5 ms·
The data and puzzling history behind California's new red food dye ban
- samtho 3y agoI seriously cannot tell whether food dyes will be this era’s “refined sugar” in terms of epidemiological impact or a massive red-3 herring.
- NickC25 3y agoNice pun. Jokes aside, that's a good point - but if you think about it, why should we want to ingest something that provides no health value and only exists to make the food product look more visually appealing? I don't know what kind of epidemiological effects dye has had in the long run, but it just makes no sense to me that as a society we have said "yeah, color our food so it looks more appealing, even though chemically it's probably not great for us". Just sort of odd, honestly. Nutritious food doesn't always look amazing, and that's completely fine by me. I don't eat food because of the color, I eat food because it's healthy or tasty.
- OJFord 3y agoWhich is why nobody uses food colouring outside of (especially children's) baking at home. But in ready meals and other prepared foods sold in supermarkets, they're adding it to make you buy it, not for your pleasure while eating it. 'Ooh it looks so vibrant and fresh' or whatever. Or in the case of sweets etc. to hint at the flavour.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoAs long as people gravitate to the best-looking food item when comparing different foods on a shelf, including meat, there's going to be an incentive to use dyes or apply some process that changes the color. You may be fine receiving an uglier food item, but I bet you don't seek it out when judging equally-priced alternatives.
- brightlancer 3y ago> but it just makes no sense to me that as a society we have said "yeah, color our food so it looks more appealing, even though chemically it's probably not great for us". Just sort of odd, honestly. How is this meaningfully different from adding salts and sugars to make food taste more appealing? While there are a relative few who would be happy with a bland looking, bland tasting shake for 3 meals a day, most people wouldn't. Biologically, it's _normal_ for people to want food to look and taste appealing.
- NickC25 3y agoAdding ingredients like salt, which are a naturally occurring substance that can positively affect the taste of a food (as well as acting as a natural preservative in some cases) is completely different than adding an artificial chemical that is designed to make the food look fresher but has no actual health or taste benefits. Also, of course we want food to taste good, that's half the point of eating and why people enjoy eating. Adding a coloring dye doesn't affect taste.
- samtho 3y agoI agree, if I could uncheck a box that says “coloring” when buying food, I would uncheck that every time. The only issue I have is that we don’t live in a world where that is possible, and food dyes inhabit anything that is wrapped in plastic. It’s very much a “take it or leave it” deal and increasingly more often, I leave it. I suspect that a major problem is the fact that everything is focus group driven and when given the choice between a frozen drink dyed red with beet juice and the same drink dyed neon red with food dyes, people will gravitate towards the neon red drink because that’s what we’ve been conditioned to believe is higher quality.
- troyvit 3y agoIt seems like these things come up once in a blue-lake moon doesn't it?
- mikeytown2 3y agoTEDx talk on the effects of food dye on kids [1]. One of my kids is affected by food dye as described in the video [1] https://youtu.be/nQzOHAwCfXs https://youtu.be/nQzOHAwCfXs
- tudorw 3y agoI'm glad you found out, I'm 50 now, found out around age 14 or so, avoiding them made a huge difference to my state of mind.
- dboreham 3y agoI hadn't heard about the mind state thing until I went onto Wikipedia just now, but I've known I was allergic to Yellow #5 since early childhood. It brings on rapid asthma type symptoms. Also discovered around Halloween time when I ate a large number of orange cookies from the grocery store, that I'll break out in hives all over my body if I ingest enough of the stuff. Have made a point not to do that again.
- eitally 3y agoWe found about (about our son's allergy) on Halloween, too, when he was 5. He got an uncontrollable neurologic eye tic that persisted for about a week.
- gruez 3y agoSo far as I can tell this is basically an anecdote. She doesn't even try to back it up aside from vague mentions of "articles" that she found (no specific studies were mentioned). Why should we give any credence to this over any other random HN commenter?
- tudorw 3y ago"The Food Standards Agency today announced its decision to recommend to Ministers the phasing out of six colours in food and drink in the EU. These six colours - sunset yellow (E110), quinoline yellow (E104), carmoisine (E122), allura red (E129), tartrazine (E102) and ponceau 4R (E124) - had been shown to increase hyperactive behaviour of children in a study published by a University of Southampton research team in September 2007." https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2008/04/food-standards-agency-cites-southampton-study.page https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2008/04/food-standards-ag...
- tudorw 3y agohttps://www.foodnavigator.com/Article/2013/06/18/EFSA-calls-for-Southampton-colours-food-safety-review https://www.foodnavigator.com/Article/2013/06/18/EFSA-calls-...
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoThis is good. Might as well switch to carminic acid (aka ground up bugs) for that cherry red color. That's been used for ages.
- huytersd 3y agoHaving watched a handful of videos, raising them seems to be a long and very labor intensive process.
- londons_explore 3y agoI'm sure it's possible to automate, if a sufficient market existed for the end product.
- riffic 3y agoAspergillus nidulans has been genetically engineered by researchers to produce carminic acid. No bugs needed. Can still cause allergenic reactions unfortunately.
- karaterobot 3y ago> Still, upon banning red dye No. 3 from cosmetics in 1990, the FDA downplayed its dangers, noting that the risk of developing cancer from the dye appeared to be less than 1 in 100,000—small compared to the risk of natural disasters (70 in 100,000) or the risk of a train or plane crash (6 in 100,000). Representatives of the food industry had similar messages, with one industry study reportedly saying a person would have to eat 724,000 cans of fruit cocktail a year for 70 years to ingest an equivalent amount of red dye No. 3 as the rats fed the high 4 percent diet dose. This feels like maybe another example of expending a lot of political energy on something that will have no impact, while almost certainly expending a lot less energy on more important matters.
- zamfi 3y agoHmm. Would you say the same thing about train or plane crashes, areas that are heavily regulated? Or is the line somewhere between 1 in 100,000 and 6 in 100,000? California has 40 million people. With something as ubiquitous as food dye, that would be 2400 people developing cancer. Preventing that doesn’t strike me as a “no impact” move. If we can avoid these things without substantial human cost on the balance (do more people die harvesting beets than producing Red #5?), why would we not?
- karaterobot 3y agoPlanes and trains are already highly regulated, likely the reason we use them as an example of something you have an absurdly low chance of being killed by. The fact that the risk from this red dye is only a fraction of even those small numbers might indicate it should be of commensurately lower priority. For context, about 1 in 54,000 people will die of a wasp or hornet attack, making that cause twice as risky as this red dye. What I'm saying is, it does not sound like this is a big deal to me.
- zamfi 3y ago> For context, about 1 in 54,000 people will die of a wasp or hornet attack, making that cause twice as risky as this red dye Yes, and we test people for allergy to these attacks, and often those people carry interventions like EpiPens, etc.—this risk is high enough that we do something about it, no? People clear nests near their homes, etc. Why not do something about red dye? I agree that it's unlikely to affect many people. At a population level, we often take action to further reduce low-risk events because the aggregate benefit is high (2400 cancers prevented) and the cost is low (a few companies spend a few bucks to replace a barely-toxic red dye with a non-toxic one). One reason we do this is that the same trade-off at the individual level is comparatively expensive and wasteful, as the benefits only accrue (and the costs may only be low) if you can aggregate them over a large enough sample size. Consider another example: most people are not affected by vehicle accidents, but the risk is still there and pretty high. At the individual level, there is very little you can do besides "not drive" and "live in a pedestrian area". Historically, few car manufacturers included safety features before they were mandated, because they increased cost and consumers did not perceive the risk as high enough to be worth it. Regulation that mandates these safety measures raises the cost floor, but not by as much because now the extra cost is somewhat amortized over the full fleet for sale. Further, some of these safety features primarily benefit people other than the vehicle owners, like backup cameras. How many people are killed by vehicles backing up? Lifetime risk is also about 1 in 100,000. Yet we still mandate this feature in new vehicles because the cost is comparatively low. There are plenty of these kinds of trade-offs that regulators make at a population level that would not necessarily make sense at an individual level. The individual impact is quite low. But the combined aggregate effect is probably quite large.
- qvrjuec 3y agoInteresting - I saw this article and thought it'd be talking about red #40, which has been linked to ADHD-like symptoms in children [1]. I've been pleased to see more food items replacing artificial colorings with things like beet juice lately. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3441937/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3441937/
- eitally 3y agoMy oldest child has a neurological response to artificial colors but we don't know exactly which and haven't tried a challenge test. This is not uncommon and has been known for quite some time, which is why the EU has banned many of these coloring additives for years. One of the reasons we often shop at Whole Foods for prepared foods & baked goods is that they don't allow any artificial colors or flavors in products they sell. It's useful for peace of mind. Beet juice, annatto, spirulina, carrot juice / beta carotene, and many other options abound. What infuriates me is when I see something white (like vanilla pudding) that contains blue #5... for no good reason.
- MrOwen 3y agoRecently, I purchased some chocolate covered sunflower seeds. Natural chocolate color so I didn't think to check ingredients at the store but when I got home, I reviewed the ingredients. It had red, blue, and yellow artificial coloring - I was blown away! Of course, I'm sure they used the colors to arrive at a nice, consistent brown color but at what cost? Why not just do away with those artificial colorings and just let the natural chocolate color show through? Surely, the inclusion of those colors is also some sort of cost that they could even save money with if they weren't used.
- dgfitz 3y agoApparently living in California gives people cancer. I’m not sure how the rest of the world survives without all the same laws.
- charonn0 3y agoThe EU had already banned this dye.
- sophacles 3y agoI don't understand? Is this some sort of jab at the concept of being cautious given that so many things that were promoted as "totally safe" turned out to be "extremely unsafe"? Do you also find the bans on lead-acetate sweeteners to be silly since the Romans managed to build a big empire while also drinking lots of wines sweetened with it?
- dekhn 3y agoThe point is that the cancer warnings in california are so omnipresent and non-informative that people ignore them.
- coding123 3y agoThis is the main problem. If we have a prop 65 warning on lead and coffee, we've lumped to entirely different risk categories together where one is really bad and one is just - well coffee.
- tigen 3y agoThey should have to include some actual reason, perhaps a QR code or something which can produce a Cancer Facts. Or really just add Cancer Facts into Nutrition Facts, complete with estimated QALY cost per serving. They should also incorporate IQ damage and not only cancer.
- mrguyorama 3y agoIt's a stupid oversight in the law, there is zero penalty for incorrectly labeling something as causing cancer, so nobody does any actual work to see if they have used an ingredient or substance worth warning for, and just slaps a cheap sticker on instead. It's the equivalent of putting "no artificial sweeteners" on a bag of sugar.
- londons_explore 3y agoLab tests of 100 mice over a few weeks seem insufficient to get data on safety of something we want to feed to 100 million people for an 80 year lifespan. Sure - in the lab experiment, the dosage is higher. But plenty of things are dangerous after time, or only for a very tiny fraction of people. Plenty of things might have effects that aren't routinely measured in mice (eg. this additive makes your eyesight worse, or that additive makes you dumber). What can be done to close this gap?
- londons_explore 3y agoDo large scale passive human studies. Do the studies based on credit card data being directly linked to ingredients lists of products purchased. If people consuming more of an ingredient end up performing worse at school, involved in more crime, having more sick days, or dying younger, then the government should spring into action and ban/restrict it pending a proper controlled study. A special government department should be set up to handle and analyze this (very private) data, firewalled off from the rest of government. It's worth it to make millions of peoples lives healthier.
- dekhn 3y agoIt seems extremely unlikely this would happen- both because of lack of political will, and because this would be considered a huge intrusion into people's privacy.
- brightlancer 3y ago> this would be considered a huge intrusion into people's privacy. It _would be_ a huge intrusion into people's privacy.
- londons_explore 3y agoBut if told "you can either get cancer and die at age 65, or live to 85 if you are happy for scientists to look at what you eat and drink", the vast majority of people would choose the latter.
- riffic 3y agonot the dye made out of crushed up insects it seems. that is labeled natural red 4, C.I. 75470, or E120 (per wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmine)