying to get out of that business. So building an expensive sea based port will simply require even large amount of investment with no more revenue to compensate. And as for the German government paying for everything, not really gone happen. They are already unhappy about what they have to pay for Ariane 6. They never even wanted Ariane 6. And they have been slushing their space budget. This seems to me to be a news site making to much of some early concept that are not close to be happening.
- az09mugen 3y agoI don't get the point of building so far from the equator, the orbital speed in this area is something like half of the orbital speed at the equator. They will have to spend more in rocket fuel to launch the rockets. Maybe there is something I'm missing there.