5 ms·
It would be nice if browsers were able to get around all these kinds of shenanigans directly, instead of having to always reach for extensions and addons and en
by ryandrake 3y ago
It would be nice if browsers were able to get around all these kinds of shenanigans directly, instead of having to always reach for extensions and addons and endlessly participate in this cat and mouse game. After all, the browser is supposed to be the user's agent. Its job is to do what the user wants and fetch the content that the user asks for.
Somewhere along the path, we've made a terrible turn and allowed the browsers to become agents of the web developers instead, gatekeeping on behalf of web sites, rather than serving the user's interests.
My ideal browser would load up a site like YouTube, and, knowing my already-configured preference for ad-free, minimalist layout, would present it as a Craigslist-style list of links with thumbnails, ignoring the mess of JS and CSS that the site's developer futilely sends.
- drdaeman 3y ago> Somewhere along the path, we've made a terrible turn It was a variation of Eternal September that caused it. ;) The majority of users became non-technical, so the focus had shifted as browser vendors needed to cater to different audiences.
- tgv 3y agoNot needed, but could. Google simply exploited that possibility, from the start.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoMy ideal getaway car would include an automated drone which flies into the store to exfiltrate the codes from the prepaid cards, and present them as credits in my phone, ignoring the mess of walking inside, paying, and typing into my phone that the retailer futilely demands.
- anon_cow1111 3y agoI don't think firefox could reasonably do this, just because a significant part of their funding comes directly from google. And maybe more relevant, having this be default behavior would just cause the cat-and-mouse to get worse, when the majority of users are now blocking it with no effort, and the bean-counters notice the ad impression numbers suddenly dropping.
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agothis is true from a practical standpoint. It's like an adult watching a child's idealism and knowing the child is right. I'm not calling the OP a child, I'm saying the OP is right and the world sucks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atleta 3y agoLookig at it source (the page downloaded when you open a YT link pointing to a video), it's almost certain that YT doesn't load without JS. It's not an html page with some extra functionality implemented in JS, it's a web app that builds the web page you see from JS. So firefox can't do much about it without actively trying to circumvent YT and YT specifically. I don't think browsers made the turn you mention. It's more like browsers became more and more capable and web developers made use of it. Sometimes it's annoying because most websites are not websites anymore but apps (GUIs) that run in the browser and some of the web sites/apps people use could never work without it. Sure, we could all deploy those apps onto our machines (or have them deploy automatically in a sandbox) and there were actually technologies that did just that (think java web start or whatever the name ended up being) but they lost to what we have now: running these apps in the browser. Also, you can't have an ad-free experience if the price of using a service is that the ad is delivered to you. On YT you can buy a subscription and you'll see no ads. But sure, most sites don't offer this.
- mandmandam 3y ago> Also, you can't have an ad-free experience if the price of using a service is that the ad is delivered to you. On YT you can buy a subscription and you'll see no ads. Just to be very clear, those are not the only two possible options. YouTube - and Facebook, Google, Whatsapp, etc - are extraordinarily simple concepts. We don't need private corporations running them for profit. In fact, it's turning out really bad for us.
- yakshaving_jgt 3y agoYou're welcome to build an alternative and claim their kingdom. The reason that hasn't happened yet is because whether or not you find YT an extraordinarily simple concept, the execution is tremendously difficult.
- littlestymaar 3y agoThe execution being nontrivial is not in fact the main reason why you can't just “claim their kingdom”, their biggest most is by far the network effect, not the technological challenges (which also nontrivial, is far more tractable today than it used to be when YouTube was founded, and even then it still only required 67 employees to build from scratch).
- tianqi 3y agoI'm not sure you can still "do what you want" because without ads Youtube would not exist.
- globular-toast 3y agoWhere does this idea that YouTube couldn't exist without ads? Not with it's current architecture, sure, but do people really lack the imagination to see a web with videos that aren't served by a monopoly? Peer-to-peer sharing has been around for a very long time and works very well. You can share large content right now with essentially no extra cost (you already pay for bandwidth, you already have storage etc). The trouble is finding said content. There is a huge conflict of interest due to the most popular search engine also owning the most popular centralised content platform. This should never have been allowed to happen, but here we are.
- pmontra 3y agoHow could that work, given that a web site can change its working every day? Each site can have its passionated circumvention developer that maintains an extension like this. Is it reasonable to expect that each browser can do the same for each website? And is it reasonable to expect it for Google's Chrome?
- vorticalbox 3y agoI guess in an idea world servers would return only data and browsers would style that data to each yours preferred looks.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoIt is within Mozilla's reach to spend an extra $200k on compatibility [hacks] for each of the top ten websites. Their CEO could easily take a $2M wage cut and still be overpaid.
- RockRobotRock 3y agoGo ahead, fork Firefox with extensions pre-installed that disable JS and default settings that disable CSS. See if your idealistic world works in reality. :)
- butz 3y agoWhat you just described is "User agent stylesheet" and in theory you could build your own styles for any website which your browser will prefer.
- petree 3y agoYou can use NoScript to disable JS and see how well that works. But more to the point, yes, a browser is a client, but without the economic incentive of either ads or direct monetization from users, many sites, YouTube included, would simply not work. Storage and bandwith costs money. Unless we decided to somehow fund all of this through some sort of additional tax through the ISPs or governments, ads or subscriptions are a necessary evil.
- tgv 3y agoStorage and bandwidth cost money, but not $14/month. You can get a server for yourself for that kind of money, and I don't think YouTube has a server per user.
- marticode 3y agoProducing content also cost money, and producers get a cut of the ads or the subscription.
- safety1st 3y agoThis kind of fantasy microeconomics debate is silly at best, disingenuous at worst. We are talking about a company with $280B in revenue per year and one of the highest profit margins in America. How they spend that money is not connected to what is fair or what makes some kind of logical sense in your head. It's connected to whatever will increase their profits further. All you are doing is laying down cover fire to support further advances by an abusive monopolist. YouTube's financials don't HAVE to add up. Google owns advertising for the entire Internet! The entirety of YT could be a loss leader just to suppress the growth of streaming video businesses outside of their control, and the Google monopoly would carry on.
- petree 3y agoHaving a loss leader like this is exactly monopolistic behavior though. The fact that Google are trying to make money from it is expected and more fair to their competitors than just having it completely free, and not having ads either.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoNow that DRM are part of the web standards, and TPM are generalized, it's game over. I predict youtube will escalate this way: - Pump up aggressive anti ad block measures. - It will fail, so they will enforce DRM so that they have control. - It will not be enough, so they will ask to only serve DRM to "trusted browsers". - And it will not suffice, so the trusted browser will have to run on a trusted OS checked by hardware. That will work since almost nobody will take the risk to jailbreak their expensive device. And we will all have lost.
- JodieBenitez 3y ago> And we will all have lost. Or we will all be gone elsewhere ?
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoWho? The people paying thousands of dollars for locked down mac devices they never modify, the ones giving all their data to social network and clicking on ads or the ones sending money to the NPC streamers to watch them licking an imaginary icecream? HN is the opposite of their market.
- _Algernon_ 3y agoYoutube just isn't valueable enough (in my mind), to get away with that.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoThe new generation knows mostly the web through jailed devices called "smartphones". They will have no idea, and just assume that's how things are. HN bubble strikes again.
- _Algernon_ 3y agoI'm well aware that I'm an outlier here which is why I stated "in my mind". Not sure why you feel the need to write "HN bubble strikes again" except for a lack of reading comprehension or an attempt at trolling.
- kzrdude 3y agoIt's a lot better if the user-agent is extensible. For one thing, so that users can customize it. But also so that it will not be summarily blocked by websites and networks.
- pchangr 3y agoDuckDuckGo browser does this by default
- cyanydeez 3y agoMost of these services just don't exist in that timeline.