6 ms·
Do You Need a Visit to the Confident Man Ranch?
- mikelitoris 3y agoIs this City Slickers?
- cjohnson318 3y agoIf I wanted to dress up like a cowboy and feel uncomfortable, I'd just move back to where I came from.
- PlunderBunny 3y agoThe smartest thing I read about the question "What does it mean to be a good man?" was that the question was wrong - it should simply be "What does it mean to be a good human being?" In my opinion, it's a much easier question to answer.
- yetihehe 3y ago"What does it mean to be a good human being" is more general, so a probably a little less easy to answer. With "How to be a good man" you can cater to a smaller group. Women and men have different needs.
- nicbou 3y agoIt seems to be less about the needs of each gender and more about the social expectations for each gender. I take the question as "what should a good man be doing", not "what does one need to be a good man".
- marliechiller 3y agoSomething being more or less generalised doesnt necessarily mean more or less easy to answer. In this instance, its much easier to give axioms to being a good person than it is to being a good man. Especially in this day and age where the very notion of being a man (or woman) is being brought into question.
- yetihehe 3y ago> Especially in this day and age where the very notion of being a man (or woman) is being brought into question. Some problems are specific to men or women exactly because our society has different expectations for men and women, so general advice good for one gender is not always good for the other. Example: Q: How to be more appealing to the other sex? A: Wear some light makeup and a nice dress.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoThat question and answer both hurt my brain. What to do to be more appealing depends more on the individual person you are trying to appeal to than on what gender they are. Individuals are not fungible.
- taway1237 3y agoIs that how native speakers understand this proverb? I always assumed "a good man" here is synonymous with "a good human", because that's how if goes in my language, and because it's the only way this makes sense.
- HL33tibCe7 3y agoI’m a native speaker and interpret “man” in this context as definitely male, and I’d be very surprised if any other native speakers disagreed with that. I think it’s because “a good man” is quantified by the indefinite article “a”. Whereas “man” in a sentence without that qualification, e.g. “one small step for man” I would not interpret the same way. So, “a man” = a male human, “man” = maybe a male human, maybe any human.
- louistsi 3y agoI definitely disagree given that Marcus Aurelius was writing in an era where "man" in the written word was synonymous with "human", in any context. If you or I said "man" in this time period, certainly we would attribute it as you say.
- hydrok9 3y agoI think he meant man as in male, given that women were a very distant 2nd class of citizen.
- seanhunter 3y agoMarcus Aurelius wrote something like "Waste no time worrying about what it means to be a good man. Be one."
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoDoesn't seem like he took his own advice, though.
- Pigalowda 3y agoYea Marcus Aurelius, what a loser Emperor. I assume you’re talking about Marcus Aurelius Antoninus.
- seanhunter 3y agoI am yes. "Alone of the emperors, he gave proof of his learning not by mere words or knowledge of philosophical doctrines but by his blameless character and temperate way of life" -Herodian about Marcus Aurelius.
- Pigalowda 3y agoI was responding to the other guy. I knew you were talking about him. Maybe the coelacanth was talking about Marcus Aurelius Antoninus Elagabalus
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoI don't mean that he was a loser, just that he obviously spent a ton of time worrying about what it means to be a good man.
- Pigalowda 3y agoOf course he did. His “Meditations” are his personal journal - he’s giving himself advice. Sort of like telling yourself to be a good person and not just think about being one
- oldpersonintx 3y agoStripping men of their unique identity does not help...this is known as "leveling"
- marginalia_nu 3y agoI think that misses the point a bit. It's an easier question, but it's also a different question. It's often easier to answer a question that glosses over the situational nuances. Whatever your circumstances, whether you're a man, woman, something else; some of that is a given. It's not just who you are or who you chose to be, but the expectations and opportunities made available to us based on who we appear to be. It is a relevant question to ask what is the best way of playing the hand you were dealt by circumstance.
- mnky9800n 3y agoWhy do people pretend to do therapy to make money? If you can simply open a dude ranch and let people talk in a group during afternoon coffee break, why is that considered legitimate therapy? What's the difference between some dude with a dude ranch and a bachelor's in engineering and organizational psychology calling himself a life coach and someone with a PhD in clinical psychology who put time and energy into studying the science and getting vetted? Why is the spectrum so wide? Can I not simply start being a life coach ala Jeremy in Peep show, fuck with people's lives for 100£ an hour, then take the alcoholics anonymous cop out that the program works if you work it blaming you for any and all problems or difficulties you have along the way? If men need to go to some kind of dude ranch experience to connect with something that's fine I guess. Im not really talking about the men who seek these experiences. Moreso the ones who offer them.
- fullmoon 3y agoIf all you need is someone to talk with, there is no difference.
- mnky9800n 3y agothen why pay someone to talk as opposed to going to the pub with your friend?
- germinalphrase 3y agoBecause your friend may be too close to your problems to be of help, may not speak with candor to avoid harming you/your relationship, may be an active participant in your problem, may have no experience talking/thinking about your problem limiting their ability to offer useful feedback… Without even broaching the diagnosis and treatment of mental health conditions, there are any number of reasons why paying a neutral third party to discuss your problems could be preferable than talking to a friend at a bar. Nor are they mutually exclusive.
- codeulike 3y agoTalking to anyone is pretty good, so you're not far wrong. A counsellor or therapist has training - think of it as a mental toolkit - to help explore things with you. Depends on their exact approach but most of them wont give advice for example, they will just ask question or reflect what you say back to you to encourage you to figure it out yourself. Or they might look for parallels between your early life and current life, as most people follow repeated patterns in their relationships (or so the theory goes). At least 75% of their skillset is just listening and occasionally asking good questions which is an underrated skill. There are many different flavours of therapy/psychotherapy/counselling and sometimes the adherents get quite religious about it (ask an integrative therapist what they think of CBT for example). But research generally shows that most 'talking therapies' are roughly equal in effectiveness and the main factor for success is the relationship between the client and therapist - i.e. whether they click. (putting aside for the moment the tricky questions about how to measure effectiveness of therapy - what does improvement look like? how do you have a control group?) There's a thing called the 'Dodo Hypothesis' - that "all empirically validated psychotherapies, regardless of their specific components, produce equivalent outcomes" - see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo_bird_verdict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo_bird_verdict People heavily invested in a particular brand of therapy dont like to hear about the Dodo Hypothesis but broadly I think its an optimistic conclusion - talking to people helps, and if you find the right one, talking to a specially trained listener can help more.
- kredd 3y agoMy friend and I have a theory that a significant chunk of the problems mentioned in the article could be solved if every guy had a genuine platonic friend who is a girl. No data point other than every guy that I know who has close friend girls, never had problems with masculinity or something. And the opposite is true as well. I might be in a very limited bubble as well, as my very close bubble of decade+ friend group is almost 50/50 guys and girls. We’ve also discussed this exact topic numerous times among ourselves.
- sirsinsalot 3y agoI think this is just being around people with good emotional literacy. This is the core skill, and one that we don't teach. In fact society promotes toxic, reactive and non-reflective emotional handling. We need better emotional literacy and self regulation. Women tend to be better at this than men on average due to western culture.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- doesnt_know 3y ago> could be solved if every guy had a genuine platonic friend who is a girl. No data point other than every guy that I know who has close friend girls, never had problems with masculinity or something. And the opposite is true as well. Feels more probable that it's the other way around. Those that don't have problems with their (toxic) masculinity can likely maintain platonic relationships with any gender.
- 63 3y agoI'll take the middle ground and say I think it's more of a vicious cycle. Grow up in a dysfunctional environment and develop a bad concept of other people and of masculinity and it becomes harder and harder to break out of that as you age. Eventually someone has to do a lot of emotional work to support you while you figure out how to treat other people and yourself. A lot of times I think if it's caught early by someone with enough emotional intelligence and a little bit of capacity to forgive you and tell you when you're being a jerk, you can break out of it while young and continue to maintain healthy relationships going forward. Alternatively you get more and more isolated as you age and no one around is willing or able to help you and you end up pretty bad off. I'd consider myself in the first group but I definitely know a lot of men who are in the second group, or at least on their way there. Men's mental health is a big deal and I think it's only getting worse. I don't know how to fix it though
- ckyngcybra 3y ago[flagged]
- ebcode 3y agoAll of us need help. But not all of us can belong.
- cobertos 3y agoShould've read the article. Tbh, this attitude is part of the problem. To be as hard as the "Marlboro Man" (mentioned in the article) and require complete stoicism seems to have landed people like those described in the article in a place of pain. Not able to reflect on themselves or feel situationally aware.
- ckyngcybra 3y ago[dead]