9 ms·
Support for Third U.S. Political Party Up to 63%
- andsoitis 3y agoMy understanding is that the US has a two-party system because of single member districts and and winner takes all elections. The winner takes all system requires candidates to compete for a plurality of votes. This means major parties must accommodate a broad range of ideologies. Multiparty democracies typically use a system in which representation is proportional to the number of votes received and those political parties can often get somewhere by catering to narrow interests.
- CountSessine 3y agoDuverger’s Law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law
- yorwba 3y agoYeah, so the Gallup poll really should have another question asking about support for proportional representation vs. first-past-the-post.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- andrewflnr 3y agoIn my experience even politically engaged Americans don't tend to think about this question. Not that they'd disagree with probably representation, but they'll never bring it up before the specific policy issue du jour. Our parties have done an excellent job distracting us.
- rsynnott 3y agoJust due to the nature of the American system, it would be virtually impossible to introduce on a national basis, so there's arguably no sense in spending time talking about it.
- lazide 3y agoMany states also have deeply embedded 2 parties into their various laws and legal systems in different ways. A viable third, or fourth, or whatever party would have a LOT of friction to overcome to actually happen.
- andrewflnr 3y agoIt would be possible if we wanted it badly enough. Which can only happen if we talk about it.
- cschmidt 3y agoI don't think American voters could understand that very well. Where I live in Massachusetts they defeated a ballot initiative for ranked choice voting, which is just clearly better (in that it reflects the will of the people), especially in a state dominated by a single party.
- mattbrewsbytes 3y agoHow would proportional representation work? Party A gets 40% of votes so they get 40% of congressional seats in a state? Party B and C each get their respective proportion? Like it re-districts a state/county/town every year?
- arlort 3y agoYou would likely need to increase the number of seats (or allow "fractional" representatives for smaller states) so that even the smallest state gets 3-4 representatives And then yes, in traditional proportional systems you vote for a list of candidates rather than a single candidate, the lists are the ones getting the seats based on vote totals. The seats can be distributed based on a fixed or flexible lists model If you have a state that now has 10 reps each party would make a list of 10 people, then if party A gets 40%, party B 35%, C 15% and D 10% you'd get 4 people from the list proposed by A, 3 (or 4) from the list for B, 2 (or 1) from C and 1 from D
- lazide 3y agoCongress currently struggles to agree that a functioning federal gov’t is desirable (as in literally, not shut down is better than shut down).
- gerikson 3y agoThis is broadly the case in the UK as well, but with regional differences (Scotland and NI).
- wkat4242 3y agoYeah and the UK is seeing the same issues as the US like extreme polarisation between parties and no incentive to reconcile. In Holland parties have to form a coalition after the elections. This is a very complex and time-consuming process but I'm very glad we have it. It's not perfect but way better than winner takes all IMO.
- varispeed 3y ago> extreme polarisation between parties and no incentive to reconcile. It's more like polarisation between party supporters. The parties themselves become virtually indistinguishable. Choosing between Tories and Labour is like choosing between Coke and Pepsi. They have very much the same agendas and are only different on minor issues (in the grand scheme of things) that are blown out of proportions.
- iMark 3y agoIn the wake of brexit, I'm not sure the argument that both parties differ only on minor issues holds up.
- wkat4242 3y agoI think what we see in the UK and the US is a really weird combo of centering politics (both parties don't want to be too much off-center to attract as many voters as possible) but also a really extreme polarisation with the 'enemy' (because they need people to vote for them and not the other party) In addition to that, politics becomes a 'zero-sum game'. Meaning a loss for one is automatically a win for the other. In other countries in Europe we don't really have this mechanism and it takes a lot of the sharp edge off politics. Because getting the other parties to fail is not automatically a win. I think especially in the US this latter point is very clear right now, one party is always trying to undermine the other, even at the cost of the country's interests (which was the one thing they were supposed to care about!). Using the shutdown as leverage is a typical example. I think any system that reduces politics to a zero-sum-game should be avoided as much as possible to reduce this very phenomenon. Because while the two parties in the US are fighting in the streets over internal issues, Russia and China don't have any internal political issues and can take full advantage of this on a geopolitical scale. That's the handy thing of being a "one party system", as awful as it is. Not saying the EU countries are perfect. Coalition forming is an awfully complex process and sometimes it takes years (I think Belgium was without a government for more than a year recently). It also leads to inaction or slow response times to external events by having too many parties at the table. But it doesn't lead to this kind of extreme infighting and stalemates.
- wyldfire 3y agoIn the history of the US, the "third party" either "spoils" in this fashion you've described -- or it subsumes the party it would've spoiled by becoming more popular. It's not inconceivable for a new coalition to form around a new ideology and have that replace the GOP.
- baggachipz 3y agoThat already happened in the 80's. ;)
- lisper 3y agoAnd again in 2016.
- rythmshifter 3y agoCould you explain this further?
- Macha 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixth_Party_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixth_Party_System
- jfengel 3y agoI had not seen this terminology before. Thank you.
- baggachipz 3y agoI was specifically thinking of the "Moral Majority" movement, Reagan doctrine, and "trickle-down economics." It was a sea change in the party and set their direction until 2016. We're still seeing the fallout from it to this day, with consolidation of wealth, pandering to extreme religious conservatives, and endless military engagements to police the globe.
- fsagx 3y agoIt seems a plausible argument that the same happened to the Democrats beginning Bill Clinton in the 90's. Obama out-fundraised from Wall Street both his Republican opponents. Also, with their lock up on big-tech (Musk aside), and their tepid or purely rhetorical support for unions, the Democrats are the big business party.
- Macha 3y agoYeah, I can see most people can agree on feeling that the two big parties don't meet their needs, but I highly doubt they agree on what that third party should be. And if that's the case there's a real "you go first" problem under FPTP for voting for new parties, because otherwise you've just given the established party on the opposite side to your own views an effective boost by switching from your traditional party to one that meets your views better. You really need at least ranked voting and ideally multi-seat PR to get out of that, which is hard as it's against the interests of the two big parties. That said, looking at the UK there does seem to be a renewed interest in moving away from FPTP in their Labour Party despite it being nominally against the parties interests, so maybe there's a way to get movement on that?
- InTheArena 3y agoI want to vote for local representatives and a real person. I don't want to vote for Republican LLC and Democratic INC. Parties have no standing at all within the United States Constitution. The fact that we are talking this way is reflective of the simple fact that the representative democracy (aka Republic) that the United States is has been corrupted by parties that work to their own interest, not the interest of the people. IF you need any evidence of that, you can see it this week when Democrats voted party line with a few Republicans to remove a speaker for no other reason than it humiliated the republican party and the speaker.
- Macha 3y agoWhat democratic nation in the world does not have political parties? It turns out from both a voter and politician perspective, the fact that banding together into parties for predictable ability to deliver results is an advantage seems to be a global phenomenon. FPTP systems are bad for delivering only two parties, but all systems cause parties of some scale.
- InTheArena 3y agoParties yes - American parties, with monopolistic grab on power and ability to suppress other ideas and parties? No.
- jt2190 3y ago> … single member districts… That single member can “cross the aisle” without being instantly dismissed from their party and loosing all speaking rights, which is why we have two party. This gives the representative more ability to represent the interests of their district, by threatening to break ranks.
- anotherhue 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation …apart from all others.
- thsksbd 3y agoThe winner takes all biases towards a two party system, but has actually been baked into law by the big two parties to discourage competition. Ballot access is extremely difficult unless you're one of the Big Two
- thejackgoode 3y ago.. and what upsets me the most about this and similar systems is that such status quo is not reformable without a huge crisis or a catastrophe. This may be naive, but I feel like humanity could experiment more with some artificial way of breaking and reforming "working" systems with minimum harm.
- lazide 3y agoWhat do you concretely propose as an alternative?
- empath-nirvana 3y agoIf people were serious about starting a third party, they would start with a hyper local strategy. There are _lots_ of places in the US where one of the two major parties is a complete shambles and there are people running unopposed for races where a third party could actually come in and win elections. Demonstrate success at the county level, work up to getting elected to the state house, demonstrate that you can govern effectively and so on. It's a 20 or 30 year project, and it's not glamorous like running for president is, though.
- InTheArena 3y agoHistorically, this isn't true. The Republicans were founded in 1854 and won the presidency in 1864. The second-party system started in 1830 and won the presidency in 1840. It's actually much easier to do this a national level, and then drive it downwards into the states.
- jf22 3y agoI don't think there are that many unopposed races and if there are they are for relatively powerless positions. Also, getting elected to state houses requires a lot of non-monetary support for field work and independent candidates won't have the resources.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> This means major parties must accommodate a broad range of ideologies. That depends on how the party primaries are arranged. Current conditions seem to favor general elections with two extremists rather than a moderate who can win a plurality.
- bigger_inside 3y agoThe UK has it as well, and it has at least 6 viable political parties that regularly win votes in districts. But yes, it makes it harder to "grow" as 5, 10% doesn't get you a foot in the door of power the way proportional representation does.
- b112 3y agoMy understanding is that the US has a two-party system because of single member districts and and winner takes all elections. Many Westminster descendants are not this way, and never have been. Canada has multiple parties, new ones crop up and old ones die. The current conservative party is a 20ish year old party, and a merger/takeover of the Reform, then Alliance, the Conservatove party absorbing the tattered remnants of the old party. We have political alliances, coalition governements where more than one party holds power, minority governments, and typically at least 3 main parties, with a smattering of others around. We typically have 5 or 6 parties sitting at one time. And yes, to the youngsters in the room, even our 3rd main party has held power from time to time. But most importantly, party names and controllers change. That's on the federal level. On the provincial level, new party spring with abandon, and form governments too. What I would suggest, is not pushing for something incredibly insane sounding to most US ears, like changing the entire voting system, but instead just push for that third party, something that sounds more tenable.
- cwmma 3y agoOpen primaries are also a really part. In other countries the party itself decides who runs in each district but in America there is an open primary where basically anyone can run and if they win the primary then they are the parties nominee. In other countries groups like the democratic socialists or the tea party would have to run as third parties because they could never get selected to run, but in America if you are in a fridge group it makes more sense to run in one of the two parties.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoRight. It used to be the Right would swing further right during election season and the Left would swing further left. Once the election was over they both drifted back closer to center. Now, well, we can easily see that's just not the case anymore.
- ceejayoz 3y agoMost people think it's a great idea in the abstract. When you get to the actual ballot box, it frequently becomes a "the relatively sane person needs every vote they can get to defeat the lunatic" sort of decision. Third parties aren't going to be a real thing in the US without a change to the way we count votes.
- Vaslo 3y agoAnd who is sane and who is a lunatic is often relative, so each side bails on the third party.
- sandworm101 3y agoOr just forget the "third party" concept and jump straight to having fourth and fifth parties. The math of the three doesn't mix with US politics. The third party will always be accused of splitting either the left or right majority, giving victory to the minority. But with fourth and fifth parties in the mix that is less of a problem. So many parties would also force politicians into cross-party coalitions, but that is probably a bridge to far for US political culture.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIf a Ross Perot-style challenger appears on one side of the political spectrum, the other side's prospective fourth party has very good reason to sit down and shut up that election.
- sandworm101 3y agoWell, that wouldn't be a true multi-party system. That would be two parties (left and right) each putting forward multiple candidates until false presences. A proper party wouldn't back down like that because they would not be so influenced by the others.
- lazide 3y agoWelcome to the United States.
- robg 3y agoFolks jump to the presidency, but seems like the biggest value prop for a third party is winning a few Senate seats. Target 10 smaller, purple states with one major media market. 2-3 wins in one year gives six years to build momentum. With each added Senate seat in subsequent years, the third party builds relevance by setting the Senate agenda. Given how evenly split the country is, just a few Senate seats have outsized influence. House is possible too, but with only 2 year terms, the value is harder to maintain and build upon.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoWinning a Senate seat has the same problems as trying to win the presidency. They should be running for state representative. Take over a state house after a few election cycles, then work on getting a governor elected, then go from there to federal elections and other states.
- robg 3y agoSame problems? I don’t see that, it’s a local-ish constituency powered by national trends. States like New Jersey, Maryland, and Massachusetts all regularly flip governors between the two parties. Adding states like Colorado, Arizona, Delaware, New Hampshire, etc isn’t crazy for down a middle agenda.
- robg 3y agoP.s. Arizona could be a good test of the theory in the next Senate campaign, albeit with an incumbent going third party.
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoPeople over the last couple of years are starting to reduce politics to the annoying people they have to deal with on a daily basis that think politics is the most important part of ones identity.
- lizardking 3y agoWhen the rubber meets the road the vast majority of that 63% will still vote against what they perceive to be the lesser of two evils.
- thejackgoode 3y agoat this point, older of two evils is a factor as well
- lizardking 3y agoFair point
- matthewmorgan 3y ago[flagged]
- sg47 3y agoNot surprising since the Republican party has fallen into a pit of extremism with no clear policies.
- tjrgergw 3y agoTheir policy is to kill the woke mind virus. Why, do you support the woke mind virus?
- explaininjs 3y ago[flagged]
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoWait, I thought conservatives were critical of Biden's withdrawal from Afghanistan. Good to see you support it. Also, every time I hear about immigration reform, why is it always being pushed by liberals and not conservatives? There's a lot of sarcasm in the above, but you get my point. Conservatives got us into our last two wars (though honestly, I'll excuse Afghanistan and agree the withdrawal was completely botched). Conservatives could absolutely get more funding to secure the southern border if they agreed to work with liberals to reform immigration and make a more streamlined legal process for immigration to this country. Maybe a points based system like Canada's, but a bit less permissive?
- explaininjs 3y agoI don’t see why we need a complete plan of how to let people in before we can secure it. Secure it first, then figure out who to let in. It’s as if you were in control of IT for a company and had discovered your networks were filled with hackers, but refused to do anything about it until you had a plan for how to allow future new hires access. Secure the walls, kick out the unauthorized, then grant new authorization as needed. It’s obvious, really.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoCome on man, you have to realize that the dems want to reform immigration as badly as the republicans want to crack down on illegal immigration. If you work together, it's a win win where both sides get what they ostensibly want. I suspect the truth of the matter is republican politicians are terrified of being seen as pro any immigration.
- vonwoodson 3y ago[flagged]
- allendoerfer 3y ago[flagged]
- InTheArena 3y agoWhen others are informed by sources that don't know what they are talking about, no need to learn from them. But when they are rational and informed, you would be wise not too. Looking at this thread, you can make your own judgement as to what of the two extremes this is closest too.
- vonwoodson 3y ago[flagged]
- tjrgergw 3y agoCould you give us an example of something specific foreigners misunderstand about American culture, and then explain to us the correct understanding?
- vonwoodson 3y ago[flagged]
- tjrgergw 3y ago[flagged]
- Xophmeister 3y agoIIRC, there's some political science theory that says that certain electoral systems -- I don't know if the US counts -- tend towards a two-party steady state.
- VikingCoder 3y agoWe desperately need to double the number of Representatives in the House. Or quadruple. And we need a National Popular Vote for President. No more ignoring solidly blue or solidly red states. We should also force anyone who wants a nomination from one of the major parties (however many there are) for office in the Federal government to pledge to live only and entirely on their pension. They must completely divest of anything but Index Funds. No more paid lobbying retirement for politicians. It's killing this country.
- InTheArena 3y agoHow about forcing the president to be non-partisan? None of this "the president leads the party" shit. Partisanship in America is a bug, not a feature.
- krapp 3y agoYou can't do that in the US, because we have freedom of speech and freedom of association - the latter of which inevitably leads to partisanship. If the party wants the President to be their leader, they have the right to decide that, and the President likewise has the right to be as partisan as they wish. Solutions that require forcing people to adhere to a specific ideological or political framework (or not to) tend towards authoritarianism. You can't stop people in a free society from acting in aggregate to further their own common interests.
- InTheArena 3y agoWe have oaths that keep people from acting in foreign countries' interest. The same can apply here. No mandatory party-line votes. No ordering representatives how to vote on issues.
- krapp 3y agoEverything you've listed is still perfectly legal, nonviolent consensual speech from people acting in what they believe to be theirs and their country's best interests, and party members are perfectly within their rights to break ranks if they want. That isn't the same class of behavior as sedition or espionage. The only solution I can see is if the parties themselves decided to change their rules, but they have no reason to. Things are only the way they are now because that is what wins votes and concentrates power.
- giantg2 3y agoYeah, 63% want some third party... until you create one and it doesn't fit their ideals because they all want different things.
- Aloha 3y agoI think there is a place for a party which is not quite as socially liberal as democrats or socially conservative as republicans, pro-worker (somewhat protectionist and anti-free trade), and less authoritarian than the extremes of either major party. That said, every effort at a third party has started at the top, with the presidency, the only way to build a party is from the bottom up - the Forwardists are trying to do this - but its a many many year effort to do so.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThird parties, as of late, are all on the "left" side of the political spectrum. The article states that support for third parties by Democrats is 46% while Republicans support for third parties is 58% and "independents" at 75%. It seems like a "centrist" third party is the only type that would have a chance at winning anything. But nobody is stepping forward to create that party.
- lazide 3y agoThe current socio/political environment just guarantees that any moderate will be shit on by both sides.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThat's probably why nobody wants to volunteer themselves. But the survey results sure seem to indicate that this is where victory would be found.
- lazide 3y agoEh, only that people think there is an opportunity there. The moment someone started to get popular, both big parties would start; 1 - flinging whatever crap they could at them. 2 - try to steal any policy differentiation they tried to do that seemed popular. 3 - would crack down on their own loyalists. 4 - use all their existing leverage to sabotage them. It’s the ‘of course I care about the environment!’ choice. It will be popular as long as it isn’t concrete and doesn’t require any real sacrifices.
- Eumenes 3y agoI wonder how a more competitive landscape would impact how lobbyists function, given they control the board.
- the_snooze 3y agoIf people were serious about change, they'd vote more in primary elections. That's where the actual power is. But non-presidential primaries have hilariously low turnouts, dominated by the most partisan voters, so we get bad choices in the general election because we cede nominating power to crazies. Change doesn't require major structural moves. It just requires less apathy towards the "boring" aspects of politics where the true power lies.
- richiebful1 3y agoIf you're dissatisfied with the direction of your preferred party, get out and vote in primaries. A lot of people have become Independent out of disgust, but if you're in a closed primary state, you just gave away your vote. If you live in a one-party state like West Virginia or Maryland, it might make sense to tactically switch to the dominant party. I've done that in my state. In a perfect world, elections reform would be great: - adopt ranked-choice voting - increase access to the ballot box (motor voter auto-registration, early voting, etc) - adopt compulsory elections (probably would never happen in the States)
- erellsworth 3y agoMore than two parties can't work in the U.S. unless we get some sort of ranked choice voting.
- howmayiannoyyou 3y ago"All Politics Is Local" These polls are almost meaningless. Why? Because its city, county and state politics is where most (not all) party power resides, particularly on election day when "get out the vote" and election integrity is determined. Trump's election in 2016 stands out as a notable exception to this general rule, but his defeat in 2020 was very much a return to the rule. Also, US elections currently come down a few dozen or so counties in the US where grass roots party activities make the biggest difference. Then, importantly, its from the State/County organizations that many political and judicial appointments are made by new administrations. A third party lacks the depth and roster of qualified applications for those roles. The problems this creates are well illustrated, again, by the Trump administration that struggled to fill positions. None of this is intended to take sides pro or con a party or person. I'm just pointing out reality having worked in a city and statewide campaign, among other related experiences.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- tananaev 3y agoPeople want another option, but the problem is that different people want different things from this new option, so I don't think a single third major party is going to be feasible any time soon. There are already a bunch of minor parties out there. For example libertarian party and green party, but their ideologies are polar opposite and they never get any significant results.
- synergy20 3y agoI support that too, someone in the middle of left and right please run for president and create a sane party, call it common-sense-party.
- 1270018080 3y agoThird parties will never happen in first past the post elections. 2 parties will have enough of the general platforms to get 51% and 49% of the every single time. And if you’re a voter who can think rationally, you’ll vote for the big party that’s close enough rather than throw your vote away on a 3rd party vote. If there are any flash in the pan third parties, their platform will get absorbed by the big 2 and it’ll disappear. A third party is fundamentally irrelevant in the design of our democracy. This poll should be 0% support.
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI had been a democrat my whole adult life, contributing to democratic candidates dozens of times. I left the Democratic Party a few years ago. My reasoning is that it makes it easier for special interests to game the system if everyone is caged into just one of our two major political parties. The DNC and RNC shamefully service special interests, not public interests. If you disagree, I would be happy to debate this all day. I still do occasionally make donations to democrats who I think are exceptional and once to a republican candidate in my state who I thought was also exceptional, but I make sure that none of my contributions every again go to DNC (or RNC if I was not liberal). EDIT: what I am suggesting is that it would be best for our representative democracy if everyone registered independent.
- footlose_3815 3y agoHaving lived through every failed third party, the answer is not a third party until FPTP is eliminated. Until then, anytime spent endorsing voting for contributing to a third party is moot.
- ericfrazier 3y agoAt the actual polls support will be about .063
- bane 3y agoThe two major American political parties should really be viewed as coalitions of a number of single or few issue parties. It's an issue of semantics, but it also explains how our parties can swing so wildly over time on certain issues -- the composition of the coalition has simply changed. The minor parties are either in one of these two coalitions or are effectively out on their own. What Americans are really saying here is that neither coalition is really working for them and they're looking for some other new coalitions to form. It's particularly acute at the moment with the Republican party where the fractures are fairly clear and have been forming for the last few decades. However, the Democratic party also has fissures and it may explain why it's turned into such a gerontocracy as the old guard seek to keep the the coalition together. In either case, the minor parties of either major probably won't seek to break away unless they believe they can form a new coalition (major) party that will win at the polls. What I think many Americans would hope, if really pressed, would be a center-right party (by American thinking of left-right politics) that ejects the more extreme right wing concerns and pulls enough of the center-left to win while also filtering out more classic left-wing politics. Where that center-left comes from? I would wager mostly various highly religious, but not necessarily evangelical, groups made heavily of recent or second generation minority immigrant groups who tend to be more conservative in thinking but pushed to align with the Democratic party because of all the race hating nonsense in the Republican party. Some of these groups have been test migrating to the Republican party over the last generation simply because the Democratic party isn't coherent in its ability to absorb multiple competing ethical and moral frameworks, but I would bet that those groups are generally unhappy being in the same room as all the anti-<insert religious ethnic group> people who don't like them and are looking for better aligned identity. Like any great American political institution, such a party would continue to be decades behind the political thought in Europe, left of most of Asia without the long-term thinking, and be paradoxically highly inclusive of race and religion while intolerant of real social progress.
- roshin 3y agoI doubt any 3rd party will go far, but they do help. When the green or libertarian party starts to gain votes, the democrat or republican party changes their policy to include concepts that the respective party had. So in the end, one of the 2 main parties will win. But their ideologies will be changed due to the third party.
- freeopinion 3y agoThe current two-party arrangement in the U.S. starves the center. But it isn't so much because of the two parties. It is because of the 2-phase voting scheme. In order for a candidate to win, they must win two elections. The first, or primary, election requires them to win a vote within their private club or party. Currently, that means that you have to be radical within that party. You have to take what would be an extreme position in the general population in order to appeal to enough people within the party. It guarantees that all candidates that emerge from the primary will overrepresent the fringe. So then you get to the general election where the only choices are polar. You see where even a pretty far right Liz Cheney fails the Trump test and isn't "Republican" enough to survive round one. Same thing happens with the Dems. A third party could lead to disaster. If you get all the conservatives that can't stomach Trump to split away, you hand elections to the likes of Sanders. And not just occassionally. The conservatives would never win another election ever because they would split the vote every time. If you get the liberals that can't stomach Biden to split away, you hand elections to the likes of Trump. Forever. I think you have to fix the process to solve the party problem. Tweak the process to push candidates back to the center instead of away from the center.
- NoGravitas 3y ago> In order for a candidate to win, they must win two elections. The first, or primary, election requires them to win a vote within their private club or party. Currently, that means that you have to be radical within that party If that were true (of both parties), then President Sanders would be in his second term right now. The last two Democratic primaries were each taken by the most conservative candidate running.
- Dem_Boys 3y agoThis thread seems a bit out of touch. Most folks are speaking on the practicalities of a 3 party system but are missing the elephant in the room. IMO This isn't so much support for the 3 party system. It's the American public saying "Hey this is obviously broken so we need to do something.... anything". Just like if you ask the average person "Hey what should we do about AI?". They'll say something like "Stop it immediately! I don't want that crap taking my job". We all know it's wayyyy more nuanced than that but the takeaway is people are uncomfortable with AI. Most people are too busy to be well read on everything.
- asow92 3y agoWhy would this post be flagged?
- Dem_Boys 3y agoI had the same question. If you had to guess why it's currently flagged, what's your hypothesis?
- asow92 3y agoI don't have enough information to say, but it definitely doesn't pass the smell test.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoBecause politics are rigged. People on HN come here for tech news, not to discuss politics. It's pointless: everyone in politics is either corrupt, or about to become corrupt. They give you an illusion of choice creating fake controversies and putting people against each others. Then you vote and nothing changes. Obama didn't achieve anything but warmongering. Trump didn't reduce spending. They were both puppets put there to give different people a bit of hope that the systems is not rigged. But it is. Nobody will save you. You're doomed to be forever slaves and give more than half of what you produce to the government. Sure, country hopping to avoid taxes will work for a bit, but soon a new Global Tax will pray on all of you and soon after they'll come up with a Global Government BS in the name of peace, climate change or something else equally vapious. So yeah, I don't need HN to think about this crap, I want to see the latest cool tech thingies.
- soupfordummies 3y agoMy prediction: we're finally going to have a "viable" (maybe. loosely.) three party system in the US, but it's going to be a monkey's paw situation where the Republican party forks.
- laomai 3y agoWhy do I feel like we put more effort into vetting/interviewing employees than political candidates in the US? Say we had to choose candidates like we choose employees, we should have: - individual tests for the employee (actual aptitude in things like strategy, diplomacy, math & statistics, science) - behavioral tests (how likely to lie/take risks) - etc. Instead it all seems to boil down to statistics-backed popularity contests half-a-step up from elementary school class elections.