3 ms·
Amazon had an “anonymous” internal Slack channel where you could discuss pay by using a bot to post on your behalf. It was called #pay-equity and there was anot
by scarface_74 3y ago
Amazon had an “anonymous” internal Slack channel where you could discuss pay by using a bot to post on your behalf. It was called #pay-equity and there was another one called #pay-equity-discussion.
I’m surprised anyone is crazy enough to try to work through a pip. They give you the choice of trying to work through an impossible, subjective list of requirements or take a severance that’s one month severance for each year you worked there + the partial year or “leave Amazon”.
If you fail the PIP you only get 1/3 of the amount.
If you appeal and lose you only get 1/2 of the 1/3.
Who would want to work there after they have already showed their true colors?
Amazon ain’t that serious to work for.
I worked there remotely knowing full well what Amazon was about from day one. It was my 8th job. I made my money, put it on my resume and gladly chose to “Leave Amazon” with a decent severance and had a job within three weeks.
People who choose to try to fight and stay after a PIP is like begging to stay in an abusive relationship.
- shostack 3y agoIf you're looking for a serious answer, not everyone has the extreme privilege of being as in demand and finding another job quickly, particularly in this economy. People may also have financial situations where they need to hold on to whatever hope they can of a job because it is less scary than taking the money and then taking the leap. I generally agree a company who has pipped you is effectively saying they want you gone outside of rare companies and circumstances. But don't presume that everyone's circumstances are your own.
- scarface_74 3y agoI worked as an average CRUD developer in Atlanta and first landed at AWS (ProServe) at 46 years old. I never did a coding interview in my entire life and didn’t do one for that job. That was my first job at any company of note. I had only opened the AWS console two years prior. When you get a PIP at Amazon you might as well give up. Would you rather give up $40K+ or $20k 6 weeks later or $7K when your appeal fails. I was making less than the average software developer at Amazon 5 years out of school or one working for any major tech company. Why weren’t they saving money? I knew what Amazon was about why didn’t they?
- Ancalagon 3y agoHow did you get in without a coding interview? How long was your tenure there, and why were you paid so little compared to new grads? I have a lot of questions sorry.
- scarface_74 3y agoThe position wasn’t a “software development” position. It was for someone who specialized in “application modernization” which means a combination of cloud architecture, enterprise development and building enterprise apps using AWS services and someone with customer facing experience who could lead implementations. My specialty is I don’t have a specialty. I can talk to and work with developers and teach them just as easily as I can work with the database folks, operations, etc They assume you can program at the simple level required by enterprise apps. The questions they have are have you demonstrated being able to do at scale and know how to think on a systems level - security, availability, disaster recover, throughput, etc. I had to walk through my previous system design work. They also want to know whether you can navigate the complexities of large organizations and you should be just as comfortable talking to CxOs or “the business” as developers. My interview was all behavioral. I didn’t say I was paid little compared to new grads. I said new grads five years out of school, I was a mid level consultant. Which was fair. I had only opened the AWS console two years prior and the startups and small IT companies I had been an architect with before had about the overall revenue of one “work stream” in a large enterprise implementation. I was still making 10% less than an equivalent SDE. I was also working remotely. Now, after leaving, I’m doing what would be considered L6 level work at my current job (without the L6 level compensation). There is also a clear road for me to get back to Amazon level pay either at my current company, by changing jobs or if I really wanted to deal with the hassle, going out on my own.
- claptrapper 3y agoBecause ProServe is its own job family that has a very different technical bar (and pay band) compared to the software development engineer job family.
- iaseiadit 3y ago
- BoorishBears 3y agoEven if you're not in demand, taking a guaranteed higher payout vs risking losing money and time to gamble on a process that is not designed for you to succeed. If you really want to drag privilege into this, if anything it speaks to your own to think that people in tough circumstances have the luxury of turning down money now for vague promises of a possibly better payout later.
- scarface_74 3y agoAs a 49 year old Black guy who graduated from an unknown state school in the mid 90s, I can’t recall the term “privilege” ever being applied to me…
- BoorishBears 3y agoAs a 29 year old Black guy who was born in a 3rd world country, I think people underestimate what counts as a privilege.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhen you get stopped by the police going home to your own neighborhood in a city where only 4% of the people look like you, it doesn’t matter where you are from…
- BoorishBears 3y agoThe world is vast: some people don't have the privilege of their next meal, a roof over their heads, their home even existing tomorrow. Getting stopped by cops in one of the many places where we're a minority doesn't really stack that high up on the scale of it all. The reality is you probably are privileged, and so am I compared to my parents who grew up on mud floors and lost siblings to easily preventable conditions, and that's why it's pointless to go around Hacker News of all places and throw around the "you're privileged card"... like 99.9% of the people here aren't also just for having the time to be here.
- appplication 3y agoWhat reasoning did your manager provide when putting you on the pip? That’s also not there worst severance. I assumed you didn’t get anything.
- scarface_74 3y agoThat’s a long story. It was a consulting project that I was only peripherally involved in. Suffice it to say during the three months I was on “focus” I got perfect feedback from my project managers, my coworkers and a perfect customer satisfaction score from my customers on projects I led - I worked in the AWS consulting division. Both of the customers reached out to me about working on contract after I left. I was suppose to be 80% billable and I met those targets all of the time. I refused to take on another project that would have had me juggle two full time projects that would have put my utilization at 140%. I was going to look for a job earlier. But everyone told me to wait on the PIP and the severance. I’m 49 years old and my shit tolerance level is much too low to put up with something like that. I knew someone would hire me either as a contractor or full time. My bills are really low (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36306966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36306966). The full time job I got after leaving was perfect. Not only that, a former CTO offered me a consulting contract the day I found out I had gotten pipped to troubleshoot an AWS implementation.
- ryzvonusef 3y agoWhat %age of Amazon employees "pass" the PiP? is there even hope of succeeding, or PiP just an extra-advanced termination notice?
- scarface_74 3y agoWho knows? The only way I would gamble on succeeding or getting half my compensation would be to bye time if I were here on status and the minute I lose my job the clock started ticking and I would have to leave the country. I guess if I were close to my next vesting date I would have tried to hang on.
- ipaddr 3y agoIf the vesting date falls within that period or if you have only been there for 2.5 years or less then hang on. At 3 years you get 2.75 months pay compared to the full 3 months pay. If this is your first year take the pip plus the appeal for the maximum payout.
- scarface_74 3y agoBut then you lose 1/2 the severance amount
- FireBeyond 3y agoIf it’s anything like any other company, I’d wager the number was in the single digit percentage wise, and low singles at that.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> I’m surprised anyone is crazy enough to try to work through a pip. They give you the choice of trying to work through an impossible, subjective list of requirements Not at Amazon but at a tech company everyone here knows, I was put on a farcical PIP. The requirements were actually reasonable in themselves, and I thought I did a decent job of meeting them. Lo and behold, final day, zoom meeting with boss and HR is there. Boss: “well, we put you on a pip for x, and after reviewing your work towards the goals set out it was decided your performance remained unsatisfactory”. I’d had an inkling. And everything was done in GDocs. So I asked him in front of HR, “so this, and this, and this, were reviewed and are unsatisfactory?” Yep. “I’m confused how you came to that conclusion because of the six work products created around these goals and shared with you, you’ve only ever looked at one, and that was before the PIP.” I reviewed them all. At which point I started sharing my screen and showed that according to GDocs he had in fact not looked at five of the six items, ever. He turned his camera off and said “we spoke about these extensively”. “When? In our 20 minutes weekly 1:1s, two of which you no showed?” (I realized this bridge was burned so I was nuking it). “We talked a lot more in Google Chat”. I pulled up our chat history for the duration of the PIP, which was easy enough, since it consisted of me giving him about a dozen updates and asking a similar number of questions, but not a single reply for the entire month. He’d basically just ghosted me - that adage about a PIP being a termination with 30 days notice is utterly true for the most part. HR had at least the common decency to look embarrassed at me calling that out, and making a similar comment, and my boss, true to fashion, said nothing the remainder of the call. A few days later someone higher in HR acknowledged that they’d looked at the same things and confirmed my perspective and said that the managers handling of the PIP was not how it should have been but that their decision was final (which was fine, I never expected it to change anyone’s mind). I made some final comments about how I thought it “odd” that manager had also talked about good things that other managers had said about working with me and that two had said if I wanted a change in direction they’d be happy to have me in their team, but somehow my efforts were insufficient. I just chalked it to personality conflict - he was a new hire and we’d never really meshed. Your last point though, so true - even if somehow they’d reconsidered I couldn’t possibly imagine working under him or even in our business unit.
- TwentyPosts 3y ago
- lumost 3y agoNot everyone has a work authorization to take the next job in 3 weeks.
- scarface_74 3y agoI understand that, one of my coworkers who is a good friend who I mentored during his onboarding process is in a constant state of fear and put up with a lot more shit on the project that started the whole thing for me. Others on the project either left AWS, nope’d out of the project or also got fired. I kept him abreast of the entire process I went through and the warning signs so he could be ready. Yes it sucks because no matter how much money he saves and how financially prepared he was, he would have to find another full time job quickly. I knew worst case I could put my virtual shingle out and do independent AWS consulting. I had a dormant LLC already that I could reactivate, I had a network and other consulting companies fall all over themselves to hire former ProServe consultants. He was just as good in his specialty as I was in mine. Another guy got sick of the project and got a job at Netflix in the data department.
- aosmith 3y agoI fought through a PIP once just because I'm a stubborn idiot. Survived the pip and found a new job shortly after. It's not something I would recommend.
- scarface_74 3y agoI did fight through a pip once about a decade ago because honestly even then with just a little retrospective, it was obviously my fault. I came into the company like a bull in a china shop and didn’t build relationships and inadvertently stepped on the wrong toes - some team leads that were a decade younger than I was. It was my second job I had after starting my recovery from “expert beginnerism” where I had been at my second job for nine years. I knew I had to learn how to place nice with people to get to the next step in my career and I also knew that I could get a job quickly - it was 2014. On top of that there was project I was leading I wanted to finish. I’m glad I did work through it. It was a great learning experience. Honestly the focus period at AWS made me step my game up and prepared me for my current architectural leadership position at my current company. I’ve never had to lead an initiative at this scale before inside a company and they wouldn’t have trusted me to do without AWS on my resume.