3 ms·
In the US still, the path to success is a highly optimized one: start early, max out the extracurriculars, become an outlier among outliers. GitHub has become t
by paulpauper 3y ago
In the US still, the path to success is a highly optimized one: start early, max out the extracurriculars, become an outlier among outliers. GitHub has become the new resume. No one cares that you worked at Petco at 17; they want to see your repos, your pull requests. Today's elite and top earners are not born, like under the aristocracy or nobility, but rather forged, of course assuming the potential is there, like IQ.
- pc86 3y agoYou seem to be conflating two mutually exclusive paths to success. Nobody in the world of banking, or politics, or manufacturing, give a shit about repos and pull requests. And nobody in the tech world gives a shit about your extracurriculars. And "become and outlier among outliers" doesn't give anyone any actual idea how to become successful and could be applied to literally any field or organization in any society at any point in history.
- paulpauper 3y agothanks for your constructive feedback
- tintedfireglass 3y agoum., is this sarcasm?
- oefrha 3y ago> And nobody in the tech world gives a shit about your extracurriculars People in the (American, and I dare say elsewhere too) tech world do give a shit about the college you went to, and the elite colleges do give a shit about extracurriculars, especially if you’re Asian or something, unfortunate as it is.
- pc86 3y agoMaybe for your first job or two, but there are plenty of self-taught FAANG developers with completely unrelated degrees from completely unknown colleges. I'm really curious what the "or something" in your race statement means though.
- oefrha 3y agoFirst job or two do affect your entire career, not to mention the lasting effects of networking. “There are plenty of counter examples” doesn’t mean people don’t give a shit in general, it means it’s not the only factor at play. As for “or something”, it is well known that the bar is very high for Asians and extracurriculars are needed to distinguish oneself (too many perfect SATs and GPAs), but maybe there are other demographics similarly affected that I don’t hear about much.
- bigstrat2003 3y ago> People in the (American, and I dare say elsewhere too) tech world do give a shit about the college you went to... Not really. Nobody gives a damn what college you went to for the vast majority of jobs. They care about whether you went to college or not, regardless of the school. And even then, it's becoming more and more rare to find employers who are sticklers that applicants must have a degree.
- oefrha 3y agoWhat's this weird confusion between "requirement" and "gives a shit"? A Stanford graduate isn't treated the same as a random state college graduate out of school, period, before you even consider relationships forged during college and alumni networks.
- bigstrat2003 3y ago> A Stanford graduate isn't treated the same as a random state college graduate out of school, period, At most jobs? Yeah, they are actually.
- saagarjha 3y agoBeing a software engineer is not the only way to achieve success.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> they want to see your repos, your pull requests I've never had any potential employer look at my GitHub. It was all about the resume, experience, and being able to explain that experience, as well as a technical coding assessment.
- arp242 3y agoEveryone asks for it, but few actually look at it. And that's fine too, because not everyone has the same hobbies and "let me see your GitHub" is essentially screening for a hobby. I say this as someone with lots of GitHub stars and such. If anything, "grinding leetcode" would be the closest analogy to Keju (although not exactly identical of course).
- ensignavenger 3y agoOn the other hand, I have been interviewd and asked about a project on my GitHub, so there are those who do.
- visarga 3y agoThat analogy would work if Github only had one single project. The problem was not the test, but the fact that there was just one single test, and the subject matter and manner of testing were supporting authoritarianism. There was no open competition for talent between multiple institutions. They outsourced brainwashing to parents and teachers.
- Spooky23 3y agoFor now. US Civil Service merit & fitness requirements were undermined by courts finding that because most examinations correlated to general intelligence as defined by IQ, they were discriminatory to various stakeholders who are either under-assessed by IQ due to cultural or disability related bias. The easy path for employers is to utilize the experience + education provided by the candidate, and clean up any mess later. (or not)
- streakfix 3y agoThere are professions other than software development
- jstarfish 3y agoEverything you say is presumably true of FAANG or SV in general. Cult rules apply there, where you have to forsake anything that might serve you in outside communities so you risk economic death in trying to get into this one. Posers aside, the rest of the world does not function this way and advice like yours really fucked my professional development up. If you're just a regular type of dude in most of the US, none of this applies. Your Petco job does matter, your employer won't even look at your Github page, and talking about PRs will only invite clarification of whether you mean public relations or Puerto Ricans. The SV-optimized path is not the only path to success in America. This country is itself entirely optimized for entrepreneurs. Tradesmen crush it and don't have to live in fear of AI obsolescence. The most successful people I know are all undereducated immigrants and ex-military types running boring businesses selling medical equipment, carpet and tile. Always boring shit people generally need, not drop-shipped dollar-store crap from Temu. To be the guy positioned to sell N95 masks in 2019 never required a Github profile or elite education.
- Apocryphon 3y agoThe software focus of this comment aside, there is something to be said about how primary and secondary education has become hyper-optimized cram school grindfests among a certain strata. Students are expected to max out not only the SATs but their entire candidate profiles in a bid to get into increasingly competitive universities even as the worth of upper education credentials becomes increasingly deflated. In some areas, preschools become competitive for parents to vie for to begin their children’s educational careers off right. This applies to all manner of white collar professions, not only engineering. Albeit then again maybe this is a Silicon Valley-centric phenomenon, and only an elite striver subset (Palo Alto, Cupertino, Saratoga, Contra Costa County) of the region.
- ssnistfajen 3y agoMany of today's elites and top earners are very much still born to previous generations of elites and top earners.