4 ms·
> The difference is that Optimized Charging kicks in only when your iPhone is normally idle, typically overnight. The new 80% charging feature (that’s limited t
by adastra22 3y ago
> The difference is that Optimized Charging kicks in only when your iPhone is normally idle, typically overnight. The new 80% charging feature (that’s limited to iPhone 15 models) doesn’t try to be as smart, and simply works all day long.
That’s not how the Optimized Battery feature works, according to the help text displayed right next to the feature in the Battery Health settings.
I question the whole premise of this article.
- spenvo 3y agoAuthor again, “I question the whole premise of the article” What? You got tripped up on my wording, sorry. But the article's premise is valid, and it's not cool that the top comment on this submission for its first three hours on HN has totally lacked curiosity and come to a sensationalist conclusion. Do you have any actual problems with the article? Could you list them? (You responded to others but not my previous comment)
- adastra22 3y agoDo you have any evidence to back up your claim that there is no hardware or inaccessible firmware difference between the iPhone 15 and 14 which might suggest a different charging strategy and/or limit their ability to roll this out to earlier versions? Or are you just spitballing here?
- spenvo 3y agoHey! (thanks for expounding on your concerns). The claim from the article is that a fixed 'charge to 80% feature' is "likely possible on earlier models". I asked Apple to comment and am curious what they say. We do have evidence for the article's claim: iPhones dating back to at least the iPhone 8 support a feature that limits charging to 80% for multiple hours per day already. It just only occurs during hours Apple chooses via its learning algorithm. I never claim that the hardware is/is-not different; you simply have to look at what is already supported to understand what the devices are capable of.
- spenvo 3y agoEdit: Ah, I can see how you thought my wording was confusing. The feature "kicking in" is that it is not charging (when it typically would be charging). But it could sound like I meant that it's charging when idle. Rephrased to be clearer, thanks. -------- Author here, I think my Optimized Charging description is a fine description of how it works in practice. To borrow from another publication: "Optimized battery charging is a feature on iOS 13 or newer that limits overnight charging to protect your phone's battery in the long term." [0] With it, iOS learns your habits and will try to keep your phone charged under 80% until soon before it thinks you will take the phone off the charger, when it tops it off to 100%. "The algorithm aims to ensure that your iPhone is still fully charged when unplugged." [1] I have also used the feature personally since it came out, and this is how it works. What do you take issue with specifically? [0] - https://www.pocket-lint.com/what-is-optimised-battery-charging-on-iphone/ https://www.pocket-lint.com/what-is-optimised-battery-chargi... [1] - https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210512 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210512
- aldebran 3y agoIt’s close enough for the purpose of the article.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> That’s not how the Optimized Battery feature works Please say what the difference is, then?
- adastra22 3y agoIt slows down and times its charging to reach the 100% right before you get up in the morning, rather than immediately after you plug it in (which would make it 100% all night long).
- Dylan16807 3y agoSo in other words, the limiting only works overnight. So, again, what is the difference from what you quoted? Is it the implication that it might work at other times of day when the phone is "normally idle"? I don't even know if that implication is true or not, since it depends on exactly how the phone calculates your schedule. But if that's your complaint, it seems pretty small to me, not enough to throw the rest of the article into question. Is there something else I'm missing?
- adastra22 3y agoOptimized Battery will charge your phone to 100%.
- Dylan16807 3y agoRight, once overnight is ending. It only optimizes overnight, with the battery limited the vast majority but not right at the end. I don't see the conflict.
- jauco 3y agoIt doesn’t work if I plug my phone in at 9am in the morning. It will charge my phone to 100% immediately in that case. Even if I leave it connected to power all day. Breaking my battery. Optimized charging is based on learning and thus unpredictable and hard to influence. It only works if you have rigid habits.