6 ms·
AI pioneers LeCun, Bengio clash in intense online AI safety, governance debate
- adolph 3y agoI don't see anything new here, just a rehash of people of differing perspectives talking past one another. Bengio argued for the importance of prudence, stating that we still do not understand how to design safe, powerful AI systems, and highlighted the need for major investment in AI safety and governance. He also questioned the wisdom of open-sourcing powerful AI systems, likening it to freely distributing dangerous weapons. LeCun . . . countered Bengio’s claims about investment in AI safety, asserting that there is a significant amount of funding being poured into making AI systems safe and reliable. LeCun also disagreed with the comparison of AI systems to weapons, stating AI is designed to enhance human intelligence, not to cause harm.
- player1234 3y agoLeCun has a lot if blood on his hands since he single handedly made radiologists obsolete. Add underselling the importance of AI security to the death count. When the prophet says jump you better ask how high. No wonder the kids these days be saying "off yourself like a radiologist", they are coming of age in this time the historians call "The LeCun havoc".
- skulk 3y agoBlood stains the hands of the society that fails to care for those whose labor has been supplanted, not those of the inventor.
- mullingitover 3y agoI wish more of the medical field could be made obsolete with AI. The American Medical Association is a cartel that purposefully limits the supply of medical providers in order to drive up prices, and they're very successful at it. The de facto rationing of medical care caused by high prices kills people who can't afford care. There's blood on hands, but it's not on the hands of the people who are increasing access to medical treatment.
- ChatGTP 3y agoFor a 23 year old who just got into radiology, being replaced is going to be a rough confusing time, if it happens..., not everyone is some rich old AMA executive sitting around gold clubs laughing about charging plebs like you a lot of money? Your comment sounds vengeful to the very people you'd turn to if you were facing a medical crisis. I understand the point though, just not sure why people have to make these sweeping statements whenever someone points out that the job losses from AI might be very very rough.
- __loam 3y agoIf some aspect of medical care can be effectively automated, we should do it. We should do everything we can to make medical care more affordable. Nobody wants to put you in particular out of a job but frankly if you're arguing that we should keep medical care more expensive because you deserve to get money for a job that a computer can do better, that's a tough argument. Fwiw, I've heard you guys aren't getting replaced by this stuff anyway.
- ChatGTP 3y agoI I’m just saying it’s not practical for everyone to be replaced because it will crush the economy. Your health depends on you having money to buy food.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]