8 ms·
It takes 12 people to use the 18k Sphere camera
- kibwen 3y ago> Aronofsky’s 18K resolution film plays back at Sphere at a blistering-fast 60 frames per second, more than twice the speed of the typical 24p motion picture, and is about half a petabyte in size, or about 500 terabytes. Aronofsky explains that the movie is about 32GB of data per second, or nearly 2,000 GB a minute. I can already see the PC gamers demanding 18K 144hz monitors.
- tmikaeld 3y agoThe human eye can only see at 60 frames per second edit: Apparently, you don't joke about frames per second.
- icegreentea2 3y agoWhat makes it a joke?
- diarrhea 3y agohttps://knowyourmeme.com/memes/human-eye-can-only-see-at-60-fps https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/human-eye-can-only-see-at-60-...
- icegreentea2 3y agoThanks lol.
- fsckboy 3y ago"the claim that the eye can only see 60 FPS has been proven false in numerous online threads"
- codetrotter 3y agohttps://www.pcgamer.com/how-many-frames-per-second-can-the-human-eye-really-see/ https://www.pcgamer.com/how-many-frames-per-second-can-the-h...
- Our_Benefactors 3y agoLet’s for a moment accept this as fact. Now consider you have a 60fps screen and 60fps natural vision. The periodicity of video frame updates and “vision frames” are not in any way synchronized. Meaning the image appears less “smooth” than if you had a higher refresh screen. Lastly, have you ever tried a 144hz and 60hz display side by side? The difference is very obvious.
- sdenton4 3y agoThere's no synchronized refresh in the retina though. Imagine pixels being randomly updated continuously in time, but each individual pixel has a refresh rate of 60Hz. The overall perceived 'frame rate' for this parallel random update will be much higher than 60Hz: Suppose 25% of the pixels in an object need to change to register a perceptible difference: then the effective framerate for noticing changes in the object will be ~240Hz.
- tmikaeld 3y agoThe fastest proven seems to be 220hz but 240hz is the maximum theoretical for humans.
- fsckboy 3y agoif you are referring to this: > The USAF, in testing their pilots for visual response time, used a simple test to see if the pilots could distinguish small changes in light. In their experiment a picture of an aircraft was flashed on a screen in a dark room at 1/220th of a second. Pilots were consistently able to "see" the afterimage as well as identify the aircraft. This simple and specific situation not only proves the ability to percieve 1 image within 1/220 of a second, but the ability to interpret higher FPS. that is not a test of FPS, it's a test of a few photons in a dark room and the afterimage affect of the retina (or is it also the optic nerve and the visual cortex?), potentially aka "blurring". I'm not taking a position on framerates, I'm taking a position on interpreting the data.
- 3y ago
- pdntspa 3y agoDude gamers get super defensive over refresh rate. It's like, don't trash my large numbers! They are large numbers! It's kind of stupid.
- Thorrez 3y agotmikaeld was joking. HN generally doesn't approve of low-effort jokes. We don't want HN to become reddit.
- bitwize 3y agoWe need to hurry up and switch to Wayland; once displays exceed 32k, they will literally be larger than X11's coordinate space.
- clnq 3y agoCertainly the Sphere will be quite difficult to use without fractional scaling as well.
- yieldcrv 3y ago[flagged]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y ago> The venue will house the world’s highest resolution LED screen: a 160,000 square-foot display plane that will wrap up, over, and behind the audience It would be great for watching horror movies.
- huytersd 3y agoHow does viewing a movie on the sphere work? From my understanding it’s a sphere that displays things on the outside. Wouldn’t this mean you would only be able to see only a small part of the screen at any given time?
- spencerflem 3y agoThere is a similar set of screens on the inside
- nicoburns 3y agoI believe there's another huge screen on the inside.
- nunez 3y agoThe Sphere's surround LED screen is 16K by 16K
- jffry 3y ago> From my understanding it’s a sphere that displays things on the outside It's got two screens! One inside and one outside. The interior screen is 16k by 16k pixels (the 18k camera resolution affords some cropping for image stabilization etc). The exterior screen doesn't have much in the way of specs other than area, but I'd expect it is comparably lower pixel density.
- ljoshua 3y agoSome mind-blowing technical details about the camera and recording system itself are in a secondary article linked from this one as well: https://petapixel.com/2023/06/12/sphere-studios-big-sky-cinema-camera-features-an-insane-18k-sensor/ https://petapixel.com/2023/06/12/sphere-studios-big-sky-cine... Bits like a fiber-to-media recording system and custom GPU-based processing systems, really awesome project
- nunez 3y ago0.5Tbps light to chip!!!!! That's insane.
- mschuster91 3y ago> What’s even more impressive is the camera can run completely separate from this recording technology as long as it is connected through its cable system, this includes distances of up to a reported mile away. That's not that impressive, Blackmagic cameras have been able to run on fiber since 2018 [1]. The bandwidth for the Sphere cam however, that is insane. 500 Gbit/sec, that used to be the domain of entire ISP's core switches, and now that kind of performance is (effectively) handheld-capable. [1] https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/media/release/20180201-02 https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/media/release/20180201-02
- jandrese 3y agoA consumer grade GeForce 4070 has that much memory bandwidth, and there are more expensive models with even more. It’s an almost unfathomable number but at the same time it is well within the realm of commodity hardware. We are living in the future.
- tgaj 3y agoMemory bandwidth is easier to achieve because of q short distance between elements on the motherboard.
- mhandley 3y ago> 500 Gbit/sec, that used to be the domain of entire ISP's core switches And then you realize that the latest datacenter Ethernet switch chips have 51 Tbit/sec agregate non-blocking capacity (128 ports of 400Gb/s, or similar setups), and a single AI cluster can use hundreds of these switches.
- xoa 3y agoObviously we're a long ways (if ever) from having such theaters available widely enough to be more then location tourist attractions, but VR will almost certainly eventually make such video accessible for home viewing as well. And the march of tech will undoubtedly eventually bring down camera costs to "very high" vs "stratospheric one of a kind high", and in turn mean more works get made with it. So from an artistic point of view, I'm a little curious long term what film makers might come up with when they get a format where it's impossible to see it all in one go. I mean yes, lots of the best films reward multiple viewings and as a practical matter it can be very hard to notice little details the first time around. Same thing for that matter with static images. But still, you can physically see everything there at once, if multiple people watch it everyone sees the same thing. Whereas in a sphere format with the work exceeds your physical field of view it'll be truly impossible to experience all of the film in a single go no matter how closely you pay attention. While it'd be very challenging to use well and I'm sure a lot of the format will be documentary type of stuff, nevertheless it seems likely there will be works eventually that really lean into it and they'll genuinely offer different experiences in the same work depending on where you choose to focus. A medium that has already long done this in a way is video games, where it's not at all uncommon for there to be games that offer multiple mutually exclusive paths; picking one means you will not ever see certain content in that run. That can be cheap sometimes, but can also used by a creative producer/writer in interesting ways. Will open a new dimension for film making perhaps.
- two_handfuls 3y agoYes as you say, video games do some of that. There is also the nascent art of 360 videos (sometimes erroneously called “VR videos”). They are developing their own conventions and experimenting with what works and what does not. As you said, the medium makes it easier to make a movie that still has something new to enjoy on the second or third watch. Another thing is discovering the best clues to direct the viewer to look where you want them to (sound, light, movement, but also having the other characters look that way).
- spacecadet 3y agoNo one has seriously shot 24p in 2 decades but Aaron. Time to catch up man... It takes his crew 12 people lol, this isn't much worse then shooting existing 8 and 12k which at most is a single well trained DIT. I looked at this setup, its not any different, hype article.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CyberDildonics 3y agoNo one has seriously shot 24p in 2 decades but Aaron What is this supposed to mean? Movies are 24fps. Here is a short list of the movies that are not 24fps. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_with_high_frame_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_with_high_frame_... at most is a single well trained DIT Is DIT supposed to mean 'Document Image Transformer' here? This is photography, not upscaling.
- spacecadet 3y agoHaha, let me grab a random list too... yours is particularly bad because you didn't understand my point. Im talking about physical limitations of film, vs digital, vs human perception and the trade offs of budget, crew, and equipment. Shooting on a camera locked at 24fps is not equal to shooting 24fps. Spend the next 20 years doing it and come back to me.
- spacecadet 3y agoHere ya go, random list, tho mine is better matched to my point. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_shot_on_digital_video_prior_to_2012 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_shot_on_digita...
- CyberDildonics 3y agoyou didn't understand my point I still don't. You said something that wasn't true in any way, so I'm still not sure what the point is. Your list doesn't seem to make any sense or have any connection to what you're saying either. Im talking about physical limitations of film, vs digital, vs human perception and the trade offs of budget, crew, and equipment. If you say so, but what your comment actually said was that no one has shot 24fps in 20 years, which is nonsense. Then you said something about 18k not being impressive because someone could shoot at 8k and scale it up, but even that wasn't very clear.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoKeep having these vibe that: simulating Sphere feels like a good goal that could show off VR well.
- atum47 3y agoDon't know if this is the right topic to be asking this but here it goes anyways: is there a 360º interactive version of the U2 show at the sphere?
- WatchDog 3y agoNot sure how “interactive” it is, but yeah U2 are putting on a show there for a while.
- atum47 3y agoI'm sorry. I think my question was not clear. I want to watch the show, preferable using oculus so i can look around inside the sphere. That's why i asked on the topic about the camera they use.
- mike503 3y agoNo - it's not 360 degrees. They have a few interesting and cool visuals for something like 5 or 6 songs, more basic or boring uses of the screen otherwise. I didn't sense any haptics off the chair nor could tell if they activated the scents either. I was there for opening night. Also went to the Sphere Experience. The experience includes the movie mentioned here and has some interesting/cool stuff. It's loud and rumbled a ton (seat haptics) and was almost to the point of "should I put my earplugs in?" but I didn't need to. It was an interesting experience. At first it seemed like they were just projecting a small rectangle movie off of it and I was about to flip out, but they eventually got the whole screen going for it once you begin the journey part. If you go I highly recommend going in 200 or 300 level. So you get the dome over your head enough; if you're in 400 level it doesn't go all the way behind you. Also, there is an overhang on 100 level so you can be closer to the artists but it's actually considered limited visibility (a lot of people were notified after the fact and quite unhappy) The venue itself is capable of some amazing stuff. U2 has a lot of social media sharing showing amazing things, but it wasn't that way the whole show. It'll be exciting to see who and what winds up using it and how. I can imagine some pretty amazing EDM shows there.
- atum47 3y ago
- fecal_henge 3y agoMain hardware comment: 4 way right angled Lemo cables. Must be fancy.
- duckfruit 3y agoGreat article. The Sphere is such a ridiculous, hilarious and fantastic project. We should be build one in every city.
- ilaksh 3y agoIt's not a sphere. It's a dome.
- Apocryphon 3y agoNot with that attitude