8 ms·
Atlas of Surveillance: Documenting police tech in our communities
- metadaemon 3y agoALPRs are totally fair play IMO -- if that's their only function. I'd rather have a robot triage criminal activity than a biased human. Facial recognition, however, is 100% the wrong move.
- Zak 3y agoI think it depends very much on how they're used. If they're set up to flag stolen vehicles and vehicles owned by fugitives and don't store irrelevant license plate numbers long-term, I have no complaints. I think in practice they often record every plate and store the data long-term, which can be used to track people who are not active targets of an investigation.
- metadaemon 3y agoMy company has a strict 30-day policy, irrelevant plates are never recorded either. But yeah I agree, some of the bigger players are pretty loosey goosey with their privacy policies.
- tptacek 3y agoIf they've decided to classify body cams as "surveillance" --- and, fair enough, I guess --- then really all they're going to need long term is an atlas of every law enforcement agency in the country.
- Zigurd 3y agoBody cams are qualitatively different in the way they are used. For example if they are used in domestic violence cases, they can be harmful. If cops are not disciplined for turning them off when encountering citizens they are meant to protect, they provide an inaccurate story, usually slanted in cops' favor. I suppose studies like this need to get finer granularity on bodycams.
- komali2 3y agoCan you clarify how being able to demonstrate the exact circumstances of an event in perpetuity is "harmful?" This seems completely counter intuitive, in fact it's a point of view regarding bodycams I've never encountered. Most dialogue around bodycams focuses on desires for extreme punishments for police that turn off their bodycams during interactions with civilians.
- Zigurd 3y agoBodycams are generally a good thing and more PDs should use them correctly. But they can put domestic violence victims in danger, too: From https://www.nsvrc.org/sarts/toolkit/5-6 https://www.nsvrc.org/sarts/toolkit/5-6 BWCs can record information about a victim's identity and whereabouts, which could potentially jeopardize a victim's safety if the perpetrator views the recording, if recorded data is handled improperly, or if that recording becomes public record. Often sexual assault takes place in areas where the expectation of privacy is high, such as a home or school, and a BWC may be seen as especially invasive in these locations. [72] The impact of BWCs on decisions to report to law enforcement is unknown, [73] but they may affect a victim's ability or willingness to speak to police. It is unknown at this time if BWCs support victims in feeling empowered.
- jstarfish 3y agoI don't agree with the parent, but they're not wrong either. A good high-profile example is Alex Skeel, who refused to tell responding officers anything about his ordeal on-camera. Guy was basically Theon Greyjoy living with Ramsay Bolton as his girlfriend. You can't testify against your torturer outside of a courtroom and risk her finding out about it. Calling for help is a big no-no when it comes to hostage-taking. Cops are not good at discretion when it comes to intelligence. Snitches get outed all the time. While off-camera, you can dismiss anything as hearsay or rumor, but you really, really don't want there to be video evidence of you snitching against someone dangerous.
- ana_winters 3y ago[dead]
- ozfive 3y agoThis can and will be used by criminals to target communities that have less tech or tech that is exploitable/circumventable. Yes I am aware that security through obscurity is not the answer.
- public_defender 3y ago> This can and will be used by criminals to target communities that have less tech or tech that is exploitable/circumventable. No it won't!
- ska 3y agoI think this makes some pretty strong assumptions about the purpose and effectiveness of at least some of the relevant technology.
- ozfive 3y agoWhat assumptions do you believe I am making about the purpose and effectiveness of at least some of the relevant technology?
- ska 3y agoYour statement presumes that such a list gives new, actionable information of benefit to criminals. This also implies that existence (or lack) of technology is a good proxy for effectiveness of policing in a locale, which in turn implies that the technology was purchased to improve said effectiveness. Neither of those things are obviously true in general, or even on average. I can see how collating such information might make things easier for some outliers, but it's hard to imagine this making much difference one way or another - the criminals who really care already have much better information sources, and the ones who don't aren't likely to do much research, or act effectively on it, anyway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _jal 3y ago
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoThere's a whole lot of: > The $LOCAL_CITY Police Department signed an agreement with Amazon's home surveillance equipment company, Ring, in $RECENT_YEAR to gain special access to the company's Neighbors app. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism
- Clubber 3y agoIf someone is breaking into houses in my neighborhood and a ring camera is able to identify and help apprehend the person, I would want that to happen.
- itishappy 3y agoThat's fine if it's your property and camera. But if somebody breaks into your neighbors place... You're really ok with police asking Amazon (without your knowledge, consent, or a warrant) for footage? (Edit: Removed "the last few weeks of footage" from the last statement, which was correctly pointed out to be exaggeration.) https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/07/ring-reveals-they-give-videos-police-without-user-consent-or-warrant https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/07/ring-reveals-they-give...
- Clubber 3y ago>You ok with police subpoenaing Amazon With a subpoena, absolutely, those need to be signed off by a judge. Warrantless, depends on the circumstance. If someone broke in between 2am and 4am, I'm fine with them requesting ring footage, explicitly for that timeframe, explicitly for the purpose of apprehending the perpetrator. I don't agree with police using it to surveil areas without a specific person and crime in mind. I'm not sure that's happening or not. >for the last few weeks of footage I don't see in the article where it says they typically request weeks of footage. Are you exaggerating to strengthen your point?
- syndicatedjelly 3y ago> The “emergency” exception to this process allows police to request video directly from Amazon, and without a warrant. But there are insufficient safeguards to protect civil liberties in this process. For example, there is no process for a judge or the device owner to determine whether there actually was an emergency. This could easily lead to police abuse: there will always be temptation for police to use it for increasingly less urgent situations.
- itishappy 3y ago
- lubesGordi 3y agoThe one that bothers me the most is the Ring integration with police. That's happening in Chicago. The neighbor across the street installs a Ring doorbell because they like gadgety shit or whatever, and suddenly my children's playing is under surveillance.
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- oldpersonintx 3y agothat ship sailed with Google Streetview, and now sat imagery look up "privacy" in the Constitution...that's right, you don't have an explicitly spelled out right to privacy in the US (you should though, and we should fix that) in the US, if you want privacy, go inside and close the blinds...sad but this is pretty much what it has come to
- whatshisface 3y agoYour right to privacy is your security against unreasonable search and seizure. Fourth amendment. No wonder it's so easy for the government to infringe our rights - we are not taught we have them!
- oldpersonintx 3y agoimho that is a limit on Government power, that particular amendment doesn't clearly speak to an inalienable privacy right for an individual (which requires an entirely new definition in the modern era)
- oooyay 3y agoA personal right to privacy and limitations on government actions/inquisitions are different. For instance, if someone wants to start filming me and following me in public then there's nothing I can do unless they city or state maintains some kind of statute against it (and some do.) A government privacy law would not defend you against that. Even uploading my likeness to YouTube and showing that video to thousands or millions of people is legal. A personal right to privacy would require releases for that kind of content to be made standard. Our current laws hinge heavily on anything in public being public domain which is simultaneously good and problematic.
- klaussilveira 3y agoSnoop on to them, as they snoop on to us.
- AlexandrB 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance
- clemailacct1 3y agoI'll always appreciate a Hackers (greatest movie of all time) quote. :)
- jduebcusk 3y agoSlightly OT, but I've been wondering for a while now if and when license plate scanner camera data will be compared and analyzed for traffic violations, like "you went from Park Ave to Boardwalk in a time frame which would have required you to exceed the posted speed limit, here's your ticket".
- pixl97 3y agoIf it doesn't catch a picture of the driver it most likely will not valid in court in most states. Be fun to troll the shit out of politicians/elected officials with this. Have someone monitor them leaving one place, then with another car and a fake plate have them get scanned at another location moments later.
- nebula8804 3y agoThey'll just add an exception to the scanners for their plates. What would stop them? Outrage? Probably not.
- pixl97 3y agoAgain, politicians and .gov employees being targeted as targets of these scanned plate tickets.
- itishappy 3y ago"Police stumped by evidence at least 200 separate vehicles use the same Senator's plate number."
- nebula8804 3y agoExtremely strict consequences for impersonating the plate will tamp that down real quick.
- metadaemon 3y agoIn my experience the cops using these systems only care about larger crimes. It's way too noisy to monitor every expired tag, for instance. Not many of these companies (if any) do speed monitoring with LPRs.
- recursive4 3y agoContains false negatives, for example only listing a single police department using Clearview (https://atlasofsurveillance.org/search?vendor=Clearview https://atlasofsurveillance.org/search?vendor=Clearview). Likely a limitation of the current data sources.
- marcod 3y ago> If an area has no markers, it may mean it hasn't been researched yet. To help collect more data, visit our Collaborate page.
- vongomben 3y agoThis is interesting. Is there anything similar for Europe?
- cobychapple 3y agoWhy US-only?
- roamerz 3y agoIt’s strange I don’t see Flock or Redflex. They are both widely used in my area.
- dang 3y agoRelated: EFF's Atlas of Surveillance: Documenting Police Tech with Open Source Research - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26270166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26270166 - Feb 2021 (2 comments) Atlas of Surveillance - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23824845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23824845 - July 2020 (134 comments)
- DonnyV 3y agoYou can't walk more than a couple miles before getting facially scanned in Michigan. Oof!
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoInteresting. Austin, TX has a police drone that flies between 8 pm and 3:30 am, and peeps into my apartment (floor-to-ceiling glass) almost every / every other night. I'd like to do something about it because it's violating and wrong.
- CatWChainsaw 3y ago... Blackout Curtains??
- oalae5niMiel7qu 3y agoThey don't include street cameras in their data.
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]