6 ms·
> Since Apple isn’t able to handle legitimate requests to disable the Activation Lock like mine, you should turn on Find My on your own MacBook, or risk it beco
by lmm 3y ago
> Since Apple isn’t able to handle legitimate requests to disable the Activation Lock like mine, you should turn on Find My on your own MacBook, or risk it becoming a brick like mine.
Why do people accept this nonsense when it's Apple? They wouldn't for any other company.
You bought and paid for a laptop from them. It's broken. You've gone through their process and they haven't fixed it. At that point you escalate to a credit card chargeback and/or small claims court.
- Veliladon 3y ago>Why do people accept this nonsense when it's Apple? They wouldn't for any other company. Because 99% of the time it saves one's ass. Three times now I've left my iPad in a shopping cart. All three times my phone has gone "WAIT! WHERE'S THE IPAD?" as I left the parking lot and all three times I was able to retrieve the iPad.
- anigbrowl 3y ago...why would you leave a tablet or a laptop in a shopping cart?! I don't mean 'why did you forget', why would you leave it out of your hand at all, or leave anything in a shopping cart? I pull out my phone to check a price or product specification sometimes when shopping, but then I put it back in my pocket, not in my grocery basket.
- arcanemachiner 3y agoShit happens.
- saghm 3y agoI imagine they can't fit their iPad in their pockets. I'm guessing they prefer using their iPad to their phone for their shopping list, maybe because it's easier for them to read.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThat's what bags are for.
- jb1991 3y agoHard to believe, but everyone is different, and lifestyles are not all the same.
- paulddraper 3y ago> why would you leave a tablet or a laptop in a shopping cart?! I'm reading in between the lines here, but I think it was a mistake.
- bigstrat2003 3y agoHonestly I'm kind of surprised one would bring their tablet at all. Having a phone is useful in situations like you said, but I can see no good reason to bring a tablet.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoSome people leave their stuff in a shopping cart, some people don't setup their new laptop completely, some people aren't careful with their equipment at airport security. It's not a personal failing, it's just the way they are.
- zakki 3y agoOP didn't ask for the benefit of Find My. I guess it is more on customer's rights.
- ddingus 3y agoFrom Apples point of view, he may not actually be the owner. That's where understanding what one bought into matters. The great security model comes with costs and risks same as anything else does.
- polski-g 3y agoApple has the serial number from the original sale and can confirm he is the guy who bought it...
- fastball 3y agoBut maybe this guy sold his computer to someone else and then stole it back, or something else crazy. The point is that having an ironclad policy in this case is a feature for most users, not a bug.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ddingus 3y agoAny number of things could have happened. Fact is, he let someone else take control of the machine. Apple really should explain this to people. It is a scenario nobody wants to be in.
- threeseed 3y agoNo they don't. Many Apple products are bought from third party resellers who don't capture this information.
- jchw 3y agoWe don't have to guess where it was purchased. It was purchased from the Apple Store, the article spells this out.
- MrVandemar 3y agoA quick look at the Australian Apple store shows iPads are AU$749.00. Why would you put goods to the value of $749 in your shopping cart, much less leave it behind there? It saves your ass, yeah, but maybe you should ask yourself if you would have learned a better lesson leaving it in there once and losing it forever and then being more careful in future.
- lmm 3y ago> Why would you put goods to the value of $749 in your shopping cart, much less leave it behind there? Because they live in a functioning society where mislaid things are generally returned to their owner with no harm done?
- swagempire 3y agoI left my iPhone at a restaurant in Ayala mall in the Philippens and when I went back an hour later they not only had it, but had wrapped it in plastic. Australia is not the only place with a functioning society.
- kaba0 3y agoNo one said it was the only one..
- dhosek 3y agoAbout ten years ago, I left my iPad in the seatback pocket on a Southwest flight. I reported the lost item assuming it was gone forever and instead was notified that it has been located and that they were sending it to me. I got it in perfect shape a few days later.
- jb1991 3y agoiPhones can be a lot more expensive than that, and people leave their phones in places all time. Your comment is rather short-sighted and not adding to the conversation.
- ddingus 3y agoPeople accept it because they believe in the security model. For a lot of those people, the security model just works. Same for their online activities and apps. There are at least these scenarios: They have been helped by the model. Yay Apple! Nothing has happened to them yet. Yay Apple, and surely Apple being so great is why. They have been burned by the model. BOO Apple! Fact is the machine is not broken and is working as designed. The owner did not take full advantage of the security and left the door open for someone else to walk through. No judgment on the owner. Now Apple? Yeah, a bit too draconian for me. And I am on the other side of this mess. Bought a very new M1 Air from them. Cheap because the owner had died and nobody knew the password. Interestingly, I had booted into recovery mode, and I found I could mount the SSD and a USB thumb drive which let me pull docs, pictures and such for them. After that, I was able to boot into installing a fresh OS, supply my Apple ID and use the computer just fine... Had it been in lost or stolen status? Probably would not have worked out.. At the time, I gave security a lot of thought. The Apple stuff is good enough people really do need to understand it or risk bad scenarios like this. (I turned Find on) My daily driver is a lenovo. The Apple is a fun machine for me. You asked why. Hope this helps.
- ohhnoodont 3y ago> Interestingly, I had booted into recovery mode, and I found I could mount the SSD I was under the impression that Apple Silicon Macbooks had disk encryption enabled by default and that this wouldn't be possible. Turns out while that is technically true, it's only relevant in the case of the SSD somehow being removed from the device and installed in another. In the case of real disk encryption FileVault needs to be enabled. Apparently it's easy to miss that step during setup, especially if you setup the Macbook without an Apple ID/iCloud.
- Gigachad 3y agoThis seems to be an extremely rare situation. OP did not lock the device to their account and left it free. Someone else picked it up, wiped it, and locked it to their own account. That stranger could have also poured apple juice on the macbook or just not responded to the request to send it back. Once someone else has their hands on your device, there is a risk it's just gone. As a Macbook user I'm not at all concerned about this happening to me since I have find my set up and my mac has stickers on it so I can clearly identify it as mine and avoid this mixup. And I also benefit from the theft resistance features.
- pests 3y agoIt's not gone though. He has it back.
- Gigachad 3y agoHe has it back in a broken state. The person who took it rendered it inoperable before returning it. Even without activation lock there are numerous other ways if you are holding the laptop in your hand.
- ddingus 3y agoActually, it is not broken. It is working as designed. He simply does not have control of it.
- hunter2_ 3y agoTrue, but at the same time, it's not performing the function that was advertised upon which the purchasing decision was made. A reasonable person would believe that if it wasn't subject to physical harm (impact, water, heat, excessive voltage, etc.) then it would perform the advertised functions for a certain useful life. "Anyone who briefly possesses it can destroy that function without physical harm" wasn't advertised. IANAL but I think a judge would see it this way.
- 3y ago
- chongli 3y agoWhy do people accept this nonsense when it's Apple? Because it's a very effective theft deterrent. All of my Apple devices have Find My turned on. If someone steals my MacBook or my iPhone, I can track them with the app. I can also remote wipe the device and brick it until my password is entered. If Apple agreed to remove the Activation Lock for the thief then they would get the full benefit of stealing it. Since Apple has an ironclad policy of refusing to remove the lock, there is nothing a thief can do to remove it. If the thief cannot unbrick the device in any way, it is worthless to them. This deters stealing.
- jb1991 3y agoIt works too: "Apple’s Activation Lock Leads To Big Drops In Smartphone Theft Worldwide" https://techcrunch.com/2015/02/11/apples-activation-lock-leads-to-big-drops-in-smartphone-theft-worldwide/?guccounter=1 https://techcrunch.com/2015/02/11/apples-activation-lock-lea...
- pwim 3y agoI'm in Japan. From what I've heard, chargebacks are nearly impossible to initiate here. Besides, I bought it with a corporate debit card, so it wasn't an option either. With small claims court, I doubt my Japanese fluency is sufficient, and researching how to go about it would take more time than it is worth. The article was worth my time because it makes others aware of the situation.
- dclowd9901 3y ago[flagged]
- davely 3y agoYou may have your reasons for lack of sympathy, but I feel like this type of response is unnecessarily callous and is not befitting of the Hacker News community. It’s a personal attack and tears someone down for no purpose that contributes to the discussion.
- solardev 3y agoHave you tried dealing with support for any electronics company? They're all bad and it takes a lot of arguing to get anything done, even when you pay for the extended corporate support.
- lmm 3y ago> Have you tried dealing with support for any electronics company? They're all bad and it takes a lot of arguing to get anything done Right, which is why you need to be prepared to escalate and not put up with their crap. Apple's no different from the others.
- PeterStuer 3y agoThe weirdest Apple cult thing I ever witnessed: A colleague at university, when the transparant bubblegum all in one line of Mac's launched bought 4 for personal use to 'support Apple'.
- Veen 3y agoThat attitude was more common years ago when Apple was beleaguered and in real danger of going out of business. People who grew up with Macs and preferred the hardware and OS didn’t want it to go away, so they made efforts to support it. I don’t think it’s as common an attitude post-iPhone.
- chrisandchris 3y ago> Why do people accept this nonsense when it's Apple? They wouldn't for any other company. [...] Said no one ever while setting up Windows 11, which forces one to use a Microsoft account, or otherwise you just can't use your device. It's not all the same, but people accept a lot of nonsense from a lot of companies just because "can't do anyway nothing against it".
- stockboss 3y agoyou can actually set up a local account for Windows which doesn't require a MS account, which is what I did after they arbitrarily suspended my account. But yes, they intentionally make it more onerous than it has to be to do so.
- diffeomorphism 3y ago... By opening a command prompt during the install and entering some cryptic command. Yeah, no. For the average user you actually cannot. https://www.tomshardware.com/how-to/install-windows-11-without-microsoft-account https://www.tomshardware.com/how-to/install-windows-11-witho...
- sanitycheck 3y agoThe second set of instructions there ("How to Create a Windows 11 Install Disk that Allows Bypassing Microsoft Accounts") seem non-cryptic and fairly approachable for anyone who can create USB install media. I haven't tried it myself, I'm trialling an "upgrade" to Pop OS rather than Win11. So far so good, full credit to System76 for the progress they've made a in a few years. I'd consider buying one of their systems if they handled tax + duty for international shipping - insanity can ensure in the UK for packages that arrive without it all arranged. Slightly more on topic, I've never trusted Apple.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoNot for recent releases of the Home edition, at least that is my understanding.