7 ms·
BitVM: Compute Anything on Bitcoin [pdf]
- breul99 3y agoplease don't. wildly inefficient
- Lerc 3y agoSo is using sed to play chess. This exists as a proof on concept not as a suggestion that it is a practical solution. Since you chose to post this request here and not on the thread about playing chess with sed, I suspect you are imagining some form of real world effect from the energy expenditure from people doing this. I think that lacks a sense of perspective, a better approach would be to consider the change in state of the world after an extended period of expected use of the approach. Considering the considerable lack of practicality of calculating in Bitcoin (and indeed playing chess in SED) the expected use is negligible and consequently the impact would also be negligible.
- gumby 3y agoWhat’s the harm?
- gotimo 3y agoimmense amounts of wasted energy
- ursuscamp 3y agoThat’s a matter of opinion. Many happen to believe it is not wasted.
- dleeftink 3y agoBut many do. Who is right? [0]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921344921005103 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092134492... [1]: https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/14/14/4254 https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/14/14/4254 [2]: https://www.cell.com/fulltext/S2542-4351(19)30255-7 https://www.cell.com/fulltext/S2542-4351(19)30255-7
- toenail 3y agoBitcoin uses less than 0.1% of the world's energy. Any time somebody says things like "uses more energy than a country" they are either dishonest or malicious and clearly have an agenda. I'd recommend to try to stick facts, not opinions.
- ninepoints 3y agoLess than .1 % for embarrassingly little volume
- toenail 3y agoLess than .1% to secure more than 500 billion of value. Bitcoin energy usage is primarily to secure the network, not for transaction "volume", but that's a common misconception for people who have yet to learn about bitcoin.
- ninepoints 3y agoYou're splitting hairs. If the energy is needed to stave away a 51% attack, that's the energy needed to support the single digit tps monstrosity you have. As for the 500 billion in value, I doubt if everyone liquidated their positions today it'd amount to a figure remotely close to that.
- kristianp 3y ago> I doubt if everyone liquidated their positions today it'd amount to a figure remotely close to that. The same goes for any stock in the S&P 500. Market Cap is just a number.
- toenail 3y agoIf once in bitcoin's history there is 51% attack, all energy that was ever used was used to prevent this one attack. Wow, you totally convinced me.
- 3y ago
- toenail 3y agoBitcoin uses a ridiculously small amount of energy to begin with.
- arcticbull 3y agoJust one country, to achieve the computational and storage power of a raspberry pi. The mental gymnastics continue to beggar belief. I wish people would just be honest and say yes, it's absurd and wasteful, but I think it'll make me rich so I don't care.
- toenail 3y agoEvery industry on this planet that is worth doing uses "more energy than one country". Anybody who parrots this "argument" is either stupid or malicious.
- plastic3169 3y agoI find it interesting to travel in such country. Take a train and when it approaches a city look at all the buildings passing by. All the lights in the windows that show that people live there. The eletric heating of many of those homes. All the electricity any of the people living there ever spends. All the factories, farms you see on the way. Massive greenhouses. Server farms. All those electric cars stuck in traffic. The train goes for hours and hours. Everything you see combined uses less electricity than bitcoin. Millions of people can run their lives and build all their businesses using less energy. The scale is mind boggling.
- toenail 3y agoLike I said, the same can be said about any industry on this planet. That this fact is mind-boggling for you shows that you haven't really ever thought about energy consumption. That you see this as a weakness of bitcoin shows that you approach bitcoin with the preconception that it is useless, and that you try to find facts that suit your view.
- ursuscamp 3y agoThis improves the efficiency of Bitcoin.
- gregw2 3y agoCool totally academic exercise. I shudder at the performance not to mention energy waste. A better question is what chain to use for efficient ( $/op or watts/op? ) verified Turing complete computation. Avax?? I really have no idea.
- aggsigme 3y agoChia uses a lisp variant, along with the a similar coin model to bitcoins utxo. So it's computationally powerful, while avoiding the security nightmares of Eths account model (i.e. no global variables, functions have no side effects)
- troymc 3y agoThe second sentence of the abstract says, "Rather than executing computations on Bitcoin, they are merely verified..."
- mouse_ 3y agoLOL always a sham
- adastra22 3y agoThis is true anywhere on any blockchain. There is no reason to do computation by chain validators, only to verify that it was done correctly. (Downvotes? I’m being serious.)
- mhluongo 3y agoIt's not true on any blockchain — Ethereum requires validators to actually run smart contract code, for example. On-chain verification is the ideal though. On-chain computation is incredibly expensive and wasteful.
- legutierr 3y agoOn-chain computation is required if state is also stored on-chain. Local state is transformed by every node on the network in exactly the same way. It's not wasteful—it's the reason that every node knows definitively that the state advertised by the rest of the network is actually correct.
- adastra22 3y agoNot true! Validators and users don't actually care what what computation happened, they only care that whatever computation happened, did so according to the rules that were set in the contract in the beginning. To make things concrete let's look at an example. Computational state in a block chain contract is typically stored in a Merkle hash trie. Let's say that the data stored is a key, and the holder of the key is allowed to spend the coins bound to the contract. The _computation_ is to check that the key is contained within the Merkel trie, then check signature of the key and the spend. However with some cool zero-knowledge crypto magic, you don't even have to reveal the Merkle inclusion proof, nor even the key itself. All you have to do is provide a zero-knowledge transcript which verifies that the computation of the contract (Merkle inclusion proof and signature check) validates. This is, essentially, how zerocash works. This result generalizes. For whatever computation you want to perform in a contract, the contract can be rewritten to instead just validate a transcript of a successful execution of that computation. This isn't just academic either. All NP problems have transcripts that are validatable in polynomial time. A derivative of this result is that while you might need Turing completeness to express the logic of a smart contract, you do NOT need Turing completeness to validate its transcript. As a trivial example, a smart contract that involves computing a hash preimage by brute force in a tight loop, could be replaced with a contract that merely takes a string and checks that it hashes to the desired value.
- guluarte 3y agoBitcon can be turing complete but it is not on purpose.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoDefinitely opens the possibility of a Bitcoin-on-Bitcoin implementation.
- thelastparadise 3y agoWhat would be the point of that? With bitcoin blocks as slow and small as they are, which is a good thing for security and decentralization, implementing bitcoin on top of the bitcoin chain would just slow this down even more. Perhaps lightning is what you're thinking of.
- dartos 3y agoWhy build anything-in-anything? It’s like a true classic computer science meme
- pcdoodle 3y agoAs funny as this comment is, I really think the bitcoin blockchain is an implementation of a truth engine. It's currently a ledger for most people but you can be pretty damn sure what has been written 1 hour ago, is the absolute truth.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago“you can be pretty damn sure that some JSON got POSTed with appropriate signatures/a hash reward attached to it to some nodes listening on a peer-to-peer network and propagated around”
- colesantiago 3y agoSo more non-solutions in search of a problem, there is no use case for this only burning more computing cycles. This is the best way to take something that doesn't work at all for the environment and make it even worse.
- RockRobotRock 3y agoSeems like a toy project
- hoc 3y agoIf there's a reactive, stateful medium, there will be a generalized Game of Life implementation described in LaTeX at some point.
- telegpt 3y ago[dead]
- westcort 3y agoTime to bring together every trend into a single product: An LLM and image generator developed through a cryptocurrency-based distributed network that is also a social media platform.
- kikokikokiko 3y agoOn the metaverse.
- mjburgess 3y agoOnly 16hrs/frame
- ben-schaaf 3y agoI was curious so I did some back of the napkin math: On ethereum you get: ~3 gas per instruction 15 million gas per block 12s per block ~420000 instructions per second From online sources of stable diffusion on a GTX 1050 at 20 steps: 40 seconds to generate 1.8 TFLOPS at full precision 70 trillion instructions That's around 5.2 years. If you account for a lack of floating point instructions (a ~34x instruction overhead) that's 180 years per image.
- andirk 3y agoSomeone brought the TCP and the HTTP together. Both popular. Worked out.
- kinakomochidayo 3y agoThe costs involved in getting this to work would be way too expensive. It's a fascinating trick, but not realistic for any practical use.
- derangedHorse 3y agoIt already works and has a proof of concept available: https://github.com/supertestnet/tapleaf-circuits https://github.com/supertestnet/tapleaf-circuits
- kinakomochidayo 3y agoYou’re missing my original point - it’s increasingly expensive for increasingly complex logic to be used for anything practical
- FearOfTheDuck 3y agoWhen to expect a running Doom on bitcoin?
- m3kw9 3y agoOk so they copy Etherum on their next bitcoin client update.
- cinndyscott 3y ago[dead]