6 ms·
Google's 21-year deal with Apple is the "heart" of monopoly case, judge says
- tpmx 3y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/25/technology/apple-google-search-antitrust.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/25/technology/apple-google-s... (https://archive.is/loAMx https://archive.is/loAMx) Apple expanded the deal for its big upcoming product: the iPhone. When Mr. Jobs unveiled the iPhone in 2007, he invited Eric Schmidt, Google’s then chief executive, to join him onstage for the first of Apple’s many famous iPhone events. “If we just sort of merged the two companies, we could just call them AppleGoo,” joked Mr. Schmidt, who was also on Apple’s board of directors. With Google search on the iPhone, he added, “you can actually merge without merging.”
- frou_dh 3y agoIt's interesting to consider that Google was a fairly young company when the original iPhone came out - only 8 years old.
- mrkramer 3y agoOnly 8 years old but already dominating web search industry. They destroyed AltaVista within like 5 years.
- tpmx 3y agoThe "web search industry" back then wasn't very large. AltaVista was kind of a PR project at DEC. It took Doubleclick's supposed reverse take-over of Google to crack the nut of how to make money from web search.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alphabetting 3y agoThe comments in the piece say Mozilla is screwed if Google is no longer allowed to pay for default search. Is that accurate?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago[flagged]
- influx 3y agoCan you expand a bit?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoBecause anything can happen. There's no guarantee they're screwed or out of options. We also don't know what the penalty will be if Google loses.
- stonemetal12 3y agoA quick search suggests 86% of Mozilla's 2020 revenue came from their Google deal. I haven't heard of any major funding changes at Mozilla, so I would guess that is still the case. 80+% of their revenue up in smoke sounds pretty dire. They would certainly need to come up with something on the quick.
- metadat 3y agoDoes Mozilla spend more than 14% of the annual budget on maintaining and improving Firefox? Based on the past few years of releases, I suspect not.. I wouldn't much mind or likely even notice if 98% of their other efforts halted (including political activities). Imagine a world where Mozilla shifted focus solely to creating a technically excellent web browser.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoI've said it before. If Mozilla stopped with their nonsense and charged an optional $9 a month for a Developer build of Firefox (which ALREADY exists mind you) under the guarantee that all proceeds would go to funding Firefox, I would pay it every month. They're not even needing to build a new type of Firefox browser build, Developer edition already exists. If you tell your potential customer base that this would be the case, I'm sure plenty of devs would buy into it. Especially if they invest in dev tool enhancements. There's still so many random things I'm astounded that not even Chrome Dev Tools can capture, like if I'm debugging postMessage, why isn't there a tool to see what messages are going from what document to what host and so on. https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/developer/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/developer/
- elicash 3y agoThis case makes zero sense to me. If just paying Apple for default automatically makes you the highest quality search engine and number one in the market, why didn't somebody else just do that? There's a second more interesting argument that Microsoft made that even if they paid more, it wouldn't matter to Apple because they rely so much on Google cooperation for Gmail, etc and that makes at least a bit of sense for a competition issue even though it'd apply to Microsoft products (Office, etc) as well. But to the degree anybody can pay to be #1, that strikes me as an open marketplace. And why is Google paying Apple to be default worse than Google selecting itself as default on its own devices? Isn't it the same principle?
- firstbabylonian 3y ago> why didn't somebody else just do that Yeah, who doesn't have a half-decent web search engine a couple of hundred billion dollars lying around.
- elicash 3y agoMicrosoft, whose testimony has gotten the most attention in this case, has $111.26 B on hand. Google pays Apple between $18 billion to $20 billion a year, supposedly, and of course makes money back in search revenue. And even more by being number one in search. If you thought I was suggesting a random person on the street would have the money, then you misunderstood. The actual answer to the question I posed, which you quoted, is that it's actually quite difficult and not a matter of just writing a check.
- pie420 3y agoThe implication is that in capitalist society without enough regulation, the monopolies will collaborate to maintain their own monopolies rather than fight each other and try to compete. Microsoft, Apple, Google, Amazon all could compete, but it's more profitable to have a gentlemen's agreement to not compete and to kill any challengers. Same as Standard Oil, J.P. Morgan, US Steel, Armour Meats, etc. last century.
- spandrew 3y agoGive everyone the option to choose which browser they'd like to use by default. 99% will choose Google. Who the eff cares about this.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoNo, 99% would not know what the question is about, ask their geek friends, who would be able to move the needle. That's how firefox became popular before google put an ad for chrome on their home page.
- kweingar 3y agoIn 2023, people know what a search engine is, and people know what Google is.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoHN bubble strikes again. You need to sit behind a help desk for a few hours to reset your expectations about humanity.
- kweingar 3y agoI think this is the case of HN bubble swinging too far in the opposite direction. People know what Google is. Among Gen Z, Google is the second most popular brand, behind YouTube. https://morningconsult.com/gen-z-favorite-brands-2022/ https://morningconsult.com/gen-z-favorite-brands-2022/
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoNope. Follow the advice. Give tech supports. It will be more convincing than any argument I can make. It will also eat your soul a little. Sorry about that.
- DRW_ 3y ago
- wvenable 3y agoI wonder how many Edge users change their default browser from Bing to Google. I think the answer to that would probably make or break this case.
- Someone 3y agoIf many users considered changing their search engine in iOS, it wouldn’t be worth $20 billion to Google to be the default. From that, I think it’s a safe bet Edge users don’t do that, either.
- Belopolye 3y ago[dead]
- ecshafer 3y agoI would seriously guess near zero. People who use Edge are, I would guess, the types of people that just use the default, the people who do not know tech and just know which thing to click for "the internet".
- AuthError 3y agoin the case they said it's in the teens, so that's after crazy level of dark patterns (probably if they do age analysis it's gonna skew towards more single digit share for younger demographic)
- wvenable 3y agoI also then wonder how many people go out and install Chrome. Edge is bundled in. It's the default. Going out and installing Chrome would be considered an even bigger challenge than just changing a setting. Maybe nobody uses the default anyway and they just type "google" into the bing bar before they do any searches.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoThis is where Google's multiple monopolies go in. If you have a Gmail account and try to use it on another browser you will get a constant barrage of popups and banners pushing you to Chrome. YouTube, same deal. If they can trick a user just once into going "okay fine", the Google installer runs and now Google's managing your defaults for everything else. Which is why obviously Microsoft tries so hard to prevent installers from taking over the default browser setting now. I regularly encounter users who have actively malicious search providers and entire web browsers they do not know how they got. Tricking people into changing over is very much a thing, and actually how Sundar became as popular as he is. People often forget that Sundar Pichai's entire claim to fame at Google was the Google Toolbar, which was snuck into Flash Player and Reader installs to hijack people's search provider. (The same bundled install trick was, of course, then adapted to growth hack Chrome's numbers as well.)
- sfink 3y agoI would like to see an estimate of how much Google earns from the Apple search traffic. The article talks about the payment as if it were pure cost to Google, which obviously isn't the case. They earn truckloads of advertising revenue from it. That's what the $20 billion should be compared to, not $0.
- jncfhnb 3y agoI disagree. They could earn a windfall or lose entirely on it. At the end of the day, other companies cannot fork over $20B to play.
- rgbrenner 3y agoMicrosoft cant afford $20B? They're literally bigger than Google by market cap.
- jncfhnb 3y agoI don’t consider just Microsoft to be healthy competition personally
- ronsor 3y agoThere aren't many search engines nowadays. Anyone that does not use Google will probably end up on Bing. DuckDuckGo and Yahoo are still repackaging Bing results last I checked, and alternatives like Brave Search or Kagi are still very niche.
- jncfhnb 3y agoDon’t care.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xethos 3y agoNot can't-can't, but realistically they can't. Per TFA: > Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella testified that Google's claim that search users have choice is "bogus," while confirming that efforts to compete for default status for Bing failed, despite Microsoft being willing to take billions in losses. At one point, Microsoft even offered to sell Bing to Apple, but Apple rejected that deal, allegedly because the deal it had with Google was just too good to let go.
- noirscape 3y agoTo be honest, the entire state of mobile browsers could (and probably should) be an antitrust case in and of itself. It's just that the technical specifics are too complex for your average customer, let alone an aging judge, to understand. On iOS customers are always locked in on the Safari ecosystem (well, for now, the DMA will probably change that) - all browsers on the app store are just skins of Safari, not meaningfully unique browsers. I hope I really don't need to explain why Apple gatekeeping non-WebKit browser implementations is bad. Android is slightly better in that on the surface you can switch out the browser for say, Firefox (although Firefox on Android is a disaster), but... then Google does a sneaky thing and make it so that any in-app browsers will still be Chrome thanks to the System WebView. So nobody gets to escape the Google ecosystem. And in recent updates to AOSP, the vendor gets to force the System WebView to be set to the Chromium System WebView (or the Chromium Canary WebView, but that's... just the beta version). Not that that one matters a whole lot directly considering there are no competing implementations for the System Webview besides Vanadium (which is just a Chrome fork - you also had Bromite in the past but a spat between Vanadium and Bromite means that Bromite System WebView is dead) and a single "just pass through to your regular browser" implementation; Mozilla has a Firefox WebView implementation for Android but largely leaves the choice up to app developers to switch out Chromium WebView instead of making it compatible with the system WebView (so nobody uses it afaict).
- jncfhnb 3y agoI’ll fly to Europe if I have to in order to get an iPhone that can run Adblock on the mobile browser
- TriangleEdge 3y agoI find it curious that these cases are only being heard now, given that we are starting to see competitors like ChatGPT, DuckDuckGo, amongst others. Seems a bit late to me. I personally find the quality of Google to have nose dived in the last 5 years. It feels to me like something along the lines of a 'wordiness' score got added to their algorithm, which I dislike. Every time I search for a recipe, I am presented with a document about the history of the potato, then the recipe, which I find super annoying. My wish is to have a no BS search, which cuts out the wordiness and gets to the point.
- Bjartr 3y agoHave you taken a look at Kagi? I've been pretty happy with them compared to Google lately.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SllX 3y agoThat’s kind of the fundamental issue with antitrust law. By the time you’re in court, the case is already pretty much irrelevant to the addressable market the prosecution is representing. The fear is that someone will dominate a market so thoroughly that they will never have any real competition from an alternative. When you were talking about railroad rights of way and maybe a finite number of salt mines, I mean, fair enough. But now we fly over those rights of way and finding new places to get mineral resources is generally not that difficult because we either find new physical locations or we develop new technologies to re-exploit sites that were thought to be tapped out (and technically were with just older technology). Plus with electrification we’ve figured out new ways to get large quantities of energy other than drilling for oil. How do you even define a market for search, when what people were really after was what search engines could get them and there are more ways than ever to get that now?
- dpe82 3y ago> The New York Times dubbed Pandu Nayak, a Google vice president of search, "the face" of Google's defense, which is that it's not Google's access to more data that keeps Google leagues ahead of competitors in search, it's "brilliant people, working tirelessly to improve its products." The notion that data isn't absolutely critical is a bold-faced lie and Pandu knows it. The usefulness of any proposed change to the search algorithm cannot be decided without sufficient user traffic to run an experiment. Every single change - even very minor tweaks - goes through user experiments on live traffic. The more traffic you have, the more experiments you can run concurrently and the quicker they converge on statistically significant results. The smartest engineers in the world cannot replace the value of live, experimentable user traffic. Pandu knows this because he's the one ultimately responsible for the weights of the various metrics used to decide which experiments are launchable, and for enforcing that policies and the culture around running those experiments are in-place and followed.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoI mean their defense is ridiculous on its face. "It's our smart enployees" half of which either now work at those competitors or were poached from those competitors. And if we talk about Google's extreme institutional incompetence across its entire portfolio... Fifteen years ago the claim Google employees are uniquely smart might've held to even minimal scrutiny but not today.
- dpe82 3y agoGoogle absolutely does have some very smart employees, and their research org does amazing work. But as they've grown headcount they've certainly regressed toward the mean.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoSure, Google has some very smart employees, but so does Microsoft, who "can't compete". The reason why is the defaults and the data volume. What Google wants you to believe in this claim is that Google employees are smarter than their competitors' employees, and that is absurd.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- koromak 3y agoI understand that this is "prosecutable", but I feel like the domination of Chromium is more dangerous than their search monopoly.
- riskable 3y agoThat's the thing, isn't it? There's so many anticompetitive things at play here it's annoying that the DOJ is focusing on just one (default search). From Chrome/Chromium to Gmail making it impossible to run your own email server to it becoming increasingly more difficult to separate the Google services from the AOSP. Also, if the DOJ is actually concerned about the anticompetitive nature of defaults they need to go after Microsoft's deals with PC vendors. If it's not OK to ship a phone with Google as the default browser why is it OK to ship a PC with Windows (prebundled and already paid for in the price) as the default OS? At the very least the consumer purchasing a PC should be required to pay for the Windows license separate from the computer itself.
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoThe DOJ is focusing on more than search: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-google-monopolizing-digital-advertising-technologies https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-googl... "Order the divestiture of, at minimum, the Google Ad Manager suite, including both Google’s publisher ad server, DFP, and Google’s ad exchange, AdX, along with any additional structural relief as needed to cure any anticompetitive harm"
- mgreg 3y agoThere’s been some good points raised by both sides in the case but there’s still some logic that doesn’t flow. * Google pays a rev share to Apple for being _default_ search provided and default was key: “no default, no deal”. Apple turned down more money from Microsoft including offers to buy all/part of Bing. Samsung also dallied with Microsoft for more money but also turned it down. * This suggests that there’s some other reason aside from money that Apple is going with Google. After all, as Google points out, if competition is just a click away why wouldn’t Apple click away to another partner? This could be: Google is just better. If Apple switched their users would notice and suffer/leave Apple. There’s additional leverage that Google has that it is leveraging e.g. search ranking penalty? Access to other Google services (especially for Samsung), Agree not to compete in other areas (like their previous no-poach agreement they had). So a couple of key questions: 1. Is Google really that much better to the _average_ internet user (note that HN crowd is not average in this regard)? Is there much risk to Apple to take the money from Bing and make them default? 2. Somewhat dependent on 1, but ff Google knew/know Apple or others are unlikely to switch because Google is that much better than why not exercise their market power and lower the rev share % they pay to others? Feels strange for both things to be true - that Google is that much better AND that they don’t negotiate down their rev share.
- elicash 3y agoOn (1), everyone in this case, even Microsoft, says yes Google is much better; they just say Google is better for unfair reasons. On (2), I think what the case said is that Microsoft would have had to pay more because it's smaller? But I'm not as sure here.
- mgreg 3y agoAgreed on 1; people in the court case are saying Google is better. Given that, why wouldn't Google negotiate a lower rev share? Consider this from Apple's Eddie Cue: "Cue implied that Bing’s technology was inferior to Google’s, saying that he doesn’t 'know what we would have done” if negotiations with Google ever fell apart.' " [1] If I were sitting across from Cue at the negotiating table and knew he felt that way I certainly would be looking at a lower rev share and saving some billions of profit for Google... [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-28/microsoft-discussed-selling-bing-to-apple-as-google-replacement?leadSource=uverify%20wall https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-28/microsoft...
- tedunangst 3y agoSomething about this feels really weird. I'm supposed to believe Apple lacks agency here? Also, it's funny to suggest that Apple must build or run their own search engine. The solution is more vertical integration monopoly?
- zeroimpl 3y agoThe article kind of implies it's Apple's fault, but Google was the well established leader before iPhone launched. Apple did build a Google Maps alternative, but it took a while for it to become good.
- robocat 3y agoThis is really saying that Apple have the monopoly. Just about every argument in the article revolves around choices that Apple makes - Google has little power except to offer money.
- annor 3y agoGoing to wait and see what Microsoft saids when they are on the chopping block. Will be interesting to hear their defense then.