7 ms·
Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic: study
- macinjosh 3y agoThis is a cruel aspect of the human body IMHO. Our ancestors went through hell to get us to the point of caloric abundance on the tech tree and our bodies are like, nah, not good enough, we liked starving better! :-)
- forward1 3y ago[flagged]
- gustavus 3y agoIs anyone having flashbacks to when fat was vilified and the food pyramid put bread at the bottom?
- chmod600 3y agoBread doesn't have fructose, right?
- Simulacra 3y agoMost bread sold in the grocery store has high fructose corn syrup
- DC-3 3y ago(in the USA)
- graton 3y agoDo you have any data to back that assertion? In my limited searching I found an article that says the opposite, but they also don't provide any data[1] [1] https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/nutrition/secrets-of-store-bought-bread-youll-wish-you-knew-sooner/ar-AA1ivtYd https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/nutrition/secrets-of-store-...
- Simulacra 3y ago#10. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/foods-with-high-fructose-corn-syrup#10.-Bread-and-crackers https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/foods-with-high-fructos... It would be nice if there was a database of food labels.
- InSteady 3y agoYou can find this info on https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/ https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/ The search function and UI is terrible, though. There used to be a website self.nutritiondata.com that was amazing. Full calorie, carb, fat, and nutrient profiles on all manner of whole foods, plus lots of branded processed food labels as well. Apparently they had to take it all down because it was out of date. They got all of their info form the USDA link above, so the data still exists and there are other web apps out there that organize it for you, but they all pale in comparison to the old self.nutritiondata, sadly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- devmor 3y agoThe packaged, pre-sliced stuff from brands, yeah. Most grocery stores also have a bakery though, and its far less common there.
- KMag 3y agoSucrose is broken down in the stomach (by the low pH) and small intestine (by sucrase) into a 50/50 mix of glucose and fructose. The most common high fructose corn syrups are (to a first-order approximation, after dehydration) 58/42 and 45/55 mixtures of glucose and fructose. I'm not saying HFCS is good, but a sucrose-sweetened bread is likely just as bad for you as an HFCS sweetened bread, if the mass of sweetener is the same. Edit: When I was at Google, I remember some employees complaining that the only free sodas were either HFCS-sweetened or artificially-sweetened. So, we later got some agave-sweetened free sodas. The things is agave nectar is 56% fructose. The most common HFCS grades are 42% and 55% fructose. Maybe agave nectar is maybe marginally more healthy, but really... if you're going to get that worked up, you're much better off training yourself to be content without the free soda. Drink soda, or not, but please don't fool yourself into thinking switching from 55% fructose to 56% fructose is a health intervention. Maybe people are afraid of trace residues from the HFCS processing, but all evidence suggests that the fructose is orders of magnitude more harmful than any ingested byproducts of the HFCS manufacturing process.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- macinjosh 3y agoYeah, I could never reconcile the concept of a "balanced" diet and the idea that a certain, easy to produce, category of food should be the majority of calories. It was clearly a nudge on the exploding post-war populations to eat foods that are good for business and not necessarily good for health. An acre of corn or wheat makes whole lot more than that same acre being used for leafy greens or grass-fed proteins and fats (i.e. livestock)
- cmiller1 3y agoModern dietary guidelines still put breads at the bottom, the Harvard Healthy Eating Pyramid is a really good version of the "pyramid infographic" style of nutritional guidance. There is some evidence the old US food pyramid guideline of 5-11 servings of grains were influenced by lobbying from the food industry, however by my calculations 5-11 servings of grains is pretty much necessary if you follow the AHA's optimal health guidelines of 300 minutes of cardio per week. If you look into the history of how the US food pyramid got made the biggest influence of industry lobbyists were on the meat and dairy recommendations, changing "no more than 2-3 servings" to "2-3 servings a day" and removing red meat from the "sparingly" peak at the top of the pyramid.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WorldMaker 3y agoThis was a problem well before the "Food Pyramid": Food Calories and the Standard Calorie Model were invented by the "scientists" at the Sanitarium at Battle Creek (aka "Wellville") who were also "coincidentally" the founders of Kellogg's and the National Biscuit Company (Nabisco) based on some weird religious beliefs that grains were God's true foods. Food Calories were invented to sell more cereals, crackers, and cookies.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoCalorie is a unit of energy equivalent to the heat energy needed to raise the temperature of 1 gram of water by 1 °C (now often defined as equal to 4.1868 joules). How was that invented to sell oreos?
- WorldMaker 3y agoThat's the definition of "little-c" calorie, not food Calorie. Food Calorie still claims a relationship to "little-c" calorie but its scale is in a further different magnitude and some of the numbers in its standard model can't be replicated so are just taken as given constants. But also the SI system dropped little-c calorie for Joules in part to shake up the over-reliance in some of the sciences of old bad Phlogiston theories, that "heat energy" is somehow usefully more indicative of energy density. (The physics formula for energy density of mass is the well known E=mc^2, nothing to do with heat.) Over-focusing on "heat energy" and a model that assumes the human body is an ideal spherical furnace ignores most, if not all, nuance in macronutrients and metabolism pathways, and biases in favor of foods that aren't as easy to set on fire (such as grains over fats). (Not to mention the very dark flipside of "exercise calories" and that if you are optimizing the human body's output as an ideal spherical furnace you are optimizing for states such as "fever" and "stroke".)
- tommychillfiger 3y agoBit of a side note on grains being "God's true food" - I read a book about the formation of the earliest states (Against the Grain by James C. Scott) where the author argues basically that grains prevailed as states developed because of their suitability as a currency for taxation compared to other staples like potatoes/root vegetables. Grains are usually harvested all at once at predictable times (so harder to lie to tax collectors), have a relatively long shelf life, and are easy to weigh/standardize. I believe they're also more laborious to grow which might benefit a fledgling state trying to maintain control over its subjects. The author has a noted anarchist bent, but definitely an interesting read and that take is kind of a funny parallel with the "God's true food" rhetoric.
- RC_ITR 3y agoNot smart enough to comment on the science but a pet peeve of mine is > When humans are hungry and running low on active energy, our bodies enter survival mode We are always in “survival mode.” Using that term instead of describing the changes occurring (do our cells change their metabolic pathway? Are certain processes suspended?) is very lazy writing.
- blakesterz 3y agoThere's a full text PDF (I think a preprint?) of the study over here: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2022.0230 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2022.023... Abstract: The fructose survival hypothesis proposes that obesity and metabolic disorders may have developed from over-stimulation of an evolutionary-based biologic response (survival switch) that aims to protect animals in advance of crisis. The response is characterized by hunger, thirst, foraging, weight gain, fat accumulation, insulin resistance, systemic inflammation and increased blood pressure. The process is initiated by the ingestion of fructose or by stimulating endogenous fructose production via the polyol pathway. Unlike other nutrients, fructose reduces the active energy (adenosine triphosphate) in the cell, while blocking its regeneration from fat stores. This is mediated by intracellular uric acid, mitochondrial oxidative stress, the inhibition of AMP kinase and stimulation of vasopressin. Mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation is suppressed, and glycolysis stimulated. While this response is aimed to be modest and short-lived, the response in humans is exaggerated due to gain of ‘thrifty genes’ coupled with a western diet rich in foods that contain or generate fructose. We propose excessive fructose metabolism not only explains obesity but the epidemics of diabetes, hypertension, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, obesity-associated cancers, vascular and Alzheimer's dementia, and even ageing. Moreover, the hypothesis unites current hypotheses on obesity. Reducing activation and/or blocking this pathway and stimulating mitochondrial regeneration may benefit health-span.
- stefan_ 3y agoThis is a crackpot paper.
- macNchz 3y agoCare to elaborate?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoMaybe so, but please don't break the site guidelines like this. They include: "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Perhaps you don't owe papers you consider crackpot better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it.
- snapcaster 3y agoSo should we stop eating fruit? what's the actionable takeaway here for someone already avoiding high-fructose corn syrup?
- devmor 3y agotl;dr - Limit processed sugars, eat significant amounts of fiber.
- imjonse 3y agoNo, but we should probably stop eating or cut back seriously on cookies, cakes, and other non-fruit sources of sugar.
- oldgradstudent 3y agoAvoid sugar, regardless of whether it is added sugar or not. Sucrose is effectively 50% fructose. And the supposed benefits of fruits are pretty much non-existent.
- r2_pilot 3y agoFruits, when consumed in moderation, also contain fiber and phytonutrients, hardly non-existent benefits.
- oldgradstudent 3y agoHumans can thrive on meat alone without any problem. No fiber and no phytonutrients. The supposed benefits of both are basically hypotheses with really crappy observational data to support them.
- r2_pilot 3y agoIf anyone is still reading this, I would not suggest taking dietary advice from this poster. Talk to a nutritionist about your specific needs instead.
- 3y ago
- Spivak 3y agoI think you should take any summary of a study from this guy that isn't based on your own conclusions from the experiment and data with a grain of salt because the dude blames fructose for everything. It might be the root of all evil but I'm wary of this being like seeing blood at every murder scene and saying it's the cause. Like I really want him to be right and it usher in an era of better health and medical outcomes from a fairly straightforward change to diet but there's as many theories as there are people studying the issue. The only thing that we can do now is verify it experimentally. If you're looking at the paper that's the "Testable Predictions" section.
- sharts 3y agoWasn’t Steve Jobs a fruititarian? Yea, he was totally obese a.f. I think they key takeaway is the the word hypothesis is used quite a bit in the summary.
- devmor 3y agoActual fruits have much smaller amounts of fructose than you find in processed food sweetened with it. They also contain fiber to help digest it properly. Industrially, it's a concentrate.
- vel0city 3y agoActual fruits often have a higher ratio of fructose to glucose than HFCS does. I agree there's probably a lot more going on with fruits such as the fiber content and potentially total sugar content.
- dilap 3y agoNot too much to go on here without the paywall-locked pdf. That said, from the abstract it seems their model of obesity depends on fructose-caused hunger driving consumption of fat: "metabolic effects that result in the increased intake of energy-dense fats." Whatever that means. It is true, I think, that most of our body fat comes from our diet, so at some level any theory of obesity ultimately has to come down to consuming fat. (Which also implies if you stick to a low-fat diet, you will not be obese. Though you might be miserable or unhealthy.) At a population level, has fructose consumption been going up as obesity has increased? That could serve as a sanity-check of the theory. (I don't know the answer to the question, so it's a real question.)
- tracerbulletx 3y agoThis is the exact opposite of what I understood to be the case. I thought that if you eat more calories than you consume you store them as fat, it doesn't matter if what you consume is fat or not, in fact consuming fat can help because it takes longer to digest and keeps you full and you may eat less than if you are eating sugary things that digest quickly.
- mnw21cam 3y agoYou're partially right. It's a complete fallacy to think that just because you consume fat, you store fat. Any fat you eat is broken down before going into the bloodstream, and is generally made available for the body to use as fuel in preference to being stored. The reason you store fat is because you have insulin in your bloodstream, which is a messenger telling cells to store energy. Insulin is released into the bloodstream in response to blood sugar levels going up. So, in order to avoid storing fat, you should avoid eating sugar (and other foods that get converted into sugar quickly, like most carbohydrates). People tend to lose weight if they consume mostly fat, and that is largely because eating fat doesn't raise blood sugar levels, and therefore doesn't stimulate insulin secretion. So it's more complicated than calories in minus calories out, and fat is good for more complicated reasons than it just taking longer to digest. Fructose does have a bad effect. But that's separate from the above - fructose is even more bad than just it being a sugar.
- 3y ago
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoIs obesity really that much of a puzzle? Have you ever looked back in US history and taken a look at portion sizes through the decades? Not year-by-year, I mean across decades and decades, average portion sizes are staggeringly different. The meals we collectively eat are different. Remember peak "Super Size Me"? By the time that movie had come out, portion sizes from McDonalds had already shrunk significantly. Then they removed the size option, but that wasn't the height of fast food consumption at all. It occurred at least two to three decades prior.
- taeric 3y agoYou are begging the question, though? Yes, we clearly consume more. As simplistic as the in/out hypothesis is, that part is not really up for debate. The question is why do we consume more. It is conceivable that it is just the availability, of course. Plenty of pet owners have found that some pets will eat as long as food is available, while some others will not. Trying to understand that seems like a good target.
- dboreham 3y agoSome constant in the neural net.
- brandonmenc 3y ago> The question is why do we consume more. Because we are offered more. Survival instinct is to eat everything in front of you. Reduce portion sizes across the board, and people would likely eat less.
- taeric 3y agoThat is countered by the rest of my post, though? Having had some pets that I can leave open buckets of food out for them, and they don't gain weight, something else is clearly at play. I'm open to the idea that, statistically, more people will eat more when given more. I'm... less open to the idea that we can't learn from looking at those that don't eat in excess in those situations.
- Geee 3y agoThis has been known for a long time. Watch "Sugar: the bitter truth": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM The main problem is that fructose is added in almost every product in the US.
- jsbisviewtiful 3y agoSeems disingenuous to say "fructose" is the problem. "High fructose corn syrup as an additive in everything" is different than just "fructose", which is naturally found at reasonable levels in fruit - a very healthy and beneficial part of our diets.
- ofrzeta 3y agoToo much fruit isn't healthy, though. It's widespread myth that you can't eat too much fruit. Depends on the type of fruit, too.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoIt's less so a myth, and more so that the Western diet tends to eat so little fruit that even suggesting that you can eat too much would lead to people eating even less than they currently do, worsening outcomes.
- InSteady 3y agoIt is a double edged sword though, because a LOT of people, including many health-conscious people, think of fruit and fruit juices as equivalent when they very much are not. You can drink down 4-7 apples/oranges/etc worth of nutrient-rich sugar juice in a matter of minutes, with only a fraction (or effectively zero) fiber. Quite terrible for the kinds of insulin and leptin resistance, ATP disrupting effects discussed in the paper. It's also worth remembering that many types of modern fruits are extremely sugary and tend to be relatively less fibrous and nutrient dense than historical, wild, and heirloom varieties. "Eat whole fruits regularly and in moderation" is much better advice overall. Simple, to the point, and cuts out problematic ambiguities.
- jononomo 3y agoYou can just cut out all plant-based calories from your diet entirely and you'll find that you will almost effortlessly get in shape. All the vitamins and nutrients that your body needs are available in animal-based foods, including vitamin C (fresh meat contains vitamin C) and in fact they are in a more bioavailable form, meaning that they are easier for your body to extract and absorb. From a health and fitness perspective a diet of meat, fish, and eggs is perfect. You'll also find that you can't stand alcohol if you follow this diet.
- _boffin_ 3y agoPlease link research to these claims.
- jononomo 3y agoThe research is a never-ending rabbit hole. I've told you what the situation is and you can either try it for yourself or live sub-optimally.
- zingababba 3y agoExcept that if you have problems with digesting dietary amines you will quickly find yourself miserable. Also putting yourself under a very large methionine load.
- 3y ago
- uslic001 3y agoIt is also the cause of all the fatty liver issues we have now.
- zingababba 3y agoI hate stuff like this, everyone is different, period. Learn what works for you. I've tried every type of diet under the sun over the years. Plant based, vertical diet, carnivore, Ray Peat inspired, keto with and without plants, full carnivore...what works best for me personally is whole foods plant based (I don't do well with histamines) - on a typical day of eating I'll get somewhere around 400g of carbs and something like 15% of my cals from fat. I stay lean as hell, my body loves carbs, including a ton of fruit. If I feel like I need some meat, I eat it.
- basch 3y agoWho does high amounts of refined fructose syrup work for? Do any of the diets you described advocate high doses of refined fructose?
- zingababba 3y agoYeah, on a RP diet refined sugars including fructose from juices are encouraged.
- taylodl 3y agoCool! Nutrition now has its own GUT!
- o0banky0o 3y agoWhat will we do without our candies and toys?
- lamontcg 3y agoProbably 20 years ago now when I was reading about sugar and atkins diet some rando on the internet suggested that high intake of sugar told our bodies (or at least my scandanavian/scottish-genetics body) to start bulking up for the winter. Looks like rando might have been right. There's also the theory in Survival of the Sickest by Moalem that the high blood sugar in diabetes acts like antifreeze and protects against frostbite in the winter. That was from 2007, I don't know what people think about that theory now. (EDIT: After looking it up it looks like Moalem was talking about type 1 Diabetes which makes no sense to me at all since historically T1 was a pretty immediate death sentence, and I can't find any decent scientific papers citing that book, its all garbage, oh well). Those theories have always been intuitively compelling to me and stuck in my head.
- 876978095789789 3y agoUS sugar consumption peaked in 2000 and has since declined, with the decline being driven primary by a decline in HFCS: https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery/chart-detail/?chartId=101051 https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery... Yet the obesity and Type 2 Diabetes epidemics have only gotten worse, with the diabetes epidemic reaching what appears (in this graph) to be an inflection point around the time sugar consumption started to decline (which makes sense when you realize it entails a shift to more fat consumption, including saturated fat): https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK568004/figure/ch3.fig22/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK568004/figure/ch3.fig2... I'm amazed that here we are, in the third decade of the low-carb era, with the obesity rate now hovering over 40% despite a decline in sugar consumption, and this nonsense is still being taken seriously, let alone by people (like HNers) who think they're well-informed. BTW go look at photos of Johnson and Lustig: they're both fat, unlike Barnard, McDougall and other doctors who advocate ultra low-fat, whole food, plant-based diets.
- sigsergv 3y agoThere are lot of food products that advertised as “healty”, “bio” etc, most of them explicitly mention that they use fructose instead of sugar. People are really made to believe that fructose-based candies are much healthier than sugar-based ones.