6 ms·
Most people think it's a great idea in the abstract. When you get to the actual ballot box, it frequently becomes a "the relatively sane person needs every vot
by ceejayoz 3y ago
Most people think it's a great idea in the abstract.
When you get to the actual ballot box, it frequently becomes a "the relatively sane person needs every vote they can get to defeat the lunatic" sort of decision.
Third parties aren't going to be a real thing in the US without a change to the way we count votes.
- Vaslo 3y agoAnd who is sane and who is a lunatic is often relative, so each side bails on the third party.
- sandworm101 3y agoOr just forget the "third party" concept and jump straight to having fourth and fifth parties. The math of the three doesn't mix with US politics. The third party will always be accused of splitting either the left or right majority, giving victory to the minority. But with fourth and fifth parties in the mix that is less of a problem. So many parties would also force politicians into cross-party coalitions, but that is probably a bridge to far for US political culture.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIf a Ross Perot-style challenger appears on one side of the political spectrum, the other side's prospective fourth party has very good reason to sit down and shut up that election.
- sandworm101 3y agoWell, that wouldn't be a true multi-party system. That would be two parties (left and right) each putting forward multiple candidates until false presences. A proper party wouldn't back down like that because they would not be so influenced by the others.
- lazide 3y agoWelcome to the United States.
- NoGravitas 3y agoHell, we don't even have a true two party system. "The United States is also a one-party state but, with typical American extravagance, they have two of them." - Julius Nyerere
- GartzenDeHaes 3y ago- John Anderson torpedoed Carter - Ralph Nader and Al Gore - Ross Perot got Bush I - Third party candidates received around 6 million votes in 2016
- ceejayoz 3y agoEach of these are examples of what I'm saying; in a particular election, one side gets a significant third-party candidate, and the other side does not, because it's not in their interest to kick themselves in the 'nads.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 3y agoNo it's more of a problem. Because the winning party now has an even smaller share of the vote, and may represent no one's preferences. First past the post voting allows only two parties: because the winner is whichever party has less competitors for it's ideological niche. It explicitly destroys any concept of a market place of ideas being possible in politics.
- mistercheph 3y agoHaving dozens of balkanized parties, each so insignificant as to be powerless, is a recipe for total corporate takeover of a democracy. I am dissatisfied with both American political parties, and I am inclined to have more parties rather than fewer, but if those parties are not strong enough to sustain political identities we will have a one party system
- wing-_-nuts 3y ago>a recipe for total corporate takeover of a democracy. Do you have an example to back this up? Europe is largely multiparty and yet seems to have much more 'corporate unfriendly' consumer protections than we do today.
- antisthenes 3y agoThe more parties you have, the less likely you are to have a lunatic close to winning the popular vote. But it's kind of a chicken and egg problem.
- willis936 3y agoThe chicken and the egg problem is resolvable. A third option in a first-past-the-post voting system is not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- InTheArena 3y agoIt makes it easier to have lunatics win power without winning the popular vote.
- toyg 3y agoMaybe less likely, but it still happens. E.g. Weimar: very fragmented scenario (there were at least 4 major parties, not including the Nazi), still a lunatic won. And don't get me started on the Italian experience, or the French republics... In practice, the more fragmentation you have, the more likely that the electorate will eventually converge towards a strongman lunatic who will "clean up the mess/corruption/etc etc". The safeguards against lunacy must go well beyond the number of parties, and still might not actually work.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNot sure that's true. If you have N parties and N/2 submit lunatic candidates, are we better off? I mean, I guess we have N/2 sane ones to choose from, which is an improvement, but we also have N/2 lunatics, any of which could win.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> When you get to the actual ballot box, it frequently becomes a "the relatively sane person needs every vote they can get to defeat the lunatic" sort of decision. Yes but it was the previous duopolistic choice of incompetent-awful vs intentional-awful led us to lunatic territory.
- InTheArena 3y agoOr rather that the other party has scared the hell out of anyone to think that the only way to avoid death is to vote for them. Fear is always more effective then hope in ensuring voters don't vote in their own interest.
- ceejayoz 3y agoSure, but until you figure out a way to ban fear, we'll have to account for this dynamic in any setup.
- daedalus_j 3y agoThird party starts to look a lot more appetizing then it's not a clear cut sane-vs-lunatic scenario. When there is no lesser of the two evils people will go looking elsewhere rather than take the easy path. It gives me a LITTLE hope that this third party support is so high. It means we may have fewer "party no matter what" voters, and the politicians MAY have to actually pay attention to the people...
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Third party starts to look a lot more appetizing then it's not a clear cut sane-vs-lunatic scenario. There are always lunatics; there'll be folks in NY who hold their nose and vote for a Democrat because the House is tight and they've heard of Lauren Boebert and Marjorie Taylor Greene. (Or for a Republican in Kansas, because they don't want AOC being in the majority. As someone pointed out elsewhere in the thread, one person's lunatic is another's hero.) > It gives me a LITTLE hope that this third party support is so high. It shouldn't. Look past the headline (to the first chart); polls have showed fairly consistent majority support for a third party for decades.
- jcranmer 3y agoIt's the curse of the third party. Most people imagine themselves to be fairly moderate and centrist, but when push comes to shove, about 70-80% of the population would rather vote for the extremist on their side of the aisle over the moderate on the other side of the aisle.
- nvm0n2 3y agoThat's not it. It may be helpful for the Americans in this thread to look at the UK, which uses FPTP but has meaningfully successful third parties anyway. The lack of them in the USA isn't to do with FPTP but more fundamental. The reality is that politics is essentially bipartisan. The left/right divide is the core of politics and the only one that actually matters in the absence of regional independence movements. Therefore, what we see is that third parties usually struggle to differentiate themselves to voters. This can be seen most clearly with the Lib Dems who are one of the main third parties in the UK. They tend to be used as a protest vote and few would be able to articulate what they actually believe. Arguably they believe nothing at all, as they have in the past reversed their position on core manifesto promises, fought against implementing referendum results (despite having "democrats" in the name) and so on. What do the Lib Dems actually stand for? What is the big difference between them and Labour or the Tories? It's unclear. This doesn't mean you can't have different third parties. You can. The SNP is a clear example of a third party that grew from nothing to take over Scottish politics. But it seems that regional independence is one of the only things that is big enough to cause this, as typically the national level parties will not want to support a regional independence movement (would reduce their own power and take up a lot of time), but voting is regional. Even there though, the SNP is basically just a clone of Labour plus that one additional policy. If Scotland were to become independent, you'd rapidly see the two party system re-establish itself there along left-wing and really-left-wing lines, because this is the only axis that matters. In Europe where FPTP often isn't being used, you do see more parties, but this doesn't result in less partisan or more harmonious politics. If anything it seems to be slightly the opposite. Germany for example has major problems with people publicly debating whether the AfD should be banned, there are physical attacks on its members, and although PR is supposed to encourage collaboration and compromise none of the other parties are willing to work with it despite it being the second most popular party or even in some parts the first most popular party. The AfD is not particularly extreme though, and its policies aren't so different to the Republicans in many ways. This problem crops up in other European countries as well, it's not unique to Germany. So a third party wouldn't fix anything in the USA. Nor would PR or more exotic voting schemes. People might occasionally use them as a protest vote, as they do already today, but there's no fundamental third ideology for a third party to express, and anyway who needs a new party when the two big ones are so internally democratic? Easier to take over one of them than make a new one.
- JoshTriplett 3y agoIf you can get enough support behind third parties, though, third parties would generally support a better voting system. If we had Condorcet voting, we would have elected much more reasonable candidates a long time ago.
- tivert 3y ago> If we had Condorcet voting, we would have elected much more reasonable candidates a long time ago. Honestly, I think any voting system with an algorithm more complicated than counting simple votes will just lead to more mistrust and further empower people who want to claim election fraud. They just scream "technical solution to a social problem." I have a feeling there's probably a contradiction at the heart of democratic politics: it needs a broad consensus to be successful, but tends to remove the mechanisms for maintaining the needed consensus amongst the people, and decays to hostile factions which will eventually destroy it.
- breuleux 3y ago> If we had Condorcet voting, we would have elected much more reasonable candidates a long time ago. I don't think that's true. Candidates, even lunatics, adapt their strategy to whatever the voting system happens to be. If a lunatic can win against a sane person in a two-party contest, I have no doubt whatsoever that a lunatic can also win under Condorcet with many more candidates. Condorcet methods could help if the problem was that the preferences of people are not being met. But that is not the problem, that has never been the problem. The problem is that people do not know how to optimize their own self-interest and genuinely prefer simple narratives that tell them what they want to hear, or what the media they listen to tells them to think. Garbage in, garbage out. Doesn't matter what the voting system is.
- jlkuester7 3y agoIt is a bit overly simplistic to say that voters are the true problem with American politics. Sure, people are easy to manipulate, and, at the end of the day, voters are the ones actually electing these folks into power. However, the current two-party-system has done a very effective job of eliminating any kind of meaningful choice for voters in most places. (Not saying there are not differences between candidates/parties, but the gap between my policy positions and the positions of either of the candidate is greater than the gap between the policy positions of the two candidates....)
- ghaff 3y agoOr they cast a mostly meaningless protest vote because they don't like either of the major candidates and the result in their state is a foregone conclusion. Third parties have been a thing in the US in times past but you probably need some distinct coalition of states to make one meaningful.
- bigger_inside 3y agothe "sane vs lunatic" was always a media construction. In US politics, for half a century, it was always "warhungry imperialist vs warhungry imperialist", only with a different color (and sometimes one of the warmongers had a nobel peace price). I mean, the Simpsons famously spoofed that in, what, 1996?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt is not a media construction that my mother/wife/sister/daughter can get the necessary healthcare in the event they have a problem during pregnancy. Nor is it a media construction my wife got 5 months of paid leave versus just 3 months of unpaid leave per federal rules. Etc etc.
- two_handfuls 3y ago“Gestures vaguely at everything that happened in the last few years.” “Sane vs lunatic” may have been a media construction at some point, but it sure is real now.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoFor real. I speak as someone who has voted for both sides in the past; One party has very much went off the rails and radicalized into something I can no longer support.
- Izkata 3y agoFuturama, 1999, Jack Johnson vs John Jackson: https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ll3iyvbsRDM https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ll3iyvbsRDM
- dmurray 3y agoThere's also a difference between "I want a third party so I can vote for them" and "I want a third party, some of my political opponents would vote for them because surely they can't all be insane enough to like Current Incumbent X"
- deaddodo 3y agoThis is literally the entire point that ranked choice voting is designed to solve. The fact that most Americans don't seem keen/prioritized on implementing it, despite wide-scale disillusion at the two party system is mind-boggling to me.
- InTheArena 3y agoAmerican politics runs on fear. If it makes you less afraid of voting for a different party, it is not in the interest of the party. Slavery is the original sin of the American Consitution - parties are the second sin.
- jcranmer 3y ago> Slavery is the original sin of the American Consitution - parties are the second sin. How can parties be the second sin of the Constitution? The Constitution literally doesn't even envision their existence, to the point that the procedure for electing the president and vice president had to be changed to account for their existence.
- ceejayoz 3y agoPerhaps not anticipating the rise of parties is the sin.
- InTheArena 3y agoNot acting to constrain them. If you read the federalist papers, you will see that they considered it. They just couldn't figure out how to resolve that.
- ceejayoz 3y agoI'm all for it. I worry that a populace that can't understand "large urban counties take longer to count their many votes, leading to big vote swings hours after the polls change" and storms Congress over it will have even more challenges understanding the ranked choice setup, though.
- hef19898 3y agoAgree, and then youbhave the practical situation of the GOP basically being at least two, if not three, different parties. Same kind of goes for the dems. Other countries do the coalition forming in parliament, the US does it before elections.
- jlkuester7 3y agoAnd given the current fiasco in the House, it turns out cramming so many competing ideologies into your circus tent with no plan for cooperation or compromise does not work super great....
- jlkuester7 3y ago> it frequently becomes a "the relatively sane person needs every vote they can get to defeat the lunatic" sort of decision. Until it becomes the a "both people are lunatics" sort of decision.... > Third parties aren't going to be a real thing in the US without a change to the way we count votes. Exactly. Perhaps the single most important (feasible) improvement that could be made in US politics is broader adoption of Instant-Runoff Voting! It keeps things simple, maintains single-representation, but avoids the absurdity of first-past-the-post voting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting
- ozymandium 3y agoAnd so, from a game theory perspective, we understand why the sane person does everything in their power to avoid defeating the lunatic. The lunatic guarantees their reelection. They need the lunatic and the threat of the lunatic is what keeps them in power.
- femiagbabiaka 3y agoHopefully we have moved past the idea that the lunatic won’t be elected now.
- perrygeo 3y agoAnd conveniently, the lunatic, despite appearing to be radically different on the surface, holds similar policy positions when it comes time to vote. Either way, the ruling class gets their legislation - further incentive to keep the political clown show going.
- bee_rider 3y agoAlso of course hypothetical third party gets lots of support, it is an imaginary party that has all my favorite policies.
- spamizbad 3y agoBiggest issue is most third parties tend to put up candidates that are either: complete cranks or well-meaning candidates that focus on issues with limited salience with voters. That, and the framers of the US government basically wanted the US to operate with 2 parties because democracy was still considered fairly experimental at that time.
- IlliOnato 3y agoI used to think so. Yet I am not sure now that only the election system is to blame. Australian way to count votes was specifically designed to avoid favoring a two-party system (basically, instead of selecting one candidate, you vote for multiple and give your preference order). Yet in effect Australia has a 2-party system, too. Why is that, I don't know.
- lapcat 3y ago> Why is that, I don't know. Big money, I suspect.
- gilbetron 3y agoBecause the voting isn't the main resource required to get someone elected, it is all the time, money, and effort it takes to make a candidate known. Unlike with ranked choice or some other vote system that allows you to vote for multiple candidates, you can't put your time, money, and energy into multiple candidates at the same time. You have to split it between however many candidates you want to support, and splitting your resources like that means any one of those candidates has less of a chance than if you put your resources into a single candidate. Consciously or unconsciously, people recognize this, and so focus on a single candidate, one of two, to maximize their odds of getting their candidate elected. It is my depressing realization after wondering the same thing as you and discovering that these alternate voting systems actually don't help, in the end, with electing someone to a position of singular power. They seem to help in other situations, though.
- blululu 3y agoThe sentiment that the other side is crazy goes both ways. 60% doesn’t mean your favorite 3rd party candidate, it means 20% want Trump, 20% want Bernie and 20% think that exhuming Ross Perot and running his corpse is still better than anything the major parties will offer.
- jeo123 3y ago3rd party isn't answer. Founding fathers already hinted public unalivement is the way to go. That is why public can get fire power and conduct operations to wipe clean disobedient politician similar nature to sicario. I have seen terminally ill veterans who are very patriotic but just gave up with a sigh and let USA runs its course like Rome.