5 ms·
What the fuck are we doing as a society, that this lady, with a machine that could compute the above in a fraction of a second, has to spend a decent chunk of h
by userbinator 3y ago
What the fuck are we doing as a society, that this lady, with a machine that could compute the above in a fraction of a second, has to spend a decent chunk of her work time doing this?
To put it bluntly: do you want her to be unemployed instead?
- tuatoru 3y agoThis is the "lump of labor" fallacy. If she turns up to work reliably, and stays on-task, there are no end of other things she could be doing that increase general welfare more than this.
- radlad 3y agoMaybe, but I'm not sure everyone has the inclination to become a programmer. And the whole thread was about how computers should work for everyone, including this lady whose job could be automated. Which begs the question: do most people actually want general purpose computing? Or does the average human prefer "apps"?
- tuatoru 3y agoWho said anything about her becoming a programmer? An interior decorator, or a gardener, or a nurse aide, or a yoga instructor, or a nail technician: they all add more to human welfare than this task. If she wants to become an architect, or a water system engineer, more power to her!
- rrr_oh_man 3y agoNot disagreeing with your point in general, but: Not everyone can become an architect or water systems engineer at 50, after having worked a "general assistant" type office job for many years. I think that (and its consequences) might be the biggest short term societal risk of automation in an aging society. How would you solve this problem?
- tuatoru 3y agoIf there are resources available, some entrepreneur will figure out a way to make use of them.
- asdff 3y agoWhy can't you become these things at 50? Considering you can become them at 23, having worked perhaps in fast food for a few years prior?
- auggierose 3y agoGood question! Wait until you are 50, maybe you can answer it then ;-)
- JohnFen 3y agoI (and most of my social circle) am over 50, and I can answer that question: there's no solid reason you can't train for and be successful in a different career later in life. I've seen it happen too often to think otherwise. Whether or not you want to is an entirely different question, of course.
- auggierose 3y agoNot there yet, but slowly getting there. Of course you can train for a different career after you are 50, but you will also have a good idea what kind of career is not a good fit for you (anymore). So just because certain careers are now looking for people, doesn't mean that these are a good fit for you.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes indeed! Our youth is when the majority of what we do is try things out to see what fits and what doesn't. In our older years, most of that experimentation is behind us and we have a pretty solid idea of what fits us and what doesn't. The trick is that the amount of experimentation should never be reduced to zero.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoWhatever you list here, she'll be competing for an entry-level position with much younger people, who have more time, more energy, lower expenses and no obligations. The older one is, the more time one spent in one line of work before being forced to find something else to do, the harder it hits. So sure, maybe you can switch to landscaping in your 50s, but that also means you and your family suddenly being kicked down one or two economic classes.
- ethbr1 3y agoI figure experience is valuable to potential employers in two ways: (1) what you can do & (2) what you know. Usually, switching industries past a certain point of tenure wipes out (2), as so much of the expert knowledge is specific. In this case, she obviously wasn't only a spreadsheet-reconciler: this lady knows thousands of things about banking that I don't. And probably that new, entry-level people at her company have no idea about. Ergo, the company would get the most benefit from assigning her new responsibilities where that information is valuable. Specifically, something in middle management where her intuition of "... that doesn't sound quite right, tell me more about..." would help prevent bad decisions.
- ethbr1 3y agoIn this scenario, she had plenty of other high-value work to perform if she never had to do this again. Which is the other side of the coin of the ubiquity of this problem -- modern businesses are so optimized on the people side that roles are collapsed down to 1-2 people, and therefore those people inevitably catch "oh, and also do this" could-be-automated work.
- asdff 3y agoIf the average human were allowed to achieve its most base preferences, we'd all be a half ton in weight, floating around in chairs, stupefied at some screen, just as depicted in Wall-e.
- JohnFen 3y agoI actually don't think this is true at all. While there will always be a percentage of people who would prefer that, my observations are that most people don't. They tend to have interests that drive them to put time and effort into doing things, instead.
- ethbr1 3y agoIf I ever luck into wealth, I have a mad scientist social experiment I want to run. Advertise a job, with midling-but-not-exceptional pay, and try the following with a few hundred people. - They report at exactly 9:00 am - They bring nothing with them - They enter a featureless room - They sit at a featureless desk - They sit there for 8 hours - They have 30 minutes for lunch - They have access to a featureless bathroom - They leave at the end of the day - They get paid weekly The question is: how long would people willingly stay in that "job"? My hypothesis is that it's a bimodal distribution. Some set of people would be perfectly fine with it, indefinitely. Some people would go batshit insane and quit quickly.
- JohnFen 3y agoI wouldn't even consider such a job. For me, the worst possible job is one where I have nothing to do. I've had those, and they are a nightmare. I'd much rather be seriously overworked!
- another2another 3y agoAfter a week or two, they'd probably call Sherlock Holmes.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoI was going to say that - I'm increasingly subscribing to "bullshit jobs" theory : * productivity for goods is high and availability is high (we can discuss inequality and distribution) * we just don't need everybody to work 40hrs a week to obtain collectively good standard of living * but as a society we are uncomfortable with universal basic income * so instead we basically do UBI through inefficient, unnecessary jobs That's my current perspective at least. As I continue to grow older and slide into cynicism though, I'm likely to switch to "everybody is idiots and everything is screwed up" theory more and more :-D
- opportune 3y agoWho's saying that lady's job is bullshit just because it can be automated? There is real value in paying some up front cost in detection/monitoring/validation of data to prevent mistakes. Just because software engineers would consider her job "beneath" them because they could do it faster or better does not make it not worth doing. There are mega-efficient factory farms in Nebraska that are immensely productive per-human involved, but that doesn't mean what hobby farmers in Connecticut or subsistence farmers in Africa are doing is bullshit. I think "bullshit jobs" are less of a thing than people believe. It's just that people devalue assembly-line or cog-in-machine work, even when they're the ones doing it - especially in the US where we grow up wanting to be a unique success story like an entertainment celebrity or rich entrepreneur and so that kind of work is antithetical to our idea of a successful person. Fact of the matter is, machines needs cogs, and we don't have an infinite capacity to replace human cogs with automated ones.
- concordDance 3y agoDoes she find that task enjoyable and fulfilling? If not, it's bullshit. And if bet money on it NOT being enjoyable and fulfilling. Humans almost universally hate being cogs doing the same repetitive trivial action over and over.
- oldsecondhand 3y agoDo janitors find their job enjoyable and fulfilling? Probably not. Their job is still important for the functioning of society, so I wouldn't call it bullshit.
- asdff 3y agoShe will not be unemployed in this situation, nor will her peers in similar situations. Available labor is always gobbled up and not left idle for long. Case in point: we've obviated jobs like the horseshoe maker and the stable boy and yet unemployment rate today at 3.8% or so is half of what it was in the 1900s when we had all these horse and stable jobs.
- yard2010 3y agoJobs do not disappear, they just change
- ben_w 3y agoThey can be fully automated out of existence, e.g the jobs of Herb Strewer and link-boy. And, indeed, that old job called "computer".
- ffgjgf1 3y agoYou have to also take into account income not just the unemployment rate. Growth has been close to non-existent if not negative over the last 40-50 years or so if earn below the median.
- JohnFen 3y agoIn the long term, yes. But shouldn't we have some compassion for those who get screwed in the short term? The horseshoe makers who were thrown out of work at the time may not have been able to find decent new employment. We have copious modern-day examples of jobs that have been obsoleted and those who were immediately affected still haven't been able to recover. These sorts of labor shifts can't avoid harming those who get the short end of the stick. Saying this is not to say that such changes shouldn't happen. It's inevitable and necessary in order for society to adapt to changing conditions. But I very often see a disregard for the reality that people really do get hurt badly in these shifts.
- ethbr1 3y agoLong-training-time jobs are the worst for this. E.g. medical By the time you mint a professional in medical something, they've put a decade+ into training for it. And in the US model, incurred substantial debt doing so. One reason I'm more sympathetic to the artificial medical supply/demand management shenanigans.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> do you want her to be unemployed instead? Yes. Compassion and reason both repel me, as a humanist and computer scientist, from the thought of another human being pointlessly wasting her life for the mere "necessity" of money to live because broken software has become an excuse for this. It is an inhuman spectacle, and the notion of "employment" here is so weak as to have no force in the argument. An unemployed person at least has the opportunity to redefine their life, whereas one who is tricked daily into believing their bullshit job is "valuable" is being robbed, no matter the remuneration. Further, as a technical person, it disgusts me to see the tools we created so comprehensively misused by idiots who are unable to intelligently deploy them - or rather deploy them as instruments of abuse rather than for human development and progress.
- ThrowAway1922A 3y agoIt's hard to believe this is an actual opinion a human holds and it wreaks of someone who has never gone through particularly hard times. Redefine their life? Good luck doing that when you suddenly don't have an income because you were automated out of employment. People who are able to recover from these events and reinvent themselves are the exception. Any job is better than no job and it's not your place to judge the value of someone's life. If said person is making an income, can tolerate their job, and enjoys their time outside of work that's all anyone can really ask for.
- spease 3y ago> To put it bluntly: do you want her to be unemployed instead? Fine. Then write her a script and continue to pay her a salary. Hell, let her keep coming into work if she wants to. Functionally, what’s the difference to the business? Presumably she’s still going to want to maintain social relationships in her life, which means she’s got an intrinsic incentive to do things to benefit someone else even absent financial incentive. But now we’ve effectively got an atomic form of UBI, which scares people. Yet 1 person’s worth of work is being done for the cost of 1 salary. In fact, if she starts doing something else productive to society with her time, you’ve got 2 people’s worth of work being done for the cost of 1 salary. And if someone automates that and she switches to something else, it increases to a 3:1 ratio. Where is her employment status a problem, except to the sensibilities of people who believe that everyone needs to be “employed”? If no one ever automated what she was doing for fear of her losing her livelihood, then the maximum productivity we’d ever expect to see is 1:1. Seems like not having UBI or a stronger safety net is creating a perverse incentive for economic inefficiency.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> continue to pay her a salary Why would any company do that?
- solatic 3y agoYes. A human mind is a terrible thing to waste. Plenty of people don't look for more fulfilling work because what they already have is "good enough" and it brings home a paycheck that supports the people who depend on them. Oftentimes, people need a push, and doing so can be an act of compassion. Laying people off is not some death sentence; it's a disruptive event that well-adjusted people will recover from. That's ultimately their private responsibility, not the company's, certainly not the company's in a day and age where few people work their entire career for the same employer anymore. Furthermore, a society where there is massive unemployment but society's economic engines are humming along, mostly automated, for the benefit of a select private few, is a society where such engines are ripe for nationalization, whether that be through public ownership or public seizure of the majority of the profits via taxation, either one of which could support basic income. So again, not necessarily a bad thing in the end. And if you think people blowing their basic income checks on panem et circenses represents some kind of civic death, I would point to the current alternative, people working bullshit jobs of questionable value, and ask if that really represents the civic virtue you're trying to uphold.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Oftentimes, people need a push, and doing so can be an act of compassion. Only if those people have asked for the push. If they haven't, then it's not at all an act of compassion.
- ThrowAway1922A 3y ago> it's a disruptive event that well-adjusted people will recover from. Some of us are not well adjusted. Some of us are barely hanging on, barely able to manage the demands of our lives and our society. Being laid off at this point for me would be worse than disruptive it would be an outright disaster.
- ethbr1 3y agoLet's create a hypothetical McDonald's worker, imbued at birth with extraordinary intelligence and capability. They have a family and are the primary means of support. They're laid off. Parent post's "act of compassion" What happens? In the US, they have unemployment benefits. They have SNAP. That's probably it as far as immediate. They hypothetically have access to Section 8 housing, but that's contingent on finding availability (current wait-lists are long and conditions of properties variable). There are some academic / training programs (merit and need-based), but I believe those are all state-administered? IOW, in the US, not great. I don't have high confidence that housing and initial retraining would be financially/practically attainable to allow them to take advantage of their abilities. Honestly, in the US, most reliable option for that person would be to join the military.