67 ms·
Next year, SpaceX aims to average one launch every 2.5 days
- vb6sp6 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway5959 3y ago> The Falcon 9 B uses 29,600 gallons, equivalent to 112,184 Kg of kerosene per launch.4 For each kilogram of kerosene burned, 3 Kg of CO2 goes into the air.5 112,184 Kg x 3 Kg CO2 = 336,552 Kg That means 336,552 kilograms of CO2 go into the atmosphere every time Falcon 9 is launched. Source: https://8billiontrees.com/carbon-offsets-credits/carbon-footprint-of-space-travel/#:~:text=The%20Falcon%209%20B%20uses,Kg%20of%20kerosene%20per%20launch.&text=For%20each%20kilogram%20of%20kerosene,2%20goes%20into%20the%20air.&text=That%20means%20336%2C552%20kilograms%20of,time%20Falcon%209%20is%20launched https://8billiontrees.com/carbon-offsets-credits/carbon-foot...
- mdeeks 3y agoI wasn’t sure if that was a lot. It sounds like a lot. But the linked article says it is the equivalent of the pollution of 73 cars in a year per launch. That actually doesn’t sound too bad?
- wilg 3y agoThis is about as much as a normal flight from LA to Sydney. Unfortunately there is no real way to do rocketry without burning fuel. We will have to offset it with carbon capture.
- avmich 3y agoTheoretically, hydrogen or ammonia burning don't produce CO2, among relatively popular rocket fuels. In practice, methane could make less CO2 than kerosene. Also, rockets are still relatively small part of aviation regarding exhaust, though with SpaceX efforts the rockets part will grow.
- wilg 3y agoSpaceX's next-generation rocket uses methane, at least.
- throwaway5959 3y agoWhich they can also manufacturer and refuel I imagine on site, which is neat.
- rbanffy 3y ago> Unfortunately there is no real way to do rocketry without burning fuel True, but NASA uses hydrolox for the SLS (apart from the uber-polluting SRBs). At least it doesn't dump CO2 in the high atmosphere.
- nickik 3y agoWhere do you think hydrogen comes from?
- jryle70 3y agoOne of the commenters on the article put it in perspective: 144 Falcon launches is less than the emissions of just the flights that take off from O'Hare in a single day. 1) Fully fueled Falcon 9 uses about 180,000kg of RP-1 2) 144 flights totals 24,920,000kg 3) O'Hare has about 1000 flights a day (about 900 domestic, 100 international) 4) 737 holds about 20,000kg of fuel (The 747 can hold 160,000kg) 5) 90/10 split gives a total of 34,000,000kg
- bmitc 3y agoIt isn't an accurate comparison. For one, rockets dump their pollutants into the upper atmosphere, unlike cars and airplanes.
- throwaway5959 3y agoCO2 doesn’t cancel out. It’s just stacking in our atmosphere.
- manuelmoreale 3y agoRelevant video that goes quite deep into the topic if you’re actually concerned about rocket pollution: https://youtube.com/watch?v=C4VHfmiwuv4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=C4VHfmiwuv4
- DarmokJalad1701 3y agoHow much of that is actually burned in the atmosphere? The rocket gets past 10 km (troposphere) in about a minute, 50km (height of stratosphere) in a little over two minutes and is over the Karman line by the three minute mark. The total burn time may be 9-10 minutes (or maybe a bit more, if there is a circularization burn). So it's not like that entire fuel load is getting burned at sea level. Majority of the CO2 is going into the vacuum of space - which is a pretty good place for fossil fuel CO2 to go to.
- avmich 3y agoRecently talking remotely on a space conference in Baku Musk talked about launching Starship 10 times a day from an ocean platform, as it will probably be "too much" for Cape Canaveral. That's 3000+ launches per year, each with 100 t payload, a couple orders of magnitude more than today's mass flow to orbit. Yet at the same time he talked about a million tons on the surface of Mars, which means 5 million tons on the LEO, which means 50000 launches - still some 15 times more than that. So maybe Starship will fly even more often, at least from all launching pads on Earth, especially given that there would be other uses for it. We're swiftly moving towards a cislunar civilization.
- bmitc 3y agoI thought he "cared" about the climate?
- throwaway69123 3y agoTrending this out are you suggesting the solution to climate change is devolution?
- morsch 3y agoTrending it out, the long term consequence of not dealing with climate change is devolution.
- schiffern 3y agoLet's not forget the original point. "Not dealing with climate change" is quite a misleading characterization of Elon Musk, his actions, and his "cares." If Elon Musk doesn't "care" about climate change just because every actions in his life isn't 100% devoted (monk-like) to maximum action on that issue, then I think you can successfully argue that nobody in human history has ever "cared" about anything. The word becomes meaningless if you redefine it that hard.
- 3y ago
- sidcool 3y agoMan. They are setting a new bar for the launch industry.
- raffraffraff 3y agoPfffff. Why? What's the point? What needs to go into space every 2.5 days? What's the co² footprint of each flight. Fuck off Musk, you child.
- Dig1t 3y agoAnti-science, anti-technology. “Rocket man bad”
- avmich 3y agoFor long time we had the conservatives who question the new ways of doing things, who don't like the tradeoffs of new benefits vs. new drawbacks. It's a bit amusing to have them on this site :) but that's how people's opinions are distributed.
- kbelder 3y ago>What needs to go into space every 2.5 days? Humans. It's an absolute requirement.
- mdhen 3y agoWhy is a luddite on hacker news?
- raffraffraff 3y agoDo you think that some day humans are gonna live on Earth II? Or on the moon? Are you a child from the 1950s? "Earth I" has a climate crisis that should be our top concern. I'm all for pushing boundaries that matter, if the cost isn't stupidly high. But this is the work of a billionaire narcissist that came up the the cybertruck. The fucking cybertruck. What's the upside of this delusional enterprise? We get better at sending rockets a pathetically short distance from the planet. Great. Space is extremely vast and mostly empty and it takes an incredible amount of finite energy and creates an incredible amount of co² emissions to do this. I'm not a Luddite, I just think that this is extremely wasteful and harmful, and in the grand scene of things, pointless. A pointless pissing contest, and an ego vehicle for Musk. I suppose I'm also a Luddite because I don't babble about crypto.