4 ms·
Tesla owner received a $21,000 bill after the battery was damaged by rain
- lgats 3y agomight this be covered under insurance? a flood of sort?
- thebruce87m 3y agoThere was an amber “do not travel” alert out for rain/floods, so I’m sure they’ve got “weasel room”. Edit: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/press-office/news/weather-and-climate/2023/amber-rain-warning-issued-in-scotland https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/press-office/news/weat... Link for the downvoter
- ender341341 3y agoI wish there were more details on the failure point, how did the water get in the battery? I can see it not being covered if it's something like they ran something over that put a giant gash in the battery, but if it's a 'the seal failed' that should 100% be a warranty issue.
- 93po 3y agoYou ask too much of modern journalism to do anything other than write rage bait that doesn’t even get copy editing.
- pvg 3y agoDiscussed here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907519
- cgb223 3y agoIf Tesla can’t make a chassis that keeps rainwater away from the battery, then they shouldn’t charge their customers for it when the battery inevitably has water ingress
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nickik 3y agoYou went very quickly from 1 headline to 'inevitably'.
- jlmorton 3y agoThere are five million Teslas on the road. Here we have a story about a single Tesla with a flooded battery compartment. This sort of issue happens on every type of car. It's not routine that a Ford F150 has a cracked block that leads the engine to hydrolock, but it does happen, and Ford doesn't cover the damage 8 years later.
- bb88 3y agoThat's why organizations like Consumer Reports are important. E.g. if Tesla batteries only last X years and you plan on keeping your Tesla for Y years, then knowing that leads to better decision making.
- jarym 3y agoWonder if this has anything to do with Elon supposedly asking his engineers to remove some plugs that prevent water ingress (page 280 of Walter Isaacson's book)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- account-5 3y agoThat has to be a good portion of the cost of the car. Electric cars are still not a cost effective form of travel, especially when if they break you can be hot with a bill like this. Fixing that car cost 5k more the my current car cost in full. Ridiculous! As is the fact normal Scottish weather broke a Tesla.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe chinese ones are incredibly cost effective. Our government just decided to ban them.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoAre they constructed better too?
- nickik 3y agoNo. But they are on-par for the most part. Often with better more 'featureful' software. But have fun getting them repaired as they have even less infrastructure then Tesla.
- outside1234 3y agoUkraine has shown us we can't take dependencies on non-democratic countries like Russia and China.
- oldpersonintx 3y agoand yet we continue to be dependent on both Russian sanctions cannot last forever, they have too many resources the West needs and as for China, tell me where your Apple products are made
- rurp 3y ago> Russian sanctions cannot last forever, they have too many resources the West needs Do they though? I'm not trying to be snarky, I really don't know what you're referring to. Russia's main exports are weapons and energy products. The west doesn't need their weapons. They might want their fossil fuels to lower prices, but that's not essential.
- machdiamonds 3y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907519
- k8sToGo 3y agoYour comment is a dupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37918690 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37918690 :)
- primitivesuave 3y agoI think the press actually devalues their ability to criticize Tesla/Elon when they push stories like this, where something out of the ordinary happens to one person. What used to be a common journalistic intent of "let's find out who else this might have happened to" is completely gone, replaced by sensational clickbait titles. This is a Scottish person driving in conditions that would never be encountered by over 99% of the Teslas out there. People who love Tesla don't care about this. People who hate Tesla/Elon will add this to their data points of why they will never buy one. The person with the $21k bill will pay it and move on with the rest of us.
- mastazi 3y ago> This is a Scottish person driving in conditions that would never be encountered by over 99% of the Teslas out there. I don't know if this was meant as a sarcastic remark; I assume that the share of Tesla drivers that live in rainy places is more than 1%
- jlmorton 3y agoThere's no way this was caused merely by excessive rain. Water does not leak into the battery compartment without physical damage. The linked article doesn't mention it, but there must have been some sort of physical damage at some point.
- kramerger 3y ago> The linked article doesn't mention it, but there must have been some sort of physical damage at some ... Do you have any information we dont have? Otherwise you are just speculating to defend Tesla.
- rokkitmensch 3y ago[dead]
- julienreszka 3y agoWhen you shill so hard you should disclose you have a stake
- lnsru 3y agoI really had high hopes about Tesla as a company when they released Model 3. It was revolutionary and I was big fan. But then this English diver “incident” happened. Ok, funny things happen and I tried to forget. And ignore continuous weird tweets from the owner. When I was able to afford one they removed ultrasonic sensors… And I understood, that this brand does not align with my understanding of ethics and technology.
- xvector 3y agoAnd they tried to paint removing it as a "feature" too. I love my Tesla but I will jump as soon as another car gets functional autopilot and compatibility with the Supercharger network.
- malfist 3y agoTesla has a functional autopilot?
- cowsup 3y agoI've been reading the Elon Musk book, I'm about halfway through. Some of the things in there, I'm surprised Musk was happy to admit to — they're intentionally cutting corners to reach self-imposed "milestones" on number of cars shipped in a given year, or reducing how waterproof their Solarlink roofs are in order to get more installed. This is the kind of thing that belongs in a damning exposé on a shoddy company, not a book promoted by the CEO.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> This is the kind of thing that belongs in a damning exposé on a shoddy company, not a book promoted by the CEO. This was the same with LTT recently, there was footage of their employees saying that they were rushed to create videos, that they'd "never been truly happy with a single video they did", that they "wished they were given more time to do things properly", etc., etc... And then I realized that this was official footage, that LTT themselves released as content!
- deleted 3y ago
- sherr 3y agoI live in Edinburgh and one of the first things I noticed when I first came here was how many Tesla's there are. I put some of it down to a dealership in a central swanky street with rich footfall (gone now). Things snowball. We get a lot of "weather" in Scotland. Not quite as much rain as Glasgow and the West, but plenty. And there has been some torrential (really, monsoon-style) rain on occasion recently (past two or three years really). I've rarely seen so much water come down so quickly. However, I would still assume a Tesla was waterproof! Something seems odd about this.
- dabbz 3y agoI swear I remember Tesla bragging about how they can turn into boats during deep water emergencies. The wheels being used as propellers, and the chassis being light enough to float. Feels like a fabrication of my mind now that I'm thinking about it...
- agloe_dreams 3y agoOh it's a fabrication of a mind, just not yours.
- choxi 3y agoyou might be thinking of Elon’s claim that the CyberTruck would be semi-amphibious
- nickik 3y agoMultiple videos of that sort of thing happening came out. Tesla driving threw high water. Musk commented something that for a short period they could float but in general they said this wasn't a supported features and don't do it. Then for the Cybertruck Musk said it should actually be able to float. But it was said as 'we are shorting for this' not 'this is a feature count on this'. As it stands this would void warranty. Tesla certainty not ever suggested that they could turn into boats in emergency situations.
- FireBeyond 3y ago
- machdiamonds 3y agoThis is probably what actually happened: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzA0U53HF2g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzA0U53HF2g
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vondur 3y agoI watched a video on Youtube of someone driving their Tesla through water that is up to its hood. Nothing seemed to happen to it (it was able to drive away). Supposedly the batteries are sealed, but I'd never test that doing it. This car was so deep in the water I'd be worried it would wash away; I guess it's so heavy that it doesn't happen. https://youtu.be/tzA0U53HF2g https://youtu.be/tzA0U53HF2g
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bell-cot 3y agoIt would be lovely if the article actually included some basic facts about the situation. Such as: - How many inches of water is a Tesla rated to be left standing in, before major damage could occur? - Are there locations in the chassis and bodywork that you can inspect after flooding may have occurred, to see whether the water got that deep? - In heavy rain, can the various drainage paths on the exterior be overwhelmed (especially if there are some leaf litter and/or spiderwebs in the wrong spots), resulting in water draining into places where it can cause serious damage?* *If this sounds impossible to you, ask a few older VW owners.
- Swizec 3y ago> In heavy rain, can the various drainage paths on the exterior be overwhelmed (especially if there are some leaf litter and/or spiderwebs in the wrong spots) My mom's Chevrolet Kalos got so bad in autumn that plants started sprouting out of the built-up fallen leaves under the hood. This was an actively used car driven almost daily. After that I started manually clearing those areas after washing the car. The amount of leaves you'd get out of a tiny little area shocked me every time. No way so much crap could fit in there and yet it did. Very easy to forget just how hollow areas under the bodywork are in a car.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion over here yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907519
- youngtaff 3y agoOriginal article https://www.edinburghlive.co.uk/news/edinburgh-news/edinburgh-couple-fume-handed-17k-27906242 https://www.edinburghlive.co.uk/news/edinburgh-news/edinburg...
- taylodl 3y agoThat's why I'm not an early adopter. There are a lot of things we're learning about the long-term viability of today's EVs. We have a lot of experience with electric motors, but that's about it. We're using lithium ion batteries in new and novel ways and exposing them to environments for which we don't have a lot of experience. We're using new gigacast manufacturing techniques that auto repair shops are saying they can't easily repair without having to re-tool and re-train. There's electronics galore all over these vehicles (and new ICE vehicles, too) that I'm not sure of their longevity in practice. I say this because we know these motors are good for 400,000+ miles. The average American drives 13,500 miles per year so that works out to a 30 year service life I'm not confident at all the rest of the car will last anywhere near that long.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoA high percentage of 2012 Leaf's and Model S's are still on the road, many with 200,000+ miles.
- sebazzz 3y agoAnd a lot of the fear of battery degration is caused by the early Leafs which didn't have any battery conditioning, and probably less mature battery management as well.