6 ms·
Discord is going to give out warnings instead of permanent bans
- FireBeyond 3y agoI feel like it is inevitable with this kind of attitude and Discord's other approaches that they are headed for a fairly ugly showdown. If you look on Disboard and such, it is trivial to find sexually explicit Discords aimed at minors, and even more troubling, ones that are sexually explicit, allow minors, and adults ("age range: 14-28"). There's going to be a newsworthy incident, soon, I'm sure of it.
- duped 3y ago> There's going to be a newsworthy incident, soon, I'm sure of it. (1) https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/social-media/discord-child-safety-social-platform-challenges-rcna89769 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/social-media/discord-child-safe... What's interesting to me is that in twenty years we've gone from "use the internet with parental supervision, don't use your real name, and don't talk to strangers online" to making platforms pick up the slack of parents and law enforcement to prevent predators talking to kids. Now I'm not saying that platforms like Discord shouldn't be doing a better job policing things, but it's also shocking to me how much the expectations of these platforms has changed in twenty years. AIM was way worse than Discord is today. Predators used to hang out on Runescape and Neopets. I feel like we're taking too much onus off of parents to monitor their kids online access.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoOld School Runescape is more alive than ever! Huge amount of predators there. Got my god sword scammed just yesterday!
- _chu1 3y agoI learned to not use my name online the hard way. I'm 15 now and I had poor opsec when people started getting mad at me on games or whatever else, and I use online personas on almost everything.
- FireBeyond 3y agoOh absolutely. When I was growing up, people looked back 20-30 years at the hornet's nest of predators at "nudist camps" and other such things that masqueraded under the umbrella of "peace love and mung beans". Now we look back at the world of AIM and ICQ and IRC as being just as bad.
- _chu1 3y agoThis will change nothing. Since 2020 and their efforts to get more than gamers on Discord it has been a cesspool of minging, predators and other nefarious activities. I've gotten like 4 or 5 Discord accounts banned for trolling, raiding, false reports or other harmless crap like that and they have no systems in place to prevent people from just making another account other than phone verification, and I have used the same phone number to verify 8 accounts before. The things going on already are newsworthy, but in my opinion TikTok/Instagram algorithms encouraging teenage girls to starve themselves is probably as serious if not more.
- altairprime 3y agoIt's not the worst approach to it, but there's a specific change they'll end up making to their proposed UI. Currently, the time limit is applied at the moment that Discord issues the warning: > You can't send messages for 1 hour. This will end up needing to incorporate a timer, so that users don't just say something offensive and then go take a nap and let the ban expire unnoticed. What they have now is easily dodged and disregarded ("I didn't see the notification!" objections). Something like this: > You can't send messages until 1 hour after acknowledging this message. So that when they next open Discord, the timer begins once then (and not prior), while removing all deniability for having 'overlooked' the notification.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoGoing and taking a nap could be the point. Just getting a user disengaged from an argument can be beneficial.
- forgotpwd16 3y agoSure is. But next time they do the same offense again because they skipped the message and be banned they'll complain they got banned without reason.
- _chu1 3y agoPeople also complain that someone stole their email address because someone with the same name made one first. You can't fix stupid unfortunately.
- altairprime 3y agoYou can certainly plan for it, though.
- jonathanlydall 3y agoI used to be WoW GM (many, many years ago now) and 3 hour suspensions effectively worked like this, if you were offline it would only start the timer when you next logged back in. I can’t recall for sure, but I think 24 and 72 hour suspensions were different and started the count down at the time applied.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoIMO, this is a good thing. Lack of transparency when it comes to moderation is a bad thing. If a user is getting punished for breaking rules, they should be shown exact the message that led to the action, so that users can't claim they got banned for no reason or for some vague reason about community standards. Also, I've never been a fan of immediately going nuclear and banning people for their first rule violation unless it's especially egregious. A simple "Hey, we don't do that here" and a short period of time-out can be a lot more effective for changing behavior.
- bastardoperator 3y agoWhat's egregious to you? I personally don't mind if doxxers, racists, or criminals(war thunder leak?) get the ban hammer immediately.
- _chu1 3y agoIt's stupid and egregious to ban someone for "breaking TOS" or "sharing harmful information" and not telling them exactly what they did and where they did it, no matter what you see them as.
- bachmeier 3y agoOnly from the perspective of the person getting banned. From the perspective of the person paying the bills, you're paying someone to spend time explaining why you kicked them out, and then you're paying them to discuss the reasoning, and then you're paying them to discuss the reason with hundreds of users that don't think there's anything wrong with calling someone [some word]. Not only that, you're doing that to satisfy the curiosity of someone you've decided you don't want anywhere near your site. I'd be on board with your line of argument if it involved a payment of $X to cover out-of-pocket expenses and the hassle of dealing with BS.
- _chu1 3y agoNobody wanted to "have a chance to explain themselves". I just wanna be told what got me banned, not a complex request.
- sparksniffer 3y ago[dead]
- PaulKeeble 3y agoDiscord only a year ago appeared to be banning people completely randomly to try and boost its new users numbers as it showed interest in IPO. Its taken a while for all the complaints about this to finally reach the point of wanting some transparency, given how atrocious their support is (mostly just a bot) I can't imagine much changes.
- hx8 3y ago> In the coming weeks, Discord is rolling out a sensitive content filter that will be enabled by default and blur sexually explicit content in DMs and in servers I wonder how this feature will work in servers. Channels can be tagged as "NSFW", and require you to opt into visiting them. Surely they won't blur content in these channels by default? Surely if you're posting sexually explicit content outside of these channels you should delete them instead of blur them.
- gpm 3y agoBlurring can probably be applied with a much higher false positive rate than deleting images...
- dotnet00 3y agoIf this feature is anything like their existing detection, it'll be near useless, buggy and just get in the way. For a while discord would detect things like close up pictures of hands as nsfw and would block sending them in a group dm channel even though none of us had the filter setting on.
- bbitmaster 3y agoI don't think I will ever understand how the freedom of separate IRC servers got replaced by a single platform that mistakenly calls each community a "server" when it's clearly all on the same server and moderated by the same company. I personally got a warning threat from discord for (I assume) joining some server, but I joined a lot of servers I never said anything and I wasn't even sure what happened on the server to warrant such a warning since it was shut down and I couldn't even see anything.