3 ms·
The main problem I have with most CAD software is that I can't do: 1. create an object, e.g. a cube 2. perform lots of random transformations 3. pe
by amelius 3y ago
The main problem I have with most CAD software is that I can't do:
1. create an object, e.g. a cube
2. perform lots of random transformations
3. perform the inverse of the above transformations
4. subtract the object from the original object
5. end up with exactly nothing
How are modern approaches solving this (robustness), if at all?
- abrouwers 3y agoAs someone who does CAD work (product design) every day, I'm curious about the use case? Starting with Surfaces (in Creo, at least) can be provide such flexibility.
- amelius 3y agoI don't have a practical usecase, it's just the fact that most CAD software is not mathematically correct that bothers me.
- dymk 3y agoAs far as I'm aware, we do not have the math needed to do what you're imagining. CSG requires a lot of numerical methods even for relatively simple operations.
- ahmetrcagil 3y agoWhat is the inverse operation of, say, beveling?
- amelius 3y agoBeveling is a lossy operation, so there is no inverse in general.
- iancmceachern 3y agoDeleting the bevel
- iancmceachern 3y agoSolidworks would do this no problem
- iancmceachern 3y agoYou can even use python or solidworks' own api to do it programmatically