2 ms·
> the USPTO's idiosyncratic usage of non-obviousness doesn't really match my intuition Remember that USPTO gets paid for each patent application, and not penal
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> the USPTO's idiosyncratic usage of non-obviousness doesn't really match my intuition
Remember that USPTO gets paid for each patent application, and not penalised when it's later falsified.
- rbehrends 3y agoWell, it was apparently upheld twice on reexamination, where they could have fixed that. The problem is more that the bar for non-obviousness is so low, it's basically on the floor. Paired with a discipline (software development), where independent reinvention is common, this is just a recipe for disaster.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoEveryone knows 1+1=2, so why did Russell spend many many pages/hours on a proof, surely if people know it then it's easy to demonstrate? /s Programmers are notoriously good at documenting everything after all. /s It's easy to give documentary evidence for things someone found self-evident and so only wrote a scribbled note about in a workbook 40 years ago. /s FWIW patent law obviousness is not the same thing as ordinary notions of obviousness either. All my personal opinion, ofc.