3 ms·
NFTs. It's like Steam's marketplace, but without having to have one company have control to ban anyone. It lets you safely make trades without having to pass yo
by charcircuit 3y ago
NFTs. It's like Steam's marketplace, but without having to have one company have control to ban anyone. It lets you safely make trades without having to pass your items to sites for them to hold on to your items for you.
- smoldesu 3y ago> It's like Steam's marketplace, but without having to have one company have control ...and without payment processing, fraud detection, customer service, moderation tools, user reviews or a refund policy.
- charcircuit 3y agoThe network does the payment processing. The rest can be implemented at a higher level. It is like offering customer support for open source software. Technically anyone can build a company on top of the software and start providing support.
- smoldesu 3y ago> The rest can be implemented at a higher level Eg. the rest is optional and doesn't come with the same guarantees as the base network. I don't hate cryptocurrency personally, but it's not hard to see how 99% of users would prefer "the rest" implemented well over a properly transparent blockchain.
- alasdair_ 3y agoWhy can't the host of the image just delete the image? At that point, the NFT is effectively banned. Also, something like OpenSea can block you and you're effectively banned for all practical purposes.
- Matticus_Rex 3y ago> Why can't the host of the image just delete the image? If it's a blockchain, there's no single host who can do that.
- charcircuit 3y agoI level mentioned anything about images. If you have a LoL skin and the game shuts down it similarly becomes useless. Digital items becoming useless is nothing new. At least with NFTs they can at least be collectors items that you can keep if you want.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoWhat does it do better than a classic centrally run steam marketplace? Why hasn’t Valve switched to NFTs?
- charcircuit 3y agoIt destroys the monopoly Valve has over item ownership and gives power to the people. Valve hasn't switched because having a monopoly is good financially.
- dkersten 3y agoIt really doesn’t. Steam or other stores still have to cooperate ro implement the items on each of their stores to make them work on their platform and then have to honour what the NFT claims. That’s still very heavily replying on the platforms and they can still ban you or pull the item out form under you (and we can trivially see this by the fact that people have been selling things they don’t even own as NFTs). For it to truly destroy the monopoly, the items that the NFTs represent would have to stand on their own, outside of any particular platform, implemented entirely in the NFT smart contract itself, but outside of the most trivial use cases (eg displaying an image) that’s not a technology that exists as platforms would have to at a minimum agree on a standard interface and functionality of items. Right now, it’s also held back by storage and transaction costs (although some blockchains are cheaper than others). But even then, if there was a common item standard and you could use that to somehow implement cross platform (or cross game or whatever) items, any particular platform could still decide not to honour it or to ban you or whatever they want.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoBut why would any company want this? You’re giving away control of your projects for… what exactly?
- charcircuit 3y agoWhy would any company make a website instead of requiring people to install a native app where they have more control?
- giantrobot 3y agoNo. NFTs let you trade some bullshit token. The token's provenance and ownership doesn't have to be respected by anyone. The state of any particular blockchain doesn't confer any copyrights, license, or real world ownership. It's about as valid as me writing "I own a pair of Air Jordans" on an index card. Unless a game developer decides to honor any particular blockchain and NFTs on it those NFTs mean nothing. There's no upside to a developer honoring third party NFTs because they make no money off them but do have support and development costs.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoCorrect. NFT's are the adult equivalent of the gold stickers we got on assignments in grade school.
- dkersten 3y agoYou are still relying on sites to hold your item for you. Items don’t exist in a vacuum, having ownership over an NFT doesn’t suddenly mean things will just interoperate. For example, if it’s a game item, you still rely on one or more games to honour your NFT that claims you own it, and to implement that item in the first place. If it’s an image, that image is still hosted somewhere (and even if it’s embedded into the NFT directly, those bits are given meaning externally). An NFT is just a receipt claiming ownership, what that receipt allows you to do still relies on external services honouring that receipt. NFTs only solve one small part of the puzzle and I’d argue it’s not even the most important one.
- usea 3y agoYou can buy and sell digital assets without cryptocurrency. Also, the blockchain is not authoritative over ownership of those assets. Good old fashioned contracts are what enable transfer of digital assets. Crypto is just a terrible payments system on top.
- uxp8u61q 3y agoCan you explain in a few words how an NFT is different from a certificate stating you own a piece of land of the Moon?
- miracle2k 3y agoThe NFT was issued by the creator of the artwork. It’s like a moon certificate issued by god plus we don’t have space flight.
- charcircuit 3y agoAn NFT could be a bond that provides 1 USDC to owner every day for the next year. A certificate saying that you own the moon can not be a bond. NFTs are much more versatile.