6 ms·
One thing he says at around 43'00" is that the shift from feudalism to capitalism, i.e., ownership of the means of production, was based on two pillars: profits
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
One thing he says at around 43'00" is that the shift from feudalism to capitalism, i.e., ownership of the means of production, was based on two pillars: profits and markets. However, the author says techno-feudalism's "markets", e.g. Amazon, Alibaba, Uber, are not markets in the classic sense, but "platforms" where trading, buying and selling, takes place outside the marketplace. The techno-feudal lords collect rents. Uber does not own cars. "The landlord does not participate in production." AirBnB, Amazon are other cited examples. As such, profits are replaced by rents and markets are replaced by techno-fiefdoms. His book argues that this is not "capitalism" in the classic sense. It's something else. He admits some of his colleagues would simply call it "rentier capitalism", but he prefers to ditch the term "capitalism". He argues our ancestors could have called capitalism "industrial feudalism" or "capital feudalism". He wants to make the point that this is not capitalism anymore, even though it's based on the triumph of capital.
He says repeatedly that "when everything has to go through" Google, Apple, Facebook, etc., but he never uses the word "intermediary". Were feudal lords intermediaries. In the early days of the internet I recall there was talk of "disintermediation" that would be enabled through the growth of the network and yet today it feels as though the internet itself has become the source of excessive, toxic intermediation. Toxic for one because it comes with absurd levels of surveillance and data collection.
The author sounds like he would be a fun professor to have as a student.
- throw310822 3y agoI think it's similar to the very beginning of industrialization, when factory owners were exploiting large numbers of entirely fungible unskilled labourers. Opening the gates to the factory in the morning and admitting as many desperate people as needed, paying them with the bare minimum necessary to their survival. And those who became sick were simply replaced by others. Today the factory has been replaced by the mega-corporation, and the "workers" are now smaller businesses and private entrepreneurs or individual producers. Their job is now skilled and personal, but the offer is so vast that each of them is fungible anyway. The platform, which acts as a gateway, has no obligations towards them and can replace them at any time (and therefore has complete power over them). Historically this situation has been solved by imposing limits to the freedom of factory owners and allowing workers to unionize, to restore a balance of power between the capitalists and the masses of workers. This has not been done yet with the new internet economy.
- lazide 3y agoMainly because the internet allows people to compete with you without a physical presence at time of sale, which breaks almost all countermeasures or ability to reduce harms in a specific area. For Uber, airports were about the only ones able to apply any real pressure.
- cbsmith 3y ago> Today the factory has been replaced by the mega-corporation, and the "workers" are now smaller businesses and private entrepreneurs or individual producers. Those factories were owned by companies. I don't think things have really changed. > Historically this situation has been solved by imposing limits to the freedom of factory owners and allowing workers to unionize, to restore a balance of power between the capitalists and the masses of workers. This has not been done yet with the new internet economy. In more recent history, the trend has been to reduce those limits, and generally remove whatever leverage labour has. Saying "it has not been done yet" seriously understates it.
- CMCDragonkai 3y agoThis is kind of why web3 is a actually a movement towards where users are owners. Thus decentralized marketplaces.
- antoniuschan99 3y agoI think web3 works for stuff like dropbox, so like dedentralized cloud computing services but has issues with things that tap into the real world like uber or airbnb in the sense that there needs to be a centralized place for support issues.
- livueta 3y agoDNMs "tap into the real world" and do shockingly well. I'd agree that it doesn't come for free and requires creative and well-implemented solutions that may not neatly translate to existing business models like uber.
- diogenes4 3y agoBeing based on crypto, which is even more wildly unequally distributed than fiat currency, makes this idea a non-starter.
- CMCDragonkai 3y agoCrypto is more unequally distributed than fiat? If that is true, that would be because fiat is unequally distributed. Nothing inherent to crypto makes it more unequal any more than capitalism itself.
- diogenes4 3y ago> Nothing inherent to crypto makes it more unequal any more than capitalism itself. Well aside from the fact that most people don't own crypto....
- thelastgallon 3y ago> Were feudal lords intermediaries. Aren't feudal lords intermediaries, empowered by the king? kings had the power to replace one feudal lord with another.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoehhh kinda. a lot of "kings" were first among equals, and had shaky loyalty from their underlings at best. the difference between a "fair and just tax levied by the local lord" and "thugs beating you until you cough up the gold, then giving a cut to their mafia boss" is small. feudalism makes a lot more sense if you think about it as loose groups of warlords and mafia dons stabbing each other and leaning on The Church for clout.
- cbsmith 3y ago> Uber does not own cars. Unlike, say, the NYSE, which owns all the equities that are traded there?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIn the interview, he actually says BlackRock, State Street and Vanguard own "90% of the stock market". NB. There are all his statements, not mine!
- hbt 3y agoaren't they the largest shareholders in 90% of companies but actually own maybe 20% of the total stock market? i don't recall the latest number but it should be around that
- throwaway5959 3y agoAnd they don’t even really own them. They’re just buying them on behalf of investors. That doesn’t sell books though or rile people up.
- hbt 3y agoYes, there are authors pushing a narrative. But, let's not pretend these institutions are powerless. They often get a board seat; although, some give up their proxy vote and they are pushing an agenda with their ESG score. Unsure how much of it is just optics.
- cbsmith 3y agoThat's a serious exaggeration. Their combined portfolios are maybe $20 trillion. The S&P 500's market cap alone is $40 trillion. They've got huge asset portfolios, yes, but the market is just so much larger.