2 ms·
The laws of physics get in the way. There is only so much energy in a gallon of gasoline (pick a different unit, point is the same). We are already close to the
by bluGill 3y ago
The laws of physics get in the way. There is only so much energy in a gallon of gasoline (pick a different unit, point is the same). We are already close to the max theoretical efficiency of a gas engine (when run in perfect conditions which are hard to get in the real world).
We can eliminate safety features to make cars lighter. We can accept higher pollution levels. Those are both trade offs we are not willing to make.
We can make cars more aerodynamic, but style often gets in the way and consumers are not willing for that trade off. (or so it is claimed).
We can make cars smaller, but people often find large cars more useful. (even though a small car is good enough for 99% of all trips, that last 1% makes it worth having the larger car. Renting is so expensive that even for the 1% trip it may still be cheaper to have the large car for everything)
There are options of course. However car makers have been working on this problem for at least 50 years (energy crisis of the 1970s is obvious, even before that fuel mileage was a concern). All the easy solutions have been done already. What is left is often a lot more expensive than what was done before and also cannot possibly return a whole lot on investment.
The reality is gas and diesel engines investment is a dead end. They are not worth any more investment as everyone in the industry already knows electric cars are coming. While they probably will live on in a few niches, those niches are not large enough to support investment in making them better, today's engines are about as good as the future ever will see.
- copperx 3y ago> Renting is so expensive that even for the 1% trip it may still be cheaper to have the large car for everything) I find that incredibly hard to believe, unless you're renting a large truck once a month.
- hightrix 3y agoAnecdotally, I fit this description. I own a large SUV as my daily driver. It is fully paid off. I use it to get lunch and other errands for most trips. About once a month or so, I need to use the full capacity of the vehicle. This would run 50-100 bucks to rent an equally capable vehicle. For me, it is absolutely worth saving 600-1200 bucks a year to not have to deal with the inconvenience of renting a vehicle to run an errand once a month. That price doesn’t include any insurance changes, getting to/from the rental place, and any additional costs I’m unaware of.
- phone8675309 3y agoIn a big city, you might be paying $100-$200 a month for parking
- bluGill 3y agoEvery try to rent a truck for use as a truck? To haul rock for example? You will spend more than a day just finding a place that will allow that (everyone else will see the scratches and dents that does to the truck and charge you expensive damages). I've also called uhaul before and discovered they we sold out (uhaul doesn't allow rock type uses, but does cover some truck needs). There are also times when you don't need a truck, just a larger car, renting that is $100/day. And again I've tried before and discovered the rental cars place was sold out when I needed one.
- Karrot_Kream 3y ago> We can make cars smaller, but people often find large cars more useful. (even though a small car is good enough for 99% of all trips, that last 1% makes it worth having the larger car. Renting is so expensive that even for the 1% trip it may still be cheaper to have the large car for everything) Partially. But CAFE standards are based on a footprint model which has kept light trucks and SUVs cheaper for a given fuel efficiency standard than smaller cars. If you close the gap, I'm pretty sure consumers would change their behavior, at least somewhat.
- datavirtue 3y agoOil is scaring me from a macroeconomic standpoint, and from a pollution standpoint but we are going to need it for a long while. Investments are being made into gasoline engines and they are paying off. The reliability and maintenance concern me with all these new clean sheet designs but the fuel efficiency is crazy good compared to previous generation engines. I'm driving an F-150 that gets 1989 Nissan Pulsar mpg in real world operation. It can carry my whole family plus 2000lbs extra in the bed. It can tow 10k lbs when I need it to, and I do often. Insane. There is a heavy cost in extra maintenance however, and some people have really gotten screwed when the maintenance has not been followed or the newly designed transmissions and engines fail before 100k miles. Point being, you go fucking with oil and gas markets and people will be suffering and dying in the real world as a result. For some reason this is being ignored. And no, no one is going to take one for the team so future generations can...blah blah blah. Ain't gonna happen.
- jfengel 3y agoWe could make cars much smaller, if we wanted. We don't sell very many two-seaters, and I don't think there are any one-seaters. Given how many cars are used for commuting and little else, these companies could sell these cars at a loss and still save money compared to the fines. One reason commuters don't want those cars is because they don't feel safe with behemoths on the road. Another approach companies could take is to raise the price of their larger vehicles, to reduce their number on the road and make the smaller cars feel safer. That would require federal coordination. As you note, all of this is about fuel economy, and that's really a dead end. The switch to electric is an opportunity to reconsider what mix of vehicles we want to have on the road. We take a lot of things for granted and it didn't have to be this way.