6 ms·
Windows 11 Pro's On-by-Default Encryption Slows SSDs Up to 45%
- robotnikman 3y ago>While many SSDs come with hardware-based encryption, which does all the processing directly on the drive, Windows 11 Pro force-enables the software version of BitLocker during installation IIRC thought the whole reason for this was because the Hardware-based encryption turned out to be so terrible on just about every drive that Microsoft just decided to not even bother using it.
- init2null 3y agoI wouldn't use them. Is there any chance at all that those don't have an NSA backdoor? I think most hardware encryption just XOR's on the phrase "We're the government. It's for your own good."
- amluto 3y agoIf I’m encrypting my disk, the NSA is far at the bottom of people I want to be safe from. At least the NSA might make a reasonably well implemented backdoor.
- fortran77 3y agoMy sympathies to you if you feel the NSA is the biggest threat you're facing. I just don't want somone who steals my laptop to be able to empty my bank account. That's why I always turn whole disk encryption on.
- Dah00n 3y agoThe same chance as Windows encryption having a backdoor of course.
- infogulch 3y agoWindows encryption could at least theoretically be audited via decompilation, whatever firmware happens to be installed on your random hard drive? Not a chance.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI think if a state entity is dead set on acquiring your data, they will do that once they have access to the chips. This notion that your encryption- any encryption- is going to stop a state-funded actor from getting past to your data is just as ridiculous IMO as the people who stockpile AR-15's and cosplay soldiers on the weekends think they're a realistic threat to the same military that has predator drones. If the government wants your data, they probably already have it, just like if they wanted you dead, you'd already be in the ground. Assuming there's enough left of you to bury anyway.
- infogulch 3y ago"State actor defeatist"-style arguments against taking any technical precautions often conflate two things that the government does: 1. Large scale mostly passive dragnet surveillance, 2. Individually targeted surveillance. Reasonable people can admit that they can't do much about case 2, while still believing that applying countermeasures against 1 can be effective. Also note there is more than one government in the world that may intend to exploit your lack of privacy... Just because you're given up on privacy and sovereignty doesn't mean you should go around infecting others with the same contagion.
- JohnFen 3y agoTrue, but worrying that your hard disk encryption is vulnerable to the NSA is something that only makes sense if you're dealing with case 2, not case 1.
- vGPU 3y agoAnd yet, Afghanistan sent the US military packing.
- colechristensen 3y agoWell if I were trying to defend myself against the NSA I would be doing different things entirely… alas there is no threat model I’m concerned with that includes the NSA. For starters hard drive encryption would be the least of my worries.
- JohnFen 3y agoExactly this. If your threat profile includes the possibility of special governmental attention, then you're playing a much more serious game and need to be off the grid entirely.
- borissk 3y agoThe only way to keep your data safe if the NSA decides they want to have a look, is to not use modern technology. Even if you have the type of resources that a big tech corporation like Google has, sooner or later the NSA will get a copy of your data.
- throaway920181 3y agoIs there any chance that Microsoft's disk encryption doesn't have an NSA backdoor?
- rwaksmunski 3y agoChances are that Microsoft disk encryption implementation is so bad, that an explicit NSA backdoor is not necessary.
- stg22 3y agoIf it does, there's zero chance that Microsoft know about it. When your company is worth $2,427,000,000,000 , you'd have to be insane to risk it all like that.
- aydyn 3y agoThe primary value of bitlocker is to defend against theft, not the NSA.
- wkat4242 3y agoAnd if you use Windows the way Microsoft wants you to, all your data is already on OneDrive, Teams, SharePoint (which actually is the backend for the former too). Which the NSA can simply demand access to.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- KennyBlanken 3y agoOn-drive encryption serves to allow for secure erase which would otherwise require an entire write cycle and cannot be done at an OS level anyway due to wear leveling and reserved space. It is not intended for providing privacy or security.
- neodymiumphish 3y agoIs secure erase reliable? If so, how can you say the intent of the encryption isn't security?
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoSecure erase via sledgehammer is pretty reliable.
- supertrope 3y agoIt depends on your threat model. Just enabling BitLocker will defeat someone from plugging in a Linux live USB and resetting your Windows password. For corporate security ATA Secure Erase done by a vendor who accepts liability and gives them a "certificate of data destruction" may be enough to meet HIPAA, FERPA, SOX compliance requirements. Or they consider drives cheap enough that physically shredding them to ensure no mistakes is the better choice. At the national security level you pulverize the drives after zeroing them, likely in a windowless room inside a facility with armed guards.
- neodymiumphish 3y agoAs one who's actually had the pleasure of getting to use one of the classified drive destroyers, there aren't armed guards. Not sure if there's a requirement that it be done in a room with no windows, though. My point was that Kenny's claim is that on-drive encryption allows for easier "erasure", presumably by deleting the keys needed to decrypt the data and leaving the drive in the same state. If that process is good enough to ensure proper "erasure" of the data (effectively complete prevention of data access), then how is it not equally secure as an encryption schema?
- 3y ago
- jiggawatts 3y agoI looked into it after buying an expensive SSD that supported the Opal encryption standard. Apparently several vendors were using fixed encryption keys and at least one vendor was using all zeros as the AES key!
- throw0101c 3y ago> IIRC thought the whole reason for this was because the Hardware-based encryption turned out to be so terrible on just about every drive that Microsoft just decided to not even bother using it. From 2018: > The two [researchers] say that the SEDs they've analyzed, allowed users to set a password that decrypted their data, but also came with support for a so-called "master password" that was set by the SED vendor. > Any attacker who read an SED's manual can use this master password to gain access to the user's encrypted password, effectively bypassing the user's custom password. > The only way users would be safe was if they either changed the master password or if they 'd configure the SED's Master Password Capability setting to "Maximum," which effectively disables it. * https://www.zdnet.com/article/flaws-in-self-encrypting-ssds-let-attackers-bypass-disk-encryption/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/flaws-in-self-encrypting-ssds-...
- hu3 3y agoI guess mileage varies but I'm using Windows 11 Pro and running `manage-bde -status` tells me none of my drives are encrypted. And I don't remember being offered to when installing it.
- belter 3y ago"Is your Windows 11 PC encrypted? The answer is surprisingly complex" - https://www.pcworld.com/article/624593/is-your-windows-11-pc-encrypted-the-answer-is-surprisingly-complex.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/624593/is-your-windows-11-pc...
- f233f2 3y agoIt's absurd that this web site is advocating for people to disable bitlocker. Also there is no source for the 45% figure.
- crazygringo 3y agoThe sources are their own tests described further down in the article. It mostly describes slowdowns of between 0–20%, but does say: > But the critical aspect is that software BitLocker dropped random write performance by 45% compared to hardware BitLocker. I don't think consumers are engaging in a lot of sustained random writes. On the other hand, it might be a reason to avoid software encryption on a database server with a lot of writes.
- dmitrygr 3y ago> I don't think consumers are engaging in a lot of sustained random writes. Let me introduce you to Windows update. It is both random and sustained permanently.
- HPsquared 3y agoWindows Update must be such an energy hog, if you consider it across all users globally. I wonder how many MWh it consumes per year?
- crazygringo 3y agoHa, good point. Definitely wasn't thinking of OS updates. Though if those are (hopefully) applied overnight, speed doesn't really matter.
- dmitrygr 3y agoOvernight... https://www.google.com/search?q=windows+update+forces+random+reboot https://www.google.com/search?q=windows+update+forces+random...
- 3y ago
- jwitthuhn 3y agoIs this a new thing? I installed windows 11 fresh about a year ago and it did not force me (or to my memory, even offer) to use bitlocker during setup.
- xnx 3y agoCombine this with the performance hit from continuous Windows Defender scanning and whatever spyware (e.g. Carbon Black) that IT installed, and you quickly get to an actively productivity-antagonistic performance situation on Windows.
- borissk 3y agoA modern PC/laptop - one with Zen 4 or Intel 12-14 gen CPU with 8+ cores - has so much spare performance, that it works perfectly well with software encryption , defender scanning, memory isolation, security bugs mitigations, etc. Don't know about enterprise IT software - haven't worked in/with big companies lately.
- Filligree 3y agoSure, if you don't care about battery life at all.
- GeekyBear 3y agoOr bandwidth.
- HPsquared 3y agoWe're talking about latency, mostly. This is about single-thread performance in many cases.
- runjake 3y ago1. A good percentage of corp people do not have these specs. 2. The whole point of the comment was enterprise IT software, and I can confirm it severely impacts the performance of high-spec computers with stuff like 32GB mem and NVMe SSDs.
- kibibu 3y agoMy work laptop is the lowest performance pc I've ever used, largely due to Windows defender and whatever interactions it has with other software. Sure it streams videos and so on (so cpu performance is OK), but basic stuff like "opening a word doc" or "launching Explorer" takes 10s of seconds. I'm back to waking up my pc and going to get a coffee for 15 minutes so it might be ready to use when I return.
- darklycan51 3y agoWow ok this sounds significant, of course up to can mean a lot but even if it is 10/20% it's a lot.
- mickelsen 3y agoWas it always like this with Windows and SW Bitlocker then? On the Mac, for more than 10 years Filevault FDE has been unnoticeable in terms of a performance hit. I remember that back then, before Macs had SSDs they also offered FV that only encrypted the user folder.
- speedgoose 3y agoA coworker claims that his personal MacBook Air m1 without encryption is much faster to update MacOs than his work MacBook Pro m2 with encryption.
- acdha 3y agoI’d want to see real benchmarks to make sure that’s not due to a confound (e.g. updates used to be slowed by things like Homebrew having huge numbers of files in the /usr/local directory which were inefficiently moved & restored by the installer). Every time I’ve tested it the difference has been negligible.
- runjake 3y agoYour coworker is "full of it" for the following reasons: - Storage is always encrypted on Apple Silicon Macs.[1] - You can enable FileVault, but all FileVault does on Apple Silicon is add the user's password as an additional key[2]. There is not an additional performance hit with FileVault. 1. https://support.apple.com/guide/security/data-protection-overview-secf6276da8a/web https://support.apple.com/guide/security/data-protection-ove... 2. https://support.apple.com/guide/security/volume-encryption-with-filevault-sec4c6dc1b6e/web https://support.apple.com/guide/security/volume-encryption-w...
- mickelsen 3y agoWow! So this explains why setting it up later down the road is almost instant on Macs with T2 or M1/M2? Because IIRC with <2016 macs there was a long wait if you already have been using that disk for a while.
- speedgoose 3y ago
- butlike 3y agoMust be using a strong algo if it's that slow
- orbital-decay 3y ago> If you are working with a desktop PC in your home and you feel really confident that nobody's going to have unauthorized physical access to the computer, you might want to do without encryption. Do you also feel confident nobody will pick your drive up at the landfill where it's going to end up?
- neodymiumphish 3y agoWorking with a Desktop PC in your home isn't the same thing as throwing your obsolete drive in the trash. There are precautions available to any user before they throw a drive away.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoAgreed, that feels like horrible advice. Even encryption with a password of “hunter2” is worthwhile in that it would stop untargeted access. Crackhead burgling my home is significantly higher risk than the NSA trying to grab my data. If the NSA wants it, my cute 32 character random password is probably insufficient to stop them.
- mickelsen 3y agoYea, I'm not sure about the US, but a few friends have had their stolen phones immediately used to contact everyone on whatsapp asking for money, sim swapped and tried access for all possible 2FAs on socials, banking, whatever they can get a hold of within the same day. For something so easy to set up as FDE on a computer, or a SIM pin in addition to the phone's passcode (to prevent them from accessing the mobile network, which I forever dismissed but after seeing how they operate I started adding the pin as well), it's a no brainer really.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoThis is the first I have ever heard of a SIM pin. Which seems like a no brainier to configure, so definitely going to do that this weekend.
- fortran77 3y agoYou really should have whole-disk encryption on any laptop. You're crazy not to, unless you never do any banking, etc, on it.
- DigitallyFidget 3y agoI don't know what Windows 11 Pro version has bitlocker on by default, but none of the systems I have at home enabled it as a default setting. Whether upgrading from 10 or complete nuke the drive and install fresh, I haven't seen it be a default setting.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoShould have just used zfs....
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoI spent a lot of time on my last install to get Hardware Encryption to work. While it has been disabled by Microsoft by Default I prefer to have it enabled as it covers my thread model. The only thing that is hard to find these days is SSDs with 4K AND OPAL. The WD 850X has 4K clusters, but not OPAL. The Samsung 980 Pro has 515B clusters, and OPAL. Not sure about the Samsung 990 Pro.
- zelly 3y agoLUKS doesn’t have this problem. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, it’s a matter of time before Windows runs on the Linux kernel. It’ll just be this big monoculture like Chromium with browsers. There really isn’t any reason to duplicate all this effort in maintaining an OS. Might as well have the whole world pitch in on one strong project.