19 ms·
Snowden Archive – documents leaked by Snowden
- henriquez 3y ago[flagged]
- clubm8 3y agois this new and if not... why today?
- loldk 3y ago[dead]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoMy theory is that trolls/bots work together to get this content to the front page and keep it there. If you pay attention you'll notice Snowden, CIA, FBI, NSA, or adjacent topics on the front page daily with a corresponding political flame war.
- dang 3y agoIt's easy to be tempted by such theories—they're almost mesmeric—but the data doesn't support them. For example in this case the early upvoters (I just checked) are mostly accounts around 10 years old, which have posted and upvoted as ordinary HN users since forever. Of course that doesn't prove they aren't trolls/bots, but it's a strong counterindicator, unless you believe they've been building up a track record of posting about functional programming languages or whatever for nefarious purposes. The upvote data isn't public, of course, but you can do much the same analysis by looking at the posting history of submitters and commenters. That is public, and what I can tell you is that on topics like this, the private data and the public data nearly always point in much the same direction. (That's not true in every context—for example, voting rings are a thing in terms of people wanting to promote their startups and whatnot, and we've put a ton of work into combating that over the years. But none of that analysis yields anything significant when it comes to a topic like the OP.) Tons of past explanations on these points can be found via https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=true&page=0&query=by:dang%20astroturf https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme... although you have to scroll back to find the interesting ones.
- natch 3y agoI love this reply and all the perspective it provides on what can be gleaned and what is the baseline state of affairs. But I'm a little sad that I had to know the extra special secret click spot (on the link showing the age of the flagged item, which item was folded away and fully hidden other than the grayed metadata/title) to even see it (it==your reply) at all. Well I'm not sad for me, because I did know how to click there, expand the post, and read your reply, but it's a pity that your reply won't be seen by more people. I do understand however that maybe you've chosen the right tradeoff here of giving the targeted info to the poster who probably was sincere and can benefit, versus showing it more widely which would be a frequent enough occurrence that it might become a distracting portion of the site content. So, I defer to your judgement; just sharing thoughts here. Thanks for what you do.
- Tao3300 3y agoI love a good HN conspiracy theory. The best was when someone accused me of being the agent of a foreign adversary intent on sowing discord for using the word "boomer". HN is clearly the vitally exposed artery of all Western media!
- mvncleaninst 3y ago> with a corresponding political flame war. aforementioned topics aren't "flame war" topics, generally the people who know about the NSA pissing on the fourth amendment aren't in favor of it
- diogenes4 3y agoBetter than tomorrow!
- imiric 3y agoBecause any day is a good day to be reminded of the surveillance machinery behind closed doors of a superpower government. Besides, I haven't seen all Snowden files as neatly organized as here. These documents should be copied and reshared in perpetuity.
- keepamovin 3y agoNo particular reason. I was watching the Snowden film for the first time, and at the same time fixing some bugs in secure document viewer code that required me to test it on large zip files (ideally containing PDFs). I just happened across this repo from a DDG search. You can see the ongoing work here: https://github.com/BrowserBox/BrowserBox https://github.com/BrowserBox/BrowserBox
- enginoor 3y agoI would recommend Citizenfour if you haven't seen it. It's a documentary where you essentially see Snowden leak the documents from his Hong Kong hotel room. It's amazing the footage exists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenfour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenfour
- keepamovin 3y agoThanks enginoor I'll take a look.
- daft_pink 3y agoDoes GitHub usually store classified documents?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jandrese 3y agoThis could be a problem. I know companies that will block entire sites if they're hosting material like that, especially in the government contracting sphere.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoMan, if you work in defense, pretend you didn't even see that URL. Back in the day, three gigs ago - when this stuff was full on the boil - bunch of people got insta-fired for just clicking on news stories about Snowden. It was insane how fast it happened. Click -> Bathroom -> boxes+guards+parkinglot. I mean, granted, leadership does[1] precious little other than looking for new ways to get rid of as many heads as possible, but it was still impressive. [1] Not counting the "Instant VPs" hired on from procurement offices, which is where virtually all new business comes from. Seriously, guys, just can the entire BD division and let the double dippers sell corner offices to their old pals.
- 3seashells 3y agoSuch reflexes are very easy exploited? One rugue person could take out key competent personal with one startup self delete script?
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoI'm not sure leadership believed anyone was all that valuable. The general impression was (and still is, sadly) that we were all worth more fired as cost savings than we were employed[1]. The only thing keeping them from doing your kind of shenanigan was probably the hit to NIST / FEDRAMP / whatever else that can get you blacklisted as a supplier. I remember one single exception. One of the regular rotating layoffs took out this one engineer who had extremely niche knowledge when it came to microphones. Like, there's four other people on the planet who do the math this guy does. But he's on the list, so there he goes. Pink slip, boxes, guards, parking lot . . and then they call him back in before he even gets everything packed. Someone must have run upstairs to yell at someone important - I mean, this guy wasn't just "make new things" sort of skill, but also "keep everything else working" sort of skill, peppered with "the FAA will get extremely angry if we don't have this sort of thing" skills. Luckily, he was a canny old gent, and replied on the spot: "Sure. I'll come back in. But it's gonna cost ya." Rumor was he managed to double his wages, and get a stock thing to boot. That still brings a smile to my face, many years later. [1]The monkey wrench is that Cost Plus pays for hours, so they're gonna try and get those hours cheap as they can. This is one of the reasons they haaaaaaaated hourly headcounts - see, you pressure your salaried people to stay 50-60 hours, but you keep billing the DoD for hours, and it's like free money. Hourly, that doesn't work so well. They converted literally everyone to salaried as soon as they possibly could.
- kennyadam 3y agoI really hoped the entire collection of documents would have been disseminated by now. Surely it's been long enough that anything in them that might compromise the security of undercover people or irrelevant personal information or whatever could have been redacted. It's so frustrating.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mike_d 3y agoLooking back it shines an interesting light on the motivations. Everything was filtered using a very specific politically motivated lens and lacked a lot of important context. You could steal all the emails of any HN user and cherry pick a few dozen to make them look like a monster, where I believe on the whole most users of this site are good people.
- asynchronous 3y agoThe feds are extremely unwilling to declassify documents that have been leaked. They usually continue to deny details or the entire existence of them even decades after it’s “public knowledge”
- patmorgan23 3y agoDefinitely not. The US military plays the long game and works very hard to conceal its exact capabilities. That's how you win wars, be more persistent, more capable, and surprise your enemies with your capabilities. There are undercover intelligence assets that have been undercover for 10-20 years.
- diogenes4 3y agoI love this, but a corporate site is probably not the best place for this.
- e12e 3y agoWas going to suggest Cryptome - but it was apparently closed this August in protest of the unfair case against Assange (Young tried to argue for being tried as a co-defendant, having published unredacted documents prior to WikiLeaks): https://www.cryptome.org/ https://www.cryptome.org/
- Ms-J 3y agoThe latest document that Cryptome is hosting on their homepage is "Douglas Valentine Sues CIA for PHOENIX Documents" dated October 14, 2023. I don't see any indication to them remaining closed, though I could be mistaken. Do you have any references you could cite? Edit: I see a letter to American judge Hilton on Cryptome where Young states that he will be closing after 27 years until Assange is granted freedom, though the site remains alive and appears there is ongoing publishing, so I'm still unclear of the current status and any references regarding the status would be welcome.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sgnelson 3y agoI am confused by this. The guy who runs Cryptome (which is arguably a thorn in the side of the US intelligence services and US government) is telling the US government that if they don't charge him with a crime (which if convicted could probably lead to the website being shutdown.), he's going to shut down that website that exposes US intelligence secrets. Um. I just don't know what to say about this. I'm so confused by this logic. I'm sure the people in the US Intelligence services are going to be crying themselves to sleep because Cryptome closes. I bet they'll be begging US prosecutors to charge him with a crime just to keep Cryptome open. I just don't get the logic behind this. Someone please explain it to me.
- Ms-J 3y agoIt's well past time for the entire Snowden document collection to be released. But that won't ever happen due to all the agreements each person or institution made with various governments who want to keep very embarrassing info on their illegal spying operations away from the public.
- krapp 3y agoIt won't happen because the Snowden archives are the goose that keeps laying golden eggs for the media. Remember that journalism is first and foremost a business.
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- spacebacon 3y agoFor those who fall into the camp that have never taken a security clearance before but have worked on more interesting tech ... why is this all so sensitive? Are we to ignore these capabilities as if they do not exist or what? Is there a handbook for stuff you read you probably shouldn't know about or are we ready to accept the fact everything is hacked or can be hacked? Personally as an independent small timer with no cool or a secret accomplishment to date ....... assumed breach is my day to day reality.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoIt's sensitive because our government is full of criminals, and that makes it look bad.
- spacebacon 3y agoReally? Do we have names and evidence or just feelings on this? From the outside looking in ... any institution feels dirty for the fact institutions sacrifice the individuals in favor of the institute. But is this criminal or systemic? Does the system define the crime or is there an individual to convict?
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoI personally would never work in intelligence because I'm capable of reading the big numbered list we can all see.
- spacebacon 3y agoWhich list?
- lazide 3y agoOne of hundreds of similar situations (literally) - [https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2010/03/other-burn-pits/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2010/03/other-burn-pits...] And the US is actually a relatively good gov’t on this front.
- precompute 3y agoYawn. He could've leaked the entire thing at once way back in '13 if he really was serious about it. Ten year old documents about programs at least 15 years old are all but worthless now. There was a time to do something about it and he never exploited it.
- Clubber 3y agoIIRC, he gave it all to the press and gave them the burden of going over them and releasing them as they saw fit. He was concerned about sensitive material getting out that would harm other US interests / people on the ground, etc. Most outlets didn't want it, but the Guardian picked them up and reported it. Assange was the one that just dumped documents, and look what happened to him.
- Ms-J 3y agoDumping is the way to go to really let people know about something serious. People will repost to torrents, file lockers, Discord channels, etc.