6 ms·
NY bill would require a criminal history check for the purchase of a 3D printer
- fastneutron 3y agoAre there any documented cases of people actually committing crimes with a 3D printed firearm?
- jprd 3y agoCommitting a crime, such as possessing a 3D printed firearm?
- Vt71fcAqt7 3y agoThat is not a crime AFAIK.
- edgineer 3y agoShould you 3d print an auto sear (a little bracket-looking thing) then you're in possession of a machine gun, which is illegal.
- refurb 3y agoWhy was this downvoted? The federal laws do state that "possession of specific machine gun parts is considered possession of a machine gun" Machine gun sears included. Also parts that convert a semi-automatic into a machine gun like a Lightening Link.
- commandar 3y agoBecause it's a non-sequitur. Unregistered machine guns are illegal to possess regardless of how they were made. 3D printing an otherwise legal firearm is not illegal at the Federal level in the United States. The exchange boils down to: Comment: That isn't illegal. Reply: well, if you do this other thing that's illegal, it is.
- indigo0086 3y agoWhere is that law applied?
- jprd 3y agohttps://www.nycourts.gov/judges/cji/2-PenalLaw/265/265-01(9).pdf https://www.nycourts.gov/judges/cji/2-PenalLaw/265/265-01(9)... https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2021/S14A https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2021/S14A https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2021/S13A https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2021/S13A https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/080823zr_dc8f.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/080823zr_dc8...
- jprd 3y agoalso - my bad formatting aside, I am NOT in favor of 3D printer registration or legislation in any way. That will be silly, counterproductive and even less impactful than having to show my license and sign an affidavit just to buy properly working cold meds in a gorram grocery store.
- core-utility 3y agoOnly illegal in certain states, not federally
- PrivateButts 3y agoIt was federally illegal until 2013 if it's wasn't able to be detected by a metal detector: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undetectable_Firearms_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undetectable_Firearms_Act Some folks have tried to reintroduce it again. It's one of the few gun laws that even the NRA approved of.
- 15155 3y ago..if you didn't include a piece of ferrous metal in the frame, which most folks specifically did to comply with that legislation. Not to mention: a magazine and all ammunition is automatically detectable (visually and magnetically.)
- PrivateButts 3y agoAFAIK 3d printed guns aren't illegal as long as they're able to be detected by a metal detector, unless a state has passed a law that imposes an additional restriction.
- yungporko 3y agoi'm not sure if it was 3d printed but shinzo abe was assassinated with a "homemade firearm". it's a bullshit law either way though.
- indigo0086 3y agoIt's illegal to kill people in japan.
- core-utility 3y agoNot 3D printed. 2 metal barrels and some wood from a hardware store. I guess those should be "firearm parts" in New York
- cainxinth 3y agoGhost gun use in U.S. crimes has risen more than 1,000% since 2017, federal report says: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ghost-gun-use-crimes-1000-percent-rise-since-2017-atf-report/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ghost-gun-use-crimes-1000-perce... Number of 3D-printed ghost guns soaring in New York: https://abc7ny.com/nyc-ghost-guns-3d-printed-printer/13345006/ https://abc7ny.com/nyc-ghost-guns-3d-printed-printer/1334500... 3D Printed Gun Arrests Tripled in Less Than Two Years – 3DPrint.com Investigates: https://3dprint.com/291684/3d-printed-gun-arrests-tripled-in-less-than-two-years-3dprint-com-investigates/ https://3dprint.com/291684/3d-printed-gun-arrests-tripled-in...
- core-utility 3y agoA 3D printed gun can be a ghost gun, but a ghost gun is not inherently 3D printed (99%+ aren't)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sirmike_ 3y agoThat does not count. Those are all from parts kits. 3D printing of firearms outside of superficial accessories is a fraction of a fraction. And newsflash to the world -- Americans have been making "ghost guns" for hundreds of years. Hardly the worth the attention of Law Enforcement. Maybe focus on real crime and not propaganda tuned to scare the average burbanite.
- m4jor 3y agoThose are all 80% polymers. Ghost Gun != 3D printed firearm
- kkielhofner 3y agoThis is almost certainly a reaction to the "Glock auto switch"[0]. They are used to convert semi-automatic Glock handguns to fully automatic (which is illegal without a tax stamp). They are very popular with criminals (typically gangs) in the US[1]. [0] - https://www.yeggi.com/q/glock+auto+switch/ https://www.yeggi.com/q/glock+auto+switch/ [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glock_switch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glock_switch
- 15155 3y ago> which is illegal without a tax stamp Or a Type 7 FFL w/ Class 3 SOT. Stamps are not obtainable post-1986, resulting in a de facto ban.
- icegreentea2 3y agoThe proposal is for 3D printers that are capable of printing a firearm, or firearm component. Which is actually really broad. From what I can find, NY law doesn't define "firearm component", but it does define "major firearm component" to include "barrel, slide, cylinder, frame or receiver". And I imagine pretty much any decent 3d printer can print a receiver for a gun designed to be 3d printed...
- thelastparadise 3y agoAt that point it seems simpler to turn a couple of sticks and some string into a bow and arrow.
- kotaKat 3y agoNo, I'm just going to go down to Lowes and buy a couple pieces of pipe, a nail, and then go find some shotgun shells. It's time that New York bans hardware stores, obviously.
- oxfordmale 3y agoJust get a brick....too late, now every brick needs to be barcoded with the biometric details of the purchaser. Such a law makes sense in countries like the UK, where it is extremely hard to get a gun as a normal civilian. The guns produced by 3D printer can be fired a limited number of time, and a long car drive allows you to buy a gun legally in the US.
- 317070 3y agoWhat makes a 3D printer different from a lathe or a CNC?
- Buxato 3y agoGood point, because without CNC, with 3d printers solely you couldn't do a firearm that do more of 1 shot. CNC are more "dangerous" for firearm production. This bill is a show of ignorance of the legislators.
- commandar 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FGC-9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FGC-9 Designed with the explicit intent of containing no parts that are regulated as firearm components in Europe. Including the barrel, which is manufactured using 3D printed jigs and a bench top power supply. These are in active use right now, most notably by anti-junta rebels in Myanmar, who have literally been running print farms in the jungle to produce them.
- namlem 3y agoThat's not true, there are ways to make pressure-bearing parts such as barrels without machining tools.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Thervicarl 3y agoNews headlines about "3D-printed guns".
- aleph_minus_one 3y agoBut what about news headlines about "CNC milled guns"? ;-)
- neallindsay 3y agoAccording to my casual Googling, metal lathes start out a lot more expensive than 3d printers. Wood lathes and CNC machines are surprisingly affordable though. So this seems like a good question.
- logicchains 3y agoWhat next, they'll ban transporting 3D printers across state borders and have the cops go around knocking down doors hunting for unlicensed 3D printers? Otherwise people would just buy them interstate.
- tinus_hn 3y agoYou can actually go all the way to the prohibition era and create the printer yourself, the designs are free.
- Euphorbium 3y agoBan stepper motors as the precursor to 3d printers. Shit, ban copper wire.
- variants 3y agoWait until they find out about machine shops that can make anything out of metal!
- gorbachev 3y agoThat amendment is so overly broad the author should be forced to re-take some sort of how to draft bills class. It would require fingerprinting for purchases of "certain 3D printers". What does that even mean? I guess the existing law defined what "firearm" means in the context of that law, but if I was a retailer selling 3D printers, I would have some serious questions about it. My 5-year-old entry level 3D printer could probably print parts of a firearm, but those parts would probably not be very durable to a point they would be completely unusable. Would selling that printer be subject to this law? Who the f** knows. I don't think the author of the bill knows either. Maybe someone could ask. She's Jenifer Rajkumar: https://nyassembly.gov/mem/Jenifer-Rajkumar https://nyassembly.gov/mem/Jenifer-Rajkumar This bill is listed on her list of sponsored bills: https://nyassembly.gov/mem/Jenifer-Rajkumar/sponsor/ https://nyassembly.gov/mem/Jenifer-Rajkumar/sponsor/
- Simulacra 3y agoIn New York legislation is drafted by attorneys, the elected person and their staff don't usually write them. It's still bloody awful but I think it's worse because an actual attorney was supposed to write this
- giantg2 3y agoIn most places, the legislation is drafted by special interest groups.
- giantg2 3y agoI also think the law is bad. I do want to point out that if you want to make durable parts with a 3D printer, the easiest thing to do would be to create the part with the printer, then use it to form a mold for casting the part out of metal. Then case harden. That's the cheap and fairly easy way. I just want to point that out because I think that use case of 3D printers gets overlooked. Or you buy a fairly expensive lathe/mill.
- swell36 3y agoMy first thought was, will this apply to basically all machinery? Because for about $2000 I can buy a mill kit that I can manufactur a complete firearm on.
- Ajay-p 3y agoI should buy a 3D printer. At university I knew a man who said any time the government wanted to make something illegal to buy he felt a compulsion to buy it. I think I see what he means now.
- gotts 3y agoIt's definitely not a bad time to join 3d printing industry. Much more mature than what it was even 5+ yrs ago
- irrational 3y agoWhat is a good 3D printer?
- lawn 3y agoA Prusa is more reliable but more expensive than the entry level printers you'll see. If you want a great DIY printer then VORON is the one to beat. Lots of people love the Bamboolabs printers.
- aranaur 3y agoIf you want a tool, buy a Prusa. If you want a project, build a Voron.
- giantg2 3y agoDepends on what you want to do with it. For small hobby projects, I like my Ender 3 Pro. There are some better ones with more features, but this one is cheap.
- tiznow 3y agoHonestly, it depends on your budget and the features you want. My main workhorse right now is a Sovol SV06, one of the "it girl" printers of 2022. I own the Sovol, an Ender 3 v2, a Mingda Magician X and an AnyCubic Kobra Go. All of these printers work for me now, but that's because I've suffered the frustrating learning curve of 3D printers. For a newer 3D printing hobbyist I would latch onto a brand that offers a 90% or 100% assembled printer -- with a large community for aftermarket add-on buys or prints. Ender, Sovol, AnyCubic, Elegoo -- just look for the brands with massive communities. They tend to keep manufacturers accountable and creative. So many companies are putting out "out of the box" wonder printers right now that I would just engage in a few weeks of YouTube watching. A printer release could come out tomorrow that completely changes the value proposition of whatever you were looking at. Funny enough, size matters -- if you want to print helmets in one piece, you have to look at larger printers.
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- sirmike_ 3y agoNope. But NY can fuck over its own citizens until the Decision Class and Elites Leave. It may take a few more decades or years for them to sink into their own version of Detroit circa the 60's. But it is already happening across once large and prosperous cities. PS, an un-friendly jab: LOL; voting blue no matter who sure is working.
- RiOuseR 3y ago[dead]
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- lawn 3y agoYou don't have to buy a 3D printer, you can build one using off-the-shelf components and printed parts. The VORON printers for example, and they're beastly printers. They should appeal to the HN audience as they're completely open source and moddable.
- rtaylorgarlock 3y agoAnd not to mention absolutely insane in terms of price to performance. Used Voron kit builds aren't that hard to find stateside either.
- Jemm 3y agoWait till they find out that you can make a 3d printer quite easily and that many 3d printers are open source.
- tiznow 3y agoVirtually any 3D printer that isn't bottom-barrel Amazon crap can print off a pistol lower. So the same item that one can buy in 49 other states at Micro Center or via Amazon now requires the same process as acquiring a firearm -- another thing that New York state is loathe about. No matter what you think about the potential of 3D printers, just consider that at any given time there are folds more people printing the Rocktopus or hose couplers than there are firearms.
- jprete 3y agoIs there any support for this bill or is it just a random NY legislator proposing a bill with no actual support or plan for getting it passed? EDIT: It looks like this bill is in committee and only has one sponsor, so I am thinking no, but one never knows.
- kobalsky 3y agoSomeone has to dip their toe in to see how people react. That no big names are behind it doesn't mean they aren't "behind" it. The people who proposed this need to be put on display tied upside down somewhere so that the message is clear. If someone tells you "I want to take a crap on your head", the apropriate response is not saying NO, it's making sure they never ask that question again.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stevespang 3y ago[dead]
- karmakaze 3y agoI was curious what NY does for purchasing a firearm and found this article[0] which says: > New York is now a point of contact state, meaning the New York State Police NICS Unit will process National Instant Criminal Background Checks (NICS) when a customer tries to purchase a firearm. NYSP NICS will contact the FBI to determine if the buyer qualifies to purchase the gun. So it's good to see that they're not imposing something on purchasing a 3D printer that isn't also done for what they're trying to control. But then the article goes on to say: > For ammunition, the division of the state police will check a state record system to decide if a customer is permitted to purchase ammunition. This state background check is a new system. Previously, there was no ammunition background check and gun shops submit requests directly to FBI NICS without passing through the state. > “They’re putting excess burden on systems that are already working,” Jeff Benty, CEO of Just Holster It Firearms and Training Center in Elma told News 4. “That communication [between the shop and FBI] is severed off and we have to pass through the state, so basically the state has used their government authority to inject themselves in the middle and now charge customers a toll fee.” > Customers have to pay $9 per firearm background check and $2.50 per ammunition background check. The state says the money collected will pay for the new background check system. Seems like the state could be rent-seeking. I sure hope the requests aren't merely forwarded to the FBI every time someone buys a 3D printer (or refill filament). [0] https://www.wivb.com/news/it-was-really-inconvenient-new-york-processes-all-gun-ammunition-background-checks/ https://www.wivb.com/news/it-was-really-inconvenient-new-yor...
- 15155 3y agoIt's not "rent seeking" - the state doesn't need $9.. it's a poll tax designed to further inconvenience one from exercising their rights.
- bentt 3y agoI grew up in NY and it's such an overbearing and oppressive state government.
- hcrean 3y agoPlease, dear God, don't anyone tell them about sand-casting... Explanation for non-mechs: Make a shape out of wood with a chisel, push it into sand to make a void, melt Alu in a glorified BBQ, pour into sand to make a perfect replica of the wooden template. You can turn out 100 high quality "mechanical parts" in alloyed metal in the same time it takes to 3D print one in PLA.
- eindiran 3y agoAgain with the casting in this thread. What parts are you imagining you can make this way? Modern small arms generally require quite good tolerances. If you aren't going for that (which you clearly aren't because you chose casting lol), just buy a pipe and move on.
- hcrean 3y agoUnfortunately your knowledge of industrial manufacturing processes might not be as strong as you think it is. The immediate evidence to consider is that people cast their own Warhammer desktop war-gaming miniatures at home: The feature accuracy of these is much higher than the milling accuracy of cheap ARmalite knock-offs.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoCountdown to people selling 80% 3d printer kits. But seriously though, I'd hope this either doesn't pass or has a clear carve-out for reprap people.
- jamesbond009 3y ago[dead]