8 ms·
Ozone hole goes large again
- romusha 3y ago[flagged]
- brutusborn 3y agoThis will make skin cancers slightly more prevalent in southern latitudes but I can’t see any other changes that aren’t marginal. It isn’t great but we are not “fucked” by any means.
- brunoqc 3y ago[flagged]
- PheonixPharts 3y ago> We deserve to burn. As quite a bit of a doomer myself, I think this attitude is extremely dangerous and really an incorrect view of the situation. Blame is inevitable when facing despair, but I think it's not a great idea to turn this into an issue about blaming yourself or others. Human beings are terrible at long term risk/reward reasoning. But this is a pretty expected consequence of any evolved species. There is zero pressure in the evolutionary system to encourage a species to develop the ability to both reason about very long term events, and act on them. Evolutionary forces just don't respond to things on this time scale. Climate change has always had the problem that the easier it was to solve, the more uncertain we were about it's effects. In 1900 we could have easily just stopped progressing, learned to become sustainable and avoided climate change at very little cost. But how would anyone seriously believe and be concerned about an existential threat to their great, great grandchildren? As the existential risk of climate change becomes more obvious, the cost to avoid it increases dramatically. There is no stopping climate change now, and even limiting its impact (which we can always do) would require a massive disruption to our way of life. We're fighting wars right now to access more fossil fuels, we aren't ready to seriously start keeping them in the ground. Our tragedy as a species is that we can see how to avoid climate change but are unable to act on it by our nature. If anything us all being "fucked" should evoke a sense of pathos. We're no different than any other living organism exposed to sources of non-renewable, cheap, high density energy. The yeast that die making the alcohol in our beer suffer the same local climate catastrophe as we will.
- brunoqc 3y ago> We're no different than any other living organism exposed to sources of non-renewable, cheap, high density energy. But we have money, the only thing we really care about. We live on a rich rock but for some reason, the whole planet is bankrupt. It's like if we got stolen by our ancestors and we dumbasses like to keep this tradition alive, maybe hoping that we will, us individually, one day, get richer than the guy next door, and feel superior, and maybe, happy.
- dmichulke 3y ago[flagged]
- junon 3y agoYeesh, I don't agree with them but don't put words and ideas in their mouth. What an incredibly unfair comment.
- dmichulke 3y agoYou literally wrote that my kids and I deserve to burn, so there's that. I don't feel offended because I don't think that was your intention but it was what you said.
- ClassyJacket 3y agoNo, but we are fucked from climate change.
- lovecg 3y agoNah, people will just buy more A/Cs. But the ecosystem collapse will do us in.
- brutusborn 3y agoAgain I disagree. The worst predictions for climate change are not based on very solid models. There are lots of clever people who are skeptical of the doomerism. As an example, the claim that more people will die from heat waves is correct, but when you compare it to the people who won’t die from cold weather then climate change is a net benefit! And in terms of environmental collapses, things like the health of ocean ecosystems is more dependent on human activities like overfishing. Focusing on climate change to fix these problems is nonsensical.
- yreg 3y agoWhat about ocean acidification? That is connected to CO2 in the atmosphere and had a good chance of leading to collapse of marine ecosystems, no?
- brutusborn 3y agoThat is definitely my biggest worry ocean-wise. I haven’t read many acidification papers but the impression I get is that ocean absorption of CO2 is relatively slow so we will only start to see noticeable changes on the order of centuries. If these problems occur faster than we can decarbonise then we will need to geoengineer ocean chemistry. Although this is a plan B, we will be able to implement it before there are significant enough changes to cause a collapse.
- spiritplumber 3y agoThis is worrying - wasn't this the one environmental thing we had managed to fix?
- dbetteridge 3y ago“The eruption of the Hunga Tonga volcano in January 2022 injected a lot of water vapour into the stratosphere which only reached the south polar regions after the end of the 2022 ozone hole. “The water vapour could have led to the heightened formation of polar stratospheric clouds, where chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) can react and accelerate ozone depletion. The presence of water vapour may also contribute to the cooling of the Antarctic stratosphere, further enhancing the formation of these polar stratospheric clouds and resulting in a more robust polar vortex.” Sounds like more of a natural expansion of the human created phenomenon, hopefully temporary
- Enginerrrd 3y agoPersonally I suspect someone is cheating on their emissions, or using something that's a bit cheaper but is ozone damaging in some process.
- 83 3y agoIts pretty well documented someone is producing cfcs. https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-48353341 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-48353341
- 6th 3y agoFunny that article doesn't mention https://research.noaa.gov/2022/03/09/two-additional-regions-of-asia-were-sources-of-banned-ozone-destroying-chemicals/ https://research.noaa.gov/2022/03/09/two-additional-regions-... Were they just asleep?
- brutusborn 3y agoThe only reason I can think of is to avoid diplomatic problems. When scientific reporting doesn’t make sense it is either due to ignorance or politics, and I doubt the ESA has an issue with ignorance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Brajeshwar 3y agoIt is not just human-made, but of late, and unfortunately, our earth hasn't been very kind to itself.
- Sosh101 3y agoIf the CFCs were not in the atmosphere, the natural occurrences would not have had this effect.
- lopis 3y agoYou mean kind to it's tenants. The earth will be fine.
- throwaway290 3y agoHumans are not tenants they are part of the planet.
- jdiez17 3y agoThe Earth will be just fine without humans.
- thicknavyrain 3y agoI find this kind of sentiment a little vacuous. Charitably, we might say "Much of the non-human life on Earth will be just fine without humans" but the kinds of ecological disaster that would wipe us would would take a significant chunk of other life along with it. Beyond that, what value is a floating chunk of rock except for the very fact it sustains conscious life, the only thing capable of valuing it? Humans, and other forms of life, are pretty much entirely what makes Earth worth caring about at all.
- morph123 3y agoValue is a human concept.
- euos 3y ago[flagged]
- LordShredda 3y agoAre you just mad that the Montreal Protocol worked?
- euos 3y ago[flagged]
- idiotsecant 3y agoWhat's it like to have a worldview that is decoupled from all physical evidence?
- bonzini 3y agoIf you're kind, unconsciously avoiding something scary. If you're not, unconsciously avoiding something scary while thinking that you are smarter than the rest.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoAre you serious? It "just went away?" CFCs were identified as the driving force, and the Montreal Protocol was ratified by nearly all nations in 1987, banning nearly all uses of CFC. And nations actually put it into effect; it wasn't just a paper agreement. It took decades but natural processes went back closer to its old equilibrium.
- tr_user 3y agoEco activists are too alarmed. DO your own research.
- ClassyJacket 3y agoIt "just went away" because governments listened to scientists and took drastic action to fix it.
- latchkey 3y agoIt got flagged, but there was a fair bit of discussion and comments: [flagged] The ozone hole above Antarctica has grown to three times the size of Brazil https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37793941 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37793941
- nomel 3y agoThe snippet from the top comment is worth reposting: > Yet despite experiencing large seasonal growth this year, the ozone hole is still decreasing in size overall. "Based on the Montreal Protocol and the decrease of anthropogenic ozone-depleting substances, scientists currently predict that the global ozone layer will reach its normal state again by around 2050," said Claus Zehner, ESA's mission manager for Copernicus Sentinel-5P.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoWasn't there a story about satellite imagery detecting massive CFC releases in China from expandable foam? Edit: found one... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/23/china-factories-releasing-thousands-of-tonnes-of-illegal-cfc-gases-study-finds https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/23/china-factorie...
- lloydatkinson 3y ago[flagged]
- atoav 3y agoIf you find yourself often linking two totally disimilar things like this you should probably do some introspection. I know it is popular to tell oneself: "but China", so one can stop thinking about what we can do, but China as of 2023 has 3 times (!) the capacity of installed renewable energy than the US. You can always find some metric where your side looks better and the other worse, the trick is not to let yourself use it to excuse your own bullshit unless you love to actively harm yourself.
- acdha 3y ago> You can always find some metric where your side looks better and the other worse, the trick is not to let yourself use it to excuse your own bullshit unless you love to actively harm yourself. This is such an important point. My family’s been in the Los Angeles area since the 1950s and I remember a semi-constant stream of whining from conservatives about California’s environmental laws, and that “someone else will just pollute more” excuse for inaction was a common refrain. This was always annoying because even if we assume that the global situation will get worse, it’s not just less bad than it would have been but also locally they reduced a massive number of deaths, illnesses, asthma cases, etc. not to mention the quality of life improvements from not getting headaches or having days where you can’t see across the street. Even if removing plastic straws or bags isn’t going to save the world, anyone who likes going to the water is going to appreciate not having all of that trash visible. The other thing we always need to keep in mind is that we are living in huge, well-developed economies with millions of people. We can do many things at once and something like a ban on single-use plastic is not a huge time sink. We banned disposable plastic bags here, and despite all of the dire predictions it took less than a week to adjust.
- nologic01 3y agoThey point to natural and temporary causes but the effect highlights at least two challenges that will complicate combating climate change: 1) Comprehensive monitoring of local releases into the atmosphere will be required to prevent ugly surprises and 2) Human impact interacts with natural phenomena in difficult to predict ways (the famous tipping points are effectively non-reversible examples of this)
- AriedK 3y agohttps://timharford.com/2022/11/cautionary-tales-the-inventor-who-almost-ended-the-world/ https://timharford.com/2022/11/cautionary-tales-the-inventor... This is a podcast worth listening to, on the inventor of CFCs and the global response to the first discovery of the hole in the ozone layer.
- okokwhatever 3y agoSo the hole grows and shrinks continuously... mmm... this time it must be...
- noam_compsci 3y ago[flagged]
- dghughes 3y agoThere have been a lot of large volume methane releases too methane are much worse ozone damaging molecule compared to CFCs. Plus Siberia and northern regions with melting permafrost are releasing large amounts of methane. Turkmenistan seems to be the worst for methane emissions from industry. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/mar/06/revealed-1000-super-emitting-methane-leaks-risk-triggering-climate-tipping-points https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/mar/06/revealed... >The variability of the size of the ozone hole is largely determined by the strength of a strong wind band that flows around the Antarctic area. Who knew water and winds could also damage the ozone layer?!
- altcognito 3y agoIt is the opposite. Methane eventually degraded to ozone: https://www.envchemgroup.com/climate-change-methane-and-ozone.html#:~:text=Oxidation%20of%20methane%20is%20responsible,by%20the%20levels%20of%20ozone https://www.envchemgroup.com/climate-change-methane-and-ozon.... It will take many years for this ozone to reach the high levels of the atmosphere
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- telegpt 3y ago[dead]
- lakomen 3y ago[flagged]
- hnarn 3y agoI agree with you, but this is the European Space Agency which makes it more or less impossible that the syntax is mm/dd/yyyy since that is (as far as I know) essentially exclusively used by Americans.
- tremon 3y agoYes, but the regular date notation in Europe is dd-mm-yyyy (with dashes, not slashes). My default heuristic is to interpret dashes as dd-mm-yyyy, but slashes as mm/yy/dddd instead.
- hnarn 3y agothat’s simply not true unfortunately, slashes are the norm in France for example, and Germany even uses dots quite often.
- defrost 3y agoIt's ESA - the European Space Agency so it's the more sensible dd/mm/yyyy 4th of October posting. For confirmation it refers to a graphic dated 24-09-2023 which has to be dd-mm-yyyy and places the article after the ninth month. There are very few countries that use mm dd yyyy, mainly just United States, Canada, and the Philippines with a few other minor cases.
- speed_spread 3y ago_Officially_, Canada's locale uses yyyy-mm-dd. But the American date format still has the popular favor, because reasons.
- resolutebat 3y agoIt goes "large again" every year with the seasons, but the overall trend is that it's still shrinking: Claus concludes, “Based on the Montreal Protocol and the decrease of anthropogenic ozone-depleting substances, scientists currently predict that the global ozone layer will reach its normal state again by around 2050.”
- arrowsmith 3y agoImagine if we'd invented CFCs but hadn't invented a way to monitor atmospheric O3 levels. We'd have burned the entire ozone layer away before we even realised that anything was wrong.
- makeworld 3y agoI wonder if we are currently not monitoring something similar that we should be.
- arrowsmith 3y agoMe too, but I'm far more concerned about the looming catastrophic problems that we are monitoring.
- Mistletoe 3y ago> In response to this, the Montreal Protocol was created in 1987 to protect the ozone layer by phasing out the production and consumption of these harmful substances, which is leading to a recovery of the ozone layer. If the hole happened now I’m sure CFC manufacturers would have AI-powered Cambridge Analytica-style social media campaigns creating ozone hole deniers and CFCs=Freedom groups and we would be arguing until the end of time over this as the ozone depleted. Thank goodness the Montreal Protocol was created in a different era where that couldn’t happen.
- XavierFras 3y ago[dead]