4 ms·
Apple's new video reactions are making therapy awkward
- JCharante 3y agoThis looks like it’s only through facetime? Do people really facetime their therapist? I expected zoom or some website with video chat built in that telehealth providers use.
- davikr 3y agoNo, it happens in other apps. [0] [0]: https://cdn.masto.host/mastodonie/cache/media_attachments/files/111/229/501/291/640/892/original/2d11ec97c6eb5c84.png https://cdn.masto.host/mastodonie/cache/media_attachments/fi...
- Ndymium 3y agoThe original post on fedi [0] claims it can happen in any video call app. [0] https://xoxo.zone/@mathowie/111229500871588422 https://xoxo.zone/@mathowie/111229500871588422
- jlarocco 3y ago> Do people really facetime their therapist? Why not Facetime?
- hellotheretoday 3y agoNot hipaa compliant for one
- rchaud 3y agoOnline therapy doesn't have to be HIPAA compliant on technology used to communicate with the client. If the client wants to use FaceTime, they have to inform them that it's not HIPAA-compliant and confirm that they're OK to continue. HIPAA comes into play if the therapist wants to securely share client care notes with another care provider.
- hellotheretoday 3y agoThis is true. That said the agreement with the insurance provider or billing processer often requires a hipaa compliant platform with a BAA. I bill through the headway platform as an example and they require a hipaa compliant telehealth platform with BAA for processing. In addition I believe my contract with Aetna specifies the same although it’s been awhile since I’ve reviewed it tbf. an interesting question that comes up for me is whether these companies are harvesting content of meetings and chats for training models and whatnot. The BAA is a (small) protection for myself in case it turns out that zoom is training their AI assistant on meeting chats or closed captioning without participant consent. Although I would hope that the liability in that scenario would mostly fall on zoom as that’s really an abuse on their part.
- kawfey 3y agohonestly I trust the security of FaceTime or Zoom more than that of third party telehealth apps.
- hellotheretoday 3y agoSure but zoom is hipaa compliant and FaceTime is not. Apple refuses to share a business associate agreement whereas zoom shares this with paid plans. I do agree that I seriously question the security of the small telehealth platforms that cropped up during Covid though, hipaa compliant or not. I am certain apple does security significantly better than simplepractice, doxy.me, etc but it’s the regulatory piece of handling PHI. The BAA is essential to that and apple/discord/etc have made it clear through their silence after years that they don’t want to be responsible for safe data handling of phi. Bottom line though is if your therapist is using FaceTime/discord/etc they are ignorant to hipaa protocols or not practicing ethically, both are concerning. Very frustrating from a consumer perspective because how the fuck are you supposed to know what is and isn’t hipaa compliant. It’s silly to have to research whether your clinician is using a regulatory compliant platform but here we are, I guess
- CHSbeachbum420 3y ago[flagged]
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- vlovich123 3y agoNot to feed the troll, but there’s ~1.5B active iPhone users. That’s 20% of all people globally use an iPhone. You really feel confident making this claim? Would you apply the same claim to Android users? Also, I don’t see why Zoom would be more trusted. FaceTime is end to end encrypted and Apple has a decent reputation with how they approach privacy and pretty well respected for security. Certainly would trust it more over zoom or some random white labeled 3p telehealth video conferencing solution.
- upon_drumhead 3y agoI use reactions via webex and zoom. I like them, and as other posters said, it’s a big green button in your menu bar to turn them off.
- jitl 3y agoIt’s part of the webcam feed provided by the OS to apps on the latest macOS. This means the effects apply across all apps. You can increase lighting adjustment (aka Studio Light) and depth of field with sliders in the system menu bar, as well as toggle thede reactions on and off. They’re on by default. For what it’s worth the lighting and background blur effects are really good, much better than the tuning built into Zoom. I’m leaving the reactions on too for the comedy for now but I’ll probably turn them off eventually.
- nickthegreek 3y agoI didn’t know this was available at an OS level. Excited to try this blur over the Google Meet implementation. Found instructions here: https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/use-video-conferencing-features-on-your-mac-mchlff01c919/mac https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/use-video-conferenc...
- snowe2010 3y agoIt doesn’t work over google meet. The other person was wrong, it does not apply to the OS video feed, apps have to explicitly support it in some manner.
- snowe2010 3y agoThe effects don’t apply across all apps. I tested in google meet last week and it didn’t work.
- kawfey 3y agoIt happened to me in the app mentioned in the article, not FaceTime, on ios. it also occurred to me in a zoom in macOS. Seems to work in any video calling app.
- outside1234 3y agoYou can turn this off people Right up there in the menu bar glowing green for you
- tumult 3y agoOn by default. If you still don't understand: this feature and setting used to not exist. Now it does. And it's on by default. So, it has been turned on for everyone. This is a thing that used to not exist, and now it exists for everyone using this OS. And they will not know what it is or how to turn it off unless they are told by someone else. One day, you get into your car and start driving. But the horn honks whenever you press on the accelerator. An angry drivers rolls down their window and yells at you: "What are you, stupid? The car company went into all of the cars last night and modified them. You need to open the trunk and disconnect the 'honk while accelerating wire'! Jeeze, how can you be so clueless?"
- cj 3y agoI think this is a bit of an unfair take. In software development, a lot of new features are on by default. If Apple hid every new feature behind a on/off setting, no one would enable new features, ever. I really love Mac’s new effect of clicking the desktop which moves all windows away to see your files underneath. Had that feature been added and off by default, there’s zero chance I would have ever enabled it. Yes, I’ve had the reactions inadvertently appear in business calls recently, but it generally just results in amusement from everyone in the meeting. Although I suppose it would kind of suck to accidentally activate the laser show effect if I’m being interviewed on live TV. (Although anyone being interviewed like that should be prepped by the show to get all the settings right for broadcast)
- CamperBob2 3y agoIf Apple hid every new feature behind a on/off setting, no one would enable new features, ever. That's because they hide the on/off settings. Discoverability is no longer considered a worthwhile design goal. Apple's attitude comes down to, "You're either with it, or you're not." (Yes, that's as inherently exclusionary as it sounds. It's astonishing to watch the irony elude nominally-progressive companies like Apple.)
- _boffin_ 3y agoTo me, these effects are akin to adding sugar and fats to food to enhance the flavor of the foods. I really don't need my interactions more enhanced. The other party's emotions, expressions, etc... are enough.
- tbragin 3y agoIt's even more ridiculous than that. I don't need my OS enhancing my own gesticulations. I am enough all by myself (thank you very much). For me, apparently I like to stick out my thumb and then index finger, when I say "first (second, third)", which triggers thumbs up first and baloons second. Really? Totally unhelpful and awkward.
- kgodey 3y agoThis happened to me in a recent work meeting, we were using Google Meet and suddenly the video had a huge animated thumbs up emoji dancing across the screen.
- jader201 3y agoIf I’m understanding the feature you’re talking about, that’s not an automatic reaction based on expressions (like this article/feature). That was shown because someone clicked the thumbs up emoji on their Meet UI. I think these are completely different things.
- kgodey 3y agoI’m pretty familiar with the Meet UI thumbs up feature and this was not it. The other person didn’t take any action other than making a actual thumbs up with their hand. They were confused by the visual as well and it distracted us from the call enough that he ended up investigating and it turned out to be the new Apple feature. Edited to add: FWIW they were on the latest macOS and I wasn’t.
- hnlmorg 3y agoApple’s new filters and animations work against any software using the webcam. Including Google Meets via your web browser. That’s the problem with this new feature. It’s on by default and alters the feed for other software. It’s not all bad though. The filters are actually pretty nice. But expressions, on the other hand, get accidentally triggered often and really shouldn’t be gesture operated (or at least disabled by default)
- fbdab103 3y agoI am reminded of the, "I'm not a cat" lawyer[0]. [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56010156 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56010156
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoThat one got so popular because it touched on several relevant aspects of the cultural zeitgeist - the struggle of everyone moving to remote work - the perceived inability of the older generation to keep up - the perceived ridiculousness of some of the features tech companies were including to try to win the arms race (even though as the article correctly points out this particular feature is decades old, it symbolized a wider trend) - a somewhat humorous spin on all of the above
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qingcharles 3y agoI was in court a lot during COVID. It was funny how many lawyers and defendants were sideways on their Zoom calls due to some issue with the software that couldn't correctly handle vertical calls. And lawyers were all doing their calls from wherever they were. Often in their cars. One lawyer doing his court appearances while shopping at Whole Foods.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- isykt 3y agoI have watched this video about a thousand times and it never, ever fails to make me laugh so hard I get tears in my eyes.
- 1shooner 3y ago"Remember when there weren't fireworks animations on video calls? How did that even work?"
- sergioisidoro 3y agoI would like to live in a world where an operating system is about enabling technology, performance, reliability and security. An OS should not be about animated emojis , or about running a CV program detecting what's going on in the video feed of the hardware, and manipulating it. Apple still makes some of the best hardware I know, but gosh, the software they make...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jitl 3y agoThe effects like background blur and “studio light” substantially improve the practical performance of the webcam and do so across all apps that capture video. The reactions are funny/annoying but as a whole the new video effect feature is the biggest improvement for me in this OS update - I’m on video calls every day sometimes in mediocre light and appreciate how much better I come through with “studio light” tuning the exposure of my face. I was considering spending $$$ on a fancy new webcam, but now I don’t feel the need.
- sergioisidoro 3y agoBut is it the responsibility of the operating system to do that, by default? What if the operating system started to bleep out swear words from the microphone? Or blurring out obscene gestures? Sure, make the software available on install, or even prompt it's configuration and opt in on installation. But it's not and should not be the responsibility of the OS to apply effects or manipulate or alter the data of the hardware.
- amazingman 3y ago> it's not and should not be the responsibility of the OS to apply effects or manipulate or alter the data of the hardware. This position is unworkable in so many cases, but it's especially so for cameras. The data coming out of these sensors is awful, and requires several computationally-expensive passes to clean up. Once you grant that there is a spectrum of data manipulation where reasonable defaults must be selected, you grant that your stated position is unrealistic.
- nilespotter 3y agoI can't think of anything more depressing about modern life than the concept of telehealth therapy. En masse we have swapped in-person interaction for an unsatisfying, vapid mirage that barely resembles it. The novel mental disorders that emerge as a result cannot be fixed with more of the same.
- nickthegreek 3y agoAnd at the same time, many people who couldn’t easy travel to offices due to family, disability or other issues now have a way to access mental health services. People who are open to having honest helpful discussions can use telehealth and achieve worthwhile results.
- danShumway 3y agoTherapy would be completely inaccessible to me without telehealth. It's a massive boon. The downsides of not being physically present with my therapist are heavily outweighed by the added benefits of having regular and consistent access to said therapist. It takes something that would otherwise be an irregular and stressful chore and makes it predictable and pleasant and something I look forward to -- and that helps make therapy a useful tool where I can pick things to work on, process how I'm doing, and plan next steps on a regular basis. I also think it's worth noting that the point of therapy is not really to form or reinforce a friendship with a therapist? This isn't like a long distance romantic or platonic relationship, my therapist is not a buddy. Therapy is a tool. I am not trying to form an emotional connection with my therapist; my therapist is there to help me process and plan and work on parts of my life that I want to improve. That's not to say that the human part of therapy isn't important, but it's important because of how it services that goal. A therapist is not a substitute for other human interaction, it's designed to be a one-way relationship. A therapist should not be the primary way that anyone is fulfilling their needs for human intimacy or vulnerability; what a therapist can do is help you identify if you're not meeting those needs and help you form an actionable plan for you to meet them better in your regular life.
- fragmede 3y ago> unsatisfying, vapid mirage that barely resembles it You seem to have a problem with projection. Have you considered seeing a therapist for this problem? If in-person therapy is inaccessible to you, have you considered teletherapy? It has benefits over traditional therapy, especially for those struggling with mental illnesses like agoraphobia or depression. Depression, an insidious disease, makes it hard to even get out of bed and off Netflix. Teletherapy is able to help in those cases as it is accessible without leaving bed or the house. I hope we can agree that some help is better than no help.
- GoodJokes 3y ago[dead]