6 ms·
Revisited mass of the Milky Way is much smaller than expectations from cosmology
- blueflow 3y agoGoogle Translated to English: https://www-observatoiredeparis-psl-eu.translate.goog/revue-fortement-a-la-baisse.html?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=de&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-observatoiredeparis-psl-eu.translate.goog/revue-...
- Timon3 3y agoEnglish version of the article from the blog: https://www.observatoiredeparis.psl.eu/revue-fortement-a-la-baisse.html?lang=en https://www.observatoiredeparis.psl.eu/revue-fortement-a-la-... @dang: should the URL be replaced?
- layer8 3y agoThat would be nice. I thought I had submitted the English version, but apparently not.
- pvg 3y agoYou probably did but HN fishes the canonical URL from the page HTML and that particular page has the wrong one instead of the one you likely submitted <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.observatoiredeparis.psl.eu/revue-fortement-a-la-baisse.html" />
- pvg 3y agoEmail that stuff to hn@ycombinator.com because the @dang, it does nothing.
- layer8 3y agoAlready done that.
- dang 3y agoChanged from https://www.observatoiredeparis.psl.eu/revue-fortement-a-la-baisse.html https://www.observatoiredeparis.psl.eu/revue-fortement-a-la-... now. Thanks! (and yes, you did submit the ?lang=en version originally, but our software switched to the canonical url as pvg explained)
- sph 3y agoWith all the automation dang has created to manage the site, I would be surprised if he doesn't have a low-priority alert for @dang.
- ccooffee 3y agoThe Arxiv[0] paper abstract seems much clearer and more informative than the linked article. In particular, it points to WHY the mass has been revised down so far -- there's seemingly a lot less mass at 19+ kiloparsecs (about 62,000 lightyears) from galactic center than we expected the galaxy to have. I'm not an expert so it isn't clear to me if the discussions in the paper about dark-vs-baryonic matter are a theoretical explanation of the gap. Here's a 2019 article[1][1b] describing the mass of the galaxy at 1.5 trillion solar masses. This current research lowers that number to just 200 billion solar masses with a 3 sigma confidence. [0] https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00048 https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00048 [1] https://www.sciencealert.com/the-most-accurate-measurement-yet-of-the-milky-way-s-mass-puts-us-ahead-of-andromeda https://www.sciencealert.com/the-most-accurate-measurement-y... [1b] https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.11348 https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.11348
- slashdev 3y agoDoes this have any implications on dark matter? I think most of the evidence for dark matter is from outside the galaxy, so not really. But might we not have made similar over estimations of baryonic matter at the edges of other galaxies? If they were true, does it imply there must be even more dark matter than we thought?
- layer8 3y agoThe implication is that there may be significantly less dark matter in the Milky Way than previously estimated. From [0]: “Using this newly derived rotation curve, a new mass was deduced for our Milky Way. And surprise... it is much lighter. It is now estimated to be only two hundred billion times that of the Sun (~2.06 x 10^11), so about four to five times lower than the previous estimates. The amount of ordinary matter did not change, thus, there must be a lot less dark matter in the Milky Way than previously thought. The new expectation is that the ordinary matter like stars and gas in the Milky Way now makes up about 1/3 of the Milky Way mass and the other 2/3 are accounted to dark matter.” [0] https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/iow_20230927 https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/iow_20230927
- 3y ago
- layer8 3y agoSee also https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/iow_20230927 https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/iow_20230927.
- sega_sai 3y agoThis observation clearly contradicts multiple other measurements of the MW mass which is not really explained. Given quite a complex set of assumptions that went into this particular derivation, I am personally quite sceptical about this measurement, but no one have identified a specific flaw of the study.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoIf I understood this correctly, this mass was derived from the rotation curve, which was itself derived from the motions of stars. The other mass estimate was from (a rotation curve derived from?) neutral gas. So there's maybe some room for the relationship between the motion of the stars and the motion of the neutral gas to be not what we expect. Or, there's room for there to be a flaw in this study. Or for a flaw in the studies (I assume plural) that used neutral gas, but it would have to be a flaw in the assumptions, or in the techniques common to all of the studies.
- sega_sai 3y agoMost of mass estimates of the MW in the outskirts come from measuring motions of stars (just not in the disk of the MW) dwarf galaxies, globular clusters or stellar streams. These measurements have their own issues, but now many of these measurements broadly agree and this new one very is an outlier. Measurements using gas have their own issues, and also they do not go as far away from the galactic centre as the new rotation curve from the paper.
- pvaldes 3y agoGreat, now we will need to rename the Milky Way to the Machiatto Way... Damned scientists.
- tannhaeuser 3y agoLa voie de la mousse de lait
- keyle 3y agoThe babyccino way!
- monkeycantype 3y agoAnother day, another nudge that we are NPCs in GTA 40, on a map that looks big but isn't
- dudeinjapan 3y agoThey say the telescope adds a few pounds…
- pmontra 3y agoIMHO the main point of the French article is that the rotation speed of the galaxy decreases according to Kepler laws for the outer parts of our galaxy. They're us a graph for that. This contradicts previous observations. They ask why our galaxy should be special and they suggest that we (they) measured rotation speed of stars in the Milky Way while we measure rotation of gas in the other galaxies. I'm not sure why gas and stars would have different orbital speeds, but well, who am I to actually understand this matter.
- sesm 3y agoWTF is the picture in the linked press release? They've multiplied Kepler curve by an arbitrary coefficient of ~2 to make it match the measurements from the paper in 16-25 kpc range, while it clearly won't match in < 16 kpc range. What is this picture supposed to tell us? Compare it to figure 5 from original paper to see the actual Kepler curve used in the study.